Rural hospitals have been threatened by declining revenues. Control over costs will be necessary to help these hospitals survive. Investigation of the determinants of hospital costs in Iowa reveals that costs are primarily caused by environmental factors, rather than variables over which managers have control. Furthermore, efforts by policy makers to improve hospital efficiency by stimulating competition among hospitals may have been ineffective, since the level of competition was not found to be associated with hospital production costs.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AstleyG. W.FomburnC. J. (1984). ‘Collective Strategy: Social Ecology of Organizational Environments’. Academy of Management Review, 9:576–587.
2.
ErmannD. A. (1990). ‘Rural Health Care: The Future of the Hospital’. Medical Care Review, 47:33–73.
3.
FarleyD. (1985). Competition among Hospitals: Market Structure and Its Relation to Utilization, Costs and Financial Position., Washington, D. C: GPO.
4.
FeldsteinP. J. (1983). Health Care Economics., New York: Wiley.
5.
HannanM. T.FreemanJ. H. (1977). ‘The Population Ecology of Organizations’. American Journal of Sociology, 82:929–964.
6.
HendricksA.CromwellJ. (1989). ‘Are Rural Referral Centers as Costly as Urban Hospitals?’. Health Services Research, 24:289–305.
7.
HurleyR. E.KaluznyA. D. (1987). ‘Organizational Ecology and Health Services Research: New Answers for Old and New Questions’. Medical Care Review, 44:235–255.
8.
Joint Task Force. (1989). ‘Health Care in Rural America: The Crisis Unfolds’. Journal of Public Health Policy, 10:99–116.
9.
KaluznyA.AlexanderJ.HurleyR.GallowayR. (1987). ‘Competition and Survival of Health Service Organizations: A Population Ecology Approach’. International Journal of Health Planning and Management, 2:1–14.
10.
Lewis-BeckM. S. (1983). Applied Regression., Beverly Hills: Sage.
11.
LutzS. (1987). ‘Rural Hospitals Offer New Services, Seek Affiliations in Effort to Survive’. Modern Healthcare, 17:30–43.
12.
LutzS. (1990). ‘Rural Hospitals Still Travelling A Bumpy Road’. Modern Healthcare, 20:28–36.
13.
MelnickG. A.ZwanzigerJ. (1988). ‘Hospital Behavior Under Competition and Cost-containment Policies’. JAMA, 260:669–2675.
14.
MillerC. A. (1988). ‘Achieving a Proper Fit between Health Services and Needs’. In Cost, Quality and Access in Health Care., SloanF. A.BlumsteinJ. F.PerrinJ. M., eds. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 129–157.
15.
MoscoviceI.RosenblattR. (1985a). ‘Prognosis for the Rural Hospital, Part I: What Is the Role of the Rural Hospital’. The Journal of Rural Health, 1:11–33.
16.
MoscoviceI.RosenblattR. (1985b). ‘Prognosis for the Rural Hospital, Part II: Are Rural Hospitals Economically Viable’. The Journal of Rural Health, 1:891–930.
17.
MullnerR. M.WhiteisD. G. (1988). ‘Rural Community Hospital Closure and health Policy’. Health Policy, 10:123–136.
18.
PedhazurE. J. (1982). Multiple Regression in Behavioral Research., New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
19.
ReillyB. J.LeggeJ. S.ReillyM. S. (1980). ‘A Rural Health Perspective: Principles for Rural Health Policy’. Inquiry, 17:120–127.
20.
RobinsonJ. C.LuftH. S. (1985). ‘The Impact of Hospital Market Structure on Patient Volume, Average Length of Stay, and the Cost of Care’. Journal of Health Economics, 4:333–356.
21.
RobinsonJ. C.LuftH. S. (1987). ‘Competition and Cost of Hospital Care, 1972 to 1982’. JAMA, 257:3241–3245.
22.
RowlandD.LyonsB. (1989). ‘Triple Jeopardy: Rural, Poor and Uninsured’. Health Services Research, 23(6): 975–1004.
SchrammE.RennS. (1984). ‘Hospital Mergers, Market Concentration and the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index’. Emory Law Journal, 33:77–96.
25.
ScritovskyA. A. (1985). ‘Changes in the Costs of Treatment of Selected Illnesses, 1971–1981’. Medical Care, 23:1345–1357.
26.
ShortellS. M. (1988). ‘The Characteristics and Performance of Rural Hospitals: Findings from the Multihospital Study’. New Alliances for Rural America: Background Paper Submitted to the Task Force on Rural Development., Washington, D. C: National Governors’ Association, 53–71.
27.
ShowstackJ. A.StoneM. H.SchroederS. A. (1985). ‘The Role of Changing Clinical Practices in the Rising Costs of Hospital Care’. New England Journal of Medicine, 313:1201–1207.
28.
U.S. General Accounting Office (1990). Rural Hospitals: Factors that Affect Risk of Closure., GAO/HRD 90–134, Washington, D. C.
29.
U.S. General Accounting Office (1991). Rural Hospitals: Federal Efforts Should Target Areas Where Closures Would Threaten Access to Care., GAO/HRD 91 41 February.
30.
Van HookR. T. (1988). ‘The Challenge of Rural Health’. Business and Health, 12:4–6.
31.
WhiteS. L.ChirikosT. N. (1988). ‘Measuring Hospital Competition’. Medical Care, 26:256–262.
