Alarm handling for health monitoring: Operator strategies used in an electrical control room of a rail network

Abstract

Alarm management is a key component of the successful operation of a prognostic or health-monitoring technology. Although alarms can alert the operator to critical information, false alarms and alarm flooding can cause major difficulties for successfully diagnosing and acting upon infrastructure faults. Human factors approaches seek to design more-effective alarm systems through a deep understanding of the contextual factors that influence alarm response, including strategies and heuristics used by operators. This paper presents an extensive analysis of alarm-handling activity in the setting of an Electrical Control Room on the rail network. The analysis is based on contextual observation, and the application of a time-stamped observation checklist. Functions, performance requirements, and general operating conditions that influence alarm handling are presented, delineating the typical operational constraints that need to be considered in the design and deployment of asset-based alarm systems. The analysis of specific alarm-handling incidents reveals the use of specific strategies that may bias operator performance. Implications for the design of health-monitoring systems are discussed.

Keywords

Human factors alarm handling strategies joint cognitive systems work analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Dadashi

Wilson

Golightly

Sharples

. A framework to support human factors of automation in railway intelligent infrastructure. Ergonomics 2014; 57(3): 387–402.

Campbell

. Collapse of an industry: nuclear power and the contradictions of US policy, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1988.

Wilkinson

Lucas

. Better alarm handling—a practical application of human factors. Measure Control 2001; 35(2): 52–54.

Timms

. Hazards equal trips or alarms or both. Process Saf Environ Protect 2009; 87(1): 3–13.

Gilson

Mouloua

Graft

McDonald

. Behavioral influences of proximal alarms. Human Factors: J Human Factors Ergonom Soc 2001; 43(4): 595–610.

Cullen

. The Ladbroke Grove rail inquiry part 1 report, Norwich, UK: HSE Books, HMSO, 2000.

Stanton

Baber

. Modelling of human alarm handling response times: a case study of the Ladbroke Grove rail accident in the UK. Ergonomics 2008; 51(4): 423–440.

Kirkland CJ. The fire in the Channel Tunnel. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology 2002; 17(2), 129–132.

Seagull

Sanderson

. Anesthesia alarms in context: an observational study. Human Factors: J Human Factors Ergonom Soc 2001; 43(1): 66–78.

10.

Omodei M, Elliott G, Clancy JM, et al. More is better? A bias toward overuse of resources in naturalistic decision-making settings. 2005.

11.

Cummings

Mitchell

. Automated scheduling decision support for supervisory control of multiple UAVs. J Aerosp Comput Inform Commun 2006; 3(6): 294–308.

12.

Stanton NA and Chris B. The ergonomics of command and control, 2006, pp.1131–1138.

13.

Woods

. The alarm problem and directed attention in dynamic fault management. Ergonomics 1995; 38(11): 2371–2393.

14.

Woods

Patterson

Roth

. Can we ever escape from data overload? A cognitive systems diagnosis. Cognition, Technol Work 2002; 4(1): 22–36.

15.

Reason

. Cognitive aids in process environments: prostheses or tools? Int J Man-Mach Studies 1987; 27(5): 463–470.

16.

Hollnagel E and Woods DD. Joint cognitive systems: Foundations of cognitive systems engineering. Florida: CRC Press, 2005.

17.

Hoc

J-M

. Towards a cognitive approach to human–machine cooperation in dynamic situations. Int J Human-Comput Studies 2001; 54(4): 509–540.

18.

Golightly

Ryan

Dadashi

. Use of scenarios and function analyses to understand the impact of situation awareness on safe and effective work on rail tracks. Saf Sci 2013; 56: 52–62.

19.

Dadashi

Wilson

Golightly

. Practical use of work analysis to support rail electrical control rooms: a case of alarm handling. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2013; 227(2): 148–160.

20.

Bisantz

Drury

. Applications of archival and observational data. Eval Human Work 2005; 3: 61–82.

21.

Sundstrom

Salvador

. Integrating field work in system design: a methodology and two case studies. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern 1995; 25(3): 385–399.

22.

Ericsson

Simon

. Protocol analysis, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1985.

23.

Bainbridge

Sanderson

Verbal protocol analysis. In: Wilson

Corlett

(eds). Evaluation of human work, Third ed. Boca Raton, Florida: Taylor & Francis Group, 2005, pp. 159–185.

24.

Sharples

Millen

Golightly

Balfe

. The impact of automation in rail signalling operations. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2011; 225(2): 179–191.

25.

Pickup

Wilson

Norris

. The integrated workload scale (IWS): a new self-report tool to assess railway signaller workload. Appl Ergonom 2005; 36(6): 681–693.

26.

Stanton

Stammers

. Alarm initiated activities: matching formats to tasks. Int J Cognitive Ergonom 1998; 2(4): 331–348.

27.

Network Rail. Specification for remote control equipment for electrical distribution systems. Report, Network Rail, London, UK, 2008.

28.

EEMUA (Engineering Equipment and Materials Users Association). Alarm systems, a guide to design, management and procurement (Publication No. 191). London: EEMUA, 1999.

29.

Miles

Huberman

. Qualitative data analysis: an expanded sourcebook, London, UK: Sage, 1994.

30.

Warm

Parasuraman

Matthews

. Vigilance requires hard mental work and is stressful. Human Factors: J Human Factors Ergonom Soc 2008; 50(3): 433–441.