Modeling and numerical analysis of multi-bolt elastic interaction with bolt stress relaxation

Abstract

Multi-bolt joint distributed around the connecting members are generally adopted to meet the high-performance assembly requirements in aerospace, energy and power industries. However, the initial preload could be low due to non-optimized preload sequence and bolt stress relaxation, especially at elevated temperature. Thus, it is necessary to take elastic interaction and bolt stress relaxation into account before jointing. In this article, a general multi-bolt elastic interaction with bolt stress relaxation is modelled analytically. First, the multi-bolt joint is characterized by ‘spring-node’ model and elastic interaction stiffness. Second, the bolt residual preload can be estimated according to linear superposition of elastic interaction and bolt stress relaxation under the condition of node displacement equilibrium. Further, the influence of preloading sequence and bolt stress relaxation on residual preload distribution was numerically analyzed using a typical circular ring with 8-bolt joint. Two bolts’ preloading sequences were planned, star sequence and counterclockwise sequence, respectively. The bolt creep simulation time was set as 10 h using the power-model at intermediate temperature. From comparison, the predicted results using the developed model were consistent with the FE simulations both with and without bolt stress relaxation.

Keywords

Multi-bolt elastic interaction bolt creep modeling

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bickford

Nassar

. Handbook of bolts and bolted joints, New York: CRC Press, 1998.

Dinger

Friedrich

. Avoiding self-loosening failure of bolted joints with numerical assessment of local contact state. Eng Fail Anal 2011; 18: 2188–2200.

Croccolo

De Agostinis

Vincenzi

. Failure analysis of bolted joints: effect of friction coefficients in torque-preloading relationship. Eng Fail Anal 2011; 18: 364–373.

Zhu L, Hong J, Yang G, et al. The slippage analysis at bearing surface of bolted joints due to cyclic transverse loads. In: Proceedings of IMECE2012: ASME international mechanical engineering congress and exposition, Houston, USA, 9–15 November 2012, pp.685–690.

Olmi

. An experimental investigation on a crack propagating from a geartrain housing in an asphalt milling machine. Eng Fail Anal 2014; 38: 38–48.

Cornwell

. Computation of load factors in bolted connections. Proc IMechE, Part C: J Mechanical Engineering Science 2009; 223: 795–808.

Majzoobi

Dabbagh

Asgari

. Improvement of performance of bolt-nut connections, Part II: Experimental investigation. Proc IMechE, Part C: J Mechanical Engineering Science 2014; 228: 3078–3089.

Mao

Wang

Liu

. Comparative study of flange-to-seal contact couplings with bolt relaxation under creep condition. ASME-J Eng Gas Turb Power 2014; 136: 072504–072504.

Abasolo

Aguirrebeitia

Avilés

. A tetraparametric metamodel for the analysis and design of bolting squences for wind generator flanges. ASME-J Press Vessel Technol 2011; 133: 041202–041202.

10.

Abasolo

Aguirrebeitia

Avilés

. Methodology for the optimization of bolting sequences for wind generator flanges. ASME-J Press Vessel Technol 2014; 136: 061202–061202.

11.

Bouzid

Galai

. A new approach to model bolted flange joints with full face gaskets. ASME-J Press Vessel Technol 2011; 133: 021203–021203.

12.

Alkelani

Nassar

Housari

. Formulation of elastic interaction between bolts during the tightening of flat-face gasketed joints. J Mech Des 2009; 131: 021004–021004.

13.

Nassar

Yang

. Novel formulation of bolt elastic interaction in gasketed joints. ASME-J Press Vessel Technol 2009; 131: 051204–051204.

14.

Abid

Hussain

. Relaxation behaviour of gasketed joints during assembly using finite element analysis. Sadhana-Acad Proc Eng Sci 2010; 35: 31–43.

15.

Bouzid

Nechache

. An analytical solution for evaluating gasket stress change in bolted flange connections subjected to high temperature loading. ASME-J Press Vessel Technol 2005; 127: 414–422.

16.

Nassar

Alkelani

. Clamp load loss due to elastic interaction and gasket stress relaxation and creep in bolted joints. ASME-J Press Vessel Technol 2006; 128: 394–401.

17.

Abboud

Nassar

. Viscoelastic strain hardening model for gasket stress relaxation and creep. ASME-J Press Vessel Technol 2013; 135: 31201–31201.

18.

Housari

Alkelani

Nassar

. A proposed model for predicting clamp load loss due to gasket stress relaxation and creep in bolted joints. ASME-J Press Vessel Technol 2012; 134: 21201–21201.

19.

Nechache

Bouzid

. Creep analysis of bolted flange joints. Int J Pressure Vessel Piping 2007; 84: 185–194.

20.

Bouzid

Nechache

. The modelling of bolted flange joints used with disc springs and tube spacers to reduce relaxation. Int J Pressure Vessel Piping 2010; 87: 730–736.

21.

Sun ZG and Gu BQ. Effect of external bending moment and creep on sealing behavior of bolted flanged connections. In: International conference on measuring technology and mechatronics automation, ICMTMA'09, IEEE, Zhangjiajie, Hunan ,11–12 April 2009, pp.75–78.