The peri-urban water poor: citizens or consumers?

Abstract

Using the results of a comparative three-year research project in five metropolitan areas, this article reviews a range of practices in accessing water and sanitation by peri-urban poor residents and producers. It starts from the observation that neither centralized supply policies nor the market through, for example, large-scale profit-making enterprises are able to meet their needs. Although they are consumers insofar as they have no option but to pay market prices for water (and often for sanitation), the peri-urban poor are, in practice, sometimes regarded as citizens with basic entitlements such as the right to water. This article outlines a conceptual distinction between “policy-driven” and “needs-driven” practices in the access to peri-urban water and sanitation services. The case studies show that this access is mainly needs-driven and informal rather than the result of formal policies. The key to structural improvements in water and sanitation lies in the recognition of these practices and their articulation to the formal system under new governance regimes.

Keywords

environmental sustainability governance infrastructure peri-urban interface poverty water and sanitation

References

Adam, C , W Cavendish and P Mistry (1992), Adjusting Privatization: Case Studies from Developing Countries, James Currey Ltd, London . www.aguatuya.com.

Allen, A (2003), “Environmental planning and management of the peri-urban interface (PUI). Perspectives on an emerging field” , Environment & Urbanization Vol 15, No 1, April, pages 135-147 .

Allen, Adriana , Julio D Dávila and Pascale Hofmann (2006), Governance of Water and Sanitation for the Peri-urban Poor: A Framework for Understanding and Action in Metropolitan Regions, Development Planning Unit, University College London .

Allen, Adriana , Julio D Dávila , Pascale Hofmann and Chris Jasko (2006), So Close to the City, So Far from the Pipes. The Governance of Water and Sanitation and the Peri-urban Poor, Development Planning Unit, University College London .

Batley, R (1996), “Public-private relationships and performance in service provision” , Urban Studies Vol 33, Nos 4-5, pages 723-751 .

Birley, M H and K Lock (1998), “Health and peri-urban natural resource production” , Environment & Urbanization Vol 10, No 1, April, pages 89-106 .

Budds, Jessica and Gordon McGranahan (2003), “Are the debates on water privatization missing the point? Experiences from Africa, Asia and Latin America” , Environment & Urbanization Vol 15, No 2, October, pages 87-113 .

Bustamante, R , J Butterworth and N Faysse (2004), “Is there a future for locally managed domestic water supply systems in peri-urban Cochabamba, Bolivia? Analysis of performance and some possible scenarios” , Working Paper for NEGOWAT project workshop, São Paulo, 16-21 August 2004.

Cook, P and C Kirkpatrick (editors) (1988), Privatization in Less-developed Countries, Wheatsheaf, Brighton, UK .

10.

Dávila, J (2005), “Falling between stools? Policies, strategies and the peri-urban interface”, in D McGregor , D Simon and D Thompson (editors), The Peri-Urban Interface: Approaches to Sustainable Natural and Human Resource Use, Earthscan, London , pages 44-56.

11.

Dávila, Julio D and R Brook (editors) (2000), The Peri-urban Interface: A Tale of Two Cities, School of Agricultural and Forest Sciences, University of Wales, and Development Planning Unit, University College London .

12.

Dávila, Julio D and Mónica Rhon (editors), (2005), “La gobernabilidad en el suministro de agua y saneamiento en la interfaz periurbana de áreas metropolitanas”, Cuaderno de Debate No 1, CIGU, Quito.

13.

Durand-Lasserve, A (2004), “Land for housing the poor in African cities. Are neo-customary processes an effective alternative to formal systems?”, in Hamdi, N (editor), Urban Futures. Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction, ITDG Publishing, Rugby, UK , pages 160-174.

14.

Gutierrez, E , B Calaguas , J Green and V Roaf (2003), New Rules, New Roles: Does Private Sector Participation Benefit the Poor?, Synthesis Report, WaterAid and Tearfund, London .

15.

Hofmann, P (2004), “Access to water supply and sanitation services of low-income households in the peri-urban interface of developing countries”, Paper prepared for the Research Project Service Provision Governance in the Peri-urban Interface of Metropolitan Areas, Development Planning Unit, University College London .

16.

Johnstone, Nick and Libby Wood (editors) (2001), Private Firms and Public Water, Edward Elgar, Chelthenham, UK .

17.

Joshi, A and M Moore (2004), “Institutionalized co-production: Unorthodox public service delivery in challenging environments” , The Journal of Development Studies Vol 40, No 4, pages 31-49 .

18.

Nickson, Andrew (1997), “The public-private mix in urban water supply” , International Review of Administrative Sciences Vol 63, pages 165-186 .

19.

Nickson, Andrew (2002), “The role of the non-state sector in urban water supply” , presented at the World Development Report 2005/04 Workshop “Making Services Work for Poor People”, Eynsham Hall, Oxford, 4-5 November.

20.

Ostrom, E (1996), “Crossing the great divide: co-production, synergy and development” , World Development Vol 24, No 6, pages 1073-1087 .

21.

Segerfeldt, F (2005), Water for Sale: How Business and the Market Can Resolve the World’s Water Crisis, Cato Institute, Washington DC .

22.

Solo, T M (2003), Independent Water Entrepreneurs in Latin America. The Other Private Sector in Water Services, The World Bank, Washington DC . www.ucl.ac.uk/dpu/pui.

23.

UN-Habitat (2003), Water and Sanitation in the World’s Cities. Local Action for Global Goals, Earthscan, London .

24.

Water Engineering and Development Centre (WEDC) (2002), Public Private Partnerships and the Poor, available at http://wedc.lboro.ac.uk.

25.

Water and Sanitation Programme (2004), “The case for marketing sanitation”, Field Note, Sanitation and Hygiene Series, WSP, Nairobi .

26.

Water Utility Partnership for Capacity Building Africa (2003), Better Water and Sanitation for the Urban Poor. Good Practice from Sub-Saharan Africa, European Communities and Water Utility Partnership, Nairobi .

27.

World Bank (1994), World Development Report 1994: Infrastructure for Development, Oxford University Press, New York .

28.

World Bank (2003), World Development Report 2004: Making Services Work for Poor People, Oxford University Press, Washington DC .

29.

World Health Organization (2003), The Right to Water, WHO, Geneva . http://wrmin.nic.in/policy/nwp2002.pdf.