Marketization of refuse collection in Denmark: social and environmental quality jeopardized

Abstract

Refuse collection has been the main public service to be out-sourced in Denmark since the EU guidelines on public procurement came into force in 1993. The contracting activities of the municipalities are framed by a complex set of ideologies and objectives, in addition to regulations. At both EU level and at national level, the demands for marketization of the public sector are counterbalanced by demands for social and environmental considerations. The procurement directive reflects the balance legalizing the inclusion of such requirements by contracting. The Danish experiences, however, tell a grim tale of subordination of social requirements in municipal contracting practices with implications for the quality of the service. The results of a recent study of developments in the working conditions at commercial collection companies show deterioration in respect of health and safety, competence building and job security concurrent with the increase in outsourcing and competition in the sector. In the analysis of the results, a combination of municipal cost-saving strategies, harsh market forces and cultural influences are identified as causal factors. Drawing on a brief institutional analysis, it is concluded that the existing normative and regulative framework of municipal contracting needs reinforcement if societal intentions of qualified public services and acceptable working conditions are to be effective. Initiatives to simultaneously improve working conditions and environmental results of collection are called for.

Keywords

Refuse collection outsourcing and contracting working conditions health and safety environmental performance quality aspects wmr 1027—1

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Blangsted, A.K. , Christiansen, J. , Flyvholm, M.A. , Nørby, H. Søgård, K. & Vinzents, P. (2000) Værktøj til arbejdsmiljøvurdering af rengøringsydelser (Tool for health and safety assessment of cleaning services). AMI og CASA, Copenhagen.

Brown, T.L. & Potoski, M. (2004) Managing the public service market. Public Administration Review, 64, 656—668.

Busck, O. (2007) Arbejdsmiljøet ved udbud af renovationsarbejde (The Working Conditions by Contracted Refuse Collection). BAR Transport/ Aalborg University, www.bartransport.dk

Busck, O. (1991) Training and education of waste workers. Waste Management and Research, 9, 219—223.

Christiansen, L.M. (2002) Kontrakter og kvalitet (Contracts and Quality) . In: Ejersbo, N. & Greve, C. (eds): Den offentlige sektor på kontrakt (The Public Sector on Contract), pp. 139—161. Børsen , Copenhagen.

DWEA, Danish Work Environment Authority (Arbejdstilsynet) (1993) Atanvisning om manuel transport og håndtering af dagrenovation mm., 4.1.0.1, (Guideline on Manual Transport and Handling of Refuse). Arbejdstilsynet, Copenhagen .

Dijkgraaf, E. , Gradus, R.H.J.M. & Melenberg, B. (2003) Contracting out refuse collection. Empirical Economics, 28, 553—570.

Ejersbo, N. & Greve, C. (2002) Den offentlige sektor på kontrakt (The Public Sector on Contract). Børsen, Copenhagen .

Elmeskov, J. & Lundsgaard, J. (2003) Incitamenter og konkurrence i offentligt finansieret service (Incitements and Competition in Publicly Financed Service), Samfundsøkonomen 11. DJF, Copenhagen.

10.

EU Commission (2001a) Interpretative communication on the Community law applicable to public procurement and the possibilities for integrating social considerations into public procurement , COM (2001) 566 final.

11.

EU Commission (2001b) Interpretative communication on the Community law applicable to public procurement and the possibilities for integrating environmental considerations into public procurement , COM (2001) 274 final.

12.

Eu (2004) Directive 2004/18/EC of the European Parliament and of the European Council of 31 March 2004 on the coordination of procedures for the award of public works contracts, public supply contracts and public service contracts.

13.

EU-court (EU-domstolen) (2002) Verdict of 17/9.2002 in case C513/99 Concordia Bus, Finland, EFT 9/11.2002, http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/ pri/da/oj/dat/2002/c_274/c_27420021109da00040005.pdf Accessed: 20 May 2006.

14.

Folketinget (Danish Parlament) (2002) Lov om ændring af lov om kommunernes styrelse, `Lov om servicestrategi' (Law on Service Strategy), Lov nr. 373 af 6. juni 2002, Copenhagen.

15.

GWU, General Workers Union (SID) (2004) Anmeldte arbejdsulykker og bevægeapparatslidelser for renovationsarbejdere 1993—2002 udtræk af Arbejdstilsynets statistik,. (Reported Work Accidents and Strain Injures, except from DWEA's statistics), SID , Copenhagen

16.

GWU, General Workers Union (SID) (2003) Effekter af udlicitering (Effects of outsourcing), Deloitte & Touche for SID, København

17.

Greve, C. (2005) Notat om udbud og udlicitering (Note on contracting and outsourcing), COWI, Copenhagen .

18.

Gustafsson, O. & Saksvig, P. (2005) Outsourcing in the public refuse collection sector: Exploiting old certainties or exploring new possibilities? Work, 25, 91—97.

19.

Jensen, P.B. (2002) Kontraktstyringens betydning for de ansatte og fagbevægelsen (The Implications of Contract-Management to the Employees and the Unions). In: Ejersbo, N. & Greve, C. (eds): Den offentlige sektor på kontrakt (The Public Sector on Contract), pp. 77—95. Børsen, Copenhagen.

20.

L 172 (2001) Beskæftigelsesministeriets lovforslag af 22.02.2001 om udbyderansvar, gennemført ved lov nr. 331 i 2001 (Bill by the Ministry of Employment of 22.02.2001 on the responsibility of contracting authorities to consider safety and health, implemented by law in June 2001).

21.

LGDK, Local Government Denmark (Kommunernes Landsforening) (1999) Håndbog: EU-udbud på affaldsområdet (Manual: EU-procurement in the waste sector), http://www.kl.dk/data/1368136/DAGHÅNslut_1199 . doc Accessed: 18.11.05.

22.

LGDK, Local Government Denmark (KL) (2001) Omfang og erfaringer. Udbud og udlicitering på det tekniske område (Extent and Experiences. Contracting and Outsourcing in the Technical Area) , Kommuneinformation, Copenhagen .

23.

MoE (Ministry of Employment) (2001) Beskæftigelsesministeriets bekendtgørelse om pligter efter lov om arbejdsmiljø i forbindelse med udbud af offentlige tjenesteydelser (Order on duties pursuant to Law on Work Environment when contracting public services) , nr. 1109 af 17. december 2001, Beskæftigelsesministeriet , Copenhagen.

24.

MoE (Ministry of Employment) (2006) Aftale om opfølgning på velfærdsaftalen fra juni 2006 om 70 mio. kr. til arbejdsmiljø og aftale om justering af arbejdsmiljøreformen (Agreement on follow-up on the well-fare-agreement of June 2006), Arbejdstilsynet , Copenhagen.

25.

Poulsen, O.M. , Breum, N.O. , Ebbehøj, N. , Hansen, A.M. , Ivens, U.I. , Van Lelieveld, D. , Malmros, P. , Mathiassen, L. , Nielsen, B.H. & Nielsen, E.M. ( National Institute of Occupational Health ) (1995) Collection of domestic waste. Review of occupational health problems and their possible causes. The Science of the Total Environment, 18, 1—19.

26.

Ohlsson, H. (2003) Ownership and production costs: Choosing between public production and contracting-out in the case of Swedish refuse collection . Fiscal Studies, 24, 451—476.

27.

Scott, W.R. (2001) Institutions and Organizations. Sage, London.

28.

Wiegmann, I.-M. , Mathiesen, K. & Hasle, P. (2004) Arbejdsmiljø ved udbud af busdrift (Work Environment by Contracting of Bus Transport). CASA, Copenhagen.

29.

Udbudsportalen (2006) Trin-for trin vejledning, renovation, trin 14 (Step-by-step manual, refuse collection, step 14) at: http://www.udbudsportalen.dk/data_udbud/1569788/Renovation1.pdf Accessed: 1 November 2006.