Abstract
We examined the association between women’s justification of wife beating and their utilization of professional antenatal and delivery care in Bangladesh. We used data which describes a nationally representative sample of currently married women aged 15 to 49 years (n = 3,449). Services from medically trained providers were considered professional antenatal care (ANC) and delivery services. Women’s attitudes toward wife beating in five circumstances (if a woman goes out without telling her husband, neglects children, argues with her husband, refuses to have sexual intercourse with her husband, and burns food) were used to describe the justification of wife beating. Chi-square tests and multilevel logistic regression analyses were performed; 74% of the women would not justify wife beating, 65% attended ≥1 ANC visits, 25% attended ≥4 ANC visits, and 44% utilized professional delivery care. Women who would not justify wife beating were more likely to utilize ≥1 ANC visits (adjusted odds ratio [AOR]: 1.89; 95% confidence interval [CI]: [1.26, 2.81]), ≥4 ANC visits (AOR: 1.14; 95% CI: [0.76, 1.71]), and professional delivery care (AOR: 1.93; 95% CI: [1.31, 2.85]). Older age, women’s and husband’s higher education, lower parity, urban residence (except for ≥1 ANC visits), and higher socioeconomic statuses including divisional differences were significant confounders for increased utilization of both professional ANC and delivery care. In addition, older age at marriage and current unemployment were also associated with increased utilization of delivery care services. This association between women’s justification of wife beating and their utilization of professional antenatal and delivery care services has potential implications for maternal and child health policy in Bangladesh where intimate partner violence is commonplace, and societal norms teach women to obey their husbands and accept submissive roles. Public policy should aim to create awareness among women about the negative impact of justifying wife beating, and accepting intimate partner violence on their own and children’s health.
Introduction
Although maternal mortality worldwide dropped by about 44% between 1990 and 2015, approximately 830 women die every day from preventable causes related to pregnancy and childbirth, and 99% of all maternal deaths occur in developing countries (World Health Organization, 2015). In spite of pregnancy and childbirth being normal physiological phenomena, estimates show that globally 9% to 10% of pregnant women or 14 million women suffer from acute maternal complications during pregnancy every year (Filippi et al., 2006; Hogan et al., 2010). In Bangladesh, the maternal mortality ratio was 194 deaths per 100,000 live births in 2010 (El Arifeen et al., 2014), and in 2014, about 36% of women did not receive any antenatal care (ANC) visits, 31% of women received ≥4 ANC visits, and 42% deliveries were assisted by trained health care providers (National Institute of Population Research and Training [NIPORT] et al., 2016). Although every pregnant woman should utilize ≥4 ANC visits to have effective clinical outcomes and perceived satisfaction (Carroli et al., 2001), low utilization of ANC and delivery care occurred due to a number of barriers, for example, costs, transportation problems, and sociocultural norms to deliver at home (Parkhurst et al., 2006). Previous studies have recognized ANC and delivery care as effective in preventing maternal mortality and serious morbidity (Carroli et al., 2001; Graham et al., 2001; Koblinsky & Tinker, 1994; McDonagh, 1996). Therefore, increasing proper utilization of ANC and delivery care services are crucial for reducing maternal deaths from preventable causes related to pregnancy and childbirth in Bangladesh, and in turn, would help achieve Sustainable Development Goals related to maternal mortality reduction.
In various developing country settings, studies show that older maternal age, higher maternal education, higher husband’s education, higher socioeconomic status, lower parity, and urban residence are associated with increased utilization of ANC and delivery care services (Gabrysch & Campbell, 2009; Onah et al., 2006). Having an unwanted pregnancy (Rahman et al., 2016) and intimate partner violence (Rahman et al., 2012) were reported to be associated with under-utilization of ANC and delivery care services from medically trained providers in Bangladesh.
Female participation in economic, household, and health care decision making are considered as the indicators of female empowerment and autonomy in Bangladesh (M. Haque et al., 2011). Earlier studies have found a positive association between female autonomy and ANC utilization and suggested that under-utilization of ANC might be due to lack of female empowerment (Adamu & Salihu, 2002; S. E. Haque et al., 2012; Matsumura & Gubhaju, 2001; Mumtaz & Salway, 2005; Pallikadavath et al., 2004; Woldemicael, 2010). In 33 developing countries, maternal health services utilization were significantly associated with economic status, education, and female empowerment (Ahmed et al., 2010). A significant positive association between the utilization of ANC and female empowerment was also found in Bangladesh (Hossain & Hoque, 2015), where female empowerment was measured by education, household decision-making power, freedom of choice and movement, and involvement in economic activities.
While women are justifying wife beating less and less—from 33% in 2011 to 28% in 2014—Bangladeshi women often agree with one or more reasons of wife beating (e.g., if a woman goes out without telling her husband, neglects children, argues with her husband, refuses to have sexual intercourse with her husband, and burns food; NIPORT et al., 2013, 2016). In Bangladesh, women’s justification of wife beating is considered to be a proxy for their status within the household and indicative of a greater sense of entitlement, self-esteem, and status (NIPORT et al., 2016). A woman who justifies wife beatings may consider herself to have low status in her household, both absolutely and relative to the men in the household. Justifying wife beating also indicates a low level of female empowerment and an acceptance of men’s malpractice of power over women (Kishor & Subaiya, 2008). Such a perception could act as a barrier to a woman accessing health care for herself and her children, and affect her attitude toward contraceptive use and her general well-being. Our recent study revealed female participation in household decision-making to be significantly and negatively associated with the justification of wife beating in Bangladesh (Alam et al., 2018). Moreover, women who do not justify wife beating are more likely to participate in household decision-making, specifically with regard to their own health care and the health care of their children (Alam, 2016). These studies suggest a hypothesis that women who do not justify wife beating may more often seek ANC and delivery care services from medically trained providers.
However, existing research is inconclusive regarding the association between justification of wife beating and health care utilization, specifically ANC and delivery care. On one hand, justification of wife beating showed no association to overall health service, ANC, and delivery care utilization in Nepal (Pandey et al., 2012), and in Kenya, Nepal, and India (Namasivayam et al., 2012). However, evidence from Namibia has demonstrated an association of the justification of wife beating with institutional deliveries, but not with ANC from medically trained providers (Namasivayam et al., 2012). And in a few other contexts, such as Albania and Ethiopia, justification of wife beating was negatively associated with ANC and delivery care utilization (S. E. Haque et al., 2012; Sado et al., 2014; Yesuf & Calderon-Margalit, 2013).
The inconsistency of these results and the implications for maternal and child health policy indicate the need for more investigation of the association between the justification of wife beating and the utilization of ANC and delivery care. If women’s justification of wife beating is associated with less utilization of ANC and delivery care, the implication is that the benefits of interventions to increase female empowerment and reduce women’s justification of wife beating may extend to the women’s own health care and to their children’s health care. The importance of these relationships is particularly salient in Bangladesh where intimate partner violence is commonplace, and societal norms teach women to obey their husbands and accept submissive roles. Hence this study examined the association between women’s justification of wife beating and the utilization of ANC and delivery care services from medically trained providers.
Method
Data
We utilized data from the 2014 Bangladesh Demographic and Health Survey (BDHS), a nationally representative sample survey of demographic and health indicators of ever-married women aged 15 to 49 years residing in non-institutional dwelling units in Bangladesh. The 2014 BDHS was conducted under the authority of the NIPORT of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare of Bangladesh. Based on a two-stage stratified sample of households, it selected 18,000 residential households. A total of 18,245 ever-married women of reproductive age (15–49 years) were identified in the selected households and 17,863 were interviewed by female interviewers, for a response rate of 98%. The surveys were conducted from June 28 to November 9, 2014. Additional details of sampling design, survey instrument, and data collection procedure can be found elsewhere (NIPORT et al., 2016).
The 2014 BDHS administered three questionnaires: a household questionnaire, a woman’s questionnaire, and a community questionnaire. The contents of the questionnaires are based on the MEASURE DHS Model Questionnaires and were developed in English, and then translated into and printed in Bangla for data collection (for more details, see https://dhsprogram.com/). The woman’s questionnaire was used to collect data on the respondent’s background characteristics, current employment status, reproductive history, family planning methods, antenatal, delivery, postnatal and newborn care, justification of wife beating, husband’s characteristics, and other information. To minimize recall bias, we restricted our sample to the currently married women of age 15 to 49 years who had at least one birth in last 3 years. A total of 13,369 women who did not give birth in last 3 years and 53 women who were not currently married were dropped. Therefore, 4,441 women remained for further analysis. A total of 951 women were asked about justification of wife beating in the presence of their children, husbands, other males, and females, and were excluded to comply with ethics. We further removed 41 observations due to missing values for all variables used in this study, which left 3,449 currently married women’s information as final sample. A few women had more than one birth in last 3 years. Utilization of ANC and delivery care for only last births were used in this study.
Outcome Variables
Three outcome variables, namely, utilization of ≥1 professional ANC, utilization of ≥4 professional ANC, and utilization of professional delivery care, were considered in the study. We define professional ANC and professional delivery care in the same way as defined in the BDHS survey (NIPORT et al., 2016). ANC services from a qualified doctor, nurse, midwife, paramedic, family welfare visitor, community skilled birth attendant, medical assistant, or sub-assistant community medical officer were considered as professional ANC. Delivery care services from a qualified doctor, nurse, midwife, paramedic, family welfare visitor, or community skilled birth attendant were considered as professional delivery care. Based on the frequency of ANC visits, two outcome variables were created: (a) women receiving at least one professional ANC versus no professional ANC and (b) women receiving four or more professional ANC versus less than four professional ANC. The third outcome, utilization of professional delivery care, was dichotomized as 1 if women received professional delivery care services and 0 otherwise.
Predictor Variable
Whether a woman would not justify wife beating was considered as the main predictor variable for this study. Specifically, the predictor variable of interest is whether a women would not justify wife beating in each of the following five circumstances: if she goes out without telling her husband, if she neglects the children, if she argues with her husband, if she refuses to have sexual intercourse with her husband, and if she burns the food. The internal consistency among the five variables (i.e., five circumstances) was .78 (Cronbach’s α = .78). The predictor variable of interest, indicating that the woman would not justify wife beating, is a binary variable equal to 1 if the woman thought that a beating would not be justifiable under any of the five circumstances. In contrast, the predictor variable of interest is equal to 0 if the woman thought that beating would be justified in any of the five circumstances.
Confounding Variables
We selected potential confounding factors based on extant literature and data availability. Individual characteristics included respondent’s current age (grouped as 15–19, 20–34, and 35+ years), age at first marriage (<18 years or ≥18 years), respondent’s and husband’s education (illiterate, primary education with less than or equal to 5 years of schooling, secondary education with 6–10 years of schooling, and higher education with 11 years of schooling and above), respondent’s current employment status (employed or unemployed), respondent’s religion (Muslim or non-Muslim), parity (grouped as 1–2, and 3+), and current contraceptive methods. Current employment status was defined by whether the respondent worked for and received cash earnings from any of the following 10 occupational categories during the 7 days preceding the survey: professional/ technical, business, factory worker/blue-collar service, semiskilled labor/service, unskilled labor, farmer/agricultural worker, poultry/cattle raising, home-based manufacturing, domestic servant, and other. Current contraceptive method was a categorical variable distinguishing those not currently using any contraceptive method from those using female methods and those using couple/male methods. Pills, IUD, injections, female sterilization, and implants/Norplant were considered female contraceptive methods, whereas periodic abstinence, withdrawal, lactational amenorrhea, condom, male sterilization, and others were considered couple/male contraceptive methods. Household characteristics included respondent’s place of residence (rural or urban), region, and socioeconomic status. Region was categorized according to seven administrative divisions of Bangladesh (Barisal, Chittagong, Dhaka, Khulna, Rajshahi, Rangpur, and Sylhet). The socioeconomic status was measured from the wealth index constructed using household assets and grouped as “poor” (bottom 40%), “middle” (next 40%), and “rich” (top 20%) (Filmer & Pritchett, 2001; Tareque et al., 2014).
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
The DHS Program is authorized to distribute, at no cost, unrestricted survey data files for legitimate academic research (see more details at http://dhsprogram.com/). We obtained permission from the DHS Program to download and analyze the 2014 BDHS dataset for the current study. As the de-identified data for this study came from secondary sources, this study does not require ethical approval. Before each interview is conducted, an informed consent statement is read to the respondent, who may accept or decline to participate. The privacy and confidentiality of the respondents during data collection were maintained strictly to avoid further endangering respondents (https://dhsprogram.com/What-We-Do/Protecting-the-Privacy-of-DHS-Survey-Respondents.cfm). In addition, due to sensitive nature of the questions on justification of wife beating, we have utilized only those women’s information who were interviewed alone.
Statistical Analyses
After descriptive statistics of the study sample, chi-square tests were used to identify differences in the proportion of professional ANC and delivery care utilization by justification of wife beating and other individual and household characteristics. Then, we examined the association between justification of wife beating and professional ANC and delivery care utilization with multilevel logistic regression models. The 2014 BDHS used multistage stratified sampling technique that was based on nested sources of variability such as individuals who were nested in households and households that were nested in communities. We thus used multilevel logistic regression models with a random intercept at the household and the community levels to take into account sampling variability. Log-likelihood ratio tests indicated that multilevel logistic regression models with random effects were necessary compared with single-level logistic regression models without random effects (results not shown). Multilevel analysis produces more valid results when lower levels are nested within higher levels (Rabe-Hesketh & Skrondal, 2006; Twisk, 2006). All analyses were performed taking into account the probability sample design, unless specified. The svy commands were used in descriptive and bivariate analyses, and probability weights, proposed by Rabe-Hesketh and Skrondal (2006), were applied in multilevel logistic regression analysis. The entire analysis of the study was performed with Stata/MP version 13.0 (StataCorp, LP, College Station, Texas, USA).
We have fit six multilevel regression models, two models for each outcome. For each outcome, the first models (results not shown) established a bivariate association between each outcome and justification of wife beating without any adjustments for confounders. The final models examined the association between each outcome and justification of wife beating with adjustment for individual and household-level confounding variables.
Results
Basic characteristics (Table 1) showed most of the respondents were under 35 years (94%), and seven in 10 respondents were married before reaching 18 years of age. Comparatively, a lower percentage of women (13%) than husbands (24%) were illiterate. Only 23% of respondents were currently working, and 70% of respondents had given birth to 1 to 2 children. One in three women were not using any contraceptive methods. Around three fourths of the respondents lived in rural areas, and one third came from Dhaka division.
Basic Characteristic of the Study Participants (N = 3,449).
Note. M = Mean.
Unweighted values.
About 74% of respondents would not justify wife beating under the circumstances investigated (Figure 1); 97% of women would not justify wife beating when the wife burns the food and 81% of women would not justify wife beating when the wife argues with her husband. About 65% of respondents received ≥1 professional ANC, 25% received ≥4 professional ANC, and 44% received professional delivery care services (Figure 2). Professional ANC visits and delivery assistances taken were comparatively lower among women aged 15 to 19 years than women aged 20 to 29 years. Although the differences in professional ANC and delivery care by age groups are not statistically significant, both ≥1 and ≥4 professional ANC were utilized in the highest percentage by women aged 35 to 39 years, while the highest rate of professional delivery care were utilized by women of age 20 to 24 years.

Percentage of women who would not justify wife beating by circumstances.

Utilization of professional antenatal and delivery care by age groups.
Table 2 showed the bivariate association between utilization of professional ANC and delivery care services and justification of wife beating and sociodemographic characteristics. A significant association between women utilizing professional ANC and delivery care and not justifying wife beating was found; women who would not justify wife beating under the circumstances investigated were found to utilize professional ANC and delivery care at a higher rate than women who would justify wife beating in at least one circumstance. The participants who were married at 18+ years, with higher education, currently not working, of parity 1 to 2, using couple/male methods, with higher educated husband, residing in urban areas, from higher socioeconomic statuses, and from Khulna division were found to utilize professional ANC and delivery care at a higher rate than their counterparts.
Descriptive Statistics of Women by Receiving Professional ANC Visits and Delivery Assistance.
Note. ANC = antenatal care.
The p values are of chi-square tests.
Unweighted values.
A bivariate association between each outcome and justification of wife beating using multilevel logistic regression without any adjustments for confounders revealed that women who would not justify wife beating under the circumstances investigated had greater odds of utilizing professional ANC and delivery services relative to women who would justify wife beating. Women who would not justify wife beating under the circumstances investigated were 3.44 times more likely to utilize ≥1 professional ANC, 2.15 times more likely to utilize ≥4 professional ANC, and 3.29 times more likely to use professional delivery care. The greater odds for not justifying wife beating persisted in ≥1 professional ANC and delivery services after adjusting for confounders in final models (Table 3). Women who would not justify wife beating under the circumstances investigated were 1.89 times more likely to utilize ≥1 professional ANC services, and 1.93 times more likely to receive professional delivery care than women who would justify wife beating in at least one circumstance. Younger women utilized professional ANC and delivery services less than older women. Older age at marriage (for only delivery services), more education, lower parity, husbands with more education, and urban residence (except for ≥1 ANC visits) were associated with greater likelihood of utilizing professional ANC and delivery services. Currently employed women had lower odds of utilizing professional delivery care than currently unemployed women. Compared with women from Barisal division, women from Dhaka, Khulna, and Rangpur divisions utilized ≥1 professional ANC services at a higher rate, women from Khulna and Rangpur divisions utilized ≥4 professional ANC services in higher rate, and women from Khulna division utilized professional delivery care services at a higher rate.
Association Between Justification of Wife Beating and Receiving Professional ANC Visits and Delivery Assistance.
Note. ANC = antenatal care; AOR = adjusted odds ratio; CI = confidence interval.
Adjusted for all variables in the table.
Discussion
The current study revealed important findings regarding women’s justification of wife beating and professional health care utilization. Women who would not justify wife beating under the five circumstances investigated utilized ≥1 professional ANC and delivery care services at significantly higher rates than women who would justify wife beating in at least one circumstance. Our findings indicated that women’s justification of wife beating needs to be considered as an important sociocultural determinant for sufficient utilization of professional maternal health services during and after pregnancy. We also identified some significant confounding factors influencing professional ANC and delivery care services, for example, women’s age, age at first marriage (for only delivery services), women’s and husband’s educational levels, women’s current employment status (for only delivery services), parity, place of residence (except for ≥1 professional ANC), and socioeconomic status including divisional differences.
The positive association between women not justifying wife beating under the circumstances investigated and their utilization of ≥1 professional ANC and delivery services utilization implies that interventions aimed at increasing the percentage of women who do not justify wife beating would significantly increase utilization of maternal health services. The association between women not justifying wife beating and the utilization of ≥4 professional ANC was not statistically significant and warrants further investigation because the utilization of ≥4 ANC visits is associated with better maternal health outcomes.
Increased utilization of professional ANC and professional delivery care services would help reduce maternal and child deaths and violence against women. Reductions to maternal and child deaths, and reduced violence against women are critical to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Further research is merited to explore additional factors associated with the justification of wife beating. In addition, given how ingrained these attitudes toward wife beating are in Bangladeshi culture, future research testing and evaluating different interventions aimed at reducing women’s justification of wife beating is necessary. Given the negative association between women’s justification of wife beating and household decision-making, policy makers and planners should consider interventions designed to empower and educate women and increase their participation in household decision-making (Alam, 2016; Alam et al., 2018). However, policy makers and planners should also consider that many women may not disclose incidence of domestic violence because of fear for further bad treatment or because of shame or embarrassment (NIPORT et al., 2009).
In terms of confounding factors, our results align with previous research suggesting that older women were more likely to utilize professional ANC and delivery care services more than younger women (Gabrysch & Campbell, 2009; Rahman et al., 2016). Younger women may feel shy to visit professional ANC and delivery care services providers than older women. As women grow older, their roles as mothers become more prominent than as wives, as they achieve a certain status at the household and community (Kishor & Johnson, 2004) which may increase the utilization of professional ANC and delivery care services. The legal age at marriage for female is 18+ years in Bangladesh. However, many marriages are arranged for girls in their teens in Bangladesh (Johnston & Naved, 2008). Numerous studies reported disadvantages for women who got married young (Islam et al., 2014, 2015; Jejeebhoy, 1998; Jensen & Thornton, 2003; Rahman et al., 2016). For instances, women who were married young tend to participate less in household decision-making, are more likely to experience domestic violence, and are less likely to utilize professional ANC and delivery care services. The current study also revealed that women who got married at 18+ years were more likely to utilize professional delivery care services than women who got married at <18 years. Therefore, implementation of the existing law (i.e., marriage is legal at 18+ years for girls) may also increase utilization of professional delivery care services for prospective healthy mothers and children in Bangladesh.
Similar to our results, respondent’s education, husbands’ education, place of residence, and socioeconomic status were also strong confounders of professional ANC and delivery care utilization in a number of studies (Anwar et al., 2015; Furuta & Salway, 2006; Raghupathy, 1996; Rahman et al., 2016). More educated women and their husbands may have greater awareness of the benefits of professional ANC and delivery services than illiterate women and husbands. They may earn more and have higher socioeconomic status. Women from urban and higher socioeconomic groups may have the opportunity to spend more on professional ANC and delivery services than their counterparts. In addition, professional ANC and delivery care services are more available in urban areas than in rural areas. This suggests that policy makers should consider ways to increase the access to professional ANC and delivery care services in rural areas and among lower socioeconomic groups.
We also found that currently employed women were significantly less likely to use professional delivery care services than their counterparts, a result which differs from previous evidence from other developing settings which suggests that employed women have better knowledge of ANC services (El-Sherbini et al., 1992). Additional analysis from the dataset we used (results not shown) revealed that the mean year of schooling for currently employed women was lower than for currently unemployed women. This difference in education levels is a plausible explanation for why currently employed women utilized professional delivery care services at a lower rate than currently unemployed women in Bangladesh.
Although Bangladeshi women with more children experienced less intimate partner violence (Islam et al., 2014, 2015), they justify wife beating at similar rate compared with women with fewer children (Alam et al., 2018). Similar to the findings of a study (Rahman et al., 2016), we also found that women with fewer children utilized professional ANC and delivery care services at a higher rate than women with more children ever born. Having fewer children ever born would neither reduce nor increase justification of wife beating among women, but may be beneficial to increasing professional ANC and delivery care services utilization in Bangladesh.
Similar to other studies (Rahman et al., 2016) which document regional differences in utilization of professional ANC and delivery services, we found significant differences in utilization rates across regional divisions in Bangladesh. Compared with women from Barisal division, women from Dhaka, Khulna, and Rangpur divisions had higher odds of utilizing ≥1 professional ANC; women from Khulna and Rangpur divisions for ≥4 professional ANC; and Khulna division for professional delivery care service. These should be considered by the policy makers at the time of formulating ANC and delivery services–related policies.
Weaknesses and Strengths
This study has some limitations which should be considered when interpreting our findings. First, data were cross-sectional, and the study was unable to provide cause–effect relationships. Second, information of currently married women who gave at least one birth in last 3 years preceding the survey were used for this study, so the prevalence should not be generalized to women of all ages in Bangladesh. This study has several strengths as well. It used large population–based sample data with national coverage. It used multilevel analysis and incorporated probability weights in all analyses.
Implications
This study provides important findings on the association between women’s justification of wife beating and their utilization of professional ANC and delivery services. These associations imply that reducing women’s justification of wife beating will reduce intimate partner violence against women, and will improve maternal and child health through higher utilization of professional ANC and delivery care. Increasing the utilization of professional ANC and delivery care will help reduce maternal and child deaths, each being critical components of the Sustainable Development Agenda. The results indicate that policy makers should explore interventions aimed at creating awareness among women of the negative impact to their health and their children’s health of justifying wife beating under any circumstances. Although Bangladesh has made remarkable progress toward gender equality in every sector—particularly in school enrollment at the primary and secondary levels—gender norms are intimately bound up with religious beliefs and cultural practices. Many women may not disclose incidence of intimate partner violence because they believe in superiority of their husbands or fear further violence or because of embarrassment or shame (NIPORT et al., 2009). However, evidence suggests that empowering women through education, economic independence, and increasing women’s status in the household and in society may help women not to justify wife beating under any circumstances (Alam et al., 2018; Gupta et al., 2013; Kim et al., 2007). Policy makers and planners are also suggested to consider the current study’s findings on age at first marriage, women’s and husband’s education, women’s current employment status, parity, place of residence, and socioeconomic status including divisional differences when they formulate professional ANC and delivery care services–related policies and programs.
Footnotes
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
