Dustiness of Compostable Waste: a Methodological Approach To Quantify the Potential of Waste To Generate Airborne Micro-Organisms and Endotoxin

Abstract

The objective of the present study was to assess the effect of different waste storage systems on the potential of the waste to emit airborne dust, micro-organisms and endotoxin. Batches of 8.8 kg of compostable waste were mcubated at 20°C for periods of 1-2 weeks in three different storage systems: a system with relatively free access of air (FA) to the waste (paper bags in the kitchen, paper sacks outside the house), a system with low access (LA) of air (plastic bags in the kitchen, a container outside the house), and an intermediate (IA) system (trash can in the kitchen, a container outside the house). The compostable waste was prepared in the laboratory using a standard recipe simulating average kitchen waste in Denmark Weight loss and temperature of the waste were recorded during the storage period. After incubation, the volume of percolate was determined and the dustiness of the waste was measured in terms of the potential of the waste to emit bio-aerosols in a rotating drum.

Storage in the FA system resulted in high weight loss of the waste (15-25% per week), a maximum temperature of 45°C and no percolate was observed. The LA system resulted in low weight loss (<3% per week), a temperature at ambient level and a volume of percolate less than 0.1 litre. Waste stored in the IA system was intermediate with a weight loss of 5-8% per week, a maximum temperature of 36°C and a volume of percolate less than 1 litre. Dustiness in terms of dust, endotoxin and micro-organisms was highly correlated to weight loss of the waste. Storage of the waste in the FA system resulted in extremely high concentrations of airborne micro-organisms in the rotating drum compared to that seen after storage in the LA system. The dustiness with respect to airborne Aspergillus fumigatus was at least a factor of 400 000 higher for FA waste compared to LA waste. The present method of testing dustiness of waste is considered important for the design of waste collection equipment and may therefore, over time, contribute to an improved air quality for the workers engaged in waste handling. © 1997 ISWA

Keywords

Dustiness compostable waste bio-aerosol fungi bacteria endotoxin weight loss temperature rotating drum tester Denmark.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

BOHS, British Occupational Hygiene Society ( 1985) Dustiness estimation methods for dry materials. Technical Guide No. 4. Science Reviews Ltd, Leeds, U.K.

Breum, N.O. , Nielsen, B.H. , Nielsen, E.M. , Wilkins, C.K. , Midtgård, U. & Poulsen, O.M. (1995) Betydning af affaldets alder og opbevaringsbetingelser for eksponering for luftforurening (Storage conditions of waste related to bioaerosol exposure). National Institute of Occupational Health, Copenhagen, Denmark.

Dutkiewicz, J. , Jablonski, L. & Olenchock, S.A. (1988) Occupational biohazards: a review. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 14, 605-623.

Gaube, J. , Jager, E. & Ruden, R. (1986) Untersuchungen der hygienischen Auswirkungen der getrennten Sammlung von Alt- und Schadstoffen (A study on hygienic aspects on the collection of source separated waste). Institut für Hygiene der Frein Universität Berlin, Berlin, Germany.

Heitbrink, W.A. , Todd, W.F. & Fischbach, T.J. (1989) Correlation of tests for material dustiness with worker exposure from the bagging of powders. Applied Industrial Hygiene 4, 12-16.

Heitbrink, W.A. , Todd, W.F. , Cooper, T.C. & O' Brien, D.M. (1990) The application of dustiness tests to the prediction of worker dust exposure. American Industrial Hygiene Association Journal 51, 217-223.

Lyons, C.P. & Mark D. (1994) Development and testing of a procedure to evaluate the dustiness of powders and dusts in industrial use. Contract Research Report No. 62/ 1994. Health and Safety Executive, Bootle, U.K.

Malmros, P. , Nersting, L. , Petersen, C. & Sigsgaard, T. (1991) Arbejdsmiljøforhold ved genanvendelse af affald (Occupational conditions in the recycling of waste). Report No. 161/ 1991, Environmental Protection Agency, Copenhagen, Denmark.

Mansdorf, S.Z. , Golembiewski, M.A. & Fletcher, M.W. (1982) Industrial Hygiene Characterization and Aerobiology of Resource Recovery Systems. NIOSH, Morgantown, U.S.A.

10.

Mortensen, B. & Domela, H. (1995) Bates Combi system-a new Danish waste collection system. Proc. Biowaste '95, 2nd Int Conf and Exhibition Forum on Biological Waste Treatment. 21-24 May, 1995. Aalborg, Denmark.

11.

Nielsen, B.H. , Würtz, H. & Holst, E. (1991) Komposterbart husholdningsaffald—undersogelse af den mikrobielle udvikling i kildesorteret grønt affald fra AFAV-området. (Compostable household waste-a study on microbial activity i source separated compostable waste from the AFAV catchment area). Report No. 29/1991, Environmental Protection Agency, Copenhagen, Denmark.

12.

Nielsen, B.H. , Würtz H. & Holst, E. (1994) Endotoxin and microorganisms in percolate derived from compostable household waste. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 25, 121-122.

13.

Nielsen, E.M. , Nielsen, B.H. & Breum, N.O. (1995) Occupational bioaerosol exposure during collection of household waste. Annals of Agricultural Environmental Medicine 1, 53-59.

14.

Palme, U. & Smedlund, L. (1995) Källesortering av komposterbart material-olika hanteringslinjer-Delförsök 2 (Guidelines for source separation of compostable waste-study No. 2). Smedlund Miljösystem AB, Sweden.

15.

Palmgren, U. , Ström, G. , Blomquist, G. & Malmberg P. (1986) Collection of airborne microorganisms on nuclepore filters, estimation and analysis-CAMNEA method. Journal of Applied Bacteriology 61, 401-406.

16.

Poulsen, O.M. , Breum, N.O. , Ebbehøj, N. , Hansen, Å.M. , Ivens, U.I. , van Lelieveld, D. , Malmros, P. , Mathiassen, L. , Nielsen, B.H. , Nielsen, E.M. , Schibye, B. , Stenbæk, E.I. & Wilkins, K.C. (1995a) Sorting and recycling of domestic waste. Review of occupational health problems and their possible causes Science Total Environment 168, 33-56.

17.

Poulsen, O.M. , Breum, N.O. , Ebbehøj, N. , Hansen, A.M. , Ivens, U.I. , van Lelieveld, D. , Malmros, P. , Mathiassen, L. , Nielsen, B.H. , Nielsen, E.M. Schibye, B. , Stenblæk, E.I. & Wilkins, K.C. (1995b) Collection of household waste: Review of occupational health problems and their possible causes. Science Total Environment 170, 1-19.

18.

Poulsen, O.M. , Breum, N.O. , Nielsen, B.H. & Nielsen, E.M. (1995c) Bioaerosol exposure in collecting compostable waste kept with the Bates Combi or the Konfiskat system (in Danish). National Institute of Occupational Health, Copenhagen , Denmark.

19.

Thompson, M.W. , Donnelly, J. , Grinshpun, S.A. , Juozaitis, A. & Willeke, K. (1994) Method and test system for evaluation of bioaerosol samplers. Journal of Aerosol Science 25, 1579-1593.

20.

Vincent, J.H. (1987) Recent advances in aspiration theory for thin walled and blunt aerosol sampling probes. Journal of Aerosol Science 18, 487-498.

21.

Weber, S. , Kullman, G. , Petsonk, E. , Jones, W.G. , Olenchock, S. , Sorenson, W. , Parker, J. , Marcelo-Baclu, R. , Frazer, D. & Castranova, V. (1993). Organic dust exposures from compost handling: case presentation and respiratory exposure assessment . American Journal of Industrial Medicine 24, 365-374.