Assessing the deflection behaviour of mechanical and insulated rail joints using finite element analysis

Abstract

Rail joints constitute a weak component in the railway system. In this paper, three-dimensional finite element analyses are carried out to study the structural deflection performance of rail joints under a fatigue static test through vertical stiffness assessment. Four different types of four-bolted joints are investigated under a dynamically enhanced static load including a glued insulated rail joint, a dry encapsulated insulated rail joint, a dry non-glued insulated rail joint and a mechanical rail joint. The analysis focused on the accurate simulation of the contact types between the interfaces of rail joint components, namely the rail, fishplate faces, bolts and insulating materials. It also focused on the effect of the elastic supporting structure of the joint with regard to the overall joint deflection. The effect of bolt pre-tension is included in the model. The vertical displacement of insulated rail joints is measured experimentally by dial gauges and a video technique in both laboratory and field settings. The numerical modelling investigated the effect of different contact types on the interfaces of the rail joint components during the performance of fishplates, and of the rail in the vicinity of the rail joint under a given support condition. The vertical displacement of the rail joint was presented and assessed against specified limits of endurance tests and field-measured deflection values that validate the model. Stress distribution in the fishplates was presented that could allow the calculation, through a stress-life approach, the fatigue life of the fishplates and, consequently, of the joints due to repeated wheel passage. A comparison of the performance of the aforementioned rail joint types is included. The results indicate that this finite element model can be routinely used in industries, as it was used in the UK Rail industry study, to allow designers to optimize the life expectancy of insulated rail joints.

Keywords

Rail joint track structure insulated rail joint fishplate three-dimensional finite element modelling

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beaty P. Experimental testing procedures to investigate and improve insulated rail joint design and life cycle. MSc Thesis, University of Sheffield, UK, 2014.

PWI. Guidance for Heritage Railways on the inspection and maintenance of permanent way and the inspection and assessment of other infrastructure that is necessary for the safety of the line. Document 4-Visual inspection. https://www.thepwi.org/technical_hub/guides (2012, accessed 13 June 2017).

Mandal

Peach

. An engineering analysis of insulated rail joints : A general perspective. Int J Eng Sci Technol 2010; 2: 3964–3988.

British Rail Research, Track Unit. Modelling 4-hole fishplated rail joint using the finite element method Report No RR MF 046, Derby, UK, June 1993.

Soylemez

Ciloglu

. Influence of track variables and product design on insulated rail joints. Transp Res Rec J Transp Res Board 2016; 2545: 1–10.

Pang T. Studies on wheel/rail contact – impact forces at insulated rail joints. MEng Thesis, Central Queensland University, Australia, 2007.

Askarinejad

Dhanasekar

Cole

. Assessing the effects of track input on the response of insulated rail joints using field experiments. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2012; 227: 176–187.

NR/SP/TRK/023 Insulated Rail Joints, March 1996.

Mandal

. FEA to assess plastic deformation of railhead material damage of insulated rail joints with fibreglass and nylon endposts. Wear 2016; 366–367: 3–12.

10.

Mandal

Dhanasekar

. Sub-modelling for the ratchetting failure of insulated rail joints. Int J Mech Sci 2013; 75: 110–122.

11.

Bandula-Heva

Dhanasekar

Boyd

. Experimental investigation of wheel/rail rolling contact at railhead edge. Exp Mech 2012; 53: 943–957.

12.

Bandula-Heva

Dhanasekar

. Failure of discontinuous railhead edges due to plastic strain accumulation. Eng Fail Anal 2014; 44: 110–124.

13.

Himebaugh

Plaut

Dillard

. Finite element analysis of bonded insulated rail joints. Int J Adhes Adhes 2008; 28: 142–150.

14.

Grossoni

Iwnicki

Bezin

et al.

Dynamics of a vehicle-track coupling system at a rail joint. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2014; 229: 364–374.

15.

Zong

Wexler

Dhanasekar

. Structural and material characterisation of insulated rail joints. Electron J Struct Eng 2013; 13: 75–87.

16.

Patel

Kumar

Nareliya

. Fatigue analysis of rail joint by using finite element analysis. Int J Res Eng Technol 2013; 2: 80–84.

17.

Talamini B, Jeong DY and Gordon J. Estimation of the fatigue life of railroad joint bars. In: ASME/IEEE 2007 joint rail conference and internal combustion engine division spring technical conference, Pueblo, CO, USA, 13–16 March 2007. New York: ASME.

18.

Dhanasekar

Bayissa

. Performance of square and inclined insulated rail joints based on field strain measurements. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2012; 226: 140–154.

19.

Vossloh Rail Services. Glued Insulated Joint IVB 30. http://www.vossloh-cogifer-uk.com/admin/resources/main-content-downloads/vtsivb30.pdf (accessed 30 June 2017).

20.

Sandström

Ekberg

. Numerical study of the mechanical deterioration of insulated rail joints. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2009; 223: 265–273.

21.

Ding

Dhanasekar

. Flexural behaviour of bonded-bolted butt joints due to bolt looseness. Adv Eng Softw 2007; 38: 598–606.

22.

Gallou

Temple

Hardwick

et al.

Potential for external reinforcement of insulated rail joints. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit. Epub ahead of print 22 Dec 2016.

23.

Van Dyk BJ, Dersch MS, Edwards JR, et al. Evaluation of dynamic and impact wheel load factors and their application for design. In: Transportation Research Board 93rd annual meeting, Washington, USA, 12–16 January 2014.

24.

British Steel: Steel grade composition and properties, 2017.

25.

Winkler

. Die Lerhe von der Elasticität und Festigkeit, Prague: Dominicus, 1867.

26.

Cope

. British railway track: Design, construction and maintenance, 6th ed. Cope GH, UK: Permanent Way Institution, 2001.

27.

GC/RT5021:2011. Railway Group Standard. Track system requirements. 2011.

28.

ANSYS Inc. An overview of methods for modelling bolts in ANSYS V15. Canonsburg, PA: ANSYS Inc., 2015.

29.

ANSYS Inc. ANSYS mechanical user’s guide. Release 17.1. Canonsburg, PA: ANSYS Inc., 2016.

30.

prEN 16843:2015. European Standard Railway applications – Infrastructure-mechanical requirements for joints in running rails, March 2015.

31.

AREMA – American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way Association, Part 3. Joining of rail. 2007.

32.

AS 1085.12-2002. Australian Standard. Reconfirmed 2013, Part 12: Insulated joint assemblies. 2002.

33.

TB/T 2975-2000. People’s Republic of China Standard. 2000.

34.

NR/SP/TRK/064. Assembly of BR MkIII 4- and 6-hole insulated joints, December 2003.

35.

Zhu

Qian

Edwards

et al.

Finite element analysis of rail end bolt-hole and fillet stress on bolted rail joints. Transp Res Rec J Transp Res Board 2017; 2607: 33–42.