The influence of precipitation and friction control agents on forces at the wheel/rail interface in heavy haul railways

Abstract

This paper presents an analysis of the influence of materials that can be present in the so-called “third-body layer” at the wheel/rail interface on curving forces generated in heavy haul operating conditions. The third-body layer is the interfacial layer whose shear properties determine the bulk frictional characteristics that emerge in wheel/rail contact. It is often postulated that precipitation (rain) provides an effective form of lubrication at the wheel tread/rail head interface, reducing curving forces and corresponding wear. The postulate is explored through the analysis of lateral and vertical force data collected under a wide range of environmental conditions in full-scale revenue service. The effects of precipitation are rigorously explored and compared with the effects of top of rail friction modifiers, which are intentionally introduced into the third-body layer.

This paper originated from the 2011 IHHA Conference.

Keywords

Friction management lubrication curving forces lateral/vertical forces precipitation heavy haul

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Eadie D, Vidler B, Hooper N and Makowsky T. Top of rail friction control: lateral force and rail wear reduction in a freight application. In: The International Heavy Haul Association conference, Fort Worth, TX, 4–9 May 2003, p.8. Virginia Beach, USA: International Heavy Haul Association.

Sroba P, Oldknow K, Dashko R and Roney M. Canadian Pacific Railway 100% effective friction management strategy. In: The International Heavy Haul Association conference, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 14–16 June 2005, p.9. Virginia Beach, USA: International Heavy Haul Association.

Eadie

Maglalang

Vidler

. Trackside top of rail friction control at CN. The International Heavy Haul Association conference. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 14–16 June 2005, p.8. Virginia Beach, USA: International Heavy Haul Association.

Reiff R. Wayside-based top of rail friction control: 95 MGT update. TTCI Technology Digest TD-07-019, 2007.

Roney

Eadie

Oldknow

. Total friction management on Canadian Pacific. The International Heavy Haul Association conference. Shanghai, People’s Republic of China, 22–25 June 2009, p.10. Virginia Beach, USA: International Heavy Haul Association.

Eadie

Santoro

Kalousek

. Railway noise and the effect of top of rail liquid friction modifiers: changes in sound and vibration spectral distributions in curves. Wear 2004; 258: 1148–1155.

Eadie D, Santoro M, Oldknow K and Oka Y. Field studies of the effect of friction modifiers on short pitch corrugation generation. In: The seventh international conference on contact mechanics and wear of rail/wheel systems, Brisbane, Australia, 24–26 September 2006, p.9.

Stock

Eadie

Elvidge

Oldknow

. Influencing rolling contact fatigue through top of rail friction modifier application – a full scale wheel-rail test rig study. The eighth international conference on contact mechanics and wear of rail/wheel systems. 15–18 September 2009, p.10. Firenze, Italy.

Cotter J, Eadie D, Elvidge D, et al. Top of rail friction control: reductions in fuel and greenhouse gas emissions. In: The International Heavy Haul Association conference, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 14–16 June 2005, p.7. Virginia Beach, USA: International Heavy Haul Association.

10.

Kalousek J, Hou K, Magel E and Chiddick K. The benefits of friction management: a third body approach. In: The world congress on railway research, Colorado Springs, CO, 17–19 June 1996, pp.461–468. New York, Chicago, Omaha, Cornwall: Simmons-Boardman Publishing Corporation.

11.

Kalousek

. Rolling radius difference: do we appreciate its significance? 2001The wheel/rail interaction conference. Chicago IL, 2001.