Experimental and numerical comparisons between finite element method,element-free Galerkin method,and extended finite element method predicted stress intensity factor and energy release rate of cortical bone considering anisotropic bone modelling

Abstract

Stress intensity factor and energy release rate are important parameters to understand the fracture behaviour of bone. The objective of this study is to predict stress intensity factor and energy release rate using finite element method, element-free Galerkin method, and extended finite element method and compare these results with the experimentally determined values. For experimental purpose, 20 longitudinally and transversely fractured single-edge notched bend specimens were prepared and tested according to ASTM standard. All specimens were tested using the universal testing machine. For numerical simulations (finite element method, element-free Galerkin method, and extended finite element method), two-dimensional model of cortical bone was developed by assuming plane strain condition. Material properties of the cortical bone were considered as anisotropic and homogeneous. The values obtained through finite element method, element-free Galerkin method, and extended finite element method are well corroborated to experimentally determined values and earlier published data. However, element-free Galerkin method and extended finite element method predict more accurate results as compared to finite element method. In the case of the transversely fractured specimen, the values of stress intensity factor and energy release rate were found to be higher as compared to the longitudinally fractured specimen, which shows consistency with earlier published data. This study also indicates element-free Galerkin method and extended finite element method predicted stress intensity factor and energy release rate results are more close to experimental results as compared to finite element method, and therefore, these methods can be used in the different field of biomechanics, particularly to predict bone fracture.

Keywords

Cortical bone stress intensity factor energy release rate finite element method element-free Galerkin method extended finite element method

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Evans

. Factors affecting the mechanical properties of bone. Bull N Y Acad Med 1973; 49: 751–764.

Wright

Hayes

. Fracture mechanics parameters for compact bone – effects of density and specimen thickness. J Biomech 1977; 10: 419–430.

Zioupos

Currey

. Changes in the stiffness, strength, and toughness of human cortical bone with age. Bone 1998; 22: 57–66.

Lucksanasombool

Higgs

WAJ

Higgs

RJED

et al . Fracture toughness of bovine bone: influence of orientation and storage media. Biomaterials 2001; 22: 3127–3132.

Weiner

Wagner

. The material bone: structure-mechanical function relations. Annu Rev Mater Sci 1998; 28: 271–298.

Bonfield

. Advances in the fracture mechanics of cortical bone. J Biomech 1987; 20: 1071–1081.

Yan

Clifton

Mecholsky

et al . Effect of temperature on the fracture toughness of compact bone. J Biomech 2007; 40: 1641–1645.

Melvin

. Fracture mechanics of bone. J Biomech Eng 1993; 115: 549–554.

ASTM E399:1997. Standard test method for plane-strain fracture toughness for metallic materials (pp.413–433).

10.

Moyle

Bowden

. Fracture of human femoral bone. J Biomech 1984; 17: 203–213.

11.

Behiri

Bonfield

. Fracture mechanics of bone – the effects of density, specimen thickness and crack velocity on longitudinal fracture. J Biomech 1984; 17: 25–34.

12.

Norman

Vashishth

Burr

. Fracture toughness of human bone under tension. J Biomech 1995; 28: 309–320.

13.

Silva

FGA

de Moura

MFSF

Dourado

et al . Fracture characterization of human cortical bone under mode I loading. J Biomech Eng 2015; 137: 121004.

14.

Ghosh

Gupta

Dickinson

et al . Experimental validation of numerically predicted strain and micromotion in intact and implanted composite hemi-pelvises. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2013; 227: 162–174.

15.

Ural

Zioupos

Buchanan

et al . The effect of strain rate on fracture toughness of human cortical bone: a finite element study. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater 2011; 4: 1021–1032.

16.

Singh

Mishra

Brahmankar

et al . Numerical simulations of 3-D cracks using coupled EFGM and FEM. Int J Comput Methods Eng Sci Mech 2014; 15: 227–231.

17.

Pathak

Singh

. Numerical simulation of bi-material interfacial cracks using EFGM and XFEM. Int J Mech Mater Des 2012; 8: 9–36.

18.

Pant

Singh

Mishra

. Numerical simulation of thermo-elastic fracture problems using element free Galerkin method. Int J Mech Sci 2010; 52: 1745–1755.

19.

Garg

Pant

. Numerical simulation of thermal fracture in functionally graded materials using element-free Galerkin method. Sadhana: Acad P Eng S 2017; 42: 417–431.

20.

Belytschko

. Element-free Galerkin methods. Int J Numer Meth Eng 1994; 37: 229–256.

21.

Moës

Dolbow

Belytschko

. A finite element method for crack growth without remeshing. Int J Numer Meth Eng 1999; 46: 131–150.

22.

Melenk

Babuska

. The partition of unity finite element method: basic theory and applications. Comput Method Appl M 1996; 139: 289–314.

23.

Feerick

Liu

McGarry

. Anisotropic mode-dependent damage of cortical bone using the extended finite element method (XFEM). J Mech Behav Biomed Mater 2013; 20: 77–89.

24.

Abdel-Wahab

Demirci

et al . Fracture process in cortical bone: X-FEM analysis of microstructured models. Int J Fracture 2013; 184: 43–55.

25.

Idkaidek

Jasiuk

. Cortical bone fracture analysis using XFEM – case study. Int J Numer Method Biomed Eng 2017; 33: 1–16.

26.

Belytschko

Black

. Elastic crack growth in finite elements with minimal remeshing. Int J Numer Meth Eng 1999; 45: 602–620.

27.

Strouboulis

Babuska

Copps

. The design and analysis of the generalized finite element method. Comput Method Appl M 2000; 181: 43–69.

28.

Daux

Moës

Dolbow

et al . Arbitrary branched and intersecting cracks with the extended finite element method. Int J Numer Meth Eng 2000; 48: 1741–1760.

29.

Silva

FGA

de Moura

MFSF

Dourado

et al . Fracture characterization of human cortical bone under mode II loading using the end-notched flexure test. Med Biol Eng Comput 2017; 55: 1249–1260.

30.

Silva

FGA

de Moura

MFSF

Dourado

et al . Mixed-mode I+II fracture characterization of human cortical bone using the Single Leg Bending test. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater 2016; 54: 72–81.

31.

Asadpoure

Mohammadi

Vafai

. Crack analysis in orthotropic media using the extended finite element method. Thin Wall Struct 2006; 44: 1031–1038.

32.

Vignoli

Kenedi

. Bone anisotropy – analytical and finite element analysis. Lat Am J Solids Stru 2016; 13: 51–72.

33.

Taylor

Roland

Ploeg

et al . Determination of orthotropic bone elastic constants using FEA and modal analysis. J Biomech 2002; 35: 767–773.

34.

Sih

Paris

Irwin

. On cracks in rectilinearly anisotropic bodies. Int J Fract Mech 1965; 1: 189–203.

35.

Wooster

. Theory of elasticity of an anisotropic elastic body by S. G. Lekhnitskii. Acta Crystallogr 1964; 17: 793.

36.

Nobile

Carloni

. Fracture analysis for orthotropic cracked plates. Compos Struct 2005; 68: 285–293.

37.

Sanjay

Mondal

Bhutani

et al . The effect of cement mantle thickness on strain energy density distribution and prediction of bone density changes around cemented acetabular component. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2018; 232: 912–921.

38.

Ghosh

Mukherjee

Gupta

. Bone remodelling around uncemented metallic and ceramic acetabular components. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2013; 227: 490–502.

39.

Zhang

Wittek

Joldes

et al . A three-dimensional nonlinear meshfree algorithm for simulating mechanical responses of soft tissue. Eng Anal Bound Elem 2014; 42: 60–66.

40.

Belytschko

Krongauz

Organ

et al . Meshless methods: an overview and recent developments. Comput Method Appl M 1996; 139: 3–47.

41.

Anderson

. Fracture mechanics: fundamentals and applications. 3rd ed. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 2005.

42.

Rice

. A path independent integral and the approximate analysis of strain concentration by notches and cracks. J Appl Mech: T ASME 1968; 35: 379–386.

43.

Pang

. Treatment of point loads in element free Galerkin method (EFGM). Commun Numer Meth En 2000; 16: 335–341.

44.

Kumar

. Elements of fracture mechanics. 7th ed. New Delhi, India: McGraw-Hill Education India Private Limited, 2014.

45.

Yan

Mecholsky

Clifton

. How tough is bone? Application of elastic-plastic fracture mechanics to bone. Bone 2007; 40: 479–484.

46.

Feng

Rho

Han

et al . Orientation and loading condition dependence of fracture toughness in cortical bone. Mat Sci Eng C 2000; 11: 41–46.

47.

Melvin

Evans

. Crack propagation in bone. In: Proceedings of the ASME biomechanics symposium, Atlanta, GA, 20–22 June 1973, pp.87–88. New York: ASME.