As Canada expands its activities in the North, it becomes necessary to understand the mental, emotional and health consequences of working in harsh, isolated environments.
This paper reviews the pertinent literature and reports on a study, commissioned by Environment Canada, of the working conditions of meteorological technicians in 33 isolated stations who were surveyed by questionnaire. Numerous personal interviews and visits to five Arctic stations were also carried out. GHQ scores of psychological distress were significantly higher than in a Saskatchewan community sample but not higher than in male air transport shift workers in Ontario. Sleep disturbances and anergia were the two most prominent symptoms in our sample. The literature also stressed these symptoms as well as alcoholism and a number of curious cognitive phenomena.
The importance and problems of group functioning are stressed. Our subjects showed fewer problems than the literature would have predicted, but it is generally agreed that there are few, if any, irreversible sequela of life in the North.
References
1.
SuedfeldP.Extreme and unusual environments. In: StokolsD, AltmanI, eds. Handbook of Environmental Psychology I.New York: Wiley, 1987.
2.
CramJM. Perceived need satisfaction of workers in isolated environments. Ph.D. thesis, University of British Columbia, 1970.
GoldbergD, KayC, ThompsonL.Psychiatric morbidity in general practice and the community. Psychol Med1976; 6: 565–569.
5.
GoldbergDP, HillerVF. A scaled version of the General Health Questionnaire. Psychol Med1976; 9: 139.
6.
D'ArcyC.Prevalence and correlates of nonpsychotic psychiatric symptoms in the general population. Can J Psychiatry1982; 27(4): 316–324.
7.
GundersonEKE. Emotional symptoms in extremely isolated groups. Arch Gen Psychiatry1963; 9: 74–80.
8.
MullinCS. Some psychological aspects of Antarctic living. Am J Psychiatry1960; 117: 323–325.
9.
PalmaiG.Psychological observations on an isolated group in Antarctica. Br J Psychiatry1963; 109: 364–370.
10.
TaylorAJW. The adaptation of New Zealand research personnel in the Antarctic. In: EdholmOG, GundersonEKE, eds. Polar Human Biology.New York: William Heinemann, 1973.
11.
WillisJS. Mental health in North. Med Serv J Canada1960; 8: 689–720.
12.
StrangeRE, KleinWJ. Emotional and social adjustment of recent US winter-over parties in isolated Antarctic stations. In: EdholmOG, GundersonEKE, eds. Polar Human Biology.New York: William Heinemann, 1973.
13.
SellsSB. American Psychiatric Association Symposium on factors affecting team performance in isolated environments. September,1967.
14.
TaylorAJW. Some behavioral science in Antarctica. N Z Med Assoc J1980; 15: 75–80.
15.
LawP.Personality problems in Antarctica. Med J Aust1960; 1: 273–282.
16.
BuckL.Circadian rhythms of performance among workers in the Arctic. Aviat Space Environ Med1980; 51(8): 805–808.
17.
LewisHE, MastertonJ.Sleep and wakefulness in the Arctic. Lancet1957; 1: 1262–1266.
18.
PatersonRA. Seasonal reduction of slow-wave sleep at an Antarctic coastal station. Lancet1975; 1: 468–469.
19.
HansenT, BratlidT, LingjardeO, Midwinter insomnia in the subarctic region: evening levels of serum melatonin and cortisol before and after treatment with bright artificial light. Acta Psychiatr Scand1987; 75: 428–434.
20.
MullinCS, ConneryHJM. Psychological study at an Antarctic IGY station. US Armed Forces Med J1959; 10(3): 1–7.
21.
RohrerJH. Human adjustment to Antarctic isolation. Report NONR, 1530(07), 1960.
22.
GundersonEKE, NelsonPD. Adaptation of small groups to extreme environments. Unit Report No. 63–15. Aerosp Med1963; 34: 111–115.
23.
TaylorAJW. Ability, stability and social adjustment among Scott base personnel, Antarctica. Occup Psychol1969; 43: 81–93.
24.
SellsSB, RawlsJR. Effects of isolation of man's performance. Texas Christian University, Institute of Behavioural Research, Report No. 8, 1968.
25.
GundersonEKE. Psychological problems in the polar environments. In: SaterJE, ed. The Arctic basin. Arctic Institute of North America,1969; 215–224.
26.
AbbottAP. Description of cabin fever. Council of North West Territories. Informaiton Item Number 7–45.
27.
ChristensenR, DowrickPW. Myths of mid-winter depression. Alaska Med1983; 25(2): 53–54.
28.
SiemensLB. Single enterprise community studies in Northern Canada. Centre for Settlement Studies, University of Manitoba, 1973.
29.
ParsonsGF. Arctic suburb: a look at the North's newcomers. Mackenzie Delta Research Project (MDRP 8), Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development, 1970.
30.
SmithWM. Observations over the lifetime of a small isolated group: structure, dangers, boredom and vision. Psychol Rep1966; 19: 475–514.
31.
EilbertLR, GlaserR.Differences between well and poorly adjusted groups in an isolated environment. J Applied Psychol1959; 43(4): 271–274.
32.
WheatonJL. Fact and fancy in deprivation studies. Air University, School of Aviation Medicine, USAF, Brooks AFB, Texas, 1959.
33.
SellsSB. A model for the social system for the multi-man extended duration spaceship. Aerosp Med1966; 37(11): 1130–1135.
34.
AltmanI, HaythornWW. Interpersonal exchange in isolation. Sociometry1965; 28: 411–426.
35.
AltmanI, HaythornWW. The effects of social isolation and group composition on performance. Hum Rel1967; 20(4): 313–340.
36.
RockwellDA, HodgsonMG, BeljanJR, Psychologic and psychophysiologic response to 105 days of social isolation. Aviat Space Environ Med1976; 47(10): 1087–1093.
37.
BalesRF. The equilibrium problem in small groups. In: HareAP, BorjattaEF, BalesRF, eds. Small groups: studies in social interaction.New York: Knopf, 1965.
38.
SmithS.Studies of small groups in confinement. In: ZubeckJP, ed. Sensory deprivation: fifteen years of research.New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1969.
39.
HaythornWW. Interpersonal stress in isolated groups. In: McGrathJE, ed. Social and psychological factors in stress.New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1970.
40.
SellsSB, ed. Conference on social-behavioral problems of long-duration space missions. Institute of Behavioral Research, Texas Christian University. September, 1967, Report of NASA Grant NGR 44-009-008.
41.
CowanEH, StricklandDA. The legal structure of a confined microsociety (A report on the cases of Penthouse I and II). Internal Working Paper No. 34. Space Sciences Laboratory, Social Sciences Project. University of California, Berkeley, California, 1965.
42.
CrocqL, RivolierJ, CazesG.Selection and psychological adjustment of individuals living in small isolated groups in the French Antarctic stations. In: EdholmOG, GundersonEKE, eds. Polar Human Biology. William Heinemann, 1973.
43.
NickelsJB, SextonDL, BayerCA. Life satisfaction in a resource frontier community. Centre for Settlement Studies, University of Manitoba, 1976.
44.
SmithWM. Scientific personnel in Antarctica: their recruitment, selection and performance. Psychol Rep1961; 9: 163–182.
45.
SmithWM, JonesMB. Astronauts, Antarctic scientists and personal autonomy. Aerosp Med1962; 33: 162–166.
46.
FrancisRD. Introversion and isolation tolerance. Percept Mot Skills1969; 28(2): 534.
47.
EilbertLR, GlaserR, HanesRM. Research on the feasibility of selection of personnel for duty at isolated stations. Lockland Air Force Base, Texas: USAF Personnel Training and Research Center, Technical Report 57–41, 1957.
48.
NickelsJB, KehoeJP. Northern communities: mental health and social adaptation. Centre for Settlement Studies, University of Manitoba, 1972.
49.
MatthiassonJS. Resident perceptions of quality of life in resources frontier communities. Series 2: Research Reports No. 2. Centre for Settlement Studies, University of Manitoba, 1970.
50.
BoagTJ. The white man in the Arctic: a preliminary study of the problems of adjustment. Am J Psychiatry1952; 109: 444–449.
51.
HobartCW. Commuting work in the Canadian north: some effects on Native people. In: Proceedings, Conference on Commuting and Northern Development, Institute for Northern Studies, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, 1979.
52.
GundersonEKE, NelsonPD. Biographical predictors of performance in an extreme environment. J Soc Psychol1965; 66: 241–249.
