This paper reviews briefly the history of mental health depopulation in Canada over the past 30 years. The term “deinstitutionalization” is often used but is unsatisfactory. Using an exploratory, qualitative, methodological approach, data were collected on the problems encountered by a disproportionate, stratified random sample of 139 formerly institutionalized patients living in various geographical locales in Eastern Canada. Adopting a symbolic interactionist theoretical approach, this study, in an effort to fill a neglect in the literature, attempted to discover what the everyday world(s) of Canadian ex-mental patients was really like. Problems encountered related to stigma, poor housing, lack of back living skills, poverty, unemployment and aftercare. Quotations from patients are provided to illustrate such themes. The findings are discussed.
References
1.
SmithC.M., HermanN.J.The chronic elderly in Canada: the clients speak. In: HavensB., Ratbone-McCuarE., eds. American elders: a comparison of U.S. and Canadian issues.Westport: Greenwood Press,1988.
2.
WingJ.K.Clinical concepts of schizophrenia in schizophrenia. In: WingJ.K., ed. Towards a New Synthesis.London: Academic Press,1976.
3.
CassellW.A., SmithC.M., GrunbergF.Comparing cost of hospital and community care.Hosp Community Psychiatry1972; 23: 17–20.
4.
FakruddinA., ManjooranA., NairN.P.V.A five year outcome of discharged psychiatric patients.Can Psychiatr Assoc J1972; 17(6): 433–435.
5.
HerjanicM., StewartA., HalesR.C.The chronic patient in the community: a two year follow-up of 338 chronic patients.Can Psychiatr Assoc J1968; 13(3): 231–234.
6.
HerjanicJ., HalesR.C., StewartA.Does it pay to discharge the chronic patient? A two year follow-up of 338 chronic patients.Acta Psychiatr Scand1969; 45: 53–61.
7.
SmithC.M.Measuring some effects of mental illness on the home.Can Psychiatr Assoc J1969; 14(2): 97–104.
8.
SmithC.M.Crisis and aftermath: community psychiatry in Saskatchewan 1963–69.Can Psychiatr Assoc J1971; 16(1): 65–76.
9.
SmithC.M.From hospital to community.Can J Psychiatry1979; 24(2): 113–120.
10.
StewartA., LafaveH.G.Problems in phasing out a large public psychiatric hospital.Am J Psychiatry1968; 125: 82–87.
11.
Ad Hoc Committee.The report of the Ad Hoc Committee on the resettlement of mental hospital patients to the Minister of Public Health, Saskatchewan, June 27, 1966.
12.
FrazierS.H., PokornyA.D.Report of a consultation to the Minister of Public Health on the Psychiatric services of Saskatchewan. Regina, January, 1968.
13.
TalbottJ.A.Assorted nits and picks. Psychiatric News, American Psychiatric Association, March 1, 1985.
14.
BorzeckiM., WormithJ.S.The criminalization of the psychiatrically ill people: a review with a Canadian perspective.Psychiatr J Univ Ottawa1985; 10: 242–247.
15.
GoodacreR.H., ColesE.M., McCurdyE.A.Hospitalization and hospital bed replacement.Can Psychiatr Assoc J1975; 20(1): 7–14.
MurphyH.B.M., EngelmanF., Teheng-LaroucheF.The influence of foster home care of psychiatric patients.Arch Gen Psychiatry1976; 33: 179–183.
19.
MurphyH.B.M., PenneeB., LuchinsD.Foster Homes: the new back wards.Can Ment Health Supplement1972; 71(suppl.).
20.
MurphyJ.Backwards from back wards: unmet needs of recovering patients in Edmonton.Boyle Street Community Services Co-operative, June, 1983.
21.
VoineskosG.New Chronic patients in the emergency service.Psychiatr J Univ Ottawa1985; 10: 95–100.
22.
Mental Health Planning Survey (John Cumming Director). Report of the Mental Health Planning Survey British Columbia, May, 1979.
23.
Regional Municipality of Ottawa-Carleton.Social overview of the central area.Ottawa, Planning Department, 1982.
24.
Social Planning Council of Metropolitan Toronto.People without homes.Toronto, January, 1983.
25.
Social Planning Department, City of Vancouver. The 44. The Urban Reader1979; 6: 13–15.
26.
Social Planning Department, City of Vancouver.Sleeping rooms.The Urban Reader1979; 7: 13–17.
27.
Social Planning Department, City of Vancouver.Gimme shelter.The Urban Reader1982; 10: 14–18.
28.
Task Force on Housing (Regina).Let the sun shine in: a report of the housing situation of Regina's low income, downtown, single persons, City Hall, Regina1985.
29.
PepperB., RyglewiczH.The young adult chronic patient.San Francisco, Jossey Bass, 1972.
30.
WattJ.A., el-GuebalyN.The chronic patient: the position of the Canadian Psychiatric Association.Can J Psychiatry1981; 26(7): 494–501.
31.
WasylenkiD., DoeringP., LanceeW., FreemanS.J.J.Psychiatric aftercare in a metropolitan Toronto setting.Can J Psychiatry1985; 30(4): 329–336.
32.
CummingE., CummingJ.Closed ranks.Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1957.
33.
D'ArcyD.Open ranks: Blackfoot revisited. In: D'ArcyD., NewM., and TerranaC. eds. Health and Canadian society.Toronto: Fitzhenry and Whiteside,1981.
34.
DearM., TaylorS.M.Not on our street — community attitudes to mental health care.New York: Methuen,1982.
35.
LiptzinB.The effects of national insurance on Canadian psychiatry.Am J Psychiatry1977; 134: 248–252.
36.
LiptzinB.Canadian and US systems of care for the mentally ill elderly.Gerontologist1984; 24: 174–178.
37.
TorreyE.F., WolfeS.M.Care of the seriously mentally ill.Public Citizen Health Research Group, Washington, D.C.1986.
38.
HermanN.J.Crazies in the community: an ethnographic study of ex-psychiatric patients: stigma, management strategies and identity transformation. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Department of Sociology, 1985.
39.
BlumerH.Symbolic interactionism.Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1969.
40.
MeadG.H.Mind, self and society.Chicago: University of Chicago Press,1934.
41.
MeadG.H.On social psychology.Chicago: University of Chicago Press,1964.
HermanN.J.Ex-psychiatric patients: stigma, management strategies and identity transformation.In revision to the Journal of Contemporary Ethnography1988.
44.
HermanN.J.Deinstitutionalization: U.S. and Canadian issues.New York: General Hall,1989.
45.
HermanN.J.The ‘Mixed Nutters’ and ‘Looney’ Tuners: the emergence, development, nature and functions of two informal subcultures of ex-psychiatric patients.Deviant behavior1987; 8: 235–258.
46.
TalbottJ.A.Community care for the chronically mentally ill.Psychiatric Clients of North America1985; 8: 437–448.
