Comparative analysis of the performance of hydrocarbon refrigerants with R22 in a sub-cooling heat exchanger refrigeration system

Abstract

In this study, the performance of some hydrocarbon refrigerants (R290, R600a and R1270) as alternatives to R22 in vapour compression refrigeration system was investigated theoretically employing a sub-cooling heat exchanger. The effects of sub-cooling on the performance of the investigated refrigerants were quantified in terms of relative capacity index. The results obtained showed that the saturated vapour pressure and specific volume of R290 and R1270 are very close to those of R22; therefore, they could be used as substitutes for R22. The condenser duty using R290, R600a and R1270 are better than that of R22 with the highest value obtained using R1270, which shows that they could perform very well as refrigerants in heat pump systems. The coefficient of performances of all the investigated refrigerants were found to be in the range 3.10–3.51. The degree of sub-cooling greatly increased the coefficient of performance and it had positive effects on the refrigerating capacity. The average relative capacity indices obtained for R290, R600a and R1270 were 35.4%, 29.5% and 27.3% higher than that of R22, respectively. Generally, the thermophysical properties of R290 and R1270 matched those of R22 and the two refrigerants exhibited better performance than R22 in sub-cooling heat exchanger refrigeration system. R600a has slightly better performance in terms of lower power per ton of refrigeration and higher coefficient of performance, but its saturation pressure and specific volume deviate significantly from that of R22, which will require major system redesign before it can be employed as R22 substitute.

Keywords

Sub-cooling hydrocarbons alternative refrigerants performance R22

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Calm

Wuebbles

Jain

. Impacts on global ozone and climate from use and emission of 2,2-dichloro1,1,1-trifluoroethane (HCFC-123). J Clim Change 1999; 42(2): 439–474.

Bolaji

. Performance investigation of ozone-friendly R404A and R507 refrigerants as alternatives to R22 in a window air-conditioner. Energy Build 2011; 43: 3139–3143.

Kim

Chang

Kim

. Thermodynamic performance analysis of vapour compression system using alternative refrigerants based on a cycle simulation program. J Ind Eng Chem 2007; 13: 674–686.

UNEP. Handbook for international treaties for protection of the ozone layers, 6th ed. Nairobi, Kenya: United Nation Environment Program, 2003.

Fernandez-Seara

Uhia

Diz

. Vapour condensation of R22 retrofit substitutes R417A, R422A and R422D on CuNi turbo C tubes. Int J Refrig 2010; 33: 148–157.

Bolaji BO. Investigating the performance of some environment-friendly refrigerants as alternative to R12 in vapour compression refrigeration system. PhD Thesis, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Federal University of Technology, Akure, Nigeria, 2008.

Calm

Didion

. Refrigerants for the 21st Century. Int J Refrig 1998; 21(4): 308–321.

Bolaji

. Experimental analysis of reciprocating compressor performance with eco-friendly refrigerants. Proc IMechE Part A: J Power Energy 2010; 224: 781–786.

Park

Jung

. Performance of heat pumps charged with R170/R290 mixture. Appl Energy 2009; 86: 2598–2603.

10.

Del-Col

Torresin

Cavallini

. Heat transfer and pressure drop during condensation of the low GWP refrigerant R1234yf. Int J Refrig 2010; 33: 1307–1318.

11.

Wongwises

Chimres

. Experimental study of hydrocarbon mixtures to replace HFC134a in a domestic refrigerator. Energy Convers Manage 2005; 46: 85–100.

12.

Hwang

Ohadi

Radermacher

. Natural refrigerants. Mech Eng 1998; 120: 96–99.

13.

Calm

Domanski

. R22 replacement status. ASHRAE J 2004; 46: 29–39.

14.

Bitzer. Refrigerant report. 15th ed. Sindelfingen, Germany: Bitzer International, 2012. http://www.bitzer.de (accessed 8 March 2012).

15.

Bolaji

Akintunde

Falade

. Comparative analysis of performance of three ozone-friendly HFC refrigerants in a vapour compression refrigerator. J Sustainable Energy Environ 2011; 2(2): 61–64.

16.

Castro

Urchueguia

Corberan

. Optimized design of a heat exchanger for an air-to-water reversible heat pump working with propane (R290) as refrigerant: modelling analysis and experimental observations. Appl Therm Eng 2005; 25: 2450–2462.

17.

Park

Jung

. Thermodynamic performance of HCFC22 alternative refrigerants for residential air-conditioning applications. Energy Build 2007; 39: 675–680.

18.

Palm

. Refrigeration systems with minimum charge of refrigerant. Appl Therm Eng 2007; 27: 1693–1701.

19.

Palm

. Hydrocarbons as refrigerants in small heat pump and refrigeration systems – a review. Int J Refrig 2008; 31: 552–563.

20.

Thonon

. A review of hydrocarbon two-phase heat transfer in compact heat exchangers and enhanced geometries. Int J Refrig 2008; 31: 633–642.

21.

Fernando

Palm

Lundqvist

. Propane heat pump with low refrigerant charge: design and laboratory tests. Int J Refrig 2004; 27: 761–773.

22.

ASHRAE. Refrigeration handbook Chapter 2. Atlanta, GA: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers Inc., 1998.

23.

Domanski

Didion

. Thermodynamic evaluation of R22 alternative refrigerants and refrigerant mixtures. ASHRAE Trans 1993; 99(2): 636–648.

24.

Domanski

Didion

Doyle

. Evaluation of suction-line/liquid-line heat exchange in the refrigeration cycle. Int J Refrig 1994; 17(7): 487–493.

25.

Klein

Reindl

Brownell

. Refrigeration system performance using liquid-suction heat exchangers. Int J Refrig 2000; 23: 588–596.

26.

Bolaji

. Effects of sub-cooling on performance of R12 alternative in a domestic refrigerator. Thammasat Int J Sci Technol 2010; 13: 12–19.

27.

Dalkilic

Wongwises

. A performance comparison of vapour-compression refrigeration system using various alternative refrigerants. Int Commun Heat Mass Transfer 2010; 37: 1340–1349.

28.

Klein

Reindl

. The relationship of optimum heat exchanger allocation and minimum entropy generation rate for refrigeration cycles. ASME J Energy Res Technol 1998; 120(2): 172–178.

29.

Didion

. The influence of the thermophysical fluid properties of the new ozone-safe refrigerants on performance. Int J Appl Thermodyn 1999; 2(1): 19–35.

30.

Lemmon EW, McLinden MO and Huber ML. NIST reference fluids thermodynamic and transport properties REFPROP 7.0. Gaithersburg, MD: National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), 2002.

31.

Kumar

Rajagopal

. Computational and experimental investigation of low ODP and low GWP R123 and R290 refrigerant mixture alternate to R12. Energy Convers Manage 2007; 48: 3053–3062.