This article argues that a new diagram is emerging in the criminal justice system as it encounters developments in the neurosciences. This does not take the form that concerns many ‘neuroethicists’ — it does not entail a challenge to doctrines of free will and the notion of the autonomous legal subject — but is developing around the themes of susceptibility, risk, pre-emption and precaution. I term this diagram ‘screen and intervene’ and in this article I attempt to trace out this new configuration and consider some of the consequences.
Alberg, C., Hatfield, B. and Huxley, P. ( 1996) Learning Materials on Mental Health Risk Assessment. Manchester: University of Manchester Press.
2.
Allen, H. ( 1984) ‘At the Mercy of Her Hormones: Premenstrual Tension and the Law’, M/F9: 19-44.
3.
American Psychiatric Association (2000) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-IV (Text Revision) . Washington, DC: APA.
4.
Anderson, C. ( 1992) ‘Brain Scans deemed Admissable at Trial’, New York Law Journal210(1).
5.
Brennan, P.A., Mednick, S.A. and Hodgins, S. ( 2000) ‘Major Mental Disorders and Criminal Violence in a Danish Birth Cohort’, Archives of General Psychiatry57(5): 494-500.
6.
Brunner, H.G. ( 1996) ‘MAOA Deficiency and Abnormal Behaviour: Perspectives on an Association’, in G. R. Bock and J. A. Goode (eds) Genetics of Criminal and Antisocial Behaviour. New York : Wiley, pp. 155-64.
7.
Brunner, H.G., Nelen, M., Breakefield, X.O. et al. (1993) ‘Abnormal Behavior associated with a Point Mutation in the Structural Gene for Monoamine Oxidase-A’, Science262(5133): 578-80.
8.
Bufkin, J.L. and Luttrell, V.R. ( 2005) ‘Neuroimaging Studies of Aggressive and Violent Behavior: Current Findings and Implications for Criminology and Criminal Justice’ , Trauma, Violence, & Abuse6(2): 176-91.
9.
Caspi, A., McClay, J., Moffitt, T.E. et al. (2002) ‘Role of Genotype in the Cycle of Violence in Maltreated Children’, Science297(5582): 851-4.
10.
Caspi, A. and Moffitt, T.E. ( 2006) ‘Gene-Environment Interactions in Psychiatry: Joining Forces with Neuroscience’, Nature Reviews Neuroscience7: 583-90.
11.
Castel, R. ( 1991) ‘From Dangerousness to Risk’, in G. Burchell, C. Gordon and P. Miller (eds) The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf, pp. 281-98.
12.
Cauffman, E., Steinberg, L. and Piquero, A.R. ( 2005) ‘Psychological, Neuropsychological and Physiological Correlates of Serious Antisocial Behavior in Adolescence: The Role of Self-Control’ , Criminology43(1): 133-75.
13.
Chen, A.C.H., Porjesz, B., Rangaswamy, M. et al. (2007) ‘Reduced Frontal Lobe Activity in Subjects with High Impulsivity and Alcoholism’, Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research31(1): 156-65.
14.
Cohen, S. ( 1985) Visions of Social Control: Crime, Punishment and Classification . Cambridge: Polity.
15.
Coid, J.W. ( 1996) ‘Dangerous Patients with Mental Illness: Increased Risks Warrant New Policies, Adequate Resources, and Appropriate Legislation’, British Medical Journal312: 965-6.
Denno, D.W. ( 1988) ‘Human-Biology and Criminal Responsibility - Free Will or Free Ride’, University Of Pennsylvania Law Review137(2): 615-71.
19.
Denno, D.W. ( 1990) Biology and Violence: From Birth to Adulthood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
20.
Department of Health (2002) Mental Health Bill Consultation Document Cm 5538-111. Norwich, Nk: Stationery Office.
21.
Douglas, M. and Wildavsky, A.B. ( 1982) Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technical and Environmental Dangers. Berkeley and London: University of California Press.
22.
Duggan, C. ( 1997) ‘Assessing Risk in the Mentally Disordered: Introduction’ , The British Journal of Psychiatry17(supp. 32): 1-39.
23.
Ericson, R.V. and Doyle, D. ( 2003) Risk and Morality. Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press.
24.
Ewald, F. ( 2001) ‘The Return of Descartes’ Malicious Demon: an Outline of a Philosophy of Precaution’, in T. Baker and J. Simon (eds) Embracing Risk: The Changing Culture of Insurance and Responsibility. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press, pp. 273-302.
25.
Farrington, D.P. ( 1997) ‘Key Issues in studying the Biosocial Bases of Violence’ , Biosocial Bases of Violence292: 293-300.
26.
Farrington, D.P. and Coid, J. ( 2003) Early Prevention of Adult Antisocial Behaviour. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
27.
Fishbein, D.H. ( 1996) ‘Prospects for the Application of Genetic Findings to Crime and Violence Prevention’, Politics and the Life Sciences15(1): 91-4.
28.
Fishbein, D.H. and Henry, S. ( 2002) ‘Biological Perspectives in Criminology’, in S. Cote (ed.) Criminological Theories: Bridging the Past to the Future. London: Sage, pp. 41-72.
29.
Garland, B. and Frankel, M.S. ( 2006) ‘The Impact of Behavioral Genetics on the Criminal Law: "Considering Convergence: a Policy Dialogue about Behavioral Genetics, Neuroscience, and Law"’, Law & Contemporary Problems69(1-2): 101-14.
30.
Gigerenzer, G. ( 2002) Reckoning with Risk: Learning to Live with Uncertainty . London: Penguin.
31.
Glannon, W. ( 2007) Bioethics and the Brain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
32.
Hacking, I. ( 1992) ‘World-Making by Kind-Making: Child Abuse for Example’ , in M. Douglas and D. Hull (eds) How Classification Works: Nelson Goodman Among the Social Sciences. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 180-238.
33.
Harrington, R. and Bailey, S. ( 2003) ‘The Scope for Preventing Antisocial Personality Disorder by Intervening in Adolescence’, NHS National Programme on Forensic Mental Health Research and Development .
34.
Haynes, J.D. and Rees, G. ( 2006) ‘Decoding Mental States from Brain Activity in Humans’ , Nature Reviews Neuroscience7(7): 523-34.
35.
Hendricks, T.J., Fyodorov, D.V., Wegman, L.J. et al. (2003) ‘Pet-1 ETS Gene plays a Critical Role in 5-HT Neuron Development and is required for Normal Anxiety-Like and Aggressive Behavior’, Neuron37(2): 233-47.
36.
Hollander, E. and Evers, M. ( 2001) ‘New Developments in Impulsivity’, The Lancet358(9286): 949-50.
37.
Home Office and Department of Health (1999 ) ‘Managing Dangerous People with Severe Personality Disorder: Proposals for Policy Development’, London: Stationery Office.
38.
Illes, J. ( 2005) Neuroethics: Defining the Issues in Theory, Practice, and Policy. Oxford and New York : Oxford University Press.
39.
Kim-Cohen, J., Moffitt, T.E., Taylor, A. et al. (2005) ‘Maternal Depression and Children’s Antisocial Behavior: Nature and Nurture Effects’, Archives of General Psychiatry62(2): 173-81.
40.
Kirchmeier, J.L. ( 2004) ‘A Tear in the Eye of the Law: Mitigating Factors and the Progression toward a Disease Theory of Criminal Justice’, Oregon Law Review83: 631.
41.
Kozel, F.A., Padgett, T.M. and George, M.S. ( 2004) ‘A Replication Study of the Neural Correlates of Deception’, Behavioral Neuroscience118(4): 852-6.
42.
Kozel, F.A., Revell, L.J., Lorberbaum, J.P. et al. (2004) ‘A Pilot Study of Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Brain Correlates of Deception in Healthy Young Men’ , Journal of Neuropsychiatry & Clinical Neurosciences16: 295-305.
43.
Krämer, U.M., Jansma, H., Tempelmann, C. et al. (2007) ‘Tit-for-tat: The Neural Basis of Reactive Aggression’, NeuroImage38(1): 203-11.
44.
Langleben, D.D., Schroeder, L., Maldjian, J.A. et al. (2002) ‘Brain Activity during Simulated Deception: an Event-Related Functional Magnetic Resonance Study’, NeuroImage15(3): 727-32.
45.
Lebowitz, B. D., ed. (2004) ‘Mild Cognitive Impairment’, Dialogues in Cognitive Neuroscience6(4): 349-50.
46.
Lee, T.-S., Ng, B.-Y. et al. (2008) ‘Neuropsychiatry - an Emerging Field’ , Annals of the Academy of Medicine Singapore37(7): 601-5.
47.
Levy, N. ( 2007) Neuroethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
48.
Maden, A. ( 2007) ‘Dangerous and Severe Personality Disorder: Antecedents and Origins’, The British Journal of Psychiatry190(supp. 49): s8-s11.
49.
Manuck, S.B., Flory, J.D., Ferrell, R.E. et al. (2000) ‘A Regulatory Polymorphism of the Monoamine Oxidase-A Gene may be associated with Variability in Aggression, Impulsivity, and Central Nervous System Serotonergic Responsivity’, Psychiatry Research95(1): 9-23.
50.
Marcus, S., ed. (2002) Neuroethics: Mapping the Field: Conference Proceedings, May 13-14, 2002, San Francisco, California. New York: Dana Press .
51.
Margo, J. and Stevens, A. ( 2008) Make Me a Criminal: Preventing Youth Crime. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
52.
Mark, V.H. and Ervin, F.R. ( 1970) Violence and the Brain. New York and London: Harper & Row.
53.
Maudsley, H. ( 1874) Responsibility in Mental Disease. London: Henry S. King.
Miczek, K.A., De Almeida, R.M.M., Kravitz, E.A. et al. (2007) ‘Neurobiology of Escalated Aggression and Violence’, Journal of Neuroscience27: 11803-6.
56.
Mobbs, D., Lau, H.C., Jones, O.D. et al. (2007) ‘Law, Responsibility, and the Brain’ , PLoS Biology5(4): 693-700.
57.
Monahan, J. ( 1981) The Clinical Prediction of Violent Behavior. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
58.
Moon, G. ( 2000) ‘Risk and Protection: the Discourse of Confinement in Contemporary Mental Health Policy’, Health and Place6(3): 239-50.
59.
Moran, R. ( 1991) ‘The Insanity Defense: Five Years after Hinckley’ , in R. J. Kelley and D. E. Macnamara (eds) Perspectives on Deviance: Domination, Degradation and Denigration. Cincinatti, OH : Anderson, pp. 77-87.
60.
Morley, K.I. and Hall, W.D. ( 2003) ‘Is there a Genetic Susceptibility to engage in Criminal Acts’, in Trends and Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice 263. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.
61.
Munro, E. and Rumgay, J. ( 2000) ‘Role of Risk Assessment in reducing Homicides by People with Mental Illness’, British Journal of Psychiatry176: 116-20.
62.
National Institute for Mental Health in England ( 2003) ‘Personality Disorder: No Longer a Diagnosis of Exclusion’, Policy Implementation Guidance for the Development of Services for People with Personality Disorder, Gateway reference 1055. London: NIMH(E).
63.
Nuffield Council on Bioethics (2009) The Forensic Use of Bioinformation: Ethical Issues. London : Nuffield Council on Bioethics.
64.
Odgers, C.L., Moffitt, T.E., Poulton, R. et al. (2008) ‘Female and Male Antisocial Trajectories: From Childhood Origins to Adult Outcomes’, Development and Psychopathology20: 673-716.
65.
Office of National Statistics (2003) Mortality Statistics: Injury and Poisoning, Series DH4 No. 26. London: ONS.
66.
Parens, E., Chapman, A.R. and Press, N. ( 2006) Wrestling with Behavioral Genetics: Science, Ethics, and Public Conversation. Baltimore, MD and London: Johns Hopkins University Press.
67.
Power, M. ( 2004) The Risk Management of Everything: Rethinking the Politics of Uncertainty. London: Demos.*
68.
Pritchard, J.C. ( 1835) A Treatise on Insanity and Other Disorders of the Mind . London: Sherwood, Gilbert & Piper.
69.
Rafter, N.H. ( 1997) Creating Born Criminals. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
70.
Raine, A. ( 2002) ‘Biosocial Studies of Antisocial and Violent Behavior in Children and Adults: a Review’, Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology30(4): 311-26.
71.
Raine, A., Brennan, P. et al. (1994) ‘Violence and Biology’, Science265(5176): 1153-1261.
72.
Raine, A., Brennan, P. and Farrington, D.P. ( 1997) ‘Biosocial Bases of Violence - Conceptual and Theoretical Issues’, Biosocial Bases of Violence292: 1-20.
73.
Raine, A., Buchsbaum, M. and LaCasse, L. ( 1997) ‘Brain Abnormalities in Murderers indicated by Positron Emission Tomography’, Biological Psychiatry42(6): 495-508.
74.
Raine, A., Buchsbaum, M.S., Stanley, J. et al. (1994) ‘Selective Reductions in Prefrontal Glucose-Metabolism in Murderers’, Biological Psychiatry36(6): 365-73.
75.
Raine, A. and Liu, J.H. ( 1998) ‘Biological Predispositions to Violence and Their Implications for Biosocial Treatment and Prevention’, Psychology, Crime & Law4(2): 107-25.
76.
Redding, R.E. ( 2006) ‘The Brain-Disordered Defendant: Neuroscience and Legal Insanity in the Twenty-First Century’, American University Law Review51: 56-127.
77.
Reiss, A.J. and Roth, J.A. ( 1993) Understanding and Preventing Violence: Report of the National Research Council Panel on the Understanding and Control of Violent Behavior . Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
78.
Reiss, A.J., Roth, J.A. and Miczek, K.A. ( 1994) Understanding and Preventing Violence: Report of the National Research Council Panel on the Understanding and Control of Violent Behavior . Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
79.
Romeo, R., Knapp, M. and Scott, S. ( 2006) ‘Economic Cost of Severe Antisocial Behaviour in Children - and Who pays It’, British Journal of Psychiatry188: 547-53.
80.
Rose, N. ( 1996) ‘Psychiatry as a Political Science: Advanced Liberalism and the Administration of Risk’, History of the Human Sciences9(2): 1-23.
81.
Rose, N. ( 1998a) ‘Governing Risky Individuals: the Role of Psychiatry in New Regimes of Control’, Psychiatry, Psychology & Law5(2): 177-95.
82.
Rose, N. ( 1998b) ‘Living Dangerously: Risk-Thinking and Risk Management in Mental Health Care’, Mental Health Care1(8): 263-6.
83.
Rose, N. ( 2000a) ‘The Biology of Culpability: Pathological Identity and Crime Control in a Biological Culture’, Theoretical Criminology4(1): 5-43.
84.
Rose, N. ( 2000b) ‘Government and Control’, British Journal of Criminology40(2): 321-39.
85.
Sachdev, P.S. ( 2002) ‘Neuropsychiatry - a Discipline for the Future’ , Journal of Psychosomatic Research53: 625-7.
86.
Saulitis, A. ( 1979) ‘Chromosomes and Criminality: the Legal Implications of the XYY Syndrome’, Journal of Legal Medicine1(3): 269-91.
87.
Scarpa, A. and Raine, A. ( 1997) ‘Biology of Wickedness’, Psychiatric Annals27(9): 624-9.
88.
Scott, S., Knapp, M., Henderson, J. et al. (2001) ‘Financial Cost of Social Exclusion: Follow-up Study of Antisocial Children into Adulthood’, British Medical Journal323(7306): 191-4.
89.
Steadman, H.J. ( 2000) ‘From Dangerousness to Risk Assessment of Community Violence: Taking Stock at the Turn of the Century’, Journal of American Academy Psychiatry and the Law28(3): 265-71.
90.
Steadman, H.J., Monahan, J., Robbins, P.C. et al. (1993) ‘From Dangerousness to Risk Assessment: Implications for Appropriate Research Strategies’, in S. Hodgins (ed.) Mental Disorder and Crime . Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
91.
Sunstein, C.R. ( 2005) Laws of Fear: Beyond the Precautionary Principle. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
92.
Taylor, P.J. and Gunn, J. ( 1999) ‘Homicides by People with Mental Illness: Myth and Reality’, The British Journal of Psychiatry174(1): 9-14.
93.
Viding, E., Blair, R.J.R., Moffitt, T.E. et al. (2005) ‘Evidence for Substantial Genetic Risk for Psychopathy in 7-year-old’, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry46(6): 592-7.
94.
Viding, E., Jones, A.P., Frick, P.J. et al. (2008) ‘Heritability of Antisocial Behaviour at 9: Do Callous-Unemotional Traits matter?’, Developmental Science11(1): 17-22.
95.
Viding, E., Larsson, H. and Jones, A.P. ( 2008) ‘Quantitative Genetic Studies of Antisocial Behaviour’ , Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B-Biological Sciences363(1503): 2519-27.
96.
Wasserman, D. ( 1995) ‘Science and Social Harm: Genetic Research into Crime and Violence’, Report from the Institute of Philosophy and Public Policy15(1): 14-19.
97.
Wasserman, D. ( 1996) ‘Research into Genetics and Crime: Consensus and Controversy’, Politics and the Life Sciences15(1): 107-9.
98.
Wasserman, D. and Wachbroit, R., eds (2001) Genetics and Criminal Behavior . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
99.
Wolpe, P.R., Foster, K.R. and Langleben, D.D. ( 2005) ‘Emerging Neurotechnologies for Lie-Detection: Promises and Perils’, American Journal of Bioethics5(2): 39-49.
100.
Yudofsky, S.C. and Hales, R.E. ( 2002) ‘Neuropsychiatry and the Future of Psychiatry and Neurology’, American Journal of Psychiatry159(8): 1261-4.
101.
Zeki, S. and Goodenough, O.R. ( 2004) ‘Law and the Brain: Introduction’, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B-Biological Sciences359(1451): 1661-5.
