Addressing Ceremonious Compliance and Problematic Agency-Level Hate Crime Reporting: Charting Progress,Promises,and Policy Possibilities

Abstract

Research in both criminology and sociology has emphasized the problem of organizational compliance with legal mandates, including law enforcement compliance. Recent research has drawn attention to the problem of police agency use of purely symbolic structures (ceremonious compliance) that appear to comply with legal mandates, while their practices reject the underlying ideals—most notably with regard to hate crime data reporting. The present work describes the current status of federal legislation regarding hate crimes and data collection, including signed legislation as well as introduced bills not yet subjected to a vote. In addition to describing the current socio-legal landscape surrounding hate crime data collection, we also discuss promising aspects of recent legislation, weaknesses, and potential changes that could be made to enhance the accuracy of hate crime data. Our results reveal how legislation shapes law enforcement hate crime reporting and how organizations respond to legal mandates more broadly.

Keywords

hate crime criminal justice policy differential police response

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bailey v. City of Philadelphia. (2011). 2:10-cv-05952, (E.D. Pa.).

Bass

(2005). Rural policing: Patterns and problems of “micro” departments. Justice Professional, 9(1), 59–74.

Bell

(2002). Policing hatred: Law enforcement, civil rights, and hate crime. New York University Press.

Bryan

(2024, June 3). New federal lawsuit filed over police’s actions in chaotic Fort Lauderdale protest. South Florida Sun-Sentinel. https://www.sun-sentinel.com/2024/06/03/chaotic-fort-lauderdale-protest-draws-new-federal-lawsuit-over-polices-response/

Bureau of Justice Assistance. (2022, November). Fact sheet: Annual governors’ Prison Rape Elimination Act certification and assurance submission. https://bja.ojp.gov/doc/annual-governors-prea-certification-assurance-submission.pdf

Bureau of Justice Assistance. (2023, June). Fact sheet: Edward Byrne memorial justice assistance grant program. https://bja.ojp.gov/doc/jag-program-fact-sheet.pdf

Congressional Research Service (2023, May 22). The 2022 Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) reauthorization (R47570).

COVID-19 Hate Crimes Act, 34 U.S.C. § 937 (2021). Retrieved from: https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/937/text

Department of Justice. (2012). Prisons and jail standards: United States Department of Justice final rule: National standards to prevent, detect, and respond to prison rape under the Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA) (28 CFR, Part 115).

10.

Edelman

L. B.

(2016). Working law: Courts, corporations, and symbolic civil rights. University of Chicago Press.

11.

Edelman

L. B.

Erlanger

H. S.

Lande

(1993). Internal dispute resolution: The transformation of civil rights in the workplace. Law & Society Review, 27(3), 497–534.

12.

Edelman

L. B.

Uggen

Erlanger

H. S.

(1999). The endogeneity of legal resolution: Grievance procedures as rational myth. American Journal of Sociology, 105(2), 454–506.

13.

Emmett Till Antilynching Act, 18 U.S.C. § 249 (2022). https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/55#:~:text=Specifically%2C%20the%20bill%20imposes%20criminal,an%20attempt%20to%20commit%20aggravated

14.

Erentzen

Schuller

(2020). Exploring the dark figure of hate: Experiences with police bias and the under-reporting of hate crime. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 62(2), 64–97.

15.

Florida State University. (2024, June 17). FSU criminology researchers invited to speak at White House hate crimes symposium [Press release]. https://criminology.fsu.edu/news/fsu-criminology-researchers-invited-speak-white-house-hate-crimes-symposium

16.

Gladfelter

A. S.

Lantz

Ruback

R. B.

(2017). The complexity of hate crime and bias activity: Variation across contexts and types of bias. Justice Quarterly, 34(1), 55–83.

17.

Goodmark

(2022). Assessing the impact of the Violence Against Women Act. Annual Review of Criminology, 5, 115–131.

18.

Hall

(2022). Counting crime: Discounting victims? International Review of Victimology, 28(1), 3–32.

19.

Hate Crime Statistics Act, 28 U.S.C. § 534 (1990). https://www.congress.gov/101/statute/STATUTE-104/STATUTE-104-Pg140.pdf

20.

Hayes

(2023, September 11). Ben Crump files $500M suit accusing Beverly Hills police of racial profiling. ABC7. https://abc7.com/beverly-hills-racial-profiling-lawsuit-ben-crump-police-department/13769133/

21.

Holder

Edwards

Osborne

(2024). An exploratory study on the structural and demographic predictors of hate crime across the rural-urban divide. Victims & Offenders, 19(3), 468–490.

22.

Improving Reporting to Prevent Hate Act of 2024, H.R. 7648, 118th Cong. (2024). https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/7648

23.

Jacobs

J. B.

Eisler

(1993). The hate crime statistics act of 1990. Criminal Law Bulletin, 29(2), 99–123.

24.

Jenness

Grattet

(2001). Making hate a crime: From social movement to law enforcement. Sage.

25.

Kena

Thompson

(2021). Hate crime victimization, 2005-2019 (Report NCJ, 300954).

26.

King

R. D.

(2007). The context of minority group threat: Race, institutions, and complying with hate crime law. Law & Society Review, 41(1), 189–224.

27.

King

R. D.

Kutateladze

B. L.

(2023). A higher bar: Institutional impediments to hate crime prosecution. Law & Society Review, 57(4), 489–507.

28.

King

R. D.

Messner

S. F.

Baller

R. D.

(2009). Contemporary hate crimes, law enforcement, and the legacy of racial violence. American Sociological Review, 74(2), 291–315.

29.

Lantz

(2022). Why more agencies and researchers should embrace the upcoming NIBRS transition: Contributions and promise of the NIBRS data. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 47(3), 462–484.

30.

Lantz

Gladfelter

A. S.

Ruback

R. B.

(2019). Stereotypical hate crimes and criminal justice processing: A multi-dataset comparison of bias crime arrest patterns by offender and victim race. Justice Quarterly, 36(2), 193–224.

31.

Lantz

Wenger

M. R.

(2021). Are Asian victims less likely to report hate crime victimization to the police? Implications for research and policy in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. Crime & Delinquency, 68(8), 1292–1319.

32.

Lantz

Wenger

M. R.

Malcom

Z. T.

(2024). Historical markers or markers of white supremacy? Confederate memorialization, racial threat, and hate crime. Social Problems, 71(2), 334–352.

33.

Ledet

Holland

M. M.

Emeigh

Givens

(2024). Carceral safety in a post-PREA era: An examination of perceptual indicators of safety among incarcerated persons in four southeast prisons. Punishment & Society, 26(1), 3–31.

34.

Loewen

(2005). Sundown towns: A hidden dimension of American racism. The New Press.

35.

Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act, 18 U.S.C. § 249 (2009). https://www.congress.gov/bill/111th-congress/senate-bill/909

36.

Michalski

Rushin

(2021). Federal (de) funding of local police. Georgetown Law Journal, 110, 54–66.

37.

Mills

J. M.

Lantz

Wenger

M. R.

(2024). Understanding community hate crimes as an incorrigible proposition: Local political attitudes, path dependence, and the ceremonious reporting of hate crime statistics. Criminology, 1–31. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9125.12378

38.

Myers

Lantz

(2020). Reporting racist hate crime victimization to the police in the United States and the United Kingdom: A cross-national comparison. The British Journal of Criminology, 60(4), 1034–1055.

39.

Nolan

J. J.

Haas

S. M.

Turley

Stump

LaValle

C. R.

(2015). Assessing the “statistical accuracy” of the National Incident-Based Reporting System hate crime data. American Behavioral Scientist, 59(12), 1562–1587.

40.

Offenhartz

(2023, July 19). New York City agrees to pay $13 million to 2020 racial injustice protestors in historic class action. AP News. https://apnews.com/article/2020-class-action-settlement-george-floyd-protests-arrests-f005beed8b5666e6807f3775c0252a8a

41.

Office of Justice Programs. (2015, June 11). Department of justice announces 50 states and territories have committed to ending prison rape. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/department-justice-announces-50-states-and-territories-have-committed-ending-prison-rape

42.

Oversight of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. 117th Cong. 2022. (Testimony of Christopher Wray).

43.

Paulsen

D. J.

(2004). To map or not to map: Assessing the impact of crime maps on police officer perceptions of crime. International Journal of Police Science & Management, 6(4), 234–246.

44.

Pezzella

F. S.

Fetzer

M. D.

Keller

(2019). The dark figure of hate crime underreporting. American Behavioral Scientist.

45.

Piatkowska

S. J.

Messner

S. F.

Yang

T. C.

(2019). Understanding the relationship between relative group size and hate crime rates: Linking methods with concepts. Justice Quarterly, 36(6), 1072–1095.

46.

Rad

A. N.

Kirk

D. S.

Jones

W. P.

(2023). Police unionism, accountability, and misconduct. Annual Review of Criminology, 6, 181–203.

47.

Roberts

J. M.

Jr. (2007). The structure of informal communication between police agencies. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 30(1), 93–107.

48.

Ruback

R. B.

Gladfelter

A. S.

Lantz

(2018). Hate crime victimization data in Pennsylvania: A useful complement to the Uniform Crime Reports. Violence and Victims, 33(2), 330–350.

49.

Smith

(2021). Correctional officer and inmate perceptions of the Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA): A thematic analysis. Journal of Crime and Justice, 44(2), 213–225.

50.

Strom

K. J.

Smith

E. L.

(2017). The future of crime data: The case for the National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS) as a primary data source for policy evaluation and crime analysis. Criminology & Public Policy, 16(4), 1027–1048.

51.

University of Minnesota. (2024, June 16). Professor Joachim Savelsberg invited to the White House [Press Release]. https://cla.umn.edu/sociology/news-events/news/professor-joachim-savelsberg-invited-white-house

52.

The University of Oklahoma. (2024, June 24). OU education professor invited to present research at White House workshop on advancing understanding of hate and bias-related incidents [Press Release]. https://ou.edu/news/articles/2024/june/ou-education-professor-invited-to-present-research-at-white-house-workshop-on-advancing-understanding-of-hate-and-biase-related-incidents

53.

Vanden Bosch

Lantz

(2025). Differential Compliance with the reporting of hate crime statistics as a function of state laws. Journal of Criminal Justice.

54.

The White House. (2022, September 15). Fact sheet: The united we stand summit: Taking action to prevent and address hate-motivated violence and foster unity. https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/09/15/fact-sheet-the-united-we-stand-summit-taking-action-to-prevent-and-address-hate-motivated-violence-and-foster-unity/

55.

The White House. (2024, March 30). Readout of white house roundtable discussion on countering hate-fueled violence. https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2024/03/30/readout-of-white-house-roundtable-discussion-on-countering-hate-fueled-violence/

56.

Xie

Baumer

E. P.

(2019). Crime victims’ decisions to call the police: Past research and new directions. Annual Review of Criminology, 2(1), 217–224.

57.

Yancey-Bragg

(2019, February 20). Utah man who wanted to “kill Mexicans” charged with federal hate crimes. USA Today.