Citizen Recourse To Self Protection: Structural,Attitudinal And Experiential Factors

Abstract

At least one fourth of the New York City subway riders surveyed in a 1986 study carry some form of self protection ranging from guns and knives to mace. The tendency of citizens to carry self protective devices is a source of concern to law enforcement officials who denounce such behavior as needless and potentially harmful. Criminal justice practitioners assert that the likelihood of becoming a victim of violent crime is small, that victims and prospective victims are incompetent in their efforts to protect themselves, and that protection against crime is primarily an area reserved to the state regardless of whether it is effective or not. How is one to explain the practice of carrying devices dedicated to self protection when it persists contrary to the advice and disapproval of criminal justice practitioners?

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Dubow. F. 1979 Reactions To Crime: A Critical Review Of The Literature . Washington. D. C.: Government Printing Office.

Furstenberg, F. 1971 Public reactions to crime in the streets. American Scholar 40: 601-610.

Garofalo, J. , and J. Laub 1978 The fear of crime: broadening our perspectives. Victimology 3: 242-253.

Grizzle, J. , C. Starmer , and G. Koch 1979 Analysis of categorical data by linear models. Biometrics 25: 489-504.

Kenney, D. 1986 Crime on the subways: Measuring the effectiveness of the guardian angels. Justice Quarterly 3: 481-496.

Kleinman, P. , and D. David 1973 Victimization and perception of crime in a ghetto community. Criminology 13: 307-343.

Lavrakos, P. 1985 Citizens Self Help And Neighborhood Crime Prevention Policy, In American Violence And Public Policy. New Haven, Ct.: Yale Univ. Press.

Lewis, D. , and G. Salem 1985 Fear Of Crime. Brunswick, N.Y. : Transaction Books.

Mangione, T. , and C. Noble 1975 Baseline Survey Measures Including Update Survey Information For The Evaluation Of A Crime Control Model. Boston Survey Research Program, Univ. of Mass.

10.

National Crime Prevention Institute 1986 Understanding Crime Prevention. Boston, MA.: Butterworths.

11.

Ortega, S. , and J. Myles 1987 Race and gender effects on fear of crime. Criminology 25: 133-152.

12.

Short, J. , and F. Strodtbeck 1965 Group Pressures And Gang Delinquency. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.

13.

Skogan, W. , and M. Maxfield 1981 Coping With Crime: Individual And Neighborhood Reactions . Beverly Hills, Sage. U. S. Department of Justice 1975 Criminal Victimization In 13 American Cities. Washington, D.C.

14.

Young, R. , D. McDowall , and C. Loftin 1987 Collective security and the ownership of firearms for protection. Criminology 25: 47-62.

15.

Ziegenhagen, E.A. 1976 The recidivist victim of violent crime. Victimology 1: 583-550.

16.

Ziegenhagen, E.A. , and D. Brosnan 1985 Victim responses to robbery and crime control policy . Criminology 23: 675-695.