Design and analysis of a large horizontal vessel supported on multiple saddles according to three-moment theorem and Zick’s method

Abstract

For the engineering design of large horizontal vessels with uneven multiple saddles, no clear specifications are given in design codes, especially with uneven settlements. In this paper, an analytical method based on three-moment theorem with settlements is introduced to evaluate the shear forces and bending moments at some critical cross-sections of a large horizontal pressure vessel supported on 10 saddles with uneven settlements. Zick’s stress analysis method for a horizontal vessel supported on two saddles is extended to the multiple saddle arrangements. It is found that as a result of varied cross-section and uneven saddle supports, the shear forces and bending moments are different at different saddle sections. Finite element calculations are also performed to prove the analytical solutions. Results show that for the vessel without settlements, the bending moments and reactions obtained by the three-moment equation method are slightly larger than those obtained by finite element method. Non-uniform deformation of the vessel at different saddles may be contributed to the differences of the two results. For the vessel with settlements, the bending moments and reactions at some saddles obtained by the three-moment equation method are quite larger than those obtained by finite element method. But if the actual axis settlement of the vessel is applied to the three-moment equation method, the two results are close to each other. Experiments are also carried out to verify the reliability of the proposed method.

Keywords

Multiple saddle settlement three-moment theorem Zick’s method horizontal vessel

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ASME. Boiler & pressure vessel design codes an international code, section VIII division 2 rules for construction of pressure vessel, part 4 design by rule requirements, subsection 15, design rules for supports and attachments, 2010.

Megyesy

. Pressure vessel handbook, Tulsa, OK: Pressure Vessel Publishing, Inc., 2001.

EN13445-3. Unfired pressure vessels – part 3: design, section 16.8: horizontal vessels on saddle supports, 2009.

Zick

. Stresses in large horizontal cylindrical pressure vessels on two saddle supports. Weld J Res Suppl 1951; 30: 435–445.

Zick

Stresses in large horizontal cylindrical pressure vessels on two saddle supports. In: 1985 ASME (eds). Pressure vessel and piping: design and analysis – a decade of progress 1985; vol. 2 New York: ASME, pp. 959–970.

Tooth

Duthie

White

. Stresses in horizontal storage vessels - a comparison of theory and experiment. J Strain Anal 1982; 17: 169–176.

Tooth

Jones

. Plastic collapse loads of cylindrical pressure vessels supported by rigid saddles. J Strain Anal 1982; 17: 187–198.

Duthie

White

Tooth

. An analysis for cylindrical vessels under local loading - application to saddle supported vessel problems. J Strain Anal 1982; 17: 157–167.

Sang

Natarajan

Widera

GEO

. On the design of horizontal pressure vessels. J Press Vessel Technol 1988; 110: 393–401.

10.

British Standards Institution. Specification for unfired fusion welded pressure vessels, PD 5500. BSI, 2009.

11.

Timoshenko

. Strength of materials, 2nd ed. New York: D. Van Nostrand Company, Inc., 1940.

12.

Stefanovic

Noman

. Design and analysis of buried liquid petroleum gas storage bullets supported on multiple saddles (PVP2010-25052). J Press Vessel Technol 2012; 134: 035001–035001.

13.

Popa

Sovarel

. Zick method adaptation for horizontal cylindrical vessels (HCV) asymmetrically supported on three saddle supports with support settlements. Rev Chim-Bucharest 2011; 62: 588–591.