The Effects of Ventilation and Preburn Time on Water Mist Extinguishing of Diesel Fuel Pool Fires

Abstract

The goal of the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Pittsburgh Research Laboratory Fire Fighting and Prevention Program is to reduce the number of fires and fire-related injuries in the mining industry. As part of this effort, water mist is being evaluated for the suppression of underground mine fires, such as fires in diesel fuel storage areas. In this study a series of large-scale fire tests was conducted to investigate the effects of ventilation and preburn time on water mist extinguishing of three diesel fuel pool fires with heat release rates of 230 kW, 1, and 3MW. The experiments were conducted in a simulated underground coal mine diesel fuel storage area under three ventilation conditions: no ventilation, natural ventilation, and forced ventilation and with two preburn times for the no ventilation condition: 30 s and 1 min. Without ventilation the 230kW fire was the most difficult to extinguish; with natural ventilation the 1MW fire took the longest time to extinguish; and with forced ventilation the 3MW fire was the most challenging one. With the 30-s preburn time, the extinguishing time was nearly the same for the 230kW fire as with the 1-min preburn time, while it increased for both 1 and 3MW fires, with the 1MW fire being the most difficult to extinguish. The extinguishing mechanisms including fuel surface cooling, flame cooling, and oxygen depletion and displacement are discussed. The critical water flow rate is estimated for the fires extinguished by the surface cooling mechanism.

Keywords

water mist pool fires fire suppression

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Mawhinney, J.R. , Dlugogorski, B.Z. and Kim, A.K. (1994). A Closer Look at the Fire Extinguishing Properties of Water Mist , In: Fire Safety Science – Proceedings of the Fourth International Symposium, pp. 47–60 .

2. Wighus, R. (1991). Extinguishment of Enclosed Gas Fires with Water Spray , In: Fire Safety Science – Proceedings of the Third International Symposium, pp. 997–1006 .

3. Downie, B. , Polymeropoulos, C. and Gogos, G. (1995). Interaction of Water Mist with a Buoyant Methane Diffusion Flame , Fire Safety Journal, 24: 359–381 .

4. Ndubizu, C.C. , Ananth, R. and Tatem, P.A. (2000). The Effects of Droplet Size and Injection Orientation on Water Mist Suppression of Low and High Boiling Point Liquid Pool Fires , Combustion Science and Technology, 157: 63–86 .

5. Prasad, K. , Li, C. , Kailasanath, K. , Ndubizu, C. , Ananth, R. and Tatem, P.A. (1998). Numerical Modeling of Water Mist Suppression of Methane-air Diffusion Flame , Combustion Science and Technology, 132: 325–364 .

6. Prasad, K. , Li, C. and Kailasanath, K. (1999). Simulation of Water Mist Suppression of Small Scale Methanol Liquid Pool Fires , Fire Safety Journal, 33: 185–212 .

7. Back, G.G. , Beyler, C.L. and Hansen, R. (2002). A Quasi-steady-state Model for Predicting Fire Suppression in Space Protected by Water Mist Systems , Fire Safety Journal, 35: 327–362 .

8. Vaari, J. (2002). A Transient One-zone Computer Model for Total Flooding Water Mist Fire Suppression in Ventilated Enclosures , Fire Safety Journal, 37: 229–257 .

9. NFPA 750 , Standard on Water Mist Fire Protection Systems, 2000 Edition, National Fire Protection Association, Quincy, MA .

10.

10. Grant, G. , Brenton, J. and Drysdale, D. (2000). Fire Suppression by Water Sprays , Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 27: 611–666 .

11.

11. Rasbash, D.J. , Rogowski, Z.W. and Stark, G.W. (1960). Mechanisms of Extinction of Liquid Fires with Water Spray , Combustion and Flame, 4: 223–234 .

12.

12. Rasbash, D.J. (1962). The Extinction of Fires by Water Sprays , Fire Research Abstracts and Reviews, 4: 28–52 .

13.

13. Back, G.G. , Lattimer, B.Y. , Beyler, C.L. , DiNenno, P.J. and Hansen, R. (1999). Full-scale Testing of Water Mist Fire Suppression Systems for Small Machinery Spaces and Spaces with Combustible Boundaries, US Coast Guard, Rpt No. CG-D-21-99, Groton, CT, October.

14.

14. Back, G.G. (1996). Full-scale Tests of Water Mist Fire Suppression Systems for Navy Shipboard Machinery Spaces , Fire Safety Science – Proceedings of Fourth International Symposium, pp. 435–444 .

15.

15. Mawhinney, J.R. (1996). Findings of Experiments Using Water Mist for Fire Suppression in an Electronic Equipment Room , In: Proceedings: Halon Alternatives Technical Working Conference, pp. 15–25 , Albuquerque, New Mexico.

16.

16. Liu, Z.G. and Kim, A.K. (2001). A Review of Water Mist Fire Suppression Technology: Part II – Application Studies , Journal of Fire Protection Engineering, 11: 16-42 .

17.

17. Bill, R.G. , Hansen, R.L. and Richards, K. (1997). Fine-spray (water mist) Protection of Shipboard Engine Rooms , Fire Safety Journal, 29: 317–336 .

18.

18. Yu, H.Z. , Dobson, P.H. , Ferron, R. , Barsamian, C. and Hanna, M. (2002). An Extrapolation Methodology for Pool Fire Extinguishment by Local Application Water Mist Systems , In: Fire Safety Science – Proceedings of Seventh International Symposium, pp. 519–530 .

19.

19. Smith, A.C. and Lazzara, C.P. (1998). Water Mist Suppression of Fires in Underground Diesel Fuel Storage Areas , Annual Conference on Fire Research – Book of Abstracts, pp. 111–112 , Gaithersburg, MD.

20.

20. Smith, A.C. and Lazzara, C.P. (2003). Water Mist Suppression of Fires in Underground Coal Mine Diesel Fuel Storage Areas , Workshop on Fire Suppression Technologies – CD ROM of Abstracts, February, Mobile, AL.

21.

21. Liu, Z.G. , Kim, A.K. and Su, J.Z. (2001). Examination of Performance of Water Mist Fire Suppression Systems under Ventilation Conditions , Journal of Fire Protection Engineering, 11: 164–193 .

22.

22. Lefebvre, A.H. (1989). Atomization and Sprays, Taylor & Francis, New York .

23.

23. Orloff, L. and De Ris, J. (1982). Froude Modeling of Pool Fires, Nineteenth Symposium (International) on Combustion, pp. 885–895, The Combustion Institute .

24.

24. Tewarson, A. , Lee, J.L. and Pion, R.F. (1981). The Influence of Oxygen Concentration on Fuel Parameters for Fire Modeling, Eighteenth Symposium (International) on Combustion, pp. 563–570, The Combustion Institute .

25.

25. Albert, R.L. (1992). Modeling of Sprinkler Spray Suppression of Fires , Proceedings of the First International Conference on Fire Suppression Research, pp. 245–260 , Sweden.

26.

26. Heskestad, G. (1984). Engineering Relations for Fire Plumes , Fire Safety Journal, 7: 25–32 .

27.

27. Peatross, M.J. and Beyler, C.L. (1997). Ventilation Effects on Compartment Fire Characterization , Fire Safety Science – Proceedings of the Fifth International Symposium, pp. 403–414 .

28.

28. Burgess, D.S. , Grumer, J. and Wolfhard, H.G. (1961). Burning Rates of Liquid Fuels in Large and Small Open Trays , International Symposium on the Use of Models in Fire Research, pp. 68–75 .