There Are No Lone Wolves: The Role of Civil Society in Aiding and Abetting Domestic Terrorists

Abstract

This paper focuses on the role Deviant Voluntary Associations (DVAs) play in the radicalizing of domestic terrorists associated with the alt-right in the United States and the outsized role social media plays in forming social capital bonds with those who become lone wolves. Drawing on Rousseau and Nietzsche, we explore the theoretical roots of the American political system particularly and liberalism more generally to better understand how violent acts such as these are deeply enmeshed in American culture. The contemporary case of paramilitary groups in the United States is explored, arguing the use of violence by these groups to achieve their ends has enabled the actions of the misnamed “lone wolf.” We end with recommendations for additional research on DVAs and civil society to further explore the connection between liberalism and nationalism, delve into the interaction of populism and civil society, document the fracture of civil religion through increased partisanship, and investigate the concomitant closing of civic spaces in the United States.

Keywords

Deviant Voluntary Associations domestic terrorism civil society nonprofit

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alves

M. A.

(2022). 4 Civil society studies in Brazil: From third sector to uncivil society? In Biekart

Fowler

(Eds.), A research agenda for civil society (pp. 45–54). Edward Elgar Publishing.

Amman

Meloy

J. R.

(2021). Stochastic terrorism. Perspectives on Terrorism, 15(5), 2–13.

Anderson

T. L.

(2019). Herrenvolk democracy: The rise of the Alt-Right in Trump’s America. In Battista

C. M.

Sande

M. R.

(Eds.), Critical theory and the humanities in the age of the Alt-Right (pp. 81–99). Springer Verlag.

Angus

(2022). Swallowing the Black Pill: Involuntary Celibates’ (Incels) anti feminism within digital society. International Journal for Crime Justice and Social Democracy, 11(1), 210–224.

Ansell-Pearson

(1991). Nietzsche contra Rousseau: A study of Nietzsche’s moral and political thought. Cambridge University Press.

Baele

S. J.

Brace

Coan

T. G.

(2021). Variations on a theme? Comparing 4chan, 8kun, and other chans’ far-right “/pol” boards. Perspectives on Terrorism, 15(1), 65–80.

Belew

(2018). Bring the war home. Harvard University Press.

Biondi

Curtis

(2019). From structural to stochastic violence. In Biondi

(Ed.), Authoritarianism and confinement in the Americas (pp. 46–52). Editora da UEMA.

Brombo

(2021). The interaction among populism, civil society organisations and European institutions. In Ruzza

Berti

Coassarini

(Eds.), The impact of populism on European Institutions and civil society: Discourses, practices, and policies (pp. 219–242). Palgrave Macmillan.

10.

Burke

(2017). The myth of the ‘lone wolf’ terrorist. The Guardian, 30.

11.

Byman

(2022). Spreading hate: The global rise of white supremacist terrorism. Oxford University Press.

12.

Campani

Fabelo Concepción

Rodriguez Soler

Sánchez Savín

(2022). The rise of Donald Trump right-wing populism in the United States: Middle American radicalism and anti-immigration discourse. Societies, 12(6), 154.

13.

Campbell

A. B.

(2022). We are proud boys: How a right-wing street gang ushered in a new era of American extremism. Hachette Books.

14.

Castle

J. J.

Stepp

K. K.

(2021). Partisanship, religion, and issue polarization in the United States: A reassessment. Political Behavior, 43, 1311–1335.

15.

Chavez

W. S.

McCracken

(2021). “He who laughs last!” Terrorists, nihilists, and jokers. Journal of Religion & Film, 25(1), 67.

16.

Chimiak

(2022). The Polish case: From darling to endangered species? In Biekart

Fowler

(Eds.), A research agenda for civil society (pp. 255–269). Edward Elgar Publishing.

17.

Della Porta

Steinhilper

(2021). Shrinking spaces and civil society contestation: An introduction. In Della Porta

Steinhilper

(Eds.), Contentious migrant solidarity (pp. 1–18). Routledge.

18.

Department of Homeland Security. (2022, October). Strategic intelligence assessment and data on domestic terrorism. https://www.fbi.gov/file-repository/fbi-dhs-domestic-terrorism-strategic-report-2022.pdf/view

19.

Dupuy

Fransen

Prakash

(2021). Restricting NGOs: From pushback to accommodation. Global Policy, 12, 5–10.

20.

Eng

Smith

D. H.

Al-Ekry

A. H.

Brilliant

E. L.

Farruggia

Faulkner

Subianto

(2016). Crime, misconduct, and dysfunctions in and by associations. In David Horton

Jurgen

Stebbins Robert

(Eds.), The Palgrave handbook of volunteering, civic participation, and nonprofit associations (pp. 1331–1359). Palgrave Macmillan.

21.

Finley

Esposito

(2020). The immigrant as bogeyman: Examining Donald Trump and the right’s anti-immigrant, anti-PC rhetoric. Humanity & Society, 44(2), 178–197.

22.

Flynn

Gerhardt

(1990). The silent brotherhood: Inside America's racist underground (Vol. 6786). Aware Journalism.

23.

Frazier

(2023, May 30). Jan. 6 sentences are piling up. Here’s a look at some of the longest handed down. Politico.com. https://www.politico.com/news/2023/05/30/january-6-arrest-sentencing-00099158

24.

Futrell

Simi

(2017). The [un] surprising alt-right. Contexts, 6(2), 76.

25.

Gaufman

Ganesh

(2024). The Trump Carnival: Populism, transgression and the far right (Vol. 35). Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co.

26.

Ghatak

Gold

Prins

B. C.

(2019). Domestic terrorism in democratic states: Understanding and addressing minority grievances. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 63(2), 439–467.

27.

Gius

(2012). Encountering the ‘other’, or encountering the self? The construction of otherness into voluntourism experiences. In McGarry

Stasiewicz-Bieńkowska

(Eds.), Landscapes of (Un) belonging: Reflections of strangeness and self (pp. 29–41). Brill.

28.

Gorski

(2019). American covenant: A history of civil religion from the puritans to the present. Princeton University Press.

29.

Habeshian

(2023, September 5). Here are the harshest punishments yet for Jan. 6 rioters. Axios.com. https://www.axios.com/2023/09/01/jan-6-longest-sentences-list

30.

Haines

(2024). Christian citizens in a democratic state: Is a true separation of church and state really possible? Religion, 15(3), 262.

31.

Hamm

Spaaj

(2015). Lone Wolf Terrorism in America: Using knowledge of radicalization pathways to forge prevention strategies. JurPC, 15-. https://www.ojp.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/248691.pdf

32.

Hawkins

Chinn

(2024). Populist views of science: how social media, political affiliation, and Alt-Right support affect scientific attitudes in the United States. Information Communication & Society, 27(3), 520–537.

33.

Hawley

(2018). The alt-right: what everyone needs to know. Oxford University Press.

34.

Hermansson

Lawrence

Mulhall

Murdoch

(2020). The international alt-right. Routledge.

35.

Institute for Economics & Peace. (2024). 2024 Global Terrorism Index. https://www.economicsandpeace.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/GTI-2024-web-290224.pdf.

36.

Johnson

P. E.

(2022). I the people: The rhetoric of conservative populism in the United States. University of Alabama Press.

37.

Kayyem

(2022, May 15). A ‘lone wolf’ shooter has an online pack. The Atlantic.

38.

Kelly

C. R.

(2020). Donald J. Trump and the rhetoric of ressentiment. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 106(1), 2–24. https://doi.org/10.1080/00335630.2019.1698756

39.

Kim

(2023). Violent political rhetoric on Twitter. Political Science Research and Methods, 11(4), 673–695.

40.

Klein

(2019). From Twitter to Charlottesville: Analyzing the fighting words between the alt-right and Antifa. Journal of International Communication, 13, 22.

41.

Kleinfeld

(2024). Closing civic space in the United States: Connecting the dots, changing the trajectory. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/03/closing-civic-space-in-the-united-states-connecting-the-dots-changing-the-trajectory?lang=en

42.

Kriner

Lewis

(2021). Pride & prejudice: The violent evolution of the proud boys. CTC Sentinel, 14(6), 26–38.

43.

Liu

(2020). Political polarization in the United States: The influences of exceptionalism and religion. International Social Science Review, 96(2): 1–24.

44.

Love

Karabinus

(2020). Creation of an Alt-Left Boogeyman: Information circulation and the emergence of ‘Antifa’. In Jones

John

Trice

(Eds.), Platforms, protests, and the challenge of networked democracy (pp. 173–198). Palgrave Macmillan.

45.

Lux

Jordan

J. D.

(2019). Alt-Right ‘cultural purity’, ideology and mainstream social policy discourse: Towards a political anthropology of ‘mainstremeist’ ideology. In Social policy review (Vol. 31, pp. 151–176). Bristol University Press.

46.

McDermott

(2020). Whiteness in America. Polity.

47.

McMillan

Schechner

(2021, January 19). Before suicide, French programmer made bitcoin bequests to pro-trump groups; FBI has been briefed on mysterious transactions as it investigates potential foreign funding of far-right groups in the U.S., according to people familiar with the matter. Wall Street Journal (Online). https://www.wsj.com/politics/policy/before-suicide-french-programmer-made-bitcoin-bequest-to-pro-trump-groups-11611023163?gaa_at=eafs&gaa_n=ASWzDAgo8D5jeITn_3HOJAqaAA3cs23PxA1J429Irsvn5Wp1Ac7L7pM6Rrg1DQjgEmU%3D&gaa_ts=6897beb7&gaa_sig=aLb169HSC7WUSh6RqMuGlv7ppsaVJU4bft0Tfyvr1i5ucPo1Tc_B2hBf2u8VV9MkDvov_2ThOADt6dhWiZqHow%3D%3D

48.

Mearsheimer

J. J.

(2021). Liberalism and nationalism in contemporary America. Political Science and Politics, 54(1), 1–8.

49.

Mirabella

Mott

W. K.

(2022). 5 Civic deviance and lawlessness: The aftermath of January 6, 2021. In Biekart

Fowler

(Eds.), A research agenda for civil society (pp. 55–68). Edward Elgar Publishing.

50.

Mirrlees

(2022). Alt-Right. In Atkinson

Ayres

(Eds.), Shades of deviance: A primer on crime, deviance and social harm (pp. 47–54). Routledge.

51.

Moffitt

(2024). What was the ‘Alt’ in Alt-Right, Alt-Lite, and Alt-Left? On ‘Alt’ as a political modifier. Political Studies, 72, 903–923.

52.

Monahan

M. J.

(2021). Racism and “self-love”: The case of White nationalism. Critical Philosophy of Race, 9(1), 1–15.

53.

Mpagi

(2022). The impact of shrinking civic space on youth activism, the resilience of civil society, and social sustainability. Department of Earth Sciences, Upsala University.

54.

Mulloy

D. J.

(2021). Years of rage: White supremacy in the United States from the Klan to the alt-right. Rowman & Littlefield.

55.

Munn

(2019). Alt-right pipeline: Individual journeys to extremism online. First Monday 24(6).

56.

New York Times. (2024a, July 19). Read the transcript of Donald J. Trump’s convention speech. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/19/us/politics/trump-rnc-speech-transcript.html

57.

New York Times. (2024b, July 18). Read the transcript of J.D. Vance’s convention speech. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/17/us/politics/read-the-transcript-of-jd-vances-convention-speech.html

58.

Nietzsche

(1994). On the genealogy of morality ( Diethe

, Trans.). Cambridge University Press. (Original work published 1887).

59.

Nietzsche

Kaufmann

W. A.

(1968). On the genealogy of morals. Vintage Books.

60.

NPR. (2022, July 12). Here’s every word from the seventh Jan. 6 committee hearing on its investigation. NPR. https://www.npr.org/2022/07/12/1111123258/jan-6-committee-hearing-transcript.

61.

Oluo

(2020). Mediocre: The dangerous legacy of white male America. Seal Press.

62.

Ott

J. S.

Dicke

(2021). The nature of the nonprofit sector. Routledge.

63.

Polletta

(1999). “Free spaces” in collective action. Theory and Society, 28(1), 1–38.

64.

Putnam

(2000). Bowling alone: Collapse and revival of American community. Simon & Schuster.

65.

Reeves

(2022). Rhetoric, violence, and the subject of civility. Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies, 19(1), 91–108.

66.

Robin

(2017). The reactionary mind: Conservatism from Edmund Burke to Donald Trump. Oxford.

67.

Roggeband

Krizsán

(2021). The selective closure of civic space. Global Policy, 12, 23–33.

68.

Rothschild

(2021). The storm is upon us: How QAnon became a movement, cult, and conspiracy theory of everything. Melville House.

69.

Rousseau

J. J.

(2011). The basic political writings ( Cress

, Trans. & Ed.). Hackett Publishing Company. (Original work published 1755).

70.

Rovelli

(2022). There are places in the world where rules are less important than kindness: And other thoughts on Physics, philosophy and the world. Penguin.

71.

Samar

V. J.

(2023). Finding the correct balance between the free exercise of religion and the establishment clauses. The First Amendment Law Review, 21, 109.

72.

Santis

E. L.

(2022). Otherness: An unfinished project in public administration. Administrative Theory & Praxis, 44(2), 133–142.

73.

Schragger

Schwartzman

Tebbe

(2024). Reestablishing religion. The University of Chicago Law Review, 92, 199.

74.

Simi

(2010). Why study white supremacist terror? A research note. Deviant Behavior, 31(3), 251–273.

75.

Smith

D. H.

(2017). Misconduct and deviance by nonprofit organizations. In A

Farazmand

(Ed.), Global encyclopedia of public administration, public policy, and governance (pp. 8197–8206). Springer Nature.

76.

Smith

D. H.

(2019). A review of deviant nonprofit groups: Seeking method in their alleged ‘madness-treason-immorality’. Voluntaristics Review, 3(5-6), 1–206.

77.

Smith

D. H.

(2020). Nonprofits daring to be different as moral dark energy improving the world: A review of deviant voluntary associations. Voluntaristics Review, 5(1), 1–65.

78.

Stewart

(2020). The rise of far-right civilizationism. Critical Sociology, 46(7-8), 1207–1220.

79.

Strachwitz

R. G.

Toepler

(2022). Contested civic spaces in liberal democracies. Nonprofit Policy Forum, 13(3), 179–193.

80.

Taylor

(2020). Alt-right. In Casey

Z. A.

(Ed.), Encyclopedia of critical whiteness studies in education (pp. 15–22). Brill.

81.

Vance

J. D.

(2016). Hillbilly elegy. William Collins.

82.

Van Tatenhove

(2023). The perils of extremism: How I left the oath keepers and why we should be concerned about a future civil war. Skyhorse Publishing.

83.

Weinberg

Pedahzur

Perliger

(2008). Political parties and terrorist groups (Vol. 10). Routledge.