Work-Based Learning on Trial

Abstract

The need for more flexible patterns of teaching and learning is well recognized both by industry and academic institutions. Leaner, more responsive ‘learning’ organizations require continuing, and more focused education and training for their employees. The development of suitable delivery methods has led to new challenges for higher education, itself involved in significant and continuing change. Integration of the daily experience of employees into the curriculum through work-based learning is one mechanism that might help meet the requirements of both industry and higher education. This paper reports early experiences of delivering an in-house, business studies degree programme to managers in the motor industry, using elements of work-based learning. The appropriateness and effectiveness of work-based learning as a delivery technique, and the strengths and weaknesses of the model in this context are evaluated. It is suggested that there are significant problems that need to be overcome if work-based learning is to reach its full potential. Recommendations for alleviation of the emergent difficulties are provided, and questions for further research are proposed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

‘Universities — Towers of Babble’, The Economist, 25 December 1993, pp 54–56; Steinbach

, ‘Continuous human improvement’, Training, Vol 30, No 10 1993, p 112.

Salaman

Butler

‘Why managers won't learn’, in Mabey

Iles

, eds, Managing Learning, Routledge, London, and The Open University, 1995.

Elliott

, ‘A model of professionalism and its implications for teacher education’ British Educational Research Journal, Vol 17, No 4 1991, pp 309–317.

Spender

J. C.

, ‘Knowing, managing and learning’, Management Learning, Vol 25, No 3, 1994.

King

, ‘Pay as you learn; students in the changing university’ in Schuller

, ed, The Changing University, Society for Research into Higher Education and Open University Press, Buckingham, 1995.

Duckenfield

Stirner

, Learning Through Work, Employment Department Report on Higher Education Developments, London, 1992.

Otala

‘The learning organization: Theory into practice’, Industry and Higher Education, Vol 9, No 3, June 1995, pp 157–164.

Portwood

‘Work based learning: Linking academic and vocational qualifications’, Journal of Further and Higher Education, Vol 17, No 3 1993, pp 61–69.

Little

‘Different approaches to the role of workplace mentoring’, People Management, Vol 1, No 4 1995, p 51.

10.

Trawler

‘Angels in marble? Accrediting prior experiential learning in higher education’, Studies in Higher Education, Vol 21, No 1 1996, pp 17–30.

11.

Paton

‘Tutoring managers: The use of experience-based assignments’, Open Learning, Vol 5, No 3 1990, pp 28–34.

12.

Presthus

The Organisational Society, St Martin's Press, New York, 1993.

13.

Chartrand

J.M.

‘A causal analysis to predict the personal and academic adjustment of non-traditional students’, Journal of Counselling Psychology, Vol 37, No 1 1990, pp 65–73.

14.

Op cit, Ref 12.

15.

Nicholls

J.G.

Nelson

J.R.

Gleaves

, ‘Learning “facts” versus learning that most questions have many answers; student evaluations of contrasting curricula’, Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol 87, No 2 1995, pp 253–260.

16.

Beaty

Morgan

‘Developing skill in learning’, Open Learning, Vol 6, No 3 1992, pp 3–11.

17.

Prideaux

Ford

‘Management development: Competencies, teams, learning contracts and work experience based learning’, Journal of Management Development, Vol 7, No 3 1988, pp 13–21.

18.

Salaman

Butler

‘Why managers won't learn: Special issue: Post-modern culture and management development’, Management Education and Development, Vol 2, No 3 1990, pp 183–191.

19.

Gregory

‘Accrediting work-based learning: Action learning — a model for empowerment’, Journal of Management Development, Vol 13, No 4 1994, pp 41–52.

20.

Op cit, Ref 18.

21.

Goodey

‘Teaching for Ford; real life and social science’, Open Learning, Vol 11, No 2 1996, pp 41–43.

22.

Guise

Winter

Holman

, Ford Asset Programme — Background Paper and Evaluation, Anglia Polytechnic University, Cambridge, 1994.

23.

Op cit, Ref 4.

24.

Op cit, Ref 12.

25.

Salmon

‘Tardy assignment submission by distance learning management students’, Open Learning, Vol 10, No 3 1995, pp 58–62.

26.

Schein

E. H.

, Organisational Culture and Leadership, Jossey Bass, San Francisco, CA, 1985.

27.

de Vries

M.F.R. Kets

Miller

‘Personality, culture and organisation’, Academy of Management Review, Vol 11, No 2 1986, pp 66–79.

28.

Op cit, Ref 17.

29.

Shackleton

‘The view from further education’ in Shuller

, ed, The Changing University, Society for Research into Higher Education (SRHE) and Open University Press, Buckingham, 1995.

30.

Uden

The Will to Learn: Individual Commitment and Adult Learning, National Organisation for Adult Learning, A Policy Discussion Paper, 1994.

31.

Op cit, Ref 8.

32.

Robertson

Work-Based Learning Contracts, Report on Department of Environment contracted work with Oxford Polytechnic, London, 1992.

33.

Duke

The Learning University; Towards a New Paradigm?, Society for Research into Higher Education (SRHE) and Open University Press, Buckingham, 1992.

34.

Op cit, Ref 17.