In-flight performance analysis of a non-cooperative radar-based sense and avoid system

Abstract

This paper discusses the outcome of flight experiments relevant to non-cooperative sense and avoid that were carried out in the framework of a collaboration between the Italian Aerospace Research Center and the University of Naples “Federico II”. Within the project, aimed at full autonomy for medium/large Unmanned Aircraft Systems, an integrated radar/electro-optical system configuration was adopted, and real-time data fusion/automatic decision-making algorithms were developed to estimate intruders’ motion, and generate and follow proper escape trajectories. All the systems were designed to guarantee collision avoidance without any dependence on the command and control link. The hardware/software sense and avoid system was installed onboard an optionally piloted flying laboratory of Very Light Aircraft category, and a single intruder aircraft of the same class was considered for avoidance experiments. In particular, the paper focuses on the results from radar-based autonomous avoidance flight tests. Performance is analyzed in terms of situational awareness before and during the maneuver, and effectiveness in performing safe avoidance maneuvers while generating smooth commands and minimizing the deviation from nominal trajectory. Statistics relevant to several encounters show that in spite of a small number of valid sensor measurements, the tracking algorithm is able to keep a satisfying level of situational awareness, thus enabling safe avoidance. However, the limits deriving from coarse radar accuracy, low scan rate, and interaction between mechanical scanning and aircraft flight dynamics are also pointed out. While these limits did not impact avoidance safety in the considered tests due to the favorable operating environment in terms of time to collision, radar detection range, and ownship maneuverability, they confirm the need of improved sensing concepts in more challenging avoidance scenarios, such as adoption of radar/electro-optical data fusion and electronic scanning technologies.

Keywords

Unmanned aircraft systems remotely piloted aircraft systems non-cooperative sense and avoid in-flight performance airborne radar-based detection and tracking autonomous/automatic collision avoidance

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Federal Aviation Administration. Integration of civil unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) in the national airspace system (NAS) roadmap. 1st ed. Washington DC, USA: U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration, 2013.

European RPAS Steering Group. Roadmap for the integration of civil remotely-piloted aircraft systems into the European Aviation System. June 2013. Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/growth/sectors/aeronautics/rpas/index_en.htm.

Chen RH, Gevorkian A, Fung A, et al. Multi-sensor data integration for autonomous sense and avoid. In: AIAA Infotech@Aerospace technical conference 2011, St. Louis, Missouri, 29–31 March 2011.

Fasano

Accardo

Moccia

. Multi-sensor-based fully autonomous non-cooperative collision avoidance system for unmanned air vehicles. AIAA J Aerosp Comput Informat Commun 2008; 5: 338–360.

Lai

Ford

Mejias

. Characterisation of sky-region morphological-temporal airborne collision detection. J Field Robot 2013; 30: 171–193.

Nussberger A, Grabner H and Van Gool L. Aerial object tracking from an airborne platform. In: 2014 international conference on unmanned aircraft systems (ICUAS). IEEE, 27–30 May 2014, pp.1284–1293.

Foerster K, Mullins M, Kaabouch N, et al. Flight testing of a right-of-way compliant ADS-B-based miniature sense and avoid system. In: 2012 AIAA Infotech@ Aerospace conference, Boston MA, USA, 19–21 June 2012.

Federal Aviation Administration. Evaluation of candidate functions for traffic alert and collision avoidance system II (TCAS II) on unmanned aircraft system (UAS) (FAA/AFS-407), Washington, DC: FAA Unmanned Aircraft Program Office, 2011.

Ramasamy S, Sabatini R and Gardi A. Avionics sensor fusion for small size unmanned aircraft Sense-and-Avoid. In: 2014 IEEE metrology for aerospace (MetroAeroSpace) workshop, Benevento, Italy, 29–30 May 2014, pp.271–276.

10.

Accardo

Fasano

Forlenza

. Flight test of a radar-based tracking system for UAS sense and avoid. IEEE Transact Aerosp Electronic Syst 2013; 49: 1139–1160.

11.

Mackie J, Spencer J and Warnick KF. Compact FMCW radar for a UAS sense and avoid system. In: 2014 IEEE antennas and propagation society international symposium (APSURSI), Memphis, Tennessee, 6–11 July 2014, pp.989–990.

12.

Moses

Rutherford

Kontitsis

. UAV-borne X-band radar for collision avoidance. Robotica 2014; 32: 97–114.

13.

Lalish

Morgansen

. Distributed reactive collision avoidance. Autonom Robot 2012; 32: 207–226.

14.

Singer

Sea

Housewright

. Derivation and evaluation of improved tracking filter for use in dense multitarget environments. IEEE Transact Inform Theor 1974; 20: 423–432.

15.

Fasano G, Accardo D, Tirri AE, et al. Radar/electro-optical data fusion for non-cooperative UAS sense and avoid. Aerospace Science and Technology 2015; 46: 436–450.

16.

Fasano G, Accardo D, Tirri AE, et al. Morphological filtering and target tracking for vision-based UAS sense and avoid. In: International conference on unmanned aircraft systems (ICUAS), Orlando, FL, 27–30 May 2014.