This article critically explores data generated within a participatory research project with young people in the care of a local authority, the (Extra)ordinary Lives project. The project involved ethnographic multi-media data generation methods used in groups and individually with eight participants (aged 10—20) over a school year and encouraged critical reflexive practices throughout. The article problematizes aspects of power, ethics and agency in participatory research from poststructural perspectives and cautions against the assumption that participatory research per se necessarily produces ‘better’ research data, equalizes power relations or enhances ethical integrity. Yet, throughout the article, there are examples of the potential contributions and challenges of participatory methodologies.
Benhabib, S. ( 1992) Situating the Self: Gender, Community and Postmodernism and Contemporary Ethics. Cambridge: Polity Press.
2.
Birch, M. and T. Miller ( 2002) ‘Encouraging Participation: Ethics and Responsibilities’ , in M. Mauthner, M. Birch, J. Jessop and T. Miller (eds) Ethics in Qualitative Research . London: Sage.
3.
Christensen, P. and A. Prout ( 2002) ‘Working with Ethical Symmetry in Social Research with Children’, Childhood9(4): 477-97.
4.
Clark, A. ( 2001) ‘How to Listen to Very Young Children: The Mosaic Approach’, Child Care in Practice7(4): 333-41.
5.
Edwards, R. and M. Mauthner ( 2002) ‘Ethics and Feminist Research: Theory and Practice’ , in M. Mauthner, M. Birch, J. Jessop and T. Miller (eds) Ethics in Qualitative Research . London: Sage.
6.
Fernandez, E. ( 2007) ‘How Children Experience Fostering Outcomes: Participatory Research with Children’, Child and Family Social Work12(4): 349-59.
7.
Foucault, M. ( 1977) Discipline and Punish, trans. A. Sheridan. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
8.
Freeman, M. ( 2007) ‘Why it Remains Important to Take Children’s Rights Seriously’, The International Journal of Children’s Rights15(1): 5-23.
9.
Gallagher, M. ( 2008a) ‘ "Power is Not an Evil": Rethinking Power in Participatory Methods’, Children’s Geographies6(2): 137-50.
10.
Gallagher, M. ( 2008b) ‘Foucault, Power and Participation’, International Journal of Children’s Rights16(3): 395-406.
11.
Gallagher, L. and M. Gallagher ( 2008) ‘Methodological Immaturity in Childhood Research? Thinking through "Participatory Methods’’ ’, Childhood15(4): 499-516.
12.
Grover, S. ( 2004) ‘Why Won’t They Listen to Us? On Giving Power and Voice to Children Participating in Social Research’, Childhood11(1): 81-93.
13.
Hill, M. ( 2006) ‘Children’s Voices on Ways of Having a Voice: Children’s and Young People’s Perspectives on Methods Used in Research and Consultation’, Childhood13(1): 69-90.
14.
Holland, S., C. Floris, A. Crowley and E. Renold ( 2010) ‘"How Was Your Day?" Learning from Experience: Informing Preventative Policies and Practice by Analysing Critical Moments in Care Leavers’ Life Histories’. End of Award Report (Voices from Care Cymru and School of Social Sciences, Cardiff University). Cardiff: Wales Office of Research and Development for Health and Social Care, (WORD). Grant ref: SCSM08-021.
15.
Kellett, M., R. Forrest, N. Dent and S. Ward ( 2004) ‘Just Teach Us the Skills, We’ll Do the Rest: Empowering Ten-Year-Olds as Active Researchers’, Children and Society18(5): 329-43.
16.
Krimmerman, L. ( 2001) ‘Participatory Action Research: Should Social Inquiry be Conducted Democratically?’, Philosophy of the Social Sciences31(1): 60-82.
17.
Prout, A. ( 2005) The Future of Childhood. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
18.
Punch, S. ( 2002) ‘Research with Children: The Same of Different from Research with Adults?’, Childhood9(3): 321-41.
19.
Renold, E. ( 2007) ‘Girls in Care: Nomadism, Compulsory Reflexivity and Legible Rage’, paper presented at ESRC seminar series, ‘Girls in Education: 3-16: Continuing Concerns, New Agendas’, Lancaster University, 13 June.
20.
Renold, E. ( 2010) ‘Fighting for an Education: Succeeding and Surviving for Girls in Care at School’, in C. Jackson, C. Paechter and E. Renold (Eds.) Girls in Education 3-16: Continuing Concerns, New Agendas. Maidenhead: Open University Press.
21.
Renold, E., S. Holland, N.J. Ross and A. Hillman ( 2008) ‘ "Becoming Participant": Problematising "Informed Consent" in Participatory Research with Children and Young People in Care’ , Qualitative Social Work7(4): 431-51.
22.
Renold, E. and N. Ross ( 2008) ‘"Look at My Eyes, They’re Lush": Representing Mediated Identities in Longitudinal Participatory Research with Children and Young People in Public Care’. Conference paper, Advancing the Use of Visual Methods in Researching Children’s Cultures, Cardiff University, April 16, 2008.
23.
Ringrose, J. and E. Renold (forthcoming) ‘Teen Girls, Working Class Femininity and Resistance: Re-theorizing Fantasy and Desire in Educational Contexts of Heterosexualized Violence’ , International Journal of Inclusive Education.
24.
Ross, N.J., E. Renold, S. Holland and A. Hillman (2009) ‘Moving Stories : Using Mobile Methods to Explore the Everyday Lives of Young People in Public Care’, Qualitative Research9(5): 605-23.
25.
Skeggs, B. ( 2002) ‘Techniques for Telling the Reflexive Self’ , in T. May (ed.) Qualitative Research in Action. London: Sage .
26.
Skelton, T. ( 2008) ‘Research with Children and Young People: Exploring the Tensions between Ethics, Competence and Participation’, Children’s Geographies6(1): 21-36.
27.
Smith, R., M. Monaghan and B. Broad ( 2002) ‘Involving Young People as Co-researchers: Facing up to the Methodological Issues’, Qualitative Social Work1(2): 191-207.
28.
Thomas, N. ( 2007) ‘Towards a Theory of Children’s Participation’ , International Journal of Children’s Rights15(2): 199-218.
29.
Thomas, N. and C. O’Kane ( 1998) ‘The Ethics of Participatory Research with Children’ , Children and Society12(5): 336-48.
30.
Thomson, F. ( 2007) ‘Are Methodologies for Children Keeping Them in Their Place?’, Children’s Geographies5(3): 207-18.
31.
Thorne, B. ( 1980) ‘You Still Takin’ Notes? Fieldwork and Problems of Informed Consent’, Social Problems27(3): 284-97.
32.
Walkerdine, V., H. Lucey and J. Melody ( 2002) ‘Subjectivity and Qualitative Method’, in T. May (ed.) Qualitative Research in Action. London: Sage .
33.
Warming, H. ( 2006) ‘ "How Can You Know? You’re Not a Foster Child": Dilemmas and Possibilities of Giving Voice to Children in Foster Care’ , Children, Youth and Environments16(2): 28-50.
34.
Wiles, R., J. Prosser, A. Bagnoli, A. Clark, K. Davies, S. Holland and E. Renold ( 2008) ‘Visual Ethics: Ethical Issues in Visual Research’ , ESRC NCRM Research Methods Review Paper 011; at: www.ncrm.ac.uk/research/outputs/publications/
