A growing literature suggests that early lesions are associated with poorer IQ outcome. Those studies covered a restricted age range in pediatric populations only and did not control for important moderator variables. The present investigation studied IQ change in brain-lesioned children and adults (age 0 to 84 years). Altogether, 725 cases with a documented unilateral focal lesion were gathered from hospital charts and from published cases in the literature, including 240 with repeated IQ testing. Multiple regression analyses isolated the contribution of age at lesion onset to IQ change. Important mediator variables included were lesion side, site, volume, etiology, and so on. An early lesion was significantly associated with poorer postlesion IQ in time and with decline of IQ in time. Later onset lesions were associated with better postlesion IQ and recovery in time. The so-called Kennard principle is refuted, with regard to IQ.
Kennard MAReorganization of motor function in the cerebral cortex of monkeys deprived of motor and premotor areas in infancy. J Neuropsychol . 1938;1:477-496.
2.
Kennard M., Fulton JFAge and reorganization of central nervous system. J Mt Sinai Hosp N Y. 1942;9:594-606.
3.
Hart K., Faust D.Prediction of the effects of mild head injury: a message about the Kennard Principle. J Clin Psychol. 1988; 44:780-782.
4.
Webb C., Rose FD, Johnson DA, Atree EHAge and recovery from brain injury: clinical opinions and experimental evidence . Brain Inj. 1996;10:303-310.
5.
Johnson DA, Rose FD, Brooks BM, Eyers S.Age and recovery from brain injury: legal opinions, clinical beliefs and experimental evidence. Pediatr Rehabil. 2003;6:103-109.
6.
Matarazzo JDWechsler's Measurement and Appraisal of Adult Intelligence. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins; 1972.
7.
Wechsler D.Measurement of Adult Intelligence. 3rd ed. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins ; 1944.
8.
Anderson VA, Morse SA, Catroppa C., Haritou F., Rosenfeld JVThirty month outcome from early childhood head injury: a prospective analysis of neurobehavioural recovery. Brain. 2004;127: 2608-2620.
9.
Corkin S., Rosen TJ, Sullivan EV, Clegg RAPenetrating head injury in young adulthood exacerbates cognitive decline in later years. J Neurosci. 1989;9:3876-3883.
10.
Woods BTThe restricted effects of right-hemisphere lesions after age one; Wechsler test data. Neuropsychologia. 1980 ;18:65-70.
11.
Banich MT, Levine SC, Kim H., Huttenlocher P.The effects of developmental factors on IQ in hemiplegic children . Neuropsychologia. 1990;28:35-47.
12.
Verger K., Junqué C., Jurado MA, Tresserras P., Bartumeus F.Age effects on long-term neuropsychological outcome in paediatric traumatic brain injury. Brain Inj. 2000;14:495-503.
13.
Anderson V., Moore C.Age at injury as a predictor of outcome following pediatric head injury: a longitudinal perspective. Child Neuropsychol. 1995;1:187-202.
14.
Anderson V., Catroppa C., Morse S., Haritou F., Rosenfeld J.Recovery of intellectual ability following traumatic brain injury in childhood: impact of injury severity and age at injury. Pediatr Neurosurg . 2000;32:282-290.
15.
Aram DM, Eisele JAIntellectual stability in children with unilateral brain lesions. Neuropsychologia. 1994;32:85-95.
16.
Vargha-Khadem F., O'Gorman AM, Watters GVAphasia and handedness in relation to hemispheric side, age at injury and severity of cerebral lesion during childhood. Brain. 1985;108: 677-696.
17.
Riva D., Cazzaniga L.Late effects of unilateral brain lesions sustained before and after age one . Neuropsychologia. 1986;24: 423-428.
18.
Aram DM, Ekelman BLScholastic aptitude and achievement among children with unilateral brain lesions . Neuropsychologia. 1988;26:903-916.
19.
Levine SC, Huttenlocher P., Banich MT, Duda E.Factors affecting cognitive functioning of hemiplegic children. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1987;29:27-35.
20.
Chadwick O. , Rutter M., Thompson J., Shaffer D.Intellectual performance and reading skills after localized head injury in childhood. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 1981;22:117-139.
21.
Ewing-Cobbs L., Miner ME, Fletcher JM, Levin HSIntellectual, motor and language sequelae following closed head injury in infants and preschoolers . J Pediatr Psychol. 1989;14: 531-547.
22.
Chadwick O. , Rutter M., Brown G., Shaffer D., Traub MUA prospective study of children with head injuries: II. Cognitive sequelae. Psychol Med. 1981;11:49-61.
23.
Dennis M.Intelligence after early brain injury. I: predicting IQ scores from medical variables. J Clin Exp Neuropsychol. 1985;7:526-554.
24.
Hogan AM, Kirkham FJ, Isaacs EBIntelligence after stroke in childhood: review of the literature and suggestions for future research. J Child Neurol. 2000;15:325-332.
25.
Lansing AE, Max JE, Delis DC, et al. Verbal learning and memory after childhood stroke. J Int Neuropsychol Soc. 2004;10:742-752.
26.
Mosch SC, Max JE, Tranel DTA matched lesion analysis of childhood versus adult-onset brain injury due to unilateral stroke. Cogn Behav Neurol. 2005 ;18:5-17.
27.
Montour-Proulx I., Braun CMJ, Daigneault S., Rouleau I., Kuehn S., Begin J.Predictors of intellectual function after a unilateral cortical lesion: study of 635 patients from infancy to adulthood . J Child Neurol. 2004;19:935-943.
28.
Taylor HG, Alden J.Age-related differences in outcomes following childhood brain insults: an introduction and overview. J Int Neuropsychol Soc. 1997;3:555-567.
29.
Cohen J., Cohen P.Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences . 2nd ed. New Jersey : Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1983.
30.
Duval J.Récupération du quotient intellectuel suite à une lésion cérébrale unilatérale: effet de l'âge à la lésion, des caractéristiques lésionnelles et du sexe. [Change in IQ after a unilateral cortical lesion: effects of age at onset, lesion characteristics and gender]. Doctoral Dissertation, Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada; 2007 .
31.
Finger S., Almli CRBrain damage and neuroplasticity. Mechanisms of recovery or development ? Brain Res. 1985;357:177-186.
32.
Isaacson RLThe myth of recovery from early brain damage. In: Ellis NR, editor. Aberrant Development in Infancy. New York, NY: Wiley ; 1975.
33.
Kolb B.Brain development, plasticity and behavior. In: Johnson MH, editor. Brain Development and Cognition. Oxford, England: Blackwell Publishers;1993:338-356.
34.
Kolb B., Whishaw IQPlasticity in the neocortex: mechanisms underlying recovery from early brain damage. Prog Neurobiol. 1989;32:235-276.
35.
Chen KS, Gage FHSomatic gene transfer of NGF to the aged brain: behavioral and morphological amelioration. J Neurosci. 1995;15:2819-2825.
36.
Mallat M., Chamak B.Brain macrophages: neurotoxic or neurotrophic effector cells? J Leukoc Biol. 1994;56:416-422.
