After the 1989 sea trout collapse in the west of Ireland, the angling community (which includes private fishery owners) attributed the collapse to coastal salmon farms, but the salmon farming community linked the sea trout collapse to environmental factors. The contending parties raised issues which are assessed here through the literature on environmental protests and the sociology of science. This paper then provides an analysis of the sea trout dispute as a conflict between angling interests and fish farming interests over the legitimate use of aquatic resources in rural Ireland. By drawing upon interview data, and government and industry publications, it will show that the dynamics of the sea trout conflict delineates the sociocultural context of science in the disputing process, as well as the nature of social change in rural Ireland.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenR.JonesT., 1990. Guests of the Nation: People of Ireland versus the Multinationals. London: Earthscan Publications.
Aquaculture Ireland. 1991. ‘Sources of State and EC Financial Assistance for Aquaculture Development’, Aquaculture Ireland. Autumn, pp.18–19, 29.
4.
BaileyC.JentoftS.SinclairP., 1996. ‘Social Science Contributions to Aquacultural Development’, pp.3–22 in BaileyC.JentoftS.SinclairP. (eds), Aquacultural Development: Social Dimensions of an Emerging Industry. Boulder: Westview Press.
5.
BeckU.1992. Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. London: Sage.
6.
FáilteBord. 1994. Developing Sustainable Tourism: Tourism Development Plan 1994–1999. Dublin: Bord Fáilte.
7.
BrophyP.DunnJ.W.CuddyM.P., 1991. ‘The Impact of Fishing on Irish Coastal Regions’, pp.63–113 in WhitakerT. K., Review of Common Fisheries Policy: Report of Advisory Group. Government of Ireland.
8.
ButtelF.TaylorP., 1994. ‘Environmental Sociology and Global Environmental Change’, pp.225–55 in RedcliftM.BentonT., (eds). Social Theory and the Global Environment. London and New York: Routledge.
9.
CallonM.1986. ‘Some Elements of a Sociology of Translation: Domestication of the Scallops and the Fishermen of St. Brieuc Bay’, pp.196–233 in LawJ. (ed.), Power, Action and Belief: A New Sociology of Knowledge?London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
10.
Central Fisheries Board. 1986. Inland Fisheries: Strategies for Management and Development. Dublin: Central Fisheries Board.
11.
Cork Examiner. 1995. Fish, Food Bodies to Merge. 6 February.
12.
CrookS.PakulskiJ.WatersM., 1992. Postmodernization: Changes in Advanced Society. London: Sage.
13.
CurtinC.VarleyT., 1991. ‘Populism and Petit Capitalism in Rural Ireland’, pp.97–119 in WhatmoreSarahLowePhilipMarsdenTerry (eds), Rural Enterprise: Shifting Perspectives on Small-Scale Production. London: David Fulton.
14.
CurtinC.VarleyT., 1989. ‘Brown Trout, ‘Gentry’ and Dutchmen: Tourism and Development in South Mayo’, pp.207–22 in CurtinC.WilsonT. M. (eds), Ireland From Below: Social Change and Local Communities. Galway: Galway University Press.
15.
CurtinC.ShieldsD., 1988. ‘The Legal Process and the Control of Mining Development in the West of Ireland’, pp.109–28 in TomlinsonM.VarleyT.McCullaghC. (eds), Whose Law and Order?: Aspects of Crime and Social Control in Irish Society. Sociological Association of Ireland.
16.
Department of the Marine. 1995a. Report of the Sea Trout Working Croup 1994. Abbotstown: Fisheries Research Centre.
17.
Department of the Marine. 1995b. ‘Appendix 5: Supplement to the 1993 Report of the Sea Trout Working Group’, pp.199–244 in Department of the Marine. 1995a. Report of the Sea Trout Working Group 1994. Abbotstown: Fisheries Research Centre.
18.
EklundE.‘Aquaculture in the Baltic Sea: Regional Development and Environmental Conflict’, pp.59–68 in BaileyC.JentoftS.SinclairP. (eds), Aquacultural Development: Social Dimensions of an Emerging Industry. Boulder: Westview Press.
19.
FinlaysonA. C.1994. Fishing For Truth: A Sociological Assessment of Northern Cod Stock Assessments from 1977–1990. St. John's: Institute of Social and Economic Research.
20.
Food and Agricultural Organization. 1992. Aquaculture Production 1984–1990: FAO Fisheries Circular No. 815. Revision 4. Rome: Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations.
21.
Green 2000 Advisory Group. 1993. Green 2000 Advisory Group: Executive Summary and Technical Papers. Report Presented to the Taoiseach Mr. Albert Reynolds, T.D. February 1993.
22.
de G. GriffithDavid1995. ‘Forward’ to ‘Appendix 5: Supplement to the 1993 Report of the Sea Trout Working Group’, pp.200–01 in Department of the Marine. 1995a. Report of the Sea Trout Working Group 1994. Abbotstown: Fisheries Research Centre.
23.
Inland Fisheries Commission. 1975. Report of the Inland Fisheries Commission. Dublin: Department of Agriculture and Fisheries.
24.
Irish Salmon Growers' Association. 1995. New Research Points Towards an Alternative Hypothesis to Explain the Sea Trout Collapse. Dublin: Irish Salmon Growers' Association.
25.
Irish Salmon Growers' Association. 1992. Preliminary Review of Sea-Trout Problems and Research to December 1991. Dublin: Irish Salmon Growers' Association.
26.
Irish Times, 1996. Letter to the Editor, 28 June.
27.
JacksonD.Dr.1995. ‘Appendix 7’, p.252 in Department of the Marine. 1995a. Report of the Sea Trout Working Group 1994. Abbotstown: Fisheries Research Centre.
28.
KearyB.1993. Aquaculture Legislation in Ireland: An Examination and Critique of Section 54 of the Fisheries Act 1980. Galway: Galway Social Sciences Research Centre.
29.
KlandermansBert. 1992. ‘New Social Movements and Resource Mobilization: The European and American Approaches Revisited’, pp.17–44 in RuchtDieter (ed.), Research on Social Movements: The State of the Art in Western Europe and the USA. Boulder: Westview Press.
30.
LoweP.CoxG.O'RiordanT.MacEwenM.WinterM., 1986. Countryside Conflicts: The Politics of Farming, Forestry and Conservation. Aldershot: Gower.
31.
MantleP.ThompsonK., 1993. ‘Economic Importance of Gamefishing to Galway and Mayo’, pp.63–65 in MeldonJ. (ed.), Aquaculture in Ireland - Towards Sustainability. Dublin: An Taisce.
32.
MarsdenT.MurdochJ.LoweP.MuntonR.FlynnA., 1992. Constructing the Countryside. UCL Press.
33.
McMahonB. M. E.BinchyW., 1990. Irish Law of Torts. Second Edition. Dublin: Butterworth (Ireland) Limited.
34.
MurphyK.1995. ‘Appendix 8’, pp.253–54 in Department of the Marine. 1995a. Report of the Sea Trout Working Group 1994. Abbotstown: Fisheries Research Centre.
35.
O'ConnorR.WhelanB. J.CrutchfieldJ. A. with O'SullivanA.J., 1992. Review of the Irish Aquaculture Sector And Recommendations For Its Development. Dublin: The Economic and Social Research Institute.
36.
O'ConnorR.1993. Fishing. Dublin: unpublished paper, Economic and Social Research Institute.
PhyneJ.1996a. ‘Balancing Social Equity and Environmental Integrity in Ireland's Salmon Farming Industry’. Society and Natural Resources, 9: 281–93.
40.
PhyneJ.1996b. ‘Along the Coast and in the State: Aquaculture and Politics in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick’, pp.69–92 in BaileyC.JentoftS.SinclairP. (eds), Aquacultural Development: Social Dimensions of an Emerging Industry. Boulder: Westview Press.
41.
PhyneJ.1995. ‘From ‘Sites of Production’ to ‘Arenas for Consumption’: Shifting Directions in Rural Sociology’, pp. 1–31 in BeesleyK. B.MacIntoshP. J. (eds), Rural Research in the Humanities and Social Sciences II. Truro, Nova Scotia: Rural Research Centre.
42.
RedcliftM.BentonT. (eds). 1994. Social Theory and the Global Environment. London and New York: Routledge.
43.
Report. 1884–85. ‘Report From the Select Committee on Salmon Fisheries (Ireland) Together With the Proceedings of the Committee, Minutes of Evidence and Appendix’. British Sessional Papers, 10, pp.29–405.
44.
RuddyM.VarleyT., 1991. ‘Sea Farming and Development in North Connemara’, pp.77–102 in VarleyT.BoylanT. A.CuddyM. P. (eds), Rural Crisis: Perspectives on Irish Rural Development. Galway: Centre for Development Studies, University College Galway.
45.
Save Our Sea Trout. 1994a. Save Our Sea Trout News, Number 1, January 1994.
46.
Save Our Sea Trout. 1994b. Save Our Sea Trout News, Number 2, April-May 1994.
SilvermanM.1992. ‘From Fisher to Poacher: Public Right and Private Property in the Salmon Fisheries of the River Nore in the Nineteenth Century’, pp.99–141 in SilvermanM.GulliverP. H. (eds), Approaching the Past: Historical Anthropology Through Irish Case Studies. New York: Columbia University Press.
49.
SkladanyM.1996. ‘Fish, Pigs, Poultry, and Pandora's Box: Integrated Aquaculture and Human Influenza’, pp.263–81 in BaileyC.JentoftS.SinclairP. (eds), Aquacultural Development: Social Dimensions of an Emerging Industry. Boulder: Westview Press.
50.
ToveyH.1993. ‘Environmentalism in Ireland: Two Versions of Development and Modernity.’International Sociology, 8(4): pp.413–30.
51.
ToveyH.1992. ‘Rural Sociology in Ireland: A Review’. Irish Journal of Sociology, 2: pp.96–121.
52.
Western Regional Fisheries Board. 1993. Inland Fisheries Development Programme 1994–1998. Galway: The Western Regional Fisheries Board.
53.
WhelanK.1993. ‘Historic Overview of the Sea Trout Collapse in the West of Ireland’, pp.51–3 in MeldonJ. (ed.), Aquaculture in Ireland - Towards Sustainability. Dublin: An Taisce.
54.
WhitakerT. K.1991. Review of Common Fisheries Policy: Report of Advisory Group.
55.
YearlyS.1994. ‘Social Movements and Environmental Change’, pp. 150–68 in RedcliftM.BentonT., (eds). Social Theory and the Global Environment. London and New York: Routledge.
56.
YearlyS.1991. The Green Case: A Sociology of Environmental Issues, Arguments and Politics. London and New York: Routledge.
57.
BrowneAshworth V., 1861. pp.421–40 in Irish Chancery Reports, 10. Dublin: Hodges Smith and Company.
58.
William Neill and Michael Fenton v. the Duke of Devonshire. 1883. pp.135–95 in Law Reports: Appeal Cases, 7. London: William Cloves and Sons.
