A new methodology for the assessment of the running resistance of trains without knowing the characteristics of the track: Application to full-scale experimental data

Abstract

The resistance to motion of trains is an essential requisite especially while designing high-speed trains and high-capacity railway lines. The optimisation of friction effects and aerodynamic performance can be done during the design stage of a new train but the actual value of the running resistance can be inferred only by means of full-scale tests during the operation of a train. A CEN standard (EN 14067-4) describes the methodologies for the assessment of the running resistance of railway vehicles starting from full-scale test measurements. According to this standard, the speed-dependent terms of the resistance force have to be determined by means of coasting tests on railway lines, whose characteristics must be well known. Since this is not always possible and small errors on the gradient could lead to major uncertainties in the evaluation of the resistance force, a new method for the estimation of the running resistance coefficients, irrespective of the characteristics of the track is proposed in this paper. The reliability of the method is verified by comparing the results with those obtained from the procedure proposed in the CEN standard. The comparison shows that the new methodology is able to evaluate the resistance coefficients with an accuracy equivalent to that of the other methods but with fewer tests and with a more robust procedure relying on a lesser number of parameters.

Keywords

Running resistance of trains full-scale tests coasting tests train aerodynamic drag

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Davis

Jr . The tractive resistance of electric locomotives and cars. Gen Electr Rev 1926; 29: 2–24.

EN 14067-4. Railway applications – aerodynamics – part 4: requirements and test procedures for aerodynamics on open track, 2013. CEN European Standard.

Raghunathana

Kimb

Setoguchic

. Aerodynamics of high-speed railway train. Prog Aerosp Sci 2002; 38: 469–514.

Rochard

Schmid

. A review of methods to measure and calculate train resistances. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail and Rapid Transit 2000; 214: 185–199.

Baker

Brockie

. Wind tunnel tests to obtain train aerodynamic drag coefficients: Reynolds number and ground simulation effects. J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn 1991; 38: 23–28.

Schetz

. Aerodynamics of high-speed trains. Annu Rev Fluid Mech 2001; 33: 371–414.

Huang S, Li Z, Yang M, et al. Research on the moving model measuring method of high-speed train aerodynamic drag based on machine vision. In: Proceedings of the international workshop on train aerodynamics, Birmingham, England, 2013, 10–11 April, 2013.

Mancini G, Malfatti A, Violi AG, et al. Effects of experimental bogie fairings on the aerodynamic drag of the ETR 500 high speed train. In: World Congress on railway research, Munich, Germany, 2001. 25–29 November, 2001.

Watkins

Saunders

Kumar

. Aerodynamic drag reduction of goods trains. J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn 1992; 40: 147–178.

10.

Tschepe1 J, Nayeri CN, Schmidt HJ, et al. Towing tank experiments for train aerodynamics. In: Third international conference on railway technology: research, development and maintenance, Cagliari, Italy, 2016. Civil-Comp Proceedings 2016; 110.

11.

Yang

et al.

Moving model test of high-speed train aerodynamic drag based on stagnation pressure measurements. PLoS One. 201712: e0169471–e0169471.

12.

Krajnovic

. Shape optimization of high-speed trains for improved aerodynamic performance. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail and Rapid Transit 2009; 223: 439–439.

13.

Munoz-Paniagua

García

Crespo

et al.

Aerodynamic optimization of the nose shape of a train using the adjoint method. J Appl Fluid Mech 2015; 8: 601–612.

14.

Jakubek D and Wagner C. Aerodynamic shape optimization of train heads using adjoint-based computational fluid dynamics with different objective functions. In: The third international conference on railway technology: research, development and maintenance, Cagliari, Italy, 2016. Civil-Comp Proceedings 2016; 110.

15.

Lukaszewicz

. Running resistance – results and analysis of full-scale tests with passenger and freight trains in Sweden. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail and Rapid Transit 2007; 221: 183–193.

16.

Baker

. A review of train aerodynamics part 2 – applications. Aeronaut J 2014; 118: 345–382.

17.

Hansen

Nawaz

Olsson

. Using operational data to estimate the running resistance of trains. Estimation of the resistance in a set of Norwegian tunnels. J Rail Transp Plann Manage 2017; 30: 1–15.

18.

Guiheu

. Resistance to forward movement of TGV-PSE trainsets: evaluation of studies and results of measurements. French Railw Rev 1983; 1: 13–26.

19.

Hara

Ohkushi

Nishimura

. Aerodynamic drag of trains. Q Rep RTRI 1967; 8: 226–229.

20.

Peters

J-L

. Measurement of the influence of tunnel length on the tunnel drag of the ICE/V train. Aerodyn Ventil Veh Tunnels 1991, pp. 739–756.

21.

Lukaszewicz

. A simple method to determine train running resistance from full-scale measurements. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail and Rapid Transit 2007; 221: 331–337.

22.

Maeda T, Kinoshita M, Kajiyama H, et al. Estimation of aerodynamic drag of Shinkansen trains from pressure rise in tunnel. In: Proceedings of the 6th international symposium on aerodynamics and ventilation of vehicle tunnels, Durham, England, 1988, 27–29 September, 1988.

23.

Bernard

Guiheu

. Recent measuring of the resistance to forward motion of rolling stock. Rev Gen Chem Fer 1976; 95: 243–255.