A plane-frame model for the analysis of cross beams in open-deck railway bridges

Abstract

This paper shows how to establish a plane-frame computational model for the analysis of a cross beam in an open-deck railway bridge. The model consists of the analysed cross beam, parts of the main girders, as well as transverse and wind-bracing struts. The model is used to examine the behaviour of cross beams in two different types of open-deck spans: a plate girder span and a truss girder span. The modelling technique is particularly useful when an immediate assessment of the service load that can be borne by particular structural component is necessary. For instance, in emergency situations or when the technical condition of one structural component is much worse than any other component. The latter situation may occur in the case of open-deck bridges where the condition of the deck’s components is usually very poor. The stress levels in test-loaded cross beams are computed using the proposed plane-frame modelling approach. The computational results are compared to stress values based on strains recorded during actual test loading of bridges. It is shown that the plane-frame modelling of a cross beam with adjacent structural components overestimates normal stresses in the top flange of the cross beams by between 15 and 30%, whereas a simply supported beam model gives an overestimation of over 100%. Rotational restraint of the cross beams at their connection to the main girders is also investigated. The plane-frame modelling approach underestimates the restraint by between 13 and 23%. This is acceptable as long as the bending moment at the mid-span position governs the load-carrying capacity. This is usually true for open decks.

Keywords

Railway bridge open deck cross beam test loading numerical analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Azizinamini

. Full scale testing of old steel truss bridge. J Construct Steel Res 2002; 58: 843–858.

DelGrego

Culmo

DeWolf

. Performance evaluation through field testing of century-old railroad truss bridge. J Bridge Engng 2008; 13: 132–138.

Malone B, Heffron M, Ramirez J and White D. Analysis and load testing of two steel through truss bridges in Indiana. Report, Perdue University, West Lafayette, IN, 1966.

Spyrakos

Raftoyiannis

Ermopoulos

. Condition assessment and retrofit of a historic steel-truss railway bridge. J Construct Steel Res 2004; 60: 1213–1225.

Yoshioka

Takahashi

Yamaguchi

Matsumoto

. Damage assessment of truss diagonal members based on frequency changes in local higher modes. Proc Engng 2011; 14: 3119–3126.

Caglayan

Ozakgul

Tezer

. Assessment of existing steel railway bridges. J Construct Steel Res 2012; 69: 54–63.

Caglayan

Ozakgul

Tezer

Uzgider

. Evaluation of a steel railway bridge for dynamic and seismic loads. J Construct Steel Res 2011; 67: 1198–1211.

Bacinskas

Kamaitis

Jatulis

Kilikevicius

. Field testing of old narrow-gauge railway steel truss bridge. Proc Engng 2013; 57: 136–143.

Ermopoulos

Spyrakos

. Validated analysis and strengthening of a 19th century railway bridge. Engng Struct 2006; 28: 783–792.

10.

Karlikowski J and Sturzbecher K. Testing of railway plate girder bridge over Warta river in Poznań (in Polish). Report, Poznań University of Technology, Poland, 1992.

11.

Mańko Z. Assessment of load carrying capacity reserves in railway truss bridge on the basis of testing (in Polish). Inżynieria i Budownictwo, 1999; 3/99: 172–176.

12.

Young

Jackson

. The relative rigidity of welded and riveted connections. J Can Res 1934; 11: 62–134.