The relationship between flexible working arrangements and the gender pay gap is explored in this article, based on a study of flexible working arrangements among Chartered Accountants in Britain. Individual interviews with 50 participants provided details on working patterns, flexibility policies and practices, and experiences of flexible working.The article considers whether gender-neutral discourses of flexible working succeed in encouraging more men and non-parents to use flexible working arrangements, thereby potentially reducing the gender pay gap. The study highlighted gendered patterns of take-up of flexible working. Women who worked flexibly or part time typically did so to combine working with caring commitments, in ways that damaged their career prospects. In contrast, men typically deferred working flexibly to a later stage when their career had progressed further. There was therefore a clear impact on current and future salary for women taking up flexible working arrangements, which was not equivalent for the men who did so. In this context, the promotion of flexible working arrangements is reinforcing the gender pay gap.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Acker, J. (1990) ‘Hierarchies Jobs and Bodies: A Theory of Gendered Organization’ , Gender and Society4(92): 139–158 .
2.
Anderson, T., Forth, J., Metcalf, H. and Kirby, S. (2001) The Gender Pay Gap. Final Report to the Women and Equality Unit. London: Cabinet Office .
3.
Anderson-Gough, F., Grey, C. and Robson, K. (2001) ‘Tests of Time: Organizational Time-Reckoning and the Making of Accountants in Two Multi-national Accounting Firms’ , Accounting, Organizations and Society26(2): 99–122 .
4.
Arulampalam, W. and Booth, A. (1997) Labour Market Flexibility and Skills Acquisition: is there a Trade-Off? Institute for Labour Research, University of Essex , Discussion Paper 97/13.
5.
Barker, P.C. and Monks, K. (1998) ‘Irish Women Accountants and Career Progression: A Research Note’ , Accounting, Organisations and Society23(8): 813–823 .
6.
Blank, R.M. (1990) ‘Are Part-time Jobs Bad Jobs?’, pp. 123–164 in G. Burtless (ed.) A Future of Lousy Jobs? The Changing Structure of US Wages. Washington, DC: Brookings Institute .
7.
Brandth, B. and Kvande, E. (2001) ‘Flexible Work and Flexible Fathers’ , Work, Employment and Society15(2): 251–267 .
8.
Brannen, J., Lewis, S., Nilsen, A., and Smithson, J. (eds) (2002) Young Europeans, Work and Family: Futures in Transition. London: Routledge .
9.
Budig, M.J. and England, P. (2001) ‘The Wage Penalty For Motherhood’ , American Sociological Review66: 204–225 .
10.
Cooper, C.L., Lewis, S., Smithson, J. and Dyer, J. (2001) Report on Stage One of Flexible Futures. A Study of Flexible Working and Work-life Integration in the Accountancy Profession. London: Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales .
11.
Coser, L. (1974) Greedy Institutions: Patterns of Undivided Commitment. New York: Free Press .
12.
Crompton, R. (ed.) (1999) Restructuring Gender Relations and Employment: The Decline of the Male Breadwinner. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
13.
Den Dulk, L., van Doorne-Huiskes, A. and Schippers, J. (1996) ‘Work–Family Arrangements and Gender Inequality in Europe’ , Women in Management Review11(5): 25–35 .
14.
Department for Education and Employment (2000) Creating a Work-Life Balance: A Good Practice Guide for Employers. Sudbury: DFEE .
15.
Department for Trade and Industry (2002) Essential Guide to Work-life Balance. London: DTI .
16.
Dex, S. (1988) Women’s Attitudes Towards Work. London: Macmillan .
17.
Duncan, S. (1996) The Diverse Worlds of European Patriarchy, in Women of the European Union: The Politics of Work and Daily Life. M. Dolores Garcia-Ramon and J. Monk (1996). London: Routledge .
18.
Epstein, C.F., Seron, C., Oglensky, B. and Saute, R. (1999) The Part-time Paradox. New York: Routledge .
19.
Equal Opportunities Commission (2002) Research Findings: Attitudes to Equal Pay. Manchester: EOC .
20.
Fagan, C. (2001) ‘Time, Money and the Gender Order: Work Orientations and Working-time Preferences in Britain’ , Gender, Work and Organization8(3): 239–266 .
21.
Gammie, B. and Gammie, E. (1997) ‘Career Progression in Accountancy – The Role of Personal and Situational Factors’ , Women in Management Review12(5): 167–173 .
22.
Garfinkel, H. (1967) Studies in Ethnomethodology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall .
23.
Gough, O. (2001) ‘The Impact of the Gender Pay Gap on Post-Retirement Earnings’ , Critical Social Policy3(68): 311–334 .
24.
Grimshaw, D. and Rubery, J. (2001) The Gender Pay Gap: A Research Review. Manchester: Equal Opportunities Commission .
25.
Grimshaw, D. and Rubery, J. (2002) The Adjusted Gender Pay Gap: A Critical Appraisal of Standard Decomposition Techniques . Paper for the Equal Opportunities Unit in the European Commission. March.
26.
Grimshaw, D., Whitehouse, G. and Zetlin, D. (2001) ‘Changing Pay Systems, Occupational Concentration and the Gender Pay Gap: Evidence from Australia and the UK’ , Industrial Relations Journal32(3): 209–229 .
27.
Hang-Yue, N. (2002) ‘Part-time Employment in Hong Kong: A Gendered Phenomenon’ , International Journal of Human Resource Management13(2): 361–377 .
28.
Hantrais, L. (1995) ‘A Comparative Perspective on Gender and Accountancy’ , The European Accounting Review4(2): 197–215 .
29.
Harkness, S. (1996) ‘The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from the UK’ , Fiscal Studies17: 1–36 .
30.
Hatter, W., Vinter, L. and Williams, R. (2002) Dads on Dads: Needs and Expectations at Home and at Work. Equal Opportunities Commission: Manchester .
Jacobs, S. (1999) ‘Trends in Women’s Career Patterns and in Gender Occupational Mobility in Britain’ , Gender, Work and Organization6(1): 32–46 .
33.
Joshi, H. and Paci, P. (1998) Unequal Pay for Women and Men: Evidence from the British Birth Cohort Studies. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
34.
Klein, K.J., Berman, L.M. and Dickson, M.W. (2000) ‘May I Work Part-time? An Exploration of Predicted Employer Responses to Employee Requests for Part Time Work’ , Journal of Vocational Behaviour57: 85–101 .
35.
Kugelberg, C. (1998) ‘Cultural Images of Young Swedes and the Transition to Adulthood’ , Sociologia: Problemas e Practicas27: 41–58 .
36.
Lewis, S. (1997) ‘Family Friendly Policies. A Route to Changing Organisational Change or Playing Around at the Margins’ , Gender, Work and Organisation4(1): 13–23 .
37.
Lewis, S. (2001) ‘Restructuring Workplace Cultures: The Ultimate Work–Family Challenge?’ , Women in Management Review16(1): 21–29 .
38.
Lewis, S. and Smithson, J. (2002) ‘Working time, client time and family time: accounting for time in the accountancy profession’ , paper presented at International Conference of Work and Family, San Francisco, February 2002.
39.
Lewis, S., Smithson, J., Cooper, C.L. and Dyer, J. (2002) Flexible Futures: Flexible Working and Work-Life Integration. Report on Phase Two. London: ICAEW .
40.
Liff, S. and Ward, K. (2001) ‘Distorted Views Through the Glass Ceiling: The Construction of Women’s Understandings of Promotion and Senior Management Positions’ , Gender, Work and Organisation8(1): 19–36 .
41.
Mumby, D. (1988) Communication and Power in Organisations. New York: Academic Press .
42.
New Earnings Survey (2002) ‘New Earnings Survey (October 1999)’ in Just Pay: A Report to the Equal Opportunities Commission. Manchester: EOC .
43.
O’Reilly, J. and Fagan, C. (1998) Part-time Prospects: An International Comparison of Part Time Work in Europe, North America and the Pacific Rim. London: Routledge .
44.
Paci, P., Joshi, H. and Makepeace, G. (1995) ‘Pay Gaps Facing Men and Women Born in 1958: Differences Within the Labour Market’, pp. 87–112 in J. Humphries and J. Rubery (eds) The Economics of Equal Opportunities. Manchester: EOC .
45.
Parker, L. and Allen, T.D. (2001) ‘Work/Family Benefits: Variables Related to Employees’ Fairness Perceptions’ , Journal of Vocational Behaviour58(3): 453–468 .
46.
Pfau-Effinger, B. (1998) ‘Culture or Structure as Explanations for Differences in Part Time Work in Germany, Finland and the Netherlands?’, in J. O’Reilly and C. Fagan (eds) Part-time Prospects: An International Comparison of Part Time Work in Europe, North America and the Pacific Rim. London: Routledge .
47.
Plantenga, J. (2002) ‘Combining Work and Care in the Polder Model: An Assessment of the Dutch Part-Time Strategy’ , Critical Social Policy, 22(1): 53–71 .
48.
Rapoport, R., Bailyn, L., Fletcher, J. and Pruitt, B. (2002) Beyond Work–Family Balance: Advancing Gender Equity and Work Performance. London: Jossey-Bass .
49.
Reeves, R. (2002) Dad’s Army. The Case for Father-friendly Workplaces. London: The Work Foundation .
50.
Rose, M. (1994) ‘Job Satisfaction, Job Skills and Personal Skills’, in R. Penn, M. Rose and J. Rubery (eds) Skill and Occupational Change. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
51.
Rubery, J. (ed.) (1998) Equal Pay in Europe? Closing the Gender Wage Gap. London: Macmillan .
52.
Rubery, J., Smith, M. and Fagan, C. (1998) ‘National Working-time Regimes and Equal Opportunities’ , Feminist Economics4(1): 71–101 .
53.
Sacks, H. (1972) ‘On the Analyzability of Stories by Children’, pp. 325–345 in J.J. Gumperz and D. Hymes (eds) Directions in sociolinguistics. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston .
54.
Scott, J. (1999) ‘Family Change: Revolution or Backlash in Attitudes’, pp. 68–99 in S. McRae (ed.) Population and Household Change. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
55.
Sheridan, A. and Conway, L. (2001) ‘Workplace Flexibility: Reconciling the Needs of Employers and Employees’ , Women in Management Review16(1): 5–11 .
56.
Silverman, D. (1993) Interpreting Qualitative Data: Methods for Analysing Talk, Text and Interaction. London: Sage .
57.
Sirianni, C. and Negrey, C. (2000) ‘Working Time as Gendered Time’ , Feminist Economics6(1): 59–76 .
58.
Smithson, J. (1999) Equal Choices, Different Futures: Young Adults Talk About Work and Family Expectations . Psychology of Women Section Review12: 43–57 .
59.
Smithson, J. and Stokoe, E.H. (2001) Discourses of Flexibility and Work-life Balance: From Equality to Diversity? , paper presented at Gender, Work and Organisation Conference, Keele, June 2001.
60.
Stokoe, E.H. and Smithson, J. (2001) ‘Making Gender Relevant: The Construction and Negotiation of Gender Categories in Discourse’ , Discourse and Society12(2): 217–244 .
61.
Stringer, J.L. and Hopper, R. (1998) ‘Generic Hein Conversation?’ , Quarterly Journal of Speech84: 209–221 .
62.
Swaffield, J. (2000) Gender, Motivation, Experience and Wages. London: CEP .
63.
Tam, M. (1997) Part-time Employment: A Bridge or a Trap? Aldershot, VT: Avebury .
64.
Walby, S. and Olsen, W. (2002) The Impact of Women’s Position in the Labour Market on Pay and Implications for UK Productivity. Report to Women and Equality Unit, Department of Trade and Industry, November 2002. London: DTI .
65.
Warren, T. (2001) ‘Divergent Female Part-time Employment in Britain and Denmark and the Implications for Gender Equity’ , The Sociological Review:548–567 .
66.
Warren, T., Rowlingson, K. and Whyley, C. (2001) ‘Female Finances, Gender Gaps and Gender Asset Gaps’ , Work, Employment and Society15: 465–488 .
67.
Weatherall, A. (2000) ‘Gender Relevance in Talk-In-Interaction and Discourse’ , Discourse and Society11(2): 286–288 .
68.
Wetherell, M. (1998) ‘Positioning and Interpretative Repertoires: Conversation Analysis and Post-structuralism in Dialogue’ , Discourse and Society9(3): 387–412 .
69.
Whitehouse, G., Zetlin, D. and Earnshaw, J. (2001) ‘Prosecuting Pay Equity: Evolving Strategies in Britain and Australia’ , Gender, Work and Organization8(4): 365–386 .
70.
Whittock, M., Edwards, C., McLaran, S. and Robinson, O. (2002) ‘“The Tender Trap”: Gender, Part-time Nursing and the Effects of “Family-friendly” Policies on Career Advancement’ , Sociology of Health and Illness24(3): 305–326 .
71.
Wood, R.G., Corcoran, M.E. and Courant, P.N. (1993) ‘Pay Differences Among the Highly Paid: The Male–female Earnings Gap in Lawyers’ Salaries’ , Journal of Labour Economics11(3): 417–441 .
