Backscattered Electron Imaging: The Role in Calcified Tissue and Implant Analysis

Abstract

Backscattered electron (BSE) imaging is being developed into an accurate and useful technique for determining changes in bone morphology, histometry, and mineral content. BSE is currently used as a tool for quantifying the response of mineralized tissue to biomaterials. This paper briefly discusses the physics of BSE imaging and its application to mineralized tissue and biomaterials research. Original research is reported which better defines the errors that are imposed by changes in specimen working distance and tilt. Two parameters, the backscattered electron profile and the weighted mean graylevel, were introduced and developed so that BSE imaging could be used as a reproducible, quantitative technique for studying mineral content changes in bone. Results demonstrated that the working distance to a cortical bone surface can vary up to 300 μm or tolerate a tilt of up to 10 degrees without altering weighted mean graylevel values by more than 2 percent.

Calibration of the BSE signal would allow for reproducible, quantitative mineral content analysis to be conducted on bone and bone/implant interfaces. Bone substitutes and pure metals were investigated to determine their potential as BSE graylevel calibration standards. Pure metals appear to be the most promising materials for standardizing BSE graylevels, due to their greater homogeneity.

Finally, interrelationships between compressive strength and stiffness, histometry, and mineral content of individual trabecula in cancellous bone are investigated. Failure site trabecular thickness and minimum trabecular thickness, two new histometric parameters defined in this study, were found to statistically correlate with cancellous bone strength and stiffness.

Keywords

Backscattered Electron (BSE) Imaging Backscattered Electron

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bloebaum

R. D.

Campbell

P. A.

Reid

S. A.

Dorr

L. D.

. Proc. Uncement. Total Jt. Replace. Symp. Harrington Arthritis Research Center, Phoenix, AZ, p. 49 (1986).

Bloebaum

R. D.

Campbell

P. A.

Reid

S. A.

Dorr

L. D.

. Trans. Soc. Biomat., 10:16 (1987).

Bachus

K. N.

Hofmann

A. A.

Dauterman

L. A.

. Trans. Orthopaed. Res. Soc., 13:308 (1988).

Hofmann

A. A.

Bachus

K. N.

Daniels

A. U.

Hornbeck

Am. Acad. Orthop. Surg., Annual Meeting Scientific Program, 56:117 (1989).

Bloebaum

R. D.

Merrell

Gustke

Simmons

Clin. Orthop., in press (1990).

Hofmann

A. A.

Bachus

K. N.

Daniels

A. U.

Dauterman

L. A.

. Trans. Soc. Biomater. Symp. on Retrieval & Analysis of Surgical Implants & Biomaterials, XI:29 (1988).

Hofmann

A. A.

Hornbeck

Bloebaum

R. D.

. Am. Acad. Orthop. Surg., Annual Meeting Scientific Program, 56:166 (1989).

Bloebaum

R. D.

Reid

S. A.

Bachus

K. N.

. Trans. Orthopaed. Res. Soc., 14:399 (1989).

Bragdon

C. R.

Jasty

Russotti

Cargill

Harrigan

T. P.

Harris

W. H.

. Trans. Orthopaed. Res. Soc., 14:378 (1989).

10.

Holmes

R. E.

Hagler

H. K.

Coletta

C. A.

. J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 21:731–739 (1987).

11.

Hofmann

A. A.

Bloebaum

R. D.

. Trans. Orthopaed. Res. Soc., 14:553 (1989).

12.

Hofmann

A. A.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Bachus

K. N.

Rubman

M. H.

. Trans. Soc Biomater., XIII:252 (1990).

13.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Rhodes

D. M.

Rubman

M. H.

Hofmann

A. A.

. Clin. Orthop., in press (1990).

14.

Hofmann

A. A.

Bloebaum

R. D.

. Trans. Soc. Biomater., Symp. on Retrieval & Analysis of Surgical Implants & Biomaterials, XI:37 (1988).

15.

Meldrum

R. D.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Dauterman

L. D.

Dorr

L. D.

. Trans. Biomater., Symp. on Retrieval & Analysis of Surgical Implants and Biomaterials, XI:32 (1988).

16.

Rhodes

D. M.

Hofmann

A. A.

Bloebaum

R. D.

. Trans. Soc. Biomater. Symp. on Retrieval & Analysis of Surgical Implants & Biomaterials, XI:36 (1988).

17.

Bachus

K. N.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Hofmann

A. A.

. Trans. Orthopaed. Res. Soc., 15:54 (1990).

18.

Becker

R. P.

Geoffroy

J. S.

. Scanning Electron Microsc., IV:195–206 (1981).

19.

Boyde

In Methods of Calcified Tissue Preparation.

Dickson

G. R.

, ed. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 251–307 (1984).

20.

Boyde

Switsur

V. R.

Fearnhead

R. W.

. J. Ultrastruct. Res., 5:201–207 (1961).

21.

Boyde

J. Microsc., 98:462–471 (1973).

22.

Boyde

. Scanning Electron Microsc., 189–198 (1975).

23.

Boyde

Scanning Electron Microsc., 507–518 (1975).

24.

Boyde

. Scanning Electron Microsc., II:67–68 (1979).

25.

Boyde

Jones

S. J.

. Metab. Bone Dis. Rel. Res., 5(3):145–150 (1983).

26.

Boyde

Jones

S. J.

. Anat. Embryol., 168(2):211–226 (1983).

27.

Boyde

Reid

S. A.

. Scan Electron Microsc., IV:1803–1814 (1983).

28.

Boyde

Cowham

M. J.

. Scanning Electron Microsc., I:227–232 (1980).

29.

Boyde

Maconnachie

Reid

S. A.

Delling

Mundy

G. R.

. Scanning Electron Microsc,. IV:1537–1554 (1986).

30.

Reid

S. A.

Boyde

J. Bone Miner. Res., 2(1):13–22 (1987).

31.

Reid

S. A.

A Study of Human Skeletal Maturation Using the Scanning Electron Microscope, Ph.D. Thesis, University College of London (1986).

32.

Pfefferkorn

Scanning Electron Microsc., III:631–646 (1975).

33.

Wells

Scanning Electron Microsc., I:747–771 (1977).

34.

Joy

D. C.

Maruszewski

C. M.

. Scanning Electron Microsc., II:379–389 (1978).

35.

Moll

S. H.

Healey

Sullivan

Johnson

Scanning Electron Microsc., II:149–154 (1979).

36.

Robinson

V. N. E.

Scanning, 3:15–26 (1980).

37.

Fathers

D. J.

Rez

Scanning Electron Microsc., I:55–66 (1979).

38.

Robinson

V. N. E.

George

E. P.

. Scanning Electron Microsc., I:859–868 (1978).

39.

Robinson

V. N. E.

Scanning Electron Microsc., I:51–60 (1975).

40.

Cosslett

V. E.

Thomas

R. N.

. Br. J. Appl. Phys., 16:779–796 (1965).

41.

Robinson

V. N. E.

Scan. Miscrosc., 1(1):107–117 (1987).

42.

Robinson

V. N. E.

Cutmore

N. G.

Burdon

R. G.

. Scanning Electron Microsc., II:483–492 (1984).

43.

Ball

M. D.

McCartney

D. G.

. J. Microsc., 124(1):57–68 (1981).

44.

Holliday

J. E.

Sternglass

J. Appl. Phys., 28(10):1189–1193 (1957).

45.

Bishop

H. E.

Br. J. Appl. Phys., 18:703–715 (1967).

46.

Bachus

K. N.

Boyce

T. M.

Bloebaum

R. D.

. Scan. Microsc., in press (1990).

47.

Boyce

T. M.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Bachus

K. N.

. Trans. Soc. Biomater., XIII:188 (1990).

48.

Reid

S. A.

Anat. Embryol. (Berl.), 174:225–234 (1986).

49.

Burr

D. R.

Schaffler

M. B.

Frederickson

R. G.

. J. Biomech., 21(11):939–945 (1988).

50.

Niedrig

Scanning, 1:17–34 (1978).

51.

Skedros

J. G.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Boyce

T. M.

. Trans. Soc. Biomater., XIII:53 (1990).

52.

Richelle

L. J.

Onkelinx

In Mineral Metabolism. New York, NY: Academic Press, pp. 123–190 (1969).

53.

Phillips

H. B.

Owens-Jones

Chandler

Calcif. Tissue Res., 26:85–89 (1978).

54.

Jowsey

Clin. Orthop., 17:210–218 (1960).

55.

Jowsey

Kelly

P. J.

Riggs

B. L.

Bianco

A. J.

Scholz

D. A.

Gershon-Cohen

J. Bone Joint Surg. [Am.], 47:785–806 (1965).

56.

Weibel

E. R.

Kistler

G. S.

Scherle

W. F.

. J. Cell. Biol., 30:23–38 (1963).

57.

Recker

R. R.

. Bone Histomorphometry: Techniques and Interpretation. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, Inc., pp. 37–142 (1983).

58.

Parfitt

A. M. M. K. Drezner

Glorieux

F. H.

Kanis

J. A.

Malluche

Meunier

P. J.

Ott

S. M.

Recker

R. R.

. J. Bone Miner. Res., 2(6):595–610 (1987).

59.

Howell

P. G. T.

Reid

S. A.

. Scanning, 8:139–144 (1986).

60.

Boyde

Howell

P. G. T.

. J. Physiol., 353:10p (1984).

61.

Detenbeck

L. C.

Jowsey

Clin. Orthop., 65:76–80 (1969).

62.

Fazzalari

N. L.

Darrocot

Vernon-Roberts

Metab. Bone Dis. Rel. Res., 5:119–125 (1983).

63.

Beddoe

A. H.

Calcif. Tissue Res., 25:273–281 (1978).

64.

Chavassieux

P. M.

Arlot

M. E.

Meunier

P. J.

. Calcif. Tissue Int., 37:345–350 (1985).

65.

Noble

Alexander

J. Bone Joint Surg. [Am.], 67:295–302 (1985).

66.

Preteux

Bergot

Laval-Jeanter

A. M.

. Anat. Clin., 7:202–208 (1985).

67.

Pugh

J. W.

Radin

E. L.

Rose

R. M.

. J. Bone Joint Surg. [Am.], 56A:313–321 (1974).

68.

Emmanual

Hornbeck

Bloebaum

R. D.

. Stain Technol., 62(6):401–410 (1987).

69.

Dougherty

E. R.

Giardina

C. R.

. In Matrix Structured Image Processing. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, pp. 37–71 (1987).

70.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Hedley

A. K.

Clarke

I. C.

Thias

M. J.

. Trans. Orthopaed. Res. Soc., 4:207 (1979).

71.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Sanderson

C. A.

Emmanual

Campbell

Emmanual

J. G.

Yocham

G. D.

. Vet. Rec., 124:399–342 (1989).

72.

Hedley

A. K.

Clarke

I. C.

Bloebaum

R. D.

Moreland

Gruen

Coster

Amstutz

H. C.

In The Hip, Proc. 7th Open Sci. Meet. Hip Soc. St. Louis, MO:CV Mosby, pp. 160–187 (1979).

73.

Hofmann

A. A.

Bachus

K. N.

Bloebaum

R. D.

. Trans. Orthopaed. Res. Soc., 15:204 (1990).

74.

Kaczmarek

Czyzewski

Hejna

Radzimski

Scanning, 9:109–116 (1987).