Non-realisability problem with the conventional method of moments in wet-steam flows

Abstract

The method of moments offers an efficient way to preserve the essence of particle size distribution, which is required in many engineering problems such as modelling wet-steam flows. However, in the context of the finite volume method, high-order transport algorithms are not guaranteed to preserve the moment space, resulting in so-called ‘non-realisable’ moment sets. Non-realisability poses a serious obstacle to the quadrature-based moment methods, since no size distribution can be identified for a non-realisable moment set and the moment-transport equations cannot be closed. On the other hand, in the case of conventional method of moments, closures to the moment-transport equations are directly calculated from the moments themselves; as such, non-realisability may not be a problem. This article describes an investigation of the effects of the non-realisability problem on the flow conditions and moment distributions obtained by the conventional method of moments through several one-dimensional test cases involving systems that exhibited similar characteristics to low-pressure wet-steam flows. The predictions of pressures and mean droplet sizes were not considerably disturbed due to non-realisability in any of the test cases. However, in one case that was characterised by strong temporal and spatial gradients, non-realisability did undermine the accuracy of the predictions of measures for the underlying size distributions, including the standard deviation and skewness.

Keywords

Wet-steam flows method of moments non-realisability

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Hill

. Condensation of water vapour during supersonic expansion in nozzles. J Fluid Mech 1966; 25: 593–620.

White

Hounslow

. Modelling droplet size distributions in polydispersed wet-steam flows. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 2000; 43: 1873–1884.

Simpson

White

. Viscous and unsteady flow calculations of condensing steam in nozzles. Int J Heat Fluid Flow 2005; 26: 71–79.

Gerber

Mousavi

. Application of quadrature method of moments to the polydispersed droplet spectrum in transonic steam flows with primary and secondary nucleation. Appl Math Model 2006; 31: 1518–1533.

Gerber

Mousavi

. Representing polydispersed droplet behavior in nucleating steam flow. J Fluids Eng 2007; 129: 1404–1414.

White

. A comparison of modelling methods for polydispersed wet-steam flow. Int J Numer Meth Eng 2003; 57: 819–834.

Afzalifar A, Turunen-Saaresti T and Grönman A. Comparison of moment-based methods for representing droplet size distributions in supersonic nucleating flows of steam. In: The 16th international symposium on transport phenomena and dynamics of rotating machinery (ISROMAC), Honolulu, Hawaii, 10–15 April 2016.

Desjardins

Fox

Villedieu

. A quadrature-based moment method for dilute fluid-particle flows. J Comput Phys 2008; 227: 2514–2539.

Vikas V, Wang ZJ, Passalacqua A, et al. Development of high-order realizable finite-volume schemes for quadrature-based moment method. In: 48th AIAA aerospace sciences meeting including the new horizons forum and aerospace exposition, Orlando, FL, 4–7 January 2010.

10.

Vikas

Wang

Passalacqua

et al.

Realizable high-order finite-volume schemes for quadrature-based moment methods. J Comput Phys 2011; 230: 5328–5352.

11.

Kah

Laurent

Massot

et al.

A high order moment method simulating evaporation and advection of a polydisperse liquid spray. J Comput Phys 2012; 231: 394–422.

12.

Wright

. Numerical advection of moments of the particle size distribution in Eulerian models. J Aerosol Sci 2007; 38: 352–369.

13.

McGraw R. Correcting moment sequences for errors associated with advective transport, http://www.ecd.bnl.gov/pubs/momentcorrection_mcgraw2006.pdf (2006, accessed 23 November 2015).

14.

Afzalifar

Turunen-Saaresti

Grönman

. Non-realizability problem with quadrature method of moments in wet-steam flows and solution techniques. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 2017; 139: 012602–012602.

15.

Marchisio

Fox

. Computational models for polydisperse particulate and multiphase systems, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013.

16.

Becker

Döring

. Kinetische behandlung der keimbildung in übersättigten dämpfen. Ann Phys 1935; 416: 719–752.

17.

Zeldovich

. On the theory of new phase formation. Zh Eksp Theor Fiz 1942; 12: 525–538.

18.

Gibbs

. On the equilibrium of heterogeneous substances. Am J Sci 1878; 96: 441–458.

19.

Thomson

. On the equilibrium of vapour at a curved surface of liquid. Proc Roy Soc Edinburgh 1872; 7: 63–68.

20.

Kantrowitz

. Nucleation in very rapid vapor expansions. J Chem Phys 1951; 19. 1097, 1951.

21.

Courtney

. Remarks on homogeneous nucleation. J Chem Phys 1961; 35: 2249–2250.

22.

Gyarmathy G. Grundlagen einer theorie der nassdampfturbine. PhD Thesis, ETH Zürich, Nr 3221, Switzerland, 1962.

23.

Young

. Spontaneous condensation of steam in supersonic nozzles. PhysicoChem Hydrodyn 1982; 3: 57–82.

24.

Randolph

Larson

. Theory of particulate processes: Analysis and techniques of continuous crystallization, San Diego, CA: Academic Press Inc, 1988.

25.

Hulburt

Katz

. Some problems in particle technology: A statistical mechanical formulation. Chem Eng Sci 1964; 19: 555–574.

26.

Vukalovich

. Thermodynamic properties of water and steam, 6th ed. Moscow: Mashgis, 1958.

27.

Keenan

Keyes

Hill

et al.

Steam tables: Thermodynamics properties of water including vapor, liquid and solid phases, New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1978.

28.

Young

. An equation of state for steam for turbomachinery and other flow calculations. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 1988; 110: 1–7.

29.

Liou

Steffen

. A new flux splitting scheme. J Comput Phys 1993; 107: 23–39.

30.

Koren

. A robust upwind discretization method for advection, diffusion and source terms. Notes Numer Fluid Mech 1993; 45: 117–138.

31.

Young

. Two-dimensional, nonequilibrium, wet-steam calculations for nozzles and turbine cascades. J Turbomach 1992; 114: 569–579.

32.

Shohat

Tamarkin

. The problem of moments, New York: American Mathematical Society, 1943.

33.

Lapenta

Finn

et al.

Modeling the large-scale structures of astrophysical jets in the magnetically dominated limit. Astrophys J 2006; 643: 92–100.

34.

Zhang

Shu

. On positivity-preserving high order discontinuous Galerkin schemes for compressible Euler equations on rectangular meshes. J Comput Phys 2010; 229: 8918–8934.

35.

Moore MJ, Walters PT, Crane RI, et al. Predicting the fog-drop size in wet-steam turbines. In: Wet Steam 4 conference, Warwick, UK, 1973.

36.

Moses

Stein

. On the growth of steam droplets formed in a Laval nozzle using both static pressure and light scattering measurements. J Fluids Eng 1978; 100: 311–322.