The Effect of Lay-Up,Core Material,and Cross-Sectional Geometry on the Structural Performance of Pultruded Fiberglass Utility Poles

Abstract

The structural performance of several pultruded fiberglass utility poles is investigated and compared with wood pole standards. The fiberglass poles are thin-walled tubes with an approximate hexagonal configuration. The outside of the poles have longitudinal grooves which create a dovetail configuration. The dovetails provide a convenient mechanism for attaching crossarms and other hardware to the tubular structure and contribute additional stiffness and strength at these attachment points. Manually operated clamping devices which can run up and down the grooves provide a safe environment for utility linemen. Structural evaluation includes a comparison of axial stiffness, flexural stiffness, maximum load, maximum bending moment, and load-deflection curves for several different pole cross-sectional geometries. Material elastic properties and fiber orientations are varied to determine the effect on structural performance. Several different fiber preforms, including unidirectional rovings and multidirectional fabrics, are evaluated. Results of the analyses are compared with the manufacturer's (Composite Power Corporation) preference in terms of manufacturabilit,. The effect of fiberglass sleeve inserts and solid foam cores is also investigated. Some of the analyses are compared with full scale test data and both the experimental and theoretical results are compared with utility standards for pole design. Failure mechanisms for different loading conditions and future analysis is discussed. Preliminary results show that the composite poles can achieve the standards required for the highest quality wood poles.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Amoco . 1994. "Lightweight Insulated Composites Hold Energy Lines," Isopolyester News, Amoco Chemical, Chicago, IL, Summer.

Anonymous . 1990. "Composite Light Poles Hold Up in Hurricane," Plastics and You, Fall.

Ballinger, C. 1991. "Development of Composites for Civil Engineering," Proceedings of the Specialty Conference on Advanced Composite Materials in Civil Engineering, ASCE, New York, NY, pp. 288-301.

Beer, F. P. and E. R. Johnston . 1992. Mechanics of Materials. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Book Company.

Burnside, P. , E. Barbero , J. Davalos and H. Gangarao . 1993. "Design Optimization of an All-FRP Bridge," Proceedings of the 38th International SAMPE Symposium and Exhibition, Covina, CA: SAMPE, 38:1789-1799.

Busel, J. 1994. "The World's First Full-Scale, All-Composites Demonstration Pier," Plastics Brief Reinforced Plastics Newsletter, XVIII(41).

Cazaly, L. 1982. 'A Comparative Analysis of Poles," Canadian Electrical Association Research Report No. 119D249, July.

Creative Pultrusions Design Guide. Creative Pultrusions Inc., Alum Bank, PA 15521-15521.

Hollaway, L. 1993. Polymer Composites for Civil and Structural Engineering. London: Blackie Academic & Professional.

10.

Idaho Power. 1982. Distribution Standards, No. 05-02-03, July.

11.

Iyer, S. L. 1993. "First Composite Cable Prestressed Bridge in the U.S.A.," Proceedings of the 38th International SAMPE Symposium and Exhibition, Covina, CA: SAMPE, 38:1766-1774.

12.

Liskey, K. 1991. "Structural Applications of Pultruded Composite Products," Proceedings of the Specialty Conference on Advanced Composite Materials in Civil Engineering, New York, NY: ASCE, pp. 182-193.

13.

McCombs, P. R. 1993. "We Believe Our Cost-Competitive, Environmentally Friendly New Technology Offers the Solution," Composite Power News, Composite Power Corp., Las Vegas, NV, Fall.

14.

O'Toole, B. J. 1994. "Design and Evaluation of Large Scale Pultruded Fiberglass Tlibular Structures," Proceedings of the American Society for Composites Ninth Technical Conference, Lancaster, PA: Technomic Publishing Company, Inc., pp. 692-699.

15.

O'Toole, B. J. and P. R. McCombs . 1995. "Pultruded Composite Structures for Pier, Sea Wall and Levy Applications," Proceedings of the ASCE/PIANC Ports '95, New York, NY: ASCE (to appear), March.

16.

Sen, R. , S. Iyer , M. Issa and M. Shahawy . 1991. "Fiberglass Pretensioned Piles for Marine Environment," Proceedings of the Specialty Conference on Advanced Composite Materials in Civil Engineering, New York, NY: ASCE, pp. 348-359.

17.

Wilkison, A. R. and Hota V. S. Gangarao . 1993. "Fiber Reinforced Polymer Matrix Composites in Construction," Proceedings of the 38th International SAMPE Symposium and Exhibition, Covina, CA: SAMPE, 38:1061-1070.