To critically review data relating the seizure duration in electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) to its therapeutic effect in the treatment of depressive illness.
Method:
The authors used MEDLINE, PSYCHINFO on CDROM, and their own knowledge of the literature to find studies or reviews concerning the role of seizure duration in ECT efficacy.
Results:
Rigorous studies cast doubt on the usefulness of seizure duration as a clinical marker. Some medications that decrease seizure time have deleterious treatment effects but also affect other seizure dynamics. Several medications dramatically shorten seizures but have no influence on treatment efficacy.
Conclusion:
The guidelines of ECT seizure length are arbitrary, suggesting exaggerated durations for ECT treatment.
MedunaIJ. Autobiography of IJ Meduna (Part 2). Convuls Ther1985;1:43–57.
12.
KalinowskyLBarreraE.Electric convulsion therapy in mental disorders. Psychiatr Q1940;14:719–30.
13.
KalinowskyLBHochPH. Shock treatments and other somatic procedures in psychiatry. New York: Grune & Stratton; 1946.
14.
CerlettiU.Electroschock therapy. In: SacklerAMSacklerMDSacklerRRMarti-IbanezF, editors. The great physiodynamic therapies in psychiatry. New York: Hoeber-Harper; 1956.
15.
AndropS.Electric shock therapy in the psychoses: Convulsive and subconvulsive methods. Psychiatr Q1941;16:730–49.
16.
LowenbachIIElectric shock treatment of mental disorders. N C Med J1943:4:123–8.
17.
SackeimHADevanandDPPrudicJ.Stimulus intensity, seizure threshold, and seizure duration: Impact on the efficacy and safety of electroconvulsive therapy. Psychiatr Clin North Am1991;14:803–43.
18.
OttossonJO. Effect of lidocaine on the seizure discharge in electro-convulsive therapy. Acta Psychiatr Scand Suppl1960;145:7–32.
19.
Standish-BarryHMDeaconVSnaithRP. The relationship of concurrent benzodiazepine administration to seizure duration in ECT. Acta Psychiatr Scand1985;71:269–71.
20.
PettinatiHMWillisKWNilsenSM, and others. Benzodiazepines reduce ECT's therapeutic effect [abstract]. In: Abstracts of the 140th annual meeting of the American Psychiatric Association; 1987 May 7–13.
21.
BowenRC. The effect of diazepam on endogenously depressed patients. J Clin Pharmacol1978;18:280–4.
22.
GreenbergRMPettinatiHM. Benzodiazepines and electroconvulsive therapy. Convuls Ther1993;9:262–73.
23.
MaletzkyBM. Seizure duration and clinical effect in electroconvulsive therapy. Compr Psychiatry1978;19:541–80.
24.
ZorumskiCFBurkeWJRutherfordJL, and others. ECT: Clinical variables, seizure duration and outcome. Convuls Ther1986;2:109–19.
25.
AbramsRA. Hypothesis to explain divergent findings among studies comparing the efficacy of unilateral and bilateral ECT in depression. Convuls Ther1986;2:253–7.
26.
AbramsRFinkM.Clinical experience with multiple electroconvulsive treatments. Compr Psychiatry1972;13:115–21.
CromholmBOttossonJO. Ultrabrief stimulus technique in electro-convulsive therapy II: Comparative studies on therapeutic effects and memory disturbances in treatment of endogenous depression with the Elther ES electroshock apparatus and the Siemens Konvulsator III. J Nerv Ment Dis1963;137:268–76.
29.
d'EliaGOttossonJOStrömgrenL.Present practice of electro-convulsive therapy in Scandinavia. Arch Gen Psychiatry1953;40:577–81.
30.
d'EliaGPerrisC.Comparison of electroconvulsive therapy with unilateral and bilateral stimulation. Acta Psychiatr Scand1970;215:9–29.
31.
d'EliaGRaotmaH.Is unilateral ECT less effective than bilateral ECT?Br J Psychiatry1975:126;83–9.
32.
FinkM.Missed seizures and the bilateral-unilateral electroconvulsive therapy controversy. Am J Psychiatry1983;140:198–9.
33.
HesheJRoderETheilgaardA.Unilateral and bilateral ECT: A psychiatric and psychological study of therapeutic effect and side effects. Acta Psychiatr Scand1978;275(Suppl):1S–180S.
34.
MillerALFaberRAHatchJP, and others. Factors affecting amnesia, seizure duration, efficacy in ECT. Am J Psychiatry1985;142:692–6.
35.
OttossonJO. Is unilateral nondominant ECT as efficient as bilateral ECT? a new look at the evidence. Convuls Ther1991;7:190–200.
36.
OverallJIRhoadesHM. A comment on the efficacy of unilateral versus bilateral ECT. Convuls Ther1986;3:245–51.
37.
PettinatiHMNilsenS.Missed and brief seizures during ECT: Differential response between unilateral and bilateral electrode placement. Biol Psychiatry1985;20:506–14.
SackeimHADecinaPKanzlerM, and others. Effects of electrode placement on the efficacy of titrated, low-dose ECT. Am J Psychiatry1987;144:1449–55.
40.
SackeimHADecinaPPortnoyS, and others. Studies of dosage, seizure threshold, and seizure duration in ECT. Biol Psychiatry1987;22:249–68.
41.
WeinerRDCoffeyCE. Minimizing therapeutic differences between bilateral and unilateral nondominant ECT. Convuls Therapy1986;2:261–5.
42.
EnderleJDStatonJDGerstJ, and others. The electroencephalographic pattern during electroconvulsive therapy III: Analysis of frontotemporal and nasopharyngeal spectral energy. Clin Electroencephalogr1986;17:66–77.
43.
KrystalADWeinerRDMcCallWW, and others. The effects of ECT stimulus dose and electrode placement on the ictal electroencephalogram: An intraindividual crossover study. Biol Psychiatry1993;34:759–67.
44.
KirsteinIOttossonJO. Experimental studies of the electroencephalographic changes following electroconvulsive therapy. Acta Psychiatr Scand Suppl1960;145:49–68.
45.
AbramsRSwartzCM. Electroconvulsive therapy and prolactin release: Relation to treatment response in melancholia. Convuls Ther1985;1:38–42.
46.
SwartzCM. Beyond seizure duration as a measure of treatment quality. Convuls Ther1993;9:1–7.
47.
AbramsRSwartzCM. Electroconvulsive therapy and prolactin release: Effects of stimulus parameters. Convuls Ther1985;1:115–9.
48.
WhalleyIJDickHWattsAG, and others. Immediate increases in plasma prolactin and neurophysin but not other hormones after electroconvulsive therapy. Lancet1982;1064–8.
49.
ScottAIFWhalleyLJLegrosJ-J.Treatment outcome, seizure duration, and the neurophysin response to ECT. Biol Psychiatry1989;25:585–97.
50.
SackeimHAPrudicJDevanandDP, and others. Effects of stimulus intensity and electrode placement on the efficacy and cognitive effects electroconvulsive therapy. N Engl J Med1993;328:839–46.
51.
SackeimHADecinaPProhovnikI, and others. Dosage, seizure threshold, and the antidepressant efficacy of electroconvulsive therapy. Ann N Y Acad Sci1986;462:398–410.
52.
FinkM.What is an adequate treatment in convulsive therapy?Acta Psychiatr Scand1991;84:424–7.
AbramsRVolavkaJFinkM.EEG seizure patterns during multiple unilateral and bilateral ECT. Compr Psychiatry1973;14:25–8.
55.
RobinAde TisseraS.A double-blind controlled comparison of the therapeutic effects of low and high energy electroconvulsive therapies. Br J Psychiatry1982;141:357–66.
56.
GreenARButtDCowenP.Increased seizure threshold following convulsion. In SandlerM, editor. Psychopharmacology of anti-convulsants. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1982.
57.
PostRMPutnamFUhdeTW, and others. Electroconvulsive therapy as an anticonvulsant: Implications for its mechanism of action in affective illness. Ann N Y Acad Sci1986;462:376–88.
58.
KrystalADWeinerRDCoffeyCE, and others. EEG evidence of more “intense” seizure activity with bilateral ECT. Biol Psychiatry1992;31:617–21.
59.
NoblerMSSackeimHASolomonM, and others. EEG manifestations during ECT: Effects of electrode placement and stimulus intensity. Biol Psychiatry1993;34:321–30.
60.
FinkMNemeroffCB. A neuroendocrine view of ECT. Convuls Ther1989;5:269–304.
61.
FinkMOttossonJO. A theory of convulsive therapy in endogenous depression: Significance of hypothalamic function. Psychiatry Res1980;2:49–61.
62.
LererB.Neurochemical and other neurobiological consequences of ECT: Implications for the pathogenesis and treatment of affective disorders. In: MeltzerHY, editor. Psychopharmacology: The third generation of progress. New York: Raven Press; 1987.
63.
CohenSJLawtonC.Do benzodiazepines interfere with the action of electroconvulsive therapy?Br J Psychiatry1992;160:545–6.
64.
GreenAR. Do benzodiazepines interfere with the action of electro-convulsive therapy?Br J Psychiatry1992;161:129–30.
65.
OttossonJO. Seizure characteristics and therapeutic efficiency in electroconvulsive therapy: An analysis of the antidepressive efficiency of grand mal and lidocaine-modified seizures. J Nerv Ment Dis1962;135:239–51.
66.
FearCFLittlejohnsCSRouseE, and others. Propofol anaesthesia in electroconvulsive therapy. Br J Psychiatry1994;165:506–9.
67.
American Psychiatric Association. The practice of electroconvulsive therapy: Recommendations for treatment, training and privileging: A task force report. Washington (DC): American Psychiatric Association Press; 1990.
68.
MalschEGratzIManiS, and others. Efficacy of electroconvulsive therapy after propofal and pethotexital anesthesia. Convuls Ther1994;10:212–9.
69.
PettinatiHMStephensSMWillisKM, and others. Evidence for less improvement in depression in patients taking benzodiazepines during unilateral ECT. Am J Psychiatry1990;147:1029–35.
70.
StrömgrenLSDalJFjeldgergN, and others. Factors influencing seizure duration and number of seizures applied in unilateral electroconvulsive therapy. Acta Psychiatr Scand1980;62:158–65.
71.
McCallWVReidSRosenquistP, and others. A reappraisal of the role of caffeine in ECT. Am J Psychiatry1993;150:1543–45.
72.
CoffeyDEFigielGSWeinerRD, and others. Caffeine augmentation of ECT. Am J Psychiatry1990;147:579–85.
73.
RosenquistPBMcCallWVFarahA, and others. Effects of caffeine pretreatment on measures of seizure impact. Convuls Ther1994;10:181–5.
74.
DanielWFCrovitzHF. Acute memory impairment following electroconvulsive therapy, 1: Effects of electrical stimulus waveform and number of treatments. Acta Psychiatr Scand1983;67:1–7.
75.
DanielWFCrovitzHF. Recovery of orientation after electroconvulsive therapy. Acta Psychiatr Scand1982;66:421–44.
