This paper presents the first 50-year study of the differential effects of incarceration and combat on the development and persistence of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in Canadian veterans and prisoners of war (POWs) from the Dieppe Raid.
Method
A large sample of Dieppe. POWs and nonPOWs completed a questionnaire diagnosing PTSD and other psychological and health problems of the veterans in 1946 and in 1992.
Results
The POWs showed a higher incidence of PTSD and other psychological symptoms than veterans with the same combat exposure. The POWs' experiences of malnutrition, maltreatment and torture, and mental suffering showed strong links to PTSD.
Conclusions
For many veterans, PTSD has lasted 50 years. Failure to be eligible for psychological disability pensions demonstrates that PTSD and other psychological disorders in these veterans have been greatly unrecognized by the Canadian Department of Veteran's Affairs.
References
1.
BeebeG.W.Follow-up studies of World War II and Korean War prisoners. II. Morbidity, disability and maladjustments.Am J Epidemiol1975; 101(5): 400–422.
2.
PageW.F., EngdahlB.E., EberlyR.E.Prevalence and correlates of depression symptoms among former prisoners of war.J Nerv Ment Dis1991; 179(11): 670–677.
3.
HermannJ.D.Report to the Minister of Veterans Affairs on a Study of Canadians who were Prisoners of War in Europe During World War II.Ottawa ON: Information Canada,1973.
4.
MillerT.W., MartinW., SpiroK.Traumatic stress disorder: diagnostic and clinical issues in former prisoners of war.Compr Psychiatry1989; 30(2): 139–148.
5.
ZeissR.A., DickmanH.R.PTSD 40 years later: incidence and person-situation correlates in former POWs.J Clin Psychol1989; 45(1): 80–87.
6.
TennantC., GoulstonK., DentO.Clinical psychiatric illness in prisoners of war of the Japanese: forty years after release.Psychol Med1986a; 16: 833–839.
7.
HeizerJ.E., LeeN., RobinsL.M.Post-traumatic stress disorder in the general population.New Engl J Med1987; 317(26): 1630–1634.
8.
KluznikJ.C., SpeedN., Van ValkenburgC.Forty-year follow-up of United States prisoners of war.Am J Psychiatry1986; 143(11): 1443–1446.
9.
SpeedN., EngdahlB., SchwartzJ.Posttraumatic stress disorder as a consequence of the POW experience.J Nerv Ment Dis1989; 177(3): 147–153.
10.
GoldsteinG., van KammenW., ShellyC.Survivors of imprisonment in the Pacific Theatre during World War II.Am J Psychiatry1987; 144(9): 1210–1213.
11.
SutkerP.B., WinsteadD.K., GalinaZ.H.Assessment of long-term psychosocial sequelae among POW survivors of the Korean conflict.J Pers Assess1990; 54(1,2): 170–180.
12.
SutkerP.B., WinsteadD.K., GalinaZ.H.Cognitive deficits and psychopathology among former prisoners of war and combat veterans of the Korean Conflict.Am J Psychiatry1991; 148(1): 67–72.
13.
FairbankJ.A., HansenD.J., FilterungJ.M.Patterns of appraisal and coping across different stressor conditions among former prisoners of war with and without post-traumatic stress disorder.J Consult Clin Psychol1991; 59: 274–281.
14.
SutkerP.B., AllainA.N.Jr.MMPI profiles of veterans of WWII and Korea: comparisons of former POW and combat survivors.Psychological Reports1991; 68: 279–284.
15.
SutkerP., BuggF., AllainA.N.Jr.Person and situation correlates of post-traumatic stress disorder among POW survivors.Psychol Rep199066: 912–914.
16.
EberlyR.E., HarknessA.R., EngdahlB.E.An adaptational view of trauma response as illustrated by the prisoner of war experience.J Trauma Stress1991; 4(3): 363–380.
17.
EngdahlB.E., PageW.F., MillerT.W.Age, education, maltreatment, and social support as predictors of chronic depression in former prisoners of war.Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol1991; 26: 63–67.
18.
EberlyR.E., EngdahlB.E.Prevalence of somatic and psychiatric disorders among former prisoners of war.Hosp Commun Psychiatry1991; 42(8): 807–813.
19.
RichardsonH.J.Report of a study of disabilities and problems of Hong Kong Veterans, 1964–1965.Ottawa ON: Canadian Pensions Commission,1965.
20.
American Psychiatric Association.Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (third edition revised).Washington DC: APA, 1987.
21.
RobertsonT.The shame and the glory: Dieppe.Toronto ON: McClelland and Stewart Limited,1962.
22.
EngdahlB.E., SpeedN., EberlyR.E.Comorbidity of psychiatric disorders and personality profiles of American World War II prisoners of war.J Nerv Ment Dis1991; 179(4): 181–187.
23.
TennantC., GoulstonK., DentO.The psychological effects of being a prisoner of war: forty years after release.Am J Psychiatry1986b; 143(5): 618–621.
24.
TennantC., GoulstonK., DentO.Australian prisoners of war of the Japanese: post-war psychiatric hospitalisation and psychological morbidity.Aust NZ J Psychiatry1986c; 20: 334–340.
25.
MillerD.J., GorecznyA.J., PerconteS.T.Comparison of symptom distress between World War II ex-POWs and Vietnam Combat Veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder.J Anxiety Dis1992; 6: 41–46.
26.
PolivyJ., ZeitlinS.B., HermanC.P.Food restriction and binge eating: a study of former prisoners of war.J Abnorm Psychol1994; 103: 409–411.
