An improved model for estimating heat release rate in horizontal cable tray fires in open space

Abstract

Electric cable fires in nuclear power plants could be disastrous and have to be studied carefully for safety and economic considerations. Based on the results of previous work on large-scale and bench-scale cable fire testing, the Flame Spread over Horizontal Cable Trays model was modified and improved to estimate the heat release rate of large-scale cable fires using bench-scale measured data. The heat release rate per unit area measured in the cone calorimeter experiment is taken as the input, to avoid introducing any prediction uncertainties caused by inconsistent values of the heat of combustion and char yield of the cable. Cable fire experiments with vertical stacks of trays with one to three layers of cables were conducted in open space to assess the accuracy of the improved model. In comparing with the experimental results, predictions using the improved model are encouraging. The local error of prediction is less than 15% and the global error lies between 19.2% and 35.7%. In addition, three cable tray fire experiments with data available in the literature were used to validate the improved model. It is shown that the improved model had good predictions for these cable tray fires.

Keywords

Cable tray fire improved Flame Spread over Horizontal Cable Trays model heat release rate open space

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Sung

ACM

Chow

Han

et al . Preliminary full-scale burning tests of electric cables. J Appl Fire Sci 2004; 12(4): 335–352.

Lee

Chow

Hung

. A study on residential fires due to electrical faults in Hong Kong. In: Proceedings of the 3rd residential building design and construction (RBDC) conference, Penn State University, State College, PA, 2–3 March 2016, pp. 369–379. The Pennsylvania Housing Research Center: The Pennsylvania State University, USA.

Hirschler

. Analysis of and potential correlations between fire tests for electrical cables, and how to use this information for fire hazard assessment. Fire Technol 1997; 33(4): 291–315.

Holt

Keong

. Fire protection of cables. Proactive Fire Trends 2004; 7(1): 42004–42006.

BS 6336:1998. Guide to the development of fire tests: the presentation of test data and the role of tests in hazard assessment.

BS EN 61537:2002. Cable tray systems and cable ladder systems for cable management.

NFPA 262. Standard method of test for flame travel and smoke of wires and cables for use in air-handling spaces. Quincy, MA: National Fire Protection Association, 2002.

ASTM D6113-03. Standard test method for using a cone calorimeter to determine fire-test-response characteristics of insulating materials contained in electrical or optical fiber cables. West Conshohocken, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials International, 2003.

ASTM D5537-03. Standard test method for heat release, flame spread, smoke obscuration, and mass loss testing of insulating materials contained in electrical or optical fiber cables when burning in a vertical cable tray configuration. West Conshohocken, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials International, 2003.

10.

Elliot

Whiteley

. A cone calorimeter test for the measurement of flammability properties of insulated wire. Polym Degrad Stabil 1999; 64: 577–584.

11.

Beyer

Breulet

Desmet

. Cone calorimeter experiments with flame retardant halogen-free cables. In: Proceedings of the 220th ACS national meeting, Washington, DC, 20–24 August 2000, vol. 2, p. 103. Washington, DC: American Chemical Society.

12.

Werner

Angner

Rowekam

et al . The OECD fire database-conclusion from phase 2 and outlook. In: Proceedings of the 11th international post-conference on fire safety in nuclear power plants and installations, Helsinki, 17–19 August 2009.

13.

Talbert

. Remembering the Browns Ferry fire, 40 years on. Nucl Eng Int 2015; 60: 20–21.

14.

Grayson

Van Hees

Green

et al . Assessing the fire performance of electric cables. Fire Mater 2001; 25: 49–60.

15.

Van Hees

Axelsson

Green

et al . Mathematical modelling of fire development in cable installations. Fire Mater 2001; 25: 169–178.

16.

Ferng

Liu

. Investigating the burning characteristics of electric cables used in the nuclear power plant by way of 3-D transient FDS code. Nucl Eng Des 2011; 241: 88–94.

17.

Courty

Garo

. External heating of electrical cables and auto-ignition investigation. J Hazard Mater 2017; 321: 528–536.

18.

Van Hees

Thureson

. Burning behavior of cables: modelling of flame spread. BRANDFORSK project 725–942, SP report 1996:30, 1 January 1996. Boras: Swedish National Testing and Research Institute.

19.

Lee

. Heat release rate characteristics of some combustible fuel sources in Nuclear Power Plants (NBSIR 85-3195). Gaithersburg, MD: National Bureau of Standards, 1985.

20.

McGrattan

Barehan

Stroup

et al . Cable heat release, ignition, and spread in tray installations during fire (CHRISTIFIRE), phase 1: horizontal trays. Report NUREG/CR-7010, vol. 1, 2012, p. 149, Nuclear Regulatory Research, Washington, DC.

21.

Zavaleta

Charbaut

Basso

et al . Multiple horizontal cable tray fire in open atmosphere. In: Proceedings of the fire and materials 2013 conference, San Francisco, CA, 28–30 January 2013. London: Interscience Communications Ltd.

22.

Beji

Verstockt

Zavaleta

et al . Flame spread monitoring and estimation of the heat release rate from a cable tray fire using video fire analysis. Fire Technol 2016; 52: 611–621.

23.

Quintiere

. Fundamentals of fire phenomena. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2006.

24.

Audouin

Chandra

Consalvi

et al . Quantifying differences between computational results and measurements in the case of a large-scale well-confined fire scenario. Nucl Eng Des 2011; 241: 18–31.