Crafting a payment mechanism for hospitals that provides for the legitimate operating needs of efficient institutions is an enduring health policy dilemma. The Prospective Payment System used by Medicare and some other payers in the US has been criticized for not adjusting for differences in severity of illness within diagnosis-related groups (DRGs). Previous studies have examined the relationship between profitability and severity of illness at the hospital level. This study examines the relationships between severity of illness and cost, revenue, and profit at the patient level. Two measures of severity (disease stage and number of unrelated diseases) were significant predictors of cost per case, and often had better predictive power than DRGs. In most instances, payers did not compensate adequately for severity so that higher values for the severity variables resulted in financial losses for the hospital.
ChristofferssonJ. G.ConklinJ. E.GonnellaJ.The impact of severity of illness on hospital utilization and outcomes. InfoPlus1991; 1: 1–8.
3.
ConklinJ. E.LiebermanJ. V.BarnesC. A.LouisD. Z.Disease staging: Implications for hospital reimbursement and management. Health Care Financing Review1984; 5(Suppl.): 13–22.
4.
FarleyD. E.KellyJ. V.The determinants of hospitals' financial positions. Paper presented at the American Public Health Association 1984 Annual Meeting, Anaheim, CA, USA.
5.
GapenskiL. C.VogelW. B.Langland-OrbanB.The determinants of hospital profitability. Paper presented at the Association of University Programs in Health Administration 1991 Annual Meeting, Washington, DC, USA.
6.
GonnellaJ. S.HombrookM.LouisD.Staging of disease: A case-mix measurement. JAMA1984; 251(5): 637–44.
GutermanS.AltmanS. H.YoungD. A.Hospitals' financial performance in the first five years of PPS. Health Affairs1990; 9(1): 25–33.
9.
Health Systems Review. HCFA to add measure of severity to DRGs. Health Systems Review1994 May/June: 29–33.
10.
HughesJ. S.IezzoniL. I.DaleyJ.GreenbergL.How severity measures rate hospitalized patients. Journal of General Internal Medicine1996; 11(May): 303–11.
11.
IezzoniL. I.CobbAsh J. L.MoskowitzM. A.Admission MedisGroups score and the cost of hospitalizations. Medical Care1988; 26(11): 1068–80.
12.
IezzoniL. I.AshA. S.CoffmanG. A.MoskowitzM. A.Admission and mid-stay MedisGroups® scores as predictors of hospitalization charges. Medical Care1991; 29(3): 210–20.
13.
MarksonL. B.NashD. B.LouisD. Z.GonnellaJ. S.Clinical outcomes management and disease staging. Evaluation & the Health Professions1991; 14(2): 201–27.
14.
ProPAC. Medicare and the American Health Care System. Report to the Congress.Washington, DC: ProPAC, 1994.
15.
ProPAC. Medicare and the American Health Care System. Report to the Congress.Washington, DC: ProPAC, 1996.
16.
ProPAC. Medicare and the American Health Care System. Report to the Congress.Washington, DC: ProPAC, 1997.
17.
RoskoM. D.DRGs and severity of illness measures: An analysis of patient classification systems. Journal of Medical Systems1988; 12(4): 257–74.
18.
RoskoM. D.CarpenterC. E.Development of a scalar hospital-specific severity of illness measure. Journal of Medical Systems1993; 17(1): 25–36.
19.
RoskoM. D.CarpenterC. B.The impact of intra-DRG severity of illness on hospital profitability: Implications for payment reform. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law1994; 19(4): 729–51.
20.
SchimmelV. B.AlleyC.HeathA. M.Measuring costs: Product line accounting versus ratio of costs to charge. Topics in Health Care Financing1987; 13(4): 76–86.
21.
ShwartzM.YoungD. W.SiegristR.The ratio of costs to charges: How good a basis for estimating costs?Inquiry1995; 32(4): 476–81.
22.
ShwartzM.IezzoniL. I.MoskowitzM. A.AshA. S.SawitzE.The importance of comorbidities in explaining differences in patient costs. Medical Care1996; 34(8): 767–82.
23.
SloanF. A.BeckerB. R.Cross-subsidies and payment for hospital care. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law1984; 8(4): 660–85.
24.
SmitsH. L.FetterR. B.McMahonL. F.Variation in resource use within diagnosis-related groups: The severity issue. Health Care Financing Review1984; 5(Suppl.): 71–8.
25.
TaroniF.LouisD. Z.YuenE. J.An analysis of health services using disease staging: A pilot study in the Emilia-Romagna region of Italy. Journal of Management in Medicine1992; 6(2): 53–66.
26.
ThomasJ. W.AshcraftM. L. F.Measuring severity of illness: Six severity systems and their ability to explain cost variations. Inquiry1991; 28(1): 39–55.
27.
ZuckermanS.Commercial insurers and all-payer regulation: Evidence on hospitals responses to financial need. Journal of Health Economics1987; 6(3): 165–87.
