Optimisation of power generation cycles using saturated liquid expansion to maximise heat recovery

Abstract

The use of two-phase screw expanders in power generation cycles can achieve an increase in the utilisation of available energy from a low-temperature heat source when compared with more conventional single-phase turbines. The efficiency of screw expander machines is sensitive to expansion volume ratio, which, for given inlet and discharge pressures, increases as the expander inlet vapour dryness fraction decreases. For single-stage screw machines with low inlet dryness, this can lead to underexpansion of the working fluid and low isentropic efficiency. The cycle efficiency can potentially be improved by using a two-stage expander, consisting of a machine for low-pressure expansion and a smaller high-pressure machine connected in series. By expanding the working fluid over two stages, the built-in volume ratios of the two machines can be selected to provide a better match with the overall expansion process, thereby increasing the efficiency. The mass flow rate though both stages must be matched, and the compromise between increasing efficiency and maximising power output must also be considered. This study is based on the use of a rigorous thermodynamic screw machine model to compare the performance of single- and two-stage expanders. The model allows optimisation of the required intermediate pressure in the two-stage expander, along with the built-in volume ratio of both screw machine stages. The results allow specification of a two-stage machine, using either two screw machines or a combination of high-pressure screw and low-pressure turbine, in order to achieve maximum efficiency for a particular power output. For the low-temperature heat recovery application considered in this paper, the trilateral flash cycle using a two-stage expander and the Smith cycle using a high-pressure screw and low-pressure turbine are both predicted to achieve a similar overall conversion efficiency to that of a conventional saturated vapour organic Rankine cycle.

Keywords

Twin-screw waste heat two-stage organic Rankine cycle expander

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

House PA. Helical-rotor expander applications for geothermal energy conversion (No. UCRL-52043). California University, Lawrence Livermore Laboratory, USA, 1976.

Elliot DG. Theory and tests of two-phase turbines (No. DOE/ER-10614-1; JPL-PUB-81-105). Jet Propulsion Laboratory, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, USA, 1982.

DiPippo

. Ideal thermal efficiency for geothermal binary plants. Geothermics 2007; 36: 276–285.

Smith IK, Stosic N and Kovacevic A. Power recovery from low cost two-phase expanders. Transactions of Geothermal Resource Council, 2001, pp. 601–606.

Smith IK, Stosic N and Kovacevic A. Screw expanders increase output and decrease the cost of geothermal binary power plant systems. Transactions of Geothermal Resource Council, 2005, pp. 25–28.

Smith

Stosic

Aldis

. Development of the trilateral flash cycle system: Part 3: The design of high-efficiency two-phase screw expanders. Proc IMechE, Part A: J Power and Energy 1996; 210: 75–93.

Smith

Stosic

Kovacevic

. Power recovery from low grade heat by means of screw expanders, New York: Elsevier, 2014.

Kane

Larrain

Favrat

. Small hybrid solar power system. Energy 2003; 28: 1427–1443.

Bombarda

Invernizzi

Pietra

. Heat recovery from Diesel engines: A thermodynamic comparison between Kalina and ORC cycles. Appl Therm Eng 2010; 30: 212–219.

10.

Taniguchi

Kudo

Giedt

. Analytical and experimental investigation of two-phase flow screw expanders for power generation. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 1988; 110: 628–635.

11.

Tang Y and Fleming JS. Obtaining the optimum geometrical parameters of a refrigeration helical screw compressor. In: 11th international compressor engineering conference, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA, 1992, pp. 221–227.

12.

Fleming JS, Tang Y, Xing ZW, et al. The use of superfeed in a refrigeration plant with a twin screw compressor: an optimization technique for plant design. In: Proceedings of the IIR XIXth congress on refrigeration, The Hague, Netherlands, 1995.

13.

Fujiwara

Osada

. Performance analysis of an oil-injected screw compressor and its application. Int J Refrig 1995; 18: 220–227.

14.

Stosic

Hanjalic

. Development and optimization of screw machines with a simulation model - Part I: Profile generation. J Fluids Eng 1997; 119: 659–663.

15.

Hanjalic

Stosic

. Development and optimization of screw machines with a simulation model - Part II: Thermodynamic performance simulation and design optimization. J Fluids Eng 1997; 119: 664–670.

16.

Smith

Stosic

Aldis

. Development of the trilateral flash cycle system: Part 3: The design of high-efficiency two-phase screw expanders. Proc IMechE, Part A: J Power and Energy 1996; 210: 75–93.

17.

Read

Stosic

Smith

. Optimization of screw expanders for power recovery from low-grade heat sources. Energy Technol Policy 2014; 1: 131–142.

18.

Sakun

. Screw compressors, Moscow, Russia: Mashgiz Press, 1960.

19.

Uusitalo A. Working fluid selection and design of small-scale waste heat recovery systems based on organic Rankine cycles. PhD Thesis, Lappeenranta University of Technology, Finland, 2014.

20.

Da Lio

Manente

Lazzaretto

. New efficiency charts for the optimum design of axial flow turbines for organic Rankine cycles. Energy 2014; 77: 447–459.

21.

Kang

. Design and experimental study of ORC (organic Rankine cycle) and radial turbine using R245fa working fluid. Energy 2012; 41: 514–524.

22.

Calm

. Comparative efficiencies and implications for greenhouse gas emissions of chiller refrigerants. Int J Refrig 2006; 29: 833–841.