This paper offers a critical response to Rahsaan Mahadeo’s article, “A Call for Counter-Public Sociology.” I argue that public sociology is neither fixed nor fated to legitimize domination; rather, it is a contested field whose trajectory has diversified since its original formulation. The paper reviews Mahadeo’s arguments—regarding the university as knowledge gatekeeper, the privileging of elite publics, and sociology’s complicity with state power—and responds by highlighting contemporary practices of public sociology that contest these limitations. Drawing on theoretical developments and empirical cases, I show how emerging forms of public sociology amplify counter-hegemonic publics and foster emancipatory outcomes. I conclude that Mahadeo’s critique risks obscuring the work many public sociologists already undertake with diverse communities to resist and challenge structures of domination. The task ahead is not to abandon or simply rename public sociology, but to identify, expand, and align its radical potential with broader struggles for social transformation.
ArribasA (2018) Reframing the public sociology debate: towards collaborative and decolonial praxis. Current Sociology66(1): 92–109.
2.
AverettKH (2020) A feminist public sociology of the pandemic: interviewing about a crisis, during a crisis. Gender, Work & Organization28(S2): 321–329.
3.
BerardARavelliB (2021) In their words: what undergraduate sociology students say about community-engaged learning. Journal of Applied Social Science15(2): 197–210.
4.
BixlerRP (2020) Fertile soil for organic public sociology: community-based natural resource management. The American Sociologist51(4): 558–565.
5.
BlokkerP (2023) Public sociology and populism. In: BifulcoLBorghiV (eds) Research Handbook on Public Sociology. Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 188–201.
6.
BrookPDarlingtonR (2013) Partisan, scholarly and active: arguments for an organic public sociology of work. Work, Employment and Society27(2): 232–243.
7.
BurawoyM (2005a) For public sociology. American Sociological Review70(1): 4–28.
8.
BurawoyM (2005b) The critical turn to public sociology. Critical Sociology31(3): 313–326.
9.
BurawoyM (2006) Public sociology vs. the market. Socio-Economic Review4(2): 356–367.
10.
BurawoyM (2009a) The public sociology wars. In: JeffriesV (ed.) Handbook of Public Sociology. Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 449–474.
11.
BurawoyM (2009b) The Extended Case Method: Four Countries, Four Decades, Four Great Transformations, and One Theoretical Tradition. University of California Press.
12.
CataldiS (2014) Public sociology and participatory approaches: towards a democratization of social research?Qualitative Sociology Review10(4): 152–172. Available at: http://www.qualitativesociologyreview.org/ENG/archive_eng.php (accessed 10 November 2024).
13.
CossyleonJSpitzG (2022) Collaborating and stepping back. In: RogersAPWillisKE (eds) Teaching Sociology Successfully: A Practical Guide for Instructors. Routledge, pp. 69–78.
14.
CoxL (2014) Movements making knowledge: a new wave of inspiration for sociology?Sociology48(5): 954–971.
15.
FairbairnJ (2019) The public sociologist as a university-community hybrid: lessons from feminism. Critical Sociology45(2): 285–304.
16.
FeaginJR (2001) Social justice and sociology: agendas for the twenty-first century. American Sociological Review66(1): 1–20.
17.
FeaginJREliasSMuellerJ (2009) Social justice and critical public sociology. In: JeffriesV (ed.) Handbook of Public Sociology. Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 71–88.
GlennEN (2007) ‘Whose public sociology? The subaltern speaks, but who is listening?’, In: ClawsonD. (ed.) Public Sociology: Fifteen Eminent Sociologists Debate Politics and the Profession in the Twenty-first Century. University of California Press, pp. 213–224.
22.
GopalP (2019) Insurgent Empire: Anticolonialism and the Making of British Dissent. Verso Books.
23.
GreenbergMLondonRAMcKaySC (2020) Community-initiated student-engaged research: expanding undergraduate teaching and learning through public sociology. Teaching Sociology48(1): 13–27.
24.
HartmannD (2023) The ever-expanding movement of public sociology. Contemporary Sociology52(6): 504–510.
LivingstoneS (2024) Campus collaboration as a gateway to public sociology: a guide for ‘unmuzzling’ graduate student instructors. Teaching Sociology52(1): 75–86.
29.
MahadeoRR (2024) A call for counter-public sociology. Critical Sociology50(3): 391–411.
30.
ManskiB (2024) Can the academy meet the moment? The promise of next system studies. Nonprofit Quarterly, April3.
31.
McMillanLA (2022) The everyday sociological imagination. In: HossfeldLKellyEBMeyerhofferC (eds) The Routledge International Handbook of Public Sociology. Routledge, pp. 239–248.
32.
MeghjiA (2024) From public sociology to sociological publics: the importance of reverse tutelage to social theory. Sociological Theory42(2): 114–136.
33.
MillsCW (1959) The Sociological Imagination. Oxford University Press.
34.
NgaiPYuanSYuhuaG, et al. (2014) Worker–intellectual unity: trans-border sociological intervention in Foxconn. Current Sociology62(2): 209–222.
35.
ParkP (1988) Toward an emancipatory sociology: abandoning universalism for true indigenisation. International Sociology3(2): 161–170.
36.
ParrottHValentineC (2022) Lessons from the field. In: RogersAPWillisKE (eds) Teaching Sociology Successfully: A Practical Guide for Instructors. Routledge, pp. 205–213.
37.
PivenFF (2007) From public sociology to politicized sociologist. In: ClawsonDZussmanRMisraJ, et al. (eds) Public Sociology: Fifteen Eminent Sociologists Debate Politics and the Profession in the Twenty-First Century. University of California Press, pp. 158–166.
38.
SieberT (2020) Worker-led research makes the case for labor justice for Massachusetts domestic workers: social research and social change at the grassroots. In: GreenbaumSDJacobsGZinnP (eds) Collaborating for Change: A Participatory Action Research Casebook. Rutgers University Press, pp. 80–94.
VejarDJ (2022) Experiences of meetings and cooperation between academics and unions: the Work Studies Group from the South (GETSUR). In: BezuidenhoutAMnwanaSvon HoldtK (eds) Critical Engagement with Public Sociology: A Perspective from the Global South. Bristol University Press, pp. 215–234.
41.
Von HoldtK (2014) Critical engagement in fields of power: cycles of sociological activism in post-apartheid South Africa. Current Sociology62(2): 181–196.
42.
WrightEO (2010) Envisioning Real Utopias. Verso Books.
