Effects of tip clearance size on the unsteady flow behaviors and performance in a counter-rotating axial flow compressor

Abstract

This paper presents the studies performed to better understand the effects of increased tip clearance size on the unsteady flow behaviors and overall performance under the rotor–rotor interaction environment in a counter-rotating axial flow compressor. The investigation method is based on the three-dimensional unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes simulations. The results show that the intensified tip leakage flow in front rotor (R1) caused by the increased tip clearance size will lead to the growth of incoming incidence angle near the tip of the rear rotor (R2). The increasing of double leakage flow range plays a significant role in the sensitivity of the efficiency to tip clearance size and its extent is enlarged gradually with the increase of tip clearance size. As the tip clearance size is increased to 1.5τ (τ represents the designed tip clearance size) from 0.5τ, the results of the fast Fourier transform for the static pressure near blade tip show that two other new fluctuating frequency components appear due to the happening of tip leakage flow self-unsteadiness in R1 and R2, respectively. Additionally, the fluctuating strength near the tip in R2 is significantly increased. However, both the overall fluctuation in R1 caused by the potential effect from downstream and the oscillation in the hub corner on the pressure side of R2 are decreased obviously. The relative inflow angle tends to increase when the incoming wakes and tip leakage flow from R1 encounter the blade leading edge of R2, which leads to the result that the trajectory of tip leakage flow is shifted more upstream.

Keywords

Counter-rotating tip clearance size tip leakage flow double leakage flow unsteady fluctuation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Denton

. Loss mechanisms in turbomachines. J Turbomach 1993; 115: 621–621.

Tan

Greitzer

. Criteria for spike initiated rotating stall. J Turbomach 2008; 130: 011023–011023.

Zhang

et al.

Relationship between the flow blockage of tip leakage vortex and its evolutionary procedures inside the rotor passage of a subsonic axial compressor. J Therm Sci 2013; 22: 522–531.

Lin

Chen

et al.

Flow structures in the tip region for a transonic compressor rotor. J Turbomach 2013; 135: 031012–031012.

Tan

Wilkes

et al.

Visualization and time-resolved particle image velocimetry measurements of the flow in the tip region of a subsonic compressor rotor. J Turbomach 2015; 137: 041007–041007.

Boudet

Cahuzac

Kausche

et al.

Zonal large-eddy simulation of a fan tip-clearance flow, with evidence of vortex wandering. J Turbomach 2015; 137: 061001–061001.

Riéra

Marty

Castillon

et al.

Zonal detached-eddy simulation applied to the tip-clearance flow in an axial compressor. AIAA J 2016, pp. 2377–2391.

Sakulkaew

Tan

Donahoo

et al.

Compressor efficiency variation with rotor tip gap from vanishing to large clearance. J Turbomach 2013; 135: 031030–031030.

Yamada K, Kikuta H, Furukawa M, et al. Effects of tip clearance on the stall inception process in an axial compressor rotor. ASME Paper No. GT2013-95479, 2013.

10.

Lejon M, Andersson N, Eriksson LE, et al. Simulation of tip-clearance effects in a transonic compressor. ASME Paper No. GT2015-43033, 2015.

11.

Berdanier

Key

. Experimental characterization of tip leakage flow trajectories in a multistage compressor. J Propul Power 2016, pp. 1022–1032.

12.

Berdanier

Key

. The effects of tip leakage flow on the performance of multistage compressors used in small core engine applications. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 2016; 138: 052605–052605.

13.

Owczarek

. On the phenomenon of pressure pulses reflecting between blades of adjacent blade rows of turbomachines. J Turbomach 2011; 133: 021016–021016.

14.

Smith

Key

. Unsteady vane boundary layer response to rotor–rotor interactions in a multistage compressor. J Propul Power 2014; 30: 416–425.

15.

Vahdati

Cumpsty

. Aeroelastic instability in transonic fans. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 2016; 138: 022604–022604.

16.

Mailach

Lehmann

Vogeler

. Periodical unsteady flow within a rotor blade row of an axial compressor—Part I: Flow field at midspan. J Turbomach 2008; 130: 041004–041004.

17.

Nolan

SPR

Botros

Tan

et al.

Effects of upstream wake phasing on transonic axial compressor performance. J Turbomach 2011; 133: 021010–021010.

18.

Ernst

Michel

Jeschke

. Analysis of rotor-stator-interaction and blade-to-blade measurements in a two stage axial flow compressor. J Turbomach 2011; 133: 011027–011027.

19.

Lee

Orkwis

Tsung

et al.

Tip flow unsteadiness and blade row interactions for a low-speed compressor rotor. J Propul Power 2013; 29: 1346–1356.

20.

Montomoli

Naylor

Hodson

et al.

Unsteady effects in axial compressors: A multistage simulation. J Propul Power 2013; 29: 1001–1008.

21.

Schimming

. Counter rotating fans—An aircraft propulsion for the future? J Therm Sci 2003; 12: 97–103.

22.

Sharma

Jain

Pundhir

. A study of some factors affecting the performance of a contra-rotating axial compressor stage. Proc IMechE, Part A: J Power and Process Engineering 1988; 202: 15–21.

23.

Nouri

Danlos

Ravelet

et al.

Experimental study of the instationary flow between two ducted counter-rotating rotors. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 2013; 135: 022601–022601.

24.

Mistry

Pradeep

. Effect of variation in axial spacing and rotor speed combinations on the performance of a high aspect ratio contra-rotating axial fan stage. Proc IMechE, Part A: J Power and Energy 2013; 227: 138–146.

25.

Mistry

Pradeep

. Influence of circumferential inflow distortion on the performance of a low speed, high aspect ratio contra rotating axial fan. J Turbomach 2014; 136: 071009–071009.

26.

Gao

Miao

et al.

Unsteady investigation on tip flow field and rotating stall in counter-rotating axial compressor. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 2015; 137: 072603–072603.

27.

Wang

Chen

et al.

Effects of tip clearance size on the performance and tip leakage vortex in dual-rows counter-rotating compressor. Proc IMechE, Part G: J Aerospace Engineering 2015; 229: 1953–1965.

28.

Mao

Liu

. Numerical investigation of the unsteady flow behaviors in a counter-rotating axial compressor. Proc IMechE, Part A: J Power and Energy 2016; 230: 289–301.

29.

Mao

Liu

. Numerical study of the unsteady behaviors and rotating stall inception process in a counter-rotating axial compressor. Proc IMechE, Part G: J Aerospace Engineering 2016; 230: 2716–2727.

30.

Sirakov

Tan

. Effect of unsteady stator wake-rotor double-leakage tip clearance flow interaction on time-average compressor performance. J Turbomach 2003; 125: 465–474.

31.

Mailach

Lehmann

Vogeler

. Periodical unsteady flow within a rotor blade row of an axial compressor—Part II: Wake-tip clearance vortex interaction. J Turbomach 2008; 130: 041005–041005.

32.

Smith

Murray

Key

. Considerations for measuring compressor aerodynamic excitations including rotor wakes and tip leakage flows. J Turbomach 2016; 138: 031008–031008.

33.

Berdanier

Key

. Experimental characterization of tip leakage flow trajectories in a multistage compressor. J Propul Power 2016, pp. 1022–1032.

34.

NUMECA International. FINE/Turbo v8.7, user manual, Brussels: NUMECA International, 2009.

35.

NUMECA International. AutoGrid5 v8.7, user manual, Brussels: NUMECA International, 2009.

36.

Spalart PR and Allmaras SR. A one-equation turbulence model for aerodynamic flows. AIAA 92-0439, 1992.

37.

Khalid

Khalsa

Waitz

et al.

Endwall blockage in axial compressors. J Turbomach 1999; 121: 499–509.

38.

Erler

. Desensitization of axial compressor performance and stability to tip clearance size. J Turbomach 2016; 138: 031006–031006.

39.

Lin

Zhang

et al.

Numerical investigation on the self-induced unsteadiness in tip leakage flow for a transonic fan rotor. J Turbomach 2010; 132: 021017–021017.