Radiocarbon-dated sediment sequences from the Belgian coastal plain: testing the hypothesis of fluctuating or smooth late-Holocene relative sea-level rise
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online December, 2008
Radiocarbon-dated sediment sequences from the Belgian coastal plain: testing the hypothesis of fluctuating or smooth late-Holocene relative sea-level rise
The late-Holocene deposits of the coastal lowlands bordering the southern North Sea were formed by a renewed expansion of the tidal environment replacing freshwater peats. The sea-level history during the last 2500 years inferred from the post-peat deposits, containing little to no datable organic material, is characterized by two conflicting schools of thought. The first one supports a smooth sea-level curve. The second approach underpins fluctuating sea-level changes. The `fluctuating' approach also uses facies variations recorded in the post-peat deposits to provide a chronostratigraphical subdivision linked to transgressions and regressions. This paper examines the controlling factors responsible for the facies variations in the post-peat deposits in order to test the approach of the fluctuating sea level. The results of sedimentological investigation coupled with radiocarbon dates of intertidal shells from four shallow outcrops located in nearby sand-filled late-Holocene tidal channels in the Belgian coastal plain are reported. The integration with results from previous work has allowed the reconstruction of the mechanisms and processes of coastal evolution during the late Holocene. The changes in the coastal landscape reflected in the facies variations are caused by multiple factors. The major one is the dynamic nature of the tidal channels responding to changes in accommodation space and sediment budget, and finally, to storm incidence and human impact. The processes of the tidal channel networks, ie, their initiation and evolution, are similar, but the changes happened at different times in different places. The facies variations do not involve rises and falls of sea level, and therefore a fluctuating sea-level rise can not be considered as realistic.
Allen, J.R.L.2000: Late Flandrian (Holocene) tidal palaeochannels, Gwent Levels (Severn Estuary), SW Britain: character, evolution and relation to shore . Marine Geology162, 353-80.
2.
Baeteman, C.1981: An alternative classification and profile type map applied to the Holocene deposits of the Belgian coastal plain . Bulletin Belgische Vereniging voor Geologie90, 257-80.
3.
---- 1983: De Holocene sedimenten van de westelijke kustvlakte: een analyse van de Belgische litteratuur . Professional Paper, Belgian Geological Survey9/204, 1-45.
4.
---- 1991: Chronology of the coastal plain development during the Holocene in West Belgium . Quaternaire2, 116-25.
5.
---- 1999: The Holocene depositional history of the IJzer palaeovalley (western Belgian coastal plain) with reference to factors controlling peat beds . Geologica Belgica2, 39-72.
6.
---- 2001: Palaeogeographical reconstruction of sedimentary environments as a control of sea-level index points - new data of Holocene high sea-level stands from the western coastal plain of Belgium . The 3rd International Conference of the IGCP Project 437, September 2001, Durham, UK. Abstract.[AQ]
7.
---- 2004a: The Holocene development of a tide-dominated coastal lowland. Western coastal plain of Belgium. Field Guide . The QRA Third International Postgraduate Symposium Fieldtrip, 17 September 2004. Belgian Geological Survey.
8.
---- 2004b: Geologische kaart van België 1/25.000. Profieltypenkaart van de Holocene Kustafzettingen. Belgische Geologische Dienst .
9.
---- 2005a: How subsoil morphology and erodibility influence the origin and pattern of late Holocene tidal channels: case studies from the Belgian coastal lowlands . Quaternary Science Reviews24, 2146-62.
10.
---- 2005b: The Streif classification system: a tribute to an alternative system for organising and mapping Holocene coastal deposits . Quaternary International133-134, 141-49.
11.
---- 2007a: De laat holocene evolutie van de Belgische kustvlakte: Sedimentatieprocessen versus zeespiegelschommelingen en Duinkerke transgressies . Geoarchaeological and Bioarchaeological Studies8, 1-17.
12.
---- 2007b: Roman peat-extraction pits as possible evidence for the timing of coastal changes. An example from the Belgian coastal plain. In Beenakker, J.J. , Horsten, F.H. , De Kraker, A.M.J. and Renes, H. , editors, Landschap in ruimte en tijd. Aksant , 16-25.
13.
Baeteman, C. , Beets, D.J. and Van Strydonck, M.1999: Tidal crevasse splays as the cause of rapid changes in the rate of aggradation in the Holocene tidal deposits of the Belgian Coastal Plain . Quaternary International56, 3-13.
14.
Baeteman, C. , Scott, D.B. and Van Strydonck, M.2002: Changes in coastal zone processes at a high sea-level stand: a late Holocene example from Belgium . Journal of Quaternary Science17, 547-59.
15.
Barckhausen, J. , Preuss, H. and Streif, H.1977: Ein lithologisches ordnungsprinzip für das Küstenholozän und seine Darstellung in Form von Profiltypen . Geologisches JarhbuchA44, 45-74.
16.
Beets, D.J. , van der Spek, A.J.F. and van der Valk, L.1994: Holocene ontwikkeling van de Nederlandse kust . Rijksgeologische Dienst, Rapport 40.016, Project Kustgenese, 1-53.
17.
Beets, D.J. , de Groot, T.A.M. and Davies, H.A.2003: Holocene tidal back-barrier development at decelerating sea-level rise: a 5 millennia record, exposed in the western Netherlands . Sedimentary Geology158, 117-44.
18.
Behre, K-E.2003: Eine neue Meeresspiegelkurve für die südliche Nordsee. Transgressionen und Regressionen in den letzten 10.000 Jahren . Probleme der Küstenforschung im südlichen Nordseegebiet28, 9-63.
19.
---- 2007: A new Holocene sea-level curve for the southern North Sea . Boreas36, 82-102.
20.
Berendsen, H.J.A.1984: Problems of lithostratigraphic classification of Holocene deposits in the perimarine area of the Netherlands . Geologie en Mijnbouw63, 351-54.
21.
Brew, D.S., Holt, T., Pye, K. and Newsham, R.2000: Holocene sedimentary evolution and palaeo-coastlines of the Fenland embayment, eastern England . Geological Society, London, Special Publications166, 253-73.
22.
Bungenstock, F. , Mauz, B. and Schäfer, A.2004: The late Holocene sea-level rise at the East Frisian coast (North Sea): new time constraints provided by optical ages of coastal deposits . In Schernewski, G. and Dolch, T., editors, Geographie der Meere und Küste - Coastline Reports1, 37-41.[AQ]
23.
Denys, L.1993: Paleoecologisch diatomeeënonderzoek van de Holocene afzetting in de westelijke Belgische kustvlakte. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Antwerpen .
24.
---- 1999: A diatom and radiocarbon perspective of the palaeoenvironmental history and stratigraphy of Holocene deposits between Oostende and Nieuwpoort (western coastal plain, Belgium) . Geologica Belgica2, 111-40.
25.
Denys, L. and Baeteman, C.1995: Holocene evolution of relative sea-level and local mean high water spring tides in Belgium - a first assessment . Marine Geology124, 1-19.
26.
Ebbing, J.H.J. , Weerts, H.J.T. and Westerhoff, W.E.2003: Towards an integrated land-sea stratigraphy of The Netherlands . Quaternary Science Reviews22, 1579-87.
27.
Ervynck, A. , Baeteman, C. , Demiddele, H. , Hollevoet, Y. , Pieters, M. , Schelvis, J. , Tys, D. , Van Strydonck, M. and Verhaeghe, F.1999: Human occupation because of a regression, or the cause of a transgression? A critical review of the interaction between geological events and human occupation in the Belgian coastal plain during the first millennium AD . Probleme der Küstenforschung im südlichen Nordseegebied26, 97-121.
28.
Evans, J.R. , Kirby, J.R. and Long, A.J.2001: The litho- and biostratigraphy of a late Holocene tidal channel in Romney Marsh, southern England . Proceedings of the Geologists'Association112, 111-30.
29.
Frouin, M. , Laignel, B. , Sebag, D. , Ogier, S. and Durand, A.2007: Sedimentological characterization and origin of the deposits in a Holocene marsh (Marais Vernier, Seine estuary, France) . Zeitschrift für Geomorphology51, 1-18.
30.
Hoffmann, D.1998: Das junge Küstenholozän an der Nordseeküste Schleswig-Holsteins . Meyniana50, 71-87.
31.
Kiden, P.1995: Holocene sea-level change and crustal movement in the southwestern Netherlands . Marine Geology124, 21-41.
32.
Long, A.J. and Innes, J.B.1993: Holocene sea-level changes and coastal sedimentation in Romney Marsh, southeast England, UK . Proceedings of the Geologists'Association104, 223-37.
33.
Long, A.J. , Scaife, R.G. and Edwards, R.J.2000: Stratigraphic architecture, relative sea level, and models of estuary development in southern England: new data from Southampton Water . In Pye, K. and Allen, J.R.L., editors, Coastal and estuarine environments: sedimentology, geomorphology and geoarchaeology . Geological Society, London, Special Publications175, 253-79.
34.
Loveluck, C. and Tys, D.2006: Coastal societies, exchange and identity along the Channel and southern North Sea shores of Europe, AD 600-1000 AD . Journal of Maritime Archaeology1, 1-30.
35.
Mauz, B. and Bungenstock, F.2007: How to reconstruct trends of late Holocene relative sea level: a new approach using tidal flat clastic sediments and optical dating . Marine Geology237, 225-37.
36.
Meurisse, M. , Van Vliet-Lanoë, B. , Talon, B. and Recourt, P.2005: Complexes dunaire et tourbeux holocènes du littoral du Nord de la France . Comptes Rendu Geoscience337, 675-84.
37.
Mrani Alaoui, M. and Anthony, E.J.2005: Sedimentary facies variability in the French Flemish coastal plain . In Baeteman, C., editor, Abstract book, late Quaternary coastal changes: sea level, sedimentary forcing and anthropogenetic impacts . A joint INQUA-IGCP Project 495 Conference, Dunkerque, 28 June-2 July 2005, 44-45.
38.
Smyth, C. and Jennings, S.1990: Late Bronze Age-Iron Age valley sedimentation in East Sussex, Southern England. In Boardman, J. , editor, Soil erosion on agricultural land. Wiley , 273-84.
39.
Streif, H.1972: The results of stratigraphical and facial investigations in the coastal Holocene of Woltzeten/Ostfriesland, Germany . Geologiska Föreningen i Stockholm Förhandlingar94, 281-99.
40.
Streif, H. and Zimmermann, B.1973: Das Küstenholozän von Rysum/Knock im Gebied der Emsmündung (Nordsee) . Geologisches JahrbuchA9, 3-20.
41.
Stuiver, M. and Reimer, P.J.1993: Extended C14 data base and revised CALIB 3.0 C14 age calibration program . Radiocarbon35, 215-30.
42.
van de Plassche, O.1982: Sea-level change and water-level movements in The Netherlands during the Holocene . Mededelingen Rijks Geologische Dienst36, 3-93.
43.
van der Spek, A.J.F. and Beets, D.J.1992: Mid-Holocene evolution of a tidal basin in the western Netherlands: a model for future changes under accelerated sea-level rise?Sedimentary Geology80, 185-97.
44.
Van Loon, A.J.1981: Problems of Holocene lithostratigraphy . In Van Loon, A.J., editor, Quaternary geology: a farewell to A .J. Wiggers. Geologie en Mijnbouw60, 353-61.
45.
van Staalduinen, C.J. , van Adrichem Boogaert, H.A. , Bless, M.J.M. , Doppert, J.W.Chr. , Harsveldt, H.M. , van Montfrans, H.M. , Oele, E. , Wermuth, R.A. and Zagwijn, W.H.1979: The geology of The Netherlands . Mededelingen Rijks Geologische Dienst31, 9-49.
46.
Van Strydonck, M. and Baeteman, C.1998: C dates of reworked shells in Late Holocene tidal channel deposits (Western Belgian coastal plain) . In Stiros, S.C. and Pirazzoli, P.A., editors, Abstract book joint meeting on rapid coastal changes in the late Quaternary . Processes, causes, modeling, impacts on coastal zones. Greece, 10-19 September 1998, 68-69.
47.
Vink, A. , Steffen, H. , Reinhardt, L. and Kaufmann, G.2007: Holocene relative sea-level change, isostatic subsidence and the radial viscosity structure of the mantle of northwest Europe (Belgium, The Netherlands, Germany, southern North Sea) . Quaternary Science Reviews26, 3249-75.
48.
Vos, P.C.1999: The subatlantic evolution of the coastal area around the Wijnaldum-Tjitsma terp. In Besteman, J.C. , Bos, J.M. , Gerrets, D.A. , Heidinga, H.A. and De Koning, J. , editors, The excavation at Wijnaldum. A.A. Balkema , 33-72.
49.
Vos, P. and Kiden, P.2005: De landschapsvorming tijdens de steentijd . Archeologie11/12, 7-37.
50.
Vos, P. and van Heeringen, R.M.1997: Holocene geology and occupation history of the province of Zeeland (SW Netherlands) . Mededelingen Nederlands Instituut voor Toegepaste Geowetenschappen TNO59, 5-109.
51.
Waller, M.P. , Long, A.J. and Schofield, J.E.2006: Interpretation of radiocarbon dates from the upper surface of late-Holocene peat layers in coastal lowlands . The Holocene16, 51-61.
52.
Weerts, H.J.T. , Westerhoff, W.E. , Cleveringa, P. , Bierkens, M.F.P. , Veldkamp, J.G. and Rijsdijk, K.F.2005: Quaternary geological mapping of the lowlands of The Netherlands, a 21st century perspective . Quaternary International133-134, 159-78.
53.
Westerhoff, W.E. , De Mulder, E.F.J. and De Gans, W.1987: Toelichtingen bij de geologische kaart van Nederland 1:50.000, blad Alkmaar West en blad Alkmaar Oost . Rijks Geologische Dienst, 227 pp.
54.
Wheeler, A.J. and Waller, M.P.1995: The Holocene lithostratigraphy of Fenland, eastern England: a review and suggestions for redefinition . Geological Magazine132, 223-33.
