Since their introduction in 2005, thousands of same-sex couples in the UK have had a civil partnership. However, many other couples have chosen not to have one. This qualitative study explores why some same-sex couples are choosing not to have a civil partnership. Seven semi-structured interviews were conducted with 12 people (five couples and two individuals) who identified as lesbian, gay or bisexual, and analysed using discourse analysis. Participants’ accounts were characterised by ambivalence about civil partnership, and three main paradoxes were identified: the ‘good but not good enough’ paradox, the ‘unwanted prize’ paradox and the ‘legal rights v. social oppression paradox. A major source of ambivalence was support for rights but resistance to assimilation into dominant heteronormative cultural frameworks. Participants negotiated this ambivalence in a variety of ways, including considering how to have a civil partnership that is different from ‘marriage’, and adopting a pragmatic position. The analysis highlights the importance of social recognition and support for a range of relationship forms and identities, as well as for an ongoing critical debate about civil partnerships and same-sex marriage.
Atkinson T. ( 1974) Amazon Odyssey. New York: Links Books.
2.
Auchmuty R. ( 2004) Same-sex marriage revived: Feminist critique and legal strategy. Feminism & Psychology14(1): 101-126.
3.
Auchmuty R. ( 2007) Out of the shadows: Feminist silence and liberal law. In: Munro V and Stychin C (eds) Sexuality and the Law: Feminist Engagements . Oxon: Routledge-Cavendish, 91-124.
4.
BBC News (2005) ‘Gay weddings’ become law in UK. 5 December. Available at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/4493094.stm (accessed November 2010).
5.
Billig M., Condor S., Edwards D., Gane M., Middleton D. and Radley A. ( 1988) Ideological Dilemmas: A Social Psychology of Everyday Thinking. London: Sage.
6.
Bonthuys E. ( 2008) Possibilities foreclosed: The Civil Union Act and lesbian and gay identity in Southern Africa. Sexualities11: 726-739.
7.
Calhoun C. ( 2000) Feminism, Family and the Politics of the Closet: Lesbian and Gay Displacement. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
8.
Clarke V., Burgoyne C. and Burns M. ( 2007) Romance, rights, recognitions, responsibilities and radicalism: Same-sex couples’ views on civil partnership and marriage. In: Clarke V and Peel E (eds) Out in Psychology: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual Trans and Queer Perspectives. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 173-194.
9.
Donovan C. ( 2004) Why reach for the moon? Because the stars aren’t enough. Feminism & Psychology14(1): 24-29.
10.
Eskridge WN ( 2002) Equality Practices: Civil Unions and the Future of Gay Rights. New York: Routledge.
11.
Ettelbrick P. ( 1997) Since when is marriage a path to liberation? In: Baird RM and Rosenbaum SE (eds) Same-Sex Marriage: The Moral and Legal Debate. Amherst, NY: Prometheus, 164-168.
12.
Giddens A. ( 1992) The Transformation of Intimacy. Sexuality, Love and Eroticism in Modern Societies. Cambridge: Polity Press.
13.
Green RJ ( 2004) Risk and Resilience in Lesbian and Gay Couples: Comment on Solomon, Rothblum and Balsam. Journal of Family Psychology18(2): 290-292.
14.
Hall S. ( 1986) Variants of liberalism. In: Donald J and Hall S (eds) Politics and Ideology. Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 34-69.
15.
Harding R. ( 2006) ‘Dogs are ‘‘registered’’, people shouldn’t be’: Legal consciousness and lesbian and gay rights. Social and Legal Studies15(4): 513-535.
16.
Harding R. ( 2008) Recognizing (and resisting) regulation: Attitudes to the introduction of civil partnership. Sexualities11(6): 741-762.
17.
Harding R. ( 2011) Regulating Sexuality: Legal Consciousness in Lesbian and Gay Lives. London: Routledge.
18.
Harding R. and Peel E. ( 2006) ‘We do?’ International perspectives on equality, legality and same-sex relationships. Lesbian & Gay Psychology Review7(2): 123-140.
19.
Human Rights First ( 2008) 2008 Hate Crime Survey. New York: Human Rights First. Available at: http://www.humanrightsfirst.org/wp-content/uploads/pdf/FD-081103-hate-crime-survey-2008.pdf (accessed February 2011).
20.
Hunt R. and Dick S. ( 2008) Serves you Right: Lesbian and Gay People’s Expectations of Discrimination. Stonewall. Available at: http://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2008/03/31/ServesYouRight.pdf .
21.
Ingraham C. ( 1999) White Weddings: Romancing Heterosexuality in Popular Culture . London: Routledge.
22.
Jamieson L., Anderson M., McCrone D., Bechhofer F., Stewart R. and Li Y. ( 2002) Cohabitation and commitment: Partnership plans of young men and women. The Sociological Review50(3): 356-377.
23.
Jeffreys S. ( 2004) The need to abolish marriage. Feminism & Psychology14(1): 327-331.
24.
Johnston C. ( 2008) The PACS and (post-) queer citizenship in contemporary Republican France. Sexualities11: 688-705.
25.
Jowett A. and Peel E.(2010) ‘Seismic culture change?’ Media representations of same-sex ‘marriage’. Women’s Studies International Forum33(3): 206-214.
26.
Kitzinger C. and Wilkinson S. ( 2004a) The re-branding of marriage: Why we got married instead of registering a civil partnership. Feminism & Psychology14(1): 127-150.
27.
Kitzinger C. and Wilkinson S. ( 2004b) Social advocacy for equal marriage: The politics of ‘rights’ and the psychology of ‘mental health’. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy4(1): 173-194.
28.
Lannutti PJ ( 2005) For better or worse: Exploring the meanings of same-sex marriage within the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered community. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships22(1): 5-18.
29.
Mauss AL ( 1975) Social Problems as Social Movements. Philadelphia: Lippincott.
30.
Meikle J. ( 2009) Civil Partnerships down by 18%. The Guardian, August. Available: www.guardian.c.uk/lifeandstyle/2009/aug/04/civil-partnerships-down-gay-marriages (accessed 21 June 2010).
31.
Miller FD ( 1999) The end of SDS and the emergence of weatherman: Demise through success. In: Freeman J and Johnson V (eds) Waves of Protest: Social Movements since the Sixties. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 303-324.
32.
Mitchell M., Dickens S. and O’Connor W. ( 2009) Same-Sex Couples and the Impact of Legislative Changes . London: National Centre for Social Research.
33.
Office for National Statistics (2006) General Household Survey 2006: Overview Report. Newport : Office for National Statistics.
34.
Office for National Statistics (2007) Social Trends. No. 37. Hampshire: Palgrave MacMillan.
35.
Office for National Statistics (2009) Civil Partnerships during 2008: United Kingdom. In: Population Trends No. 137. Autumn 2009. Hampshire : Office for National Statistics/ Palgrave MacMillan.
36.
Ottosson D. ( 2010) State-Sponsored Homophobia: A World Survey of Laws Prohibiting Same Sex Activity between Consenting Adults. International Lesbian: Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association.
37.
Parker I. ( 1992) Discourse Dynamics: Critical Analysis for Social and Individual Psychology. London: Routledge.
38.
Peel E. ( 2002) Lesbian and gay awareness training: Homophobia, liberalism, and managing stereotypes. In: Coyle A and Kitzinger C (eds) Lesbian and Gay Psychology: New Perspectives. Oxford: BPS Blackwell, 255-274.
39.
Peel E. ( 2009) Civil Partnership: Exploring the Meanings of Commitment, Ritual and Recognition for Same-Sex Couples - Summary of Findings. Aston University: unpublished document.
40.
Peel E. and Harding R. ( 2004) Divorcing romance, rights and radicalism: Beyond pro and anti in the lesbian and gay marriage debate. Feminism & Psychology14(1): 588-599.
41.
Peel E. and Jowett A. ( 2006) ‘What do you mean we’re not expecting gifts!’ Complexities of couple interviewing. British Psychological Society Lesbian and Gay Psychology Section Conference, 1-2 December, London. [Abstract published in Lesbian & Gay Psychology Review 2007 8(2): 106].
42.
Rich A. ( 1983) Compulsory heterosexuality and lesbian existence. In: Snitow A, Stansell C and Thompson S (eds) Desire: The Politics of Sexuality. London: Virago, 212-241.
43.
Richardson D (ed.) (1996) Theorising Heterosexuality: Telling it Straight. Buckingham: Open University Press.
44.
Rimmerman CA ( 2007) The Lesbian and Gay Movements: Assimilation or Liberation?Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
45.
Shipman B. and Smart C. ( 2007) ‘It’s made a huge difference’: Recognition, rights, and the personal significance of civil partnerships. Sociological Research Online12(1). Available at: http://www.socresonline.org.uk/12/1/shipman.html .
46.
Smart C. ( 2008) ‘Can I be bridesmaid?’ Combining the personal and political in same-sex weddings. Sexualities11(6): 761-776.
47.
Tilly C. ( 1978) From Mobilization to Revolution. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
48.
Village Citizens Advice Bureau (2007) Civil Partnerships: Another Year On. Manchester: Citizens Advice Bureau.
49.
Walton C. ( 2007) Doing discourse analysis. In: Lyons E and Coyle A (eds) Analysing Qualitative Data in Psychology. London: Sage, 117-130.
50.
Ward L. ( 2006) More than 15,500 civil partnerships prove popularity of legislation. The Guardian, 5 December. Available at: www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2006/dec/05/lifeandhealth.topstories3 (accessed 21 June 2010).
51.
Weeks J., Heavy B. and Donovan C. ( 2001) Same Sex Intimacies: Families of cHoice and Other Life Experiments. London: Routledge.
52.
Wetherell M. ( 1995) Romantic discourse and feminist analysis: Interrogating investment, power and desire. In: Wilkinson S and Kitzinger C (eds) Feminism and Discourse: Psychological Perspectives. London : Sage.
53.
Willig C. ( 2000) A discourse-dynamic approach to the study of subjectivity in health psychology. Theory & Psychology10: 547-570.
54.
Willig C. ( 2008) Discourse analysis. In: Smith J (ed.) Qualitative Psychology: A Practical Guide to Research Methods, 2nd edition. London : Sage, 160-187.
55.
Yip A. ( 2004) Same-sex marriage: Contrasting perspectives among lesbian, gay and bisexual Christians. Feminism & Psychology14(1): 173-180.
