Marketers’ use of the new information technologies has provided the opportunity for improved market segmentation and target marketing. However, the profession faces ethical conflicts because application of these technologies commonly invades consumer privacy. The authors examine the ethical dimensions of marketing practice in relation to consumer privacy. The meaning of privacy in a marketing context is explored and specific marketing threats to consumer privacy are described. After examining current and potential mechanisms to safeguard consumer privacy, the authors conclude that marketers must make an active commitment to ethical behavior in this area if restrictive legislation is to be avoided.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AkeroydAnne V. (1988), “Ethnography, Personal Data and Computers: The Implications of Data Protection Legislation for Qualitative Social Research,”Studies in Qualitative Methodology, 1, 179–219.
2.
BirnbaumJeffrey H. (1991), “House Says ‘Sorry, Wrong Number’ to Telephone Sales,”Wall Street Journal (November 19)B1.
3.
BloomPaul N., MilneGeorge R., and AdlerRobert (1992), A Framework for Identifying the Legal and Political Risks of Using New Information Technologies to Support Marketing Programs: Commentary, Report No. 92-102 (February). Cambridge, MA: Marketing Science Institute.
4.
BuchholzRogene A. (1989), Fundamental Concepts and Problems in Business Ethics.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
5.
BulkeleyWilliam M. (1992), “Congress's ‘Cure’ for Junk Calls Faces a Skeptical FCC,”Wall Street Journal (May 19)B14.
6.
ChaumDavid (1985), “Security Without Identification: Transaction Systems To Make Big Brother Obsolete,”Communications of the Association for Computing Machinery, 28(October), 1030–44.
ClarkLorenne M. G. (1978), “Privacy, Property, Freedom, and the Family,” in Philosophical Law: Authority, Equality, Adjudication, Privacy, BronaughRichard, ed. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 167–87.
10.
Computer Professionals for Social Responsibility (1992), “Clinton/Gore Campaign Pledges Strong Consumer Protections; Blasts Bush/Quayle Record” (excerpt), Computer Privacy Digest (Internet electronic mail digest), 1 (95, October 26), message 7.
11.
Della PostaMelissa (1989), “List Restrictions Loom as Privacy Debate Heats Up,”Catalog Age, 6(August), 1, 28–30.
12.
EatonJoseph W. (1986), Card-Carrying Americans: Privacy, Security, and the National ID Card.Totowa, NJ: Rowman & Littlefield.
FreedmanWarren (1987), The Right to Privacy in the Computer Age.New York: Quorum Books.
16.
GerberickDahl A., ed. (1976), Privacy, Security, and the Information Processing Industry, a report of the Association for Computing Machinery, Los Angeles Chapter, Ombudsman Committee on Privacy. New York: Association for Computing Machinery.
17.
GillmorDonald M., BarronJerome A., SimonTodd F., and TerryHerbert A. (1990), Mass Communication Law.St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co.
18.
GoodwinCathy (1991), “Privacy: Recognition of a Consumer Right,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 10(Spring), 149–66.
19.
HallCarl T. (1992), “Pacific Bell Caller ID Approved But Company May Drop Plan Because of PUC Restrictions,”San Francisco Chronicle (June 18)A1.
20.
HibbertChris (1992), What to Do When They Ask For Your Social Security Number, contribution to Internet discussion list “alt.privacy” (October 27).
21.
HumeScott (1992), “McD's May Be Fried by Database Rental,”Advertising Age (March 30)1.
22.
JohnsonDeborah G. (1985), Computer Ethics.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
23.
JonesMary Gardiner (1991), “Privacy: A Significant Marketing Issue for the 1990s,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 10(Spring), 133–48.
24.
Katz v. United States (1967), 389 U.S. 347.
25.
KonradWalecia, and PowerChristopher (1992), “Smoking Out the Elusive Smoker,”Business Week (March 16)62–3.
26.
LacayoRichard (1991), “Nowhere to Hide,”Time (November 11)34–40.
27.
LevinGary (1992), “DMA to Battle Tougher Privacy Laws,”Advertising Age (November 2)15.
28.
Marketing News (1992), “Computer Dial Ban Overturned” (April 27), 1.
29.
MarxGary (1991), “Privacy and Technology,”Whole Earth Review (Winter), 90.
MillerMichael W. (1991a), “Firms Peddle Information From Driver's Licenses,”Wall Street Journal (November 25)B1.
32.
MillerMichael W. (1991b), “As Phone Technology Swiftly Advances, Fears Grow They'll Have Your Number,”Wall Street Journal (December 13)B1.
33.
MillerMichael W., moderator (1992), “Tech Talk: An On-Line Discussion—Via an Electronic Bulletin Board—of the Risks of the Computer Revolution,”Wall Street Journal (April 6)R12.
34.
MurphyPatrick E., and Dee PridgenM. (1991), “Ethical and Legal Issues in Marketing,” in Advances in Marketing and Public Policy: A Research Annual, Vol. 2, BloomPaul N., ed. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, Inc., 185–244.
35.
Paul v. Davis (1976), 424 U.S. 693.
36.
Privacy Protection Study Commission (1977), Personal Privacy in an Information Society.Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
37.
PyleChristopher H. (1982), “The Invasion of Privacy,” in The Communications Revolution in Politics, BenjaminGerald, ed. New York: Academy of Political Science, 131–42.
38.
RogersC. B.Jr. (1992), “Credit-Reporting Reform: Everyone Is a Winner” (letter to the editor), Business Week (June 22)10.
39.
RoseJeffrey J. (1992), “Technology Pits Privacy vs. Information Age,”San Diego Union (June 7)A1.
40.
RuleJames, McAdamDouglas, StearnsLinda, and UglowDavid (1980), The Politics of Privacy: Planning for Personal Data Systems as Powerful Technologies.New York: Elsevier Science Publishing Company, Inc.
41.
SchwartzEvan I. (1992), “Snooping on the Behalf of the Right to Privacy,”Business Week (June 29)39–40.
SmithGlenn Chatmas (1989), “We've Got Your Number! (Is It Constitutional To Give It Out?): Caller Identification Technology and the Right to Informational Privacy,”UCLA Law Review (October), 145–223.
44.
SpiegelmanArthur (1992), “American Express Agrees to Tell Cardholders About Profile Data,”Boston Globe (May 14)39.
45.
SurteesLawrence (1992), “Telephone Privacy Gets Hard Look,”Toronto Globe and Mail (June 30)B3.
46.
TaffAnita (1990), “FCC May Be Referee in Caller ID Dispute; N.Y. Engineer Asks the Commission to Examine His Proposal to Solve the Sticky Privacy Issue,”Network World (September 10)13.
47.
United States Code Congressional and Administrative News (1991), 102nd Congress-First Session, Vol. 3. St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co.
48.
WasserstromRichard A. (1978), “Privacy: Some Arguments and Assumptions,” in Philosophical Law: Authority, Equality, Adjudication, Privacy, BronaughRichard, ed., Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 148–66.
49.
WestinAlan F. (1992), “Privacy: A Private Future,”American Demographics, 14(August), 19.
50.
WestinAlan F., and BakerMichael A. (1972), Databanks in a Free Society: Computers, Record-Keeping and Privacy.New York: Quandrangle/The New York Times Book Co.
