Lithic raw material sourcing and the assessment of Mesolithic landscape organization and mobility strategies in northern England

Abstract

Analysis of the early evolution of cultural landscapes, particularly the regional organization of space by mobile hunter-gatherers, is often hampered by a lack of overt landscape marking and modification and/or a lack of sufficient biological material with which to assess regional affinity. This situation places a premium on the accurate sourcing of durable materials, such as stone for tool manufacture (commonly employed as proxy measures of space utilization), and including resource procurement, control, and movement. In an effort to understand the Mesolithic (10 000—5500 BP) organization of space in northern England, we undertake studies on black cherts, employing LA-ICP-MS, an efficient and minimally destructive geochemical technique. Comparisons between primary sources of black cherts, and archaeologically derived chert artefacts, from the site of Lismore Fields in Derbyshire, reveals that systematic application of this approach allows both the chemical differentiation of sources and an understanding of the chemical relationship between archaeological samples and specific analysed sources. These results are consistent with results of earlier studies employing different analytic methods and allow the partial testing of two alternative models of Mesolithic landscape organization in the region. We conclude that the use of LA-ICP-MS is a useful method to employ for chemical characterization of sources and results reinforce an interpretation of regional Mesolithic landscape organization being framed around east—west trending, upland-coastal transects consistent with natural drainage features.

Keywords

chert geochemical sourcing hunter-gatherers LA-ICP-MS landscape Mesolithic

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aitkenhead N. , Chisholm JI and Stevenson IP ( 1985) Geology of the Country Around Buxton, Leek and Bakewell . Memoirs of the British Geological Survey, (Sheet 111), Natural Environment Research Council /Her Majesty’s Stationary Office.

Clark JGD ( 1932) The Mesolithic Age in Britain. Cambridge University Press.

Clark JGD ( 1972) Star Carr: A Case Study in Bioarchaeology. Reading: Modular Publications 10.

Donahue RE , Lovis WA ( 2003) Initial evaluation of Grahame Clark’s model of Mesolithic transhumance in northern England: A perspective from the Pennine Uplands. In: Larson L , Kindgren H , Knutsson K , Loeffler D and Åkerlund A (eds) Mesolithic on the Move. Oxbow Books, 310-315.

Donahue RE , Lovis WA ( 2006) Regional settlement systems in Mesolithic northern England: Scalar issues in mobility and territoriality. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 25: 248-258.

Dunham KC , Wilson AA ( 1985) Stainmore to Craven, geology of the northern Pennine Orefield . In: Economic Memoirs of the British Geological Survey (Sheets 40, 41, 50 and Parts 31, 32, 51, 60, 61), Vol. 2. Natural Environment Research Council, Her Majesty’s Stationary Office.

Evans AA , Wolframm YB , Donahue RE and Lovis WA ( 2007) A pilot study of ‘black chert’ sourcing and implications for assessing hunter-gatherer mobility strategies in northern England. Journal of Archaeological Science 34: 2161-2169.

Garton D. ( 1987) Buxton. Current Archaeology 103: 250-253. Grigson C. (1981) Fauna. In: Simmons I, Tooley M (eds) The Environment in British Prehistory. Duckworth, 82-124.

Hess SC ( 1996) Chert provenance analysis at the Mack Canyon site, Sherman County, Oregon: An evaluative study. Geoarchaeology 11(1): 51-81.

10.

Hind D. ( 1998) Chert use in the Mesolithic of northern England . Assemblage 4. Available at: http://www.assemblage.group.shef.ac.uk/4/ (accessed 8 March 2009).

11.

Jacobi R. ( 1978) Northern England in the eighth millennium BC: An essay . In: Mellars P (ed.) The Early Postglacial Settlement of Northern Europe: An Ecological Perspective . Duckworth, 128-140.

12.

Jarvis KE , Gray AL and Houk RS ( 2003) Handbook of Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry . Working: Viridian Publishing.

13.

Jefferies TE ( 2004) Laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry . In: Janssens K, van Grieken R (eds) Non-destructive Microanalysis of Cultural Heritage Materials: Wilson & Wilson’s Comprehensive Analytical Chemistry , Vol. XLII. Elsevier, 313-358.

14.

Langer JL ( 2007) Characterisation of black chert from northern England using LA-ICP-MS. Masters dissertation, University of Bradford .

15.

Legge AJ , Rowley-Conwy PA ( 1988) Star Carr Revisited: A Re-analysis of the Large Mammals . Birkbeck College.

16.

Longerich J. ( 2001) Chemometrics. In: Sylvester P (ed.) Laser-ablation-ICPMS in the Earth Sciences: Principles and Applications. Short Course Series Vol. 29, Raeside R, series editor, Mineralogical Association of Canada, 21-28.

17.

Lovis WA ( 2008) Space, information, and knowledge: North American Boreal hunter-gatherers. Abstracts of the 73rd Annual Meeting , Vancouver, BC, Canada. Society for American Archaeology.

18.

Luedtke BE ( 1978) Chert sources and trace-element analysis. American Antiquity 43: 413-423.

19.

Mellars P. , Dark P. ( 1998) Star Carr in Context. McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research.

20.

Moroni B. , Petrelli M. ( 2005) Geochemical characterization of flint artifacts by inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry with laser sampling (LA-ICP-MS): Results and prospects. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 5(2): 49-62.

21.

Orme GR ( 1974) Silica in the Visean limestones of Derbyshire, England . Proceedings of the Yorkshire Geological Society 40: 63-104.

22.

Pearce NJG , Perkins WT , Westgate JA , Gorton MP , Jackson SE , Neal CR et al. (1996) A compilation of new and published major and trace element data for NIST SRM 610 and NIST SRM 612 glass reference materials . Geostandards Newsletter 21: 115-144.

23.

Pitts M. ( 1979) Hides and antlers: A new look at the gatherer-hunter site at Star Carr, North Yorkshire, England. World Archaeology 11: 32-42.

24.

Richards MP , Schulting RJ and Hedges REM ( 2001) Sharp shift in diet at onset of Neolithic. Nature 425: 366.

25.

Roll TE , Neely MP , Speakman RJ and Glascock MD ( 2005) Characterization of Montana cherts by LA-ICP-MS . In: Speakman RJ , Neff H (eds) Laser Ablation-ICP-MS in Archaeological Research . Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.

26.

Rowley-Conwy P. ( 1995) Mesolithic settlement patterns: New zoological evidence from the Vale of Pickering, Yorkshire. University of Durham and University of Newcastle Upon Tyne Archaeological Reports 1994. University of Durham, 1-6.

27.

Schulting RJ , Richards MP ( 2000) The use of stable isotopes in studies of subsistence and seasonality. In: Young R (ed.) Mesolithic Lifeways, Current Research from Britain and Ireland. Leicester Archaeology Monographs 7, University of Leicester, 55-65.

28.

Wolframm YB ( 2005) Chert sourcing and Mesolithic hunter-gatherer mobility in the Pennines. PhD dissertation, University of Bradford .