Public Sector Collective Bargaining: A Meta-Review

Abstract

Public sector labor unions and their commitment to collective bargaining are central to the study of public sector human resource management. This study explores collective bargaining scholarship in the United States as exemplified in the public administration literature. Systematically coding 220 articles from the top fifteen (mainstream) peer-reviewed public administration journals over a period of 50 years (1970–2020), this study examines how public sector collective bargaining is framed and conceptualized in public administration research, identifying, and studying the dimensions of public sector collective bargaining research in the United States. The primary purpose of this article is to map trends and gaps in local, state, and federal public sector collective bargaining scholarship, which is an essential public personnel function in need of further academic attention. It is also hoped that this study could stimulate future research into public sector collective bargaining.

Keywords

public sector unions public sector collective bargaining labor unions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abood v. Detroit Board of Education , 431 U.S. 209 (1977).

Adhikari

Waldrop

Wall

(2020). In union, there is strength: How our union benefits our nonprofit’s mission. Nonprofit Quarterly. Retrieved September 27, 2021, from. https://nonprofitquarterly.org/in-union-there-is-strength-how-our-union-benefits-our-nonprofits-mission/

Aleks

Saksida

Kolahgar

(2021). Practice what you preach: The gender pay gap in labor union compensation. Industrial Relations, 60(4), 403–435.

Barzelay

Armajani

B. J.

(1990). Manging state government operations: Changing visions of staff agencies. Journal of Policy Analysis and management, 9(3), 307–338.

Bishow

J. L.

Monaco

(2016). Nonprofit pay and benefits: Estimates from the National Compensation Survey. Monthly Labor Review. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. https://doi.org/10.21916/mlr.2016.4

Bishu

S. G.

Kennedy

A. R.

(2020). Trends and gaps: A meta-review of representative bureaucracy. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 40(4), 559–588.

Blessett

Gaynor

T. S.

(2021). Race, racism and administrative callousness: Using critical race theory for a race-conscious public administration. Public Integrity, 23(5), 455–458.

Bolton

(2021). Ideology, unionization, and personnel politics in the federal budget process. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 31(1), 38–55.

Byrne

Dezhbakhsh

King

(1996). Unions and police productivity: An econometric investigation. Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society, 35(4), 566–584.

10.

Chandler

T. D.

Gely

(1996). Toward identifying the determinants of public-employee unions’ involvement in political activities. The American Review of Public Administration, 26(4), 417–438.

11.

Choi

Chung

I. H.

(2016). Voice effects of public sector unions on turnover: Evidence from teacher contracts. Public Personnel Management, 45(2), 213–233.

12.

Cunningham

G. L.

Avner

M. L.

Justilien

(2014). The urgency of now: Foundations’ role in ending racial inequity. The Foundation Review, 6(1), 6.

13.

Davis

R. L.

(2010). More perfect unions. Harvard University Press.

14.

Davis

R. S.

(2012). Union commitment and stakeholder red tape: How union values shape perceptions of organizational rules. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 33(4), 365–383.

15.

Douglas

J. M.

(1990). Labor relations in public authorities: The New York state experience. Public Studies Journal, 18(4), 1015–1031.

16.

Employee Relations in the Public Service . (1942). A report submitted to the civil service assembly by the committee on employee relations in the public service. Civil Service Assembly of the United States and Canada.

17.

Essex

Milligan

Williams

Weldon

S. M.

(2022). The impact of strike action on patient morbidity: A systematic literature review. International Journal of Health Planning and Management, 37(3), 1311–1326.

18.

European Trade Union Institute. (2013). Worker participation (see footnotes for various citations and dates). Retrieved October 11, 2021, from https://www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Relations/Across-Europe/Trade-Unions2

19.

Falagas

M. E.

Pitsouni

E. I.

Malietzis

G. A.

Pappas

(2008). Comparison of PubMed, Scopus, web of science, and Google scholar: Strengths and weaknesses. The FASEB Journal, 22(2), 338–342.

20.

Fereday

Muir-Cochrane

(2006). Demonstrating rigor using thematic analysis: A hybrid approach of inductive and deductive coding and theme development. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 5(1), 80–92.

21.

Foged

S. K.

Aaskoven

(2017). Public sector unions and privatization: Evidence from the eldercare sector in Danish municipalities. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 27(1), 135–149.

22.

Ford

M. R.

Ihrke

D. M.

(2021). Reform adoption in a postcollective bargaining governance environment. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 41(3), 546–565.

23.

Frymer

Grumbach

J. M.

(2021). Labor unions and white racial politics. American Journal of Political Science, 65(1), 225–240.

24.

Hoeniger

(1941). Individual employment contract under the Wagner Act: I. Fordham Law Review, 10(14), 2.

25.

Holter

(1990). Labor law and the road to Taft-Hartley: Wisconsin’s Little Wagner Act, 1935-1945. Labor Studies Journal, 15(2), 20–47.

26.

Janus v. American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees , 585 U.S. ___; 138 S. Ct. 2448 (2018).

27.

Kearney

R. C.

(1984). Labor relations in the public sector. Marcel Dekker.

28.

Kearney

R. C.

(2010). Public sector labor—Management relations: Change or status Quo? Review of Public Personnel Administration, 30(1), 89–111.

29.

Kearney

R. C.

Mareschal

P. M.

(2014). Labor relations in the public sector (5th ed.). CRC Press.

30.

Lee

Learmonth

Harding

(2008). Queer (y) ing public administration. Public Administration, 86(1), 149–167.

31.

Levi

(1977). Bureaucratic insurgency: The case of police. D. C. Heath.

32.

Lewin

Keefe

J. H.

Kochan

T. A.

(2012). The new great debate about unionism and collective bargaining in US state and local governments. ILR Review, 65(4), 749–778.

33.

Methè

D. T.

Perry

J. L.

(1980). The impacts of collective bargaining on local government services: A review of the research. Public Administration Review, 40(4), 359–371.

34.

Mohiddin

Langat

Orwa

Naanyu

Temmerman

(2022). Exploring the impact of health worker strikes on maternal and child health in a Kenyan county. BMC Health Services Research, 22(1139), 1–9.

35.

Oberfield

(2021). Unionization and street-level bureaucracy: An examination of public school teachers in the United States. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 41(3), 419–446.

36.

Perry

J. L.

(1985). The “old testament”: A litany of beliefs about public sector bargaining. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 5, 1–4.

37.

Peters

J. B.

Masaoka

(2000). A house divided: How nonprofits experience union drives. Nonprofit Management & Leadership, 10(3), 305–317.

38.

Petticrew

Roberts

(2006). Why do we need systematic reviews. Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences: A Practical Guide, 1–26.

39.

Pynes

J. E.

Newman

M. A.

(2001). Nonprofit sector unionization and gender equity: Learning lessons from a case study of a teacher organization in the St. Louis Archdiocese. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 21(1), 5–26.

40.

Reilly

Singla

(2017). Union business leave practices in large U.S. municipalities: An exploratory study. Public Personnel Management, 46(4), 342–367.

41.

Rendon

(2023). Here come the nonprofit unions? The Chronicle of Philathropy. https://www.philanthropy.com/article/here-come-the-nonprofit-unions

42.

Riccucci

N. M.

(2011). Public sector labor relations’ scholarship: Is there a “there,” there? Public Administration Review, 71, 203–209.

43.

Rosenbloom

D. H.

Shafritz

J. M.

(1985). Essentials of labor relations. Reston Publishing.

44.

Selden

S. C.

Sowa

J. E.

Sandfort

(2006). The impact of nonprofit collaboration in early child care and education on management and program outcomes. Public Administration Review, 66(3), 412–425.

45.

Shierholz

(2020). The number of workers represented by a union held steady in 2019, while union membership fell. Economic Policy Institute. Retrieved accessed March 26, 2021, from https://www.epi.org/publication/2019-union-membership-data/

46.

Shivaram

(2022). House votes to allow congressional staffers to unionize. NPR, May 11. Retrieved July 17, 2022, from https://www.npr.org/2022/05/06/1097103804/house-vote-congressional-staffers-unionize

47.

Small

(2022). U.S. museums see rise in unions even as labor movement slumps. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/21/arts/design/museums-unions-labor.html

48.

Sowa

J. E.

Selden

S. C.

Sandfort

J. R.

(2004). No longer unmeasurable? A multidimensional integrated model of nonprofit organizational effectiveness. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 33(4), 711–728.

49.

Spero

S. D.

Capozzola

J. M.

(1973). The urban community and its unionized bureaucracies: Pressure politics in local government labor relations. Dunellen.

50.

Stivers

(1991). Toward a feminist perspective in public administration theory. Women & Politics, 10(4), 49–65.

51.

Thomas

D. R.

(2006). A general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data. American Journal of Evaluation, 27(2), 237–246.

52.

U.K. Office for National Statistics. (2010). Gov.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/department-for-business-energy-and-industrial-strategy/about/statistics, accessed October 11, 2021.

53.

Uman

L. S.

(2011). Systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Journal of the Canadian Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 20(1), 57.

54.

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (1998). Union affiliation of employed wage and salary workers by occupation and industry. https://www.bls.gov/cps/aa1998/AAT42.TXT, accessed September 27, 2021.

55.

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2020). Union affiliation of employed wage and salary workers by occupation and industry. Retrieved September 27, 2021, from https://www.bls.gov/news.release/union2.t03.htm

56.

Warner

K. O.

(1965). Developments in public employee relations: legislative, judicial, administrative.

57.

Waghorne

(1999). Public sector trade unions in the face of privatisation. Development in Practice, 9(5), 557–568.

58.

Walsh

R. E.

(ed.). (1969). Sorry . . . No government today. Beacon Press.

59.

Warner

K. O.

(1963). Management relations with organized public employees. Public Personnel Association.

60.

Wellington

H. H.

Winter

R. K.

Jr. (1972). The unions and the cities. The Brookings Institution.

61.

Zagoria

(ed.). (1965). Developments in public employee relations. Public Personnel Association.

62.

Zagoria

(ed.). (1972). Public workers and public unions. Prentice Hall.