The Lack of Sustainability in Police Reform Mental Health Support and Their Inconclusive Effectiveness

Abstract

Those calling for police reformation have advocated for reducing police-led response to mental health crises and instead, transferring these calls to adequately trained mental health professionals. This support program is commonly referred to as the mental health, “co-responder” model. The empirical evidence currently supporting co-responder models suggests inconsistencies in program development, unclear objectives, and a lack of standards for rigorous program evaluation. Thus, the purpose of this review was to identify co-responder models throughout the United States and assess the anecdotal in-/effectiveness of these programs as well as potential factors contributing to the hindrance of or boost in sustainability of this reformative support model. The Transform911 initiative facilitated by the University of Chicago Health Lab from 2020 to 2022 was utilized as the foundation of this review. Findings suggest a consistent theme across program objectives and render important recommendations for current and future co-responder teams.

Keywords

community policing program evaluation mental health alternative response

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abramson

(2021). Building mental health into emergency responses. American Psychological Association, 52(5), 30–31.

Aguilar

(2021, February). Denver wants police to be less involved in calls about the city’s homeless encampments. The Denver Post. https://www.denverpost.com/2021/02/22/homeless-encampments-police-denver-response/

Anderson

(2023, February). Co-responder programs. Colorado Behavioral Health Administration. https://bha.colorado.gov/behavioral-health/co-responder

Bailey

Lowder

E. M.

Grommon

Rising

Ray

B. R.

(2021). Evaluation of a police–mental health co-response team relative to traditional police response in Indianapolis. Psychiatric Services, 73(4), 366–373. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ps.202000864

Baltimore City Health Department. (2020). Greater Baltimore regional integrated crisis system (G-BRICS) proposal.

Blais

Landry

Elazhary

Carrier

Savard

A.-M.

(2020). Assessing the capability of a co-responding police-mental health program to connect emotionally disturbed people with community resources and decrease police use-of-force. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 18, 41–65. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11292-020-09434-x

Bonfine

Ritter

Munetz

M. R.

(2014). Police officer perceptions of the impact of crisis intervention team (CIT) programs. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 37, 341–350.

Boscarato

Lee

Kroschel

Hollander

Brennan

Warren

(2014). Consumer experience of formal crisis-response services and preferred methods of crisis intervention. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 23(4), 287–295. https://doi.org/10.1111/inm.12059

Bureau of Justice Assistance. (n.d.). Police-Mental Health Collaboration (PMHC) Toolkit. U.S. Department of Justice. https://bja.ojp.gov/program/pmhc

10.

Carey

(2021, July). Pilot program gives Loudoun County deputies time to follow up with mental health crisis calls. NBC4 Washington. https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local/pilot-program-gives-loudoun-county-deputies-time-to-follow-up-with-mental-health-crisis-calls/2728594/

11.

Center for Police Research and Policy. (2021). Assessing the impact of co-responder team programs: A review of research (BJA Grant No. 2020-NT-BX-K001). International Association of Chiefs of Police (IAPC) & University of Cincinnati.

12.

Chang

Edmondson

West

(2024). Mental health alternative first response: Community roadmap. Center for Police Equity.

13.

Clarke

Scott

(2021). State cuts funding to mental health services including CCH, CCS project. Campbell County Health.

14.

Cobbina-Dungy

J. E.

Jones-Brown

(2023). Too much policing: Why calls are made to defund the police. Punishment & Society, 25(1), 3–20. https://doi.org/10.1177/14624745211045652

15.

Davidson

(2022). City of Alexandria Co-Response Program (ACORP): Initial evaluation report. OMNI Institute. https://wtop.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/22-1122_ACORP-6-Month-Report_FINAL.pdf

16.

DeJong

(2022, February 12). Polis announces public safety package that would help fund mental health response teams. Summit Daily. https://www.aspentimes.com/news/polis-announce-public-safety-package-that-would-help-fund-mental-health-response-teams/

17.

Dempsey

Quanbeck

Bush

Kruger

(2020). Decriminalizing mental illness: Specialized policing responses. CNS Spectrums, 25(2), 181–195. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1092852919001640

18.

Derrick

(2021, July). Mayor Jenny Durkan announces proposal to create a new specialized triage response to provide alternative to sworn police response. Office of the Mayor.

19.

Dyer

Steer

Biddle

(2015). Mental health street triage. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, 9(4), 377–387. https://doi.org/10.1093/police/pav018

20.

Ellis

H. A.

(2014). Effects of a crisis intervention team (CIT) training program upon police officers before and after crisis intervention team training. Arch Psychiatric Nurse, 28, 10–16. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apnu.2013.10.003

21.

Gasior

(2022, December 22). Policing the mentally ill: How changes in tactic and best practices impact your department. PowerDMS. https://www.aspentimes.com/news/polis-announce-public-safety-package-that-would-help-fund-mental-health-response-teams/

22.

Georgetown Law. (n.d.). Alternative first response. Georgetown University Law Center. https://www.law.georgetown.edu/cics/alternative-first-response/#:~:text=These%20are%20designed%20to%20provide, alone%20or%20alongside%20police%20officers

23.

Ghiasi

Azhar

Singh

(2023). Psychiatric illness and criminality. StatPearls Publishing. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK537064/

24.

Gotoff

Nienaber

Lake

Markowitz

Pugh

Ferrentino

(2023). Beyond traditional policing: Public support for co-responder and alternative responder models. Lake Research Center & The Tarrance Group.

25.

Gross

A. J.

(2008). What blood won’t tell: A history of race on trial in America. Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674037977

26.

Haigh

C. B.

Kringen

A. L.

Kringen

J. A.

(2020). Mental illness stigma: Limitations of crisis intervention team training. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 31(1), 42–57. https://doi.org/10.1177/0887403418804871

27.

Justice Center. (2019). Police-mental health collaborations: A framework for implementing effective law enforcement responses for people who have mental health needs. The Council of State Governments. https://csgjusticecenter.org/publications/police-mental-health-collaborations-a-framework-for-implementing-effective-law-enforcement-responses-for-people-who-have-mental-health-needs/

28.

Justice Center. (2024). Law enforcement-mental health learning sites. The Council of State Governments. https://csgjusticecenter.org/projects/law-enforcement-mental-health-learning-sites/

29.

Kidston

(2022, October). Missoula’s mobile support team sees call volume double, eyes funding to grow. Missoula Current. https://missoulacurrent.com/mobile-support-team/

30.

Krider

Huerter

Gaherty

Moore

(2020). Responding to individuals in behavioral health crisis via co-responder models: The roles of cities, counties, law enforcement, and providers. Policy Research, Inc. & National League of Cities.

31.

Kummerer

Green

(n.d.). “Do I Call for Help?” More than a third of central NC officer-involved shootings involve mental health crises. ABC11 News. https://abc11.com/feature/mental-health-policing-officer-involved-shooting-i-team/10534981/

32.

Lamanna

Shapiro

G. K.

Kirst

Matheson

F. I.

Nakhost

Stergiopoulos

(2018). Co-responding police–mental health programs: Service user experiences and outcomes in a large urban center. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 27, 891–900. https://doi.org/10.1111/inm.12384

33.

Laniyonu

Goff

P. A.

(2021). Measuring disparities in police use of force and injury among persons with serious mental illness. BMC Psychiatry, 21, Article 500.

34.

Lappen

(2022, January). Review and reform Wisconsin’s mental health system. Milwaukee County Behavioral Health Services. https://www.wicounties.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Mon-Review-and-Reform-WI-Mental-Health.pdf

35.

Lum

Koper

C. S.

(2022). Can we really defund the police? A nine-agency study of police response to calls for service. Police Quarterly, 25(3), 255–280. https://doi.org/10.1177/10986111211035002

36.

Mental Health America. (2018). How Trump’s budget will affect people with mental health conditions.

37.

Moorman

(2021, August). Data from city’s alternative response pilot program shows its potential. Columbus Underground. https://columbusunderground.com/data-from-citys-alternative-response-pilot-program-shows-potential-tm1/

38.

National Alliance on Mental Illness. (n.d.). Stopping harmful practices. NAMI. https://www.nami.org/Advocacy/Policy-Priorities/Stopping-Harmful-Practices

39.

National Institute of Justice. (2024). NIJ FY24 Research and Evaluation on 911, Alternative Hotlines, and Alternative Responder Models [O-NIJ-2024-171981]. https://nij.ojp.gov/funding/opportunities/o-nij-2024-171981

40.

NBC New York. (2021, July 22). NYC’s non-police mental health pilot increasing rate of those getting aid, data show. https://www.nbcnewyork.com/investigations/nycs-non-police-mental-health-pilot-increasing-rate-of-those-getting-aid-data-show/3165520/

41.

Neusteter

R. S.

Pollack

(2022). Transforming 911: Assessing the landscape and identifying new areas of action and inquiry. University of Chicago Health Lab. https://www.transform911.org/#

42.

Niemietz

(2020, July 9). Small town police department saved money, lowered arrests by hiring social worker to assist cops. New York Daily News. https://www.nydailynews.com/2020/07/29/small-town-police-department-saved-money-lowered-arrests-by-hiring-social-worker-to-assist-cops/

43.

Perry

Craig

T. K. J.

(2015). Homelessness and mental health. Trends in Urology & Men’s Health, 6(2), 19–21. https://doi.org/10.1002/tre.445

44.

Peterson

Densley

(2018). Is crisis intervention team (CIT) training evidence-based practice? A systematic review. Journal of Crime and Justice, 41(5), 521–534. https://doi.org/10.1080/0735648X.2018.1484303

45.

Puntis

Perfect

Kirubarajan

Bolton

Davies

Hayes

Harriss

Molodynski

(2018). A systematic review of co-responder models of police mental health “street” triage. BMC Psychiatry, 18, Article 256. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-018-1836-2

46.

Ramirez

(2022, January 31). PCSD, city of Tucson addressing mental health crisis calls. 13 News. https://www.kold.com/2022/02/01/pcsd-city-tucson-addressing-mental-health-crisis-calls/

47.

Ranker

(2020, August). An officer may not answer your 911 call under a new plan for Fort Worth’s police. Fort Worth Star-Telegram. https://www.star-telegram.com/news/local/fort-worth/article244958465.html

48.

Russell

Doom

(2020, December). Dallas works to avoid sending people in crisis to emergency rooms or jails. The Pew Charitable Trusts. https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2020/12/08/dallas-works-to-avoid-sending-people-in-crisis-to-emergency-rooms-or-jails

49.

Scott

R. L.

(2000). Evaluation of a mobile crisis program: Effectiveness, efficiency, and civilian satisfaction. Psychiatric Services, 51(9), 1153–1156. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ps.51.9.1153

50.

Seo

Kim

Kruis

N. E.

(2021). Variation across police response models for handling encounters with people with mental illnesses: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Criminal Justice, 72, 101752. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2020.101752

51.

Shapiro

G. K.

Cusi

Kirst

O’Campo

Nakhost

Stergiopoulos

(2015). Co-responding police-mental health programs: A review. Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 42, 606–620.

52.

Sullaway

(2004). Psychological perspectives on hate crime laws. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 10(3), 250–292. https://doi.org/10.1037/1076-8971.10.3.250

53.

10TV Web Staff. (2021, July). City leaders say pilot program for mental health, addiction 911 calls show early success. 10TV News. https://www.10tv.com/article/news/local/ginther-city-leaders-provide-update-on-program-piloting-911-response-teams-for-non-emergency-calls/530-615848f8-a871-49c6-92b6-fe54b709217a

54.

Traxler

(2021, April). Santa Fe to launch alternative response unit for low-threat 911 calls. Santa Fe New Mexican. https://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/santa-fe-to-launch-alternative-response-unit-for-low-threat-911-calls/article_e265bddc-a120-11eb-b88d-0f24e42a0143.html

55.

Turner

(2022, April 6). We need to think beyond police in mental health crises. Vera. https://www.vera.org/news/we-need-to-think-beyond-police-in-mental-health-crises

56.

University of Memphis CIT Center. (n.d.). CIT Center. http://www.cit.memphis.edu/

57.

Vitka

(2021, May). DC’s new mental health pilot program shifts 911 calls away from police. WTOP News. https://wtop.com/dc/2021/05/dcs-new-mental-health-pilot-program-shifts-911-calls-away-from-police/

58.

The Washington Post, A1. (2022). Police shootings database. https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/investigations/police-shootings-database/

59.

Watson

A. C.

Compton

M. T.

Draine

J. N.

(2017). The crisis intervention team (CIT) model: An evidence-based policing practice? Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 35(5–6), 431–441. https://doi.org/10.1002/bsl.2304

60.

Weiner

(2021, May). D.C. to divert some mental health calls away from police. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/dc-mental-health-crisis-response/2021/05/17/2c761706-b746-11eb-96b9-e949d5397de9_story.html

61.

Yang

S. M.

Gill

C. E.

Y. F.

Azam

Kanewske

L. C.

(2024). A police-clinician co-response team to people with mental illness in a suburban-rural community: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Experimental Criminology. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11292-023-09603-8