‘Community leadership’ and ‘place-shaping’ embody the outward-facing orientation of English local government to engage local communities in deliberative governance. The apparent synergies between them suggest they might be complementary roles yet one emphasizes ‘sense of direction’ while the other stresses ‘sense of place’. What do they mean in practice? Evidence of the impact of community leadership since 2000 suggests the engagement of communities into community governance spaces such as Local Strategic Partnerships (LSPs) has been partially successful. Rather than empowering participation in governance spaces, community power has been concentrated into the hands of political and managerial elites. Policy statements since 2006 have emphasized a need for councils to exert strong local leadership. Do community leadership and place-shaping provide a complementary governance framework, or does place-shaping indicates a shift away from a normative and problematic model of community empowerment? Using Bourdieu’s notion of the social space, this article considers the nature of ‘governance space’ and its role in a changing model of community governance.
Andrews. R., Cowell. R., Downe. J., Martin. S. and Turner. D. ( 2008) ‘Supporting Effective Citizenship in Local Government: Engaging, Educating, and Empowering Local Citizens’, Local Government Studies, 34(4): pp. 489-507.
2.
Aspden. J. and Birch. D. ( 2005) New Localism - Citizen Engagement, Neighbourhood and Public Services: Evidence from Local Government. London: ODPM.
3.
Audit Commission (2003) Community Leadership: Learning from Comprehensive Performance Assessment Briefing 1 . London: Audit Commission.
4.
Bailey. N. ( 2003) ‘Local Strategic Partnerships in England. The Continuing Search for Collaborative Advantage, Leadership and Strategy in Urban Governance’, Planning Theory and Practice, 4(4): pp. 443-57.
5.
Barnes, M., Newman, J. and Sullivan, H. ( 2006) ‘Discursive Arenas: Deliberation and the Constitution of Identity in Public Participation at a Local Level’, Social Movement Studies, 5(3): pp. 193-207.
6.
Blair, Tony Rt. Hon (1998) Leading the Way: A New Vision for Local Government . Brighton: IPPR.
7.
Bourdieu, P. ( 1990) The Logic of Practice. Cambridge: The Polity Press.
8.
Bourdieu, P. ( 1991) Language and Symbolic Power, ed. E.P. Thompson.Cambridge: The Polity Press.
9.
Bourdieu, P. ( 2005) ‘The Mystery of Ministry’, in Pierre Bourdieu and Democratic Politics, ed. L. Wacquant.Cambridge: The Polity Press.
10.
Bteg (2006) Participation and Local Strategic Partnerships: A Research Project for the Commission for Racial Equality. London: BTEG Urban Forum /CRE.
11.
Clegg, S. and McNulty, K. ( 2002) ‘Partnership Working in Delivering Social Inclusion: Organizational and Gender Dynamics’, Journal of Education Policy, 17(5): pp. 587-601.
12.
Cochrane, A. ( 2003) ‘The New Urban Policy: Towards Empowerment or Incorporation?: The Practice of Urban Policy’, in R. Imrie and M. Raco (eds) Urban Renaissance?: New Labour, Community and Urban Policy. Bristol: The Polity Press.
13.
Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (CABE) (2002) ‘Streets of Shame, Summary of Findings’, in Public Attitudes to Architecture and the Built Environment . London: CABE.
14.
Conisbee, M., Kjell, P., Oram, J., Bridges-Palmer, J., Simms, A. and Taylor, J. ( 2004) Clone Town Britain: The Loss of Local Identity on the Nation’s High Streets. London: New Economics Foundation.
15.
Cooke, P. (ed.) (1989) Localities: The Changing Face of Urban Britain. London: Unwin Hyman Ltd.
16.
Dclg (2006a) Local Area Agreements Research: Round 2 Negotiations and Early Progress in Round 1. London: DCLG.
17.
Dclg (2006b) Strong and Prosperous Communities: The Local Government White Paper. London, Cmd 6939-1.
18.
Delanty, G. ( 2003) Community: Key Ideas. London: Routledge.
19.
Detr (1998) Modern Local Government: In Touch with the People. London, Cmd 4014.
20.
Dtlr (2001) Local Strategic Partnerships: Government Guidance. London: DTLR .
21.
Downe. J. and Martin. S. ( 2006) ‘Joined up Policy in Practice?: The Coherence and Impacts of the Local Government Modernisation Agenda’, Local Government Studies, 32(4): pp. 465-88.
22.
Egan, J. ( 2004) The Egan Review: Skills for Sustainable Communities. London: DCLG.
23.
Figueira-McDonagh, J. ( 2001) Community Analysis and Praxis. Philadelphia , PA: Taylor & Francis.
24.
Fung, A. ( 2004) Empowered Participation: Reinventing Urban Democracy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
25.
Gains. F. and John. P. ( 2005) Political Leadership Under the New Political Management Structures. London: ODPM.
26.
Gains, F., Greasley, S., John, P. and Stoker, G. ( 2007) Does Leadership Matter?: A Summary of Evidence on the Role and Impact of Political Leadership in Local Government. London: DCLG.
27.
Gaventa, J. ( 2004) Representation, Community Leadership and Participation: Citizen Involvement in Neighbourhood Renewal and Local Governance. Prepared for the Neighbourhood Renewal Unit Office of Deputy Prime Minister. Brighton: Institute of Development Studies.
28.
Geddes, M. ( 2005) Making Public Private Partnerships Work. Building Relationships and Understanding Cultures. Aldershot: Gower.
29.
Goss, S. ( 2005) National Evaluation of Local Strategic Partnerships Issues Paper: Leadership in LSPs. London: Office for Public Management.
30.
Grint. K. ( 2005) Leadership: Limits and Possibilities. Basingstoke: Palgrave and Macmillan.
31.
Grönn. P. ( 2002) ‘Distributed Leadership’, in K. Leithwood, P. Hallinger , K. Seashore-Louis, G. Furman-Brown, P. Grönn , W. Mulford and K. Riley (eds) Second International Handbook of Educational Leadership and Administration. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
32.
Heifetz, R.A. ( 2003), Adaptive Work, in The Adaptive State, Bently, T. & Wilsdon, J. (eds). (London, Demos)
33.
Hunter, F. ( 1953), Community Power Structure: A Study of Decision Makers, (USA University of North Carolina Press)
34.
Imrie, R. and Raco, M. ( 2003) ‘Community and the Changing nature of Urban Policy’ , in R. Imrie and M. Raco (eds) Urban Renaissance?: New Labour, Community and Urban Policy. Bristol: The Polity Press.
35.
Jenkins, R. ( 1992, 2000 edn) Pierre Bourdieu. Oxford: Routledge.
36.
Leach, S., Lowndes, V., Cowell, R. and Downe, J. ( 2005) Meta-Evaluation of the Local Government Modernisation Agenda: progress Report on Stakeholder Engagement with Local Government. London: ODPM.
37.
Leadership Centre for Local Government (2008 ) The Politics of Place. London: Leadership Centre for Local Government.
38.
Lowndes, V. and Leach, S. ( 2004) ‘Understanding Local Political Leadership: Constitutions , Contexts and Capabilities’, Local Government Studies , 30(4): pp. 557-75.
39.
Lowndes, V. and Sullivan, H. ( 2004) ‘Like a Horse and Carriage or a Fish on a Bicycle: How Well do Local Partnerships and Public Participation go Together?’ , Local Government Studies, 30(1): pp. 51-73.
40.
Lyons, M. Sir ( 2007) The Lyons Inquiry into Local Government. London: The Stationery Office.
41.
Milliband, D. Rt. Hon. (2006) Empowerment and the Deal for Devolution. London: ODPM.
42.
Mitchell, L. and Skinner, S. ( 2007) Skilling Up for LSPs: Research on Leadership Skills for Effective Strategic Representation. A Report for the Improving Local Partnerships Project at NACVA. Sheffield: NACVA .
43.
Morris, J. ( 2006) Removing the Barriers to Participation. A Report by the National Community Forum. London: Neighbourhood Renewal Unit.
44.
Munro, H., Roberts, M. and Skelcher, C. ( 2008) ‘Partnership, Governance and Democratic Effectiveness’ , Public Policy & Administration, 23(1): pp. 61-79.
45.
Northouse, P. ( 1997) Leadership: Theory and Practice. Thousand, CA: SAGE.
46.
Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (ODPM) ( 2005) Vibrant Local Leadership. London: ODPM/Local Vision.
47.
Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (ODPM) ( 2006) National Evaluation of Local Strategic Partnerships: Formative Evaluation and Action Research Programme: Final Report. London: ODPM/Department of Transport .
48.
Ostrom, E. ( 1999) ‘Institutional Rational Choice: An Assessment of the Institutional and Development Framework’, in P.A. Sabatier (ed.) Theories of the Policy Process. Boulder, CO and Oxford: Westview Press.
49.
Purdue, D. ( 2001) ‘Neighbourhood Governance: Leadership, Trust and Social Capital’, Urban Studies, 38(12): pp. 2211-24.
50.
Purdue, D. ( 2005) ‘Community Leadership Cycles and the Consolidation of Neighbourhood Coalitions in the New Local Governance’, Public Management Review, 7(2): pp. 247-66.
51.
Pye. A. ( 2005) ‘Leadership and Organising: Sensemaking in Action’ , Leadership, 1(1): pp. 31-50.
52.
Rai, S. ( 2008) Routes and Barriers to Citizen Governance. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
53.
Raynsford, N. ( 2004) Speech on the Future of Local Government to Local Government Association, 16 December 2004. London: DCLG.
54.
Russell, H. ( 2005) National evaluation of Local Strategic Partnerships. Issues Paper: Voluntary and Community Sector Engagement in LSPs. London: OPDM/ Department of Transport.
55.
Russell, H. ( 2008) Community Engagement: Some Lessons from the New Deal for Communities Programme. London: DCLG.
56.
Simmons. R., Birchall. J., Doheny. S. and Powell. M. ( 2007) ‘"Citizen Governance": Opportunities for Inclusivity in Policy and Policy Making’, Policy and Politics, 35(3): pp. 457-78.
57.
Skelcher. C., Mathur. N. and Smith. M. ( 2005) ‘The Public Governance of Collaborative Space: Discourse , Design and Democracy’, Public Administration, 83(3): 573-96.
58.
Stoker, G. ( 2004) Transforming Local Governance: From Thatcherism to New Labour. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
59.
Stoker, G., Gains, F., Greasley, S., John, P. and Rao, N. ( 2007) The New Council Constitutions: The Outcomes and Impact of the LGA 2000. London: DCLG.
60.
Stone, C. ( 1989) Regime Politics: Governing Atlanta 1946-1988. USA, Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.
61.
Sullivan, H. ( 2008) Meta-evaluation of the Local Government Modernisation Agenda. The State of Governance of Places: Community Leadership and Stakeholder Engagement. London: DCLG.
62.
Sullivan, H. and Howard, J. ( 2005) Below the LSP, Issues paper, national evaluation of LSPs . London: ODPM.
63.
Sullivan, H. and Sweeting, D. ( 2005) Community Leadership: Impacts of the LGMA. London: DCLG.
64.
’t Hart, P., Uhr, J., Kane. J. and Patapan. H. ( 2008) ‘Understanding Dispersed Leadership in Democracy’ , paper presented at the Political Studies Association Conference, 1-3 April.
65.
Thompson, J.B. (ed.) ‘Editor’s Introduction’, in P. Bourdieu ( 1991) Language and Symbolic Power. Cambridge : The Polity Press.
66.
Wainwright, H. ( 2001) ‘Measuring Power and Democratic Legitimacy’ , paper presented at the Audit Commission, Seminar , London, 4 December.
