Diachronic evolution in subsistence strategies of ancient humans from the Neolithic Age to the Bronze Age in the Western Liaohe River Basin and its influencing factors
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online February, 2025
Diachronic evolution in subsistence strategies of ancient humans from the Neolithic Age to the Bronze Age in the Western Liaohe River Basin and its influencing factors
The Western Liaohe River Basin, rich in prehistoric cultures, is one of the significant origins of Chinese civilization. However, what is the subsistence basis that supports the development of prehistoric cultures in this region? More importantly, which role did agriculture play in the development of various prehistoric cultures? Which factors drive the diachronic evolution in subsistence strategies? These issues are worthy of study. Based on this, we systematically collected zooarchaeological, archaeobotanical, and stable isotope data from various prehistoric archeological cultural sites spanning from the Neolithic Age to the Bronze Age in the Western Liaohe River Basin, attempting to explore their economic characteristics, evolution process as well as driving factor. The study found that in the Western Liaohe River Basin, the cultivation of millet crops may have begun as early as the Xiaohexi cultural period, and domestic pigs and dogs may have occurred in the Xinglongwa cultural period (Xionglongwa and Xionglonggou site respectively). However, during Hongshan cultural period, collection and hunting (cervids) remained the main subsistence strategy. In the Lower Xiajiadian cultural period, millet agriculture and domestic pig breeding replaced gathering and hunting, as the predominant subsistence strategy. This subsistence pattern was also adopted by subsequent Upper Xiajiadian cultural populations, and in some areas, animal husbandry developed during this period. We analyze that the evolution of the subsistence strategies of the prehistoric humans in this region may be related with Holocene climate change. Meanwhile, other factors such as improvements in production technology, population pressure and the environmental impacts they brought may also play a role. This study reveals the evolution process of subsistence strategies of prehistoric cultures in the Western Liaohe River Basin, and is of great significance in understanding the relationship between subsistence evolution of ancient populations and environmental changes in northern China.
Agricultural Research Group (2011) Technical and Economic Research on the Formation and Early Development of Chinese Civilization from 3500BC to 1500BC: Agricultural Research, Institute of Archaeology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Science and Technology Archaeology Center, edited: Science and Technology Archaeology (Series 3), Science Press, China, pp.1–35.
2.
BaoSYuX (2020) Research on the animal remains of the Lower Xiajiadian culture. Archaeology40(4): 36–41.
3.
ChenQ (2006) Animal remains unearthed from Jinggou Zi Xiliang site, Linxi County, Inner Mongolia. Inner Mongolia Archaeological Relics26(2): 105–110.
4.
ChenQZhangZ (2017) An archaeological study of animals unearthed at Weijiawopu Site in Chifeng City from 2010 to 2011. Steppe Cultural Relics37(01): 104–114.
5.
DengH (1997) Evolution of human-land relationship in Yanbei area during Holocene great warm period. Acta Geographica Sinica52(1): 63–71.
6.
DengZ (2022) The origin and early spread of millet. Archaeological Research31(01): 172–214 (in Chinese).
7.
FullerDQQinL (2010) Declining oaks, increasing artistry, and cultivating rice: The environmental and social context of the emergence of farming in the lower Yangtze Region. Environmental Archaeology15(2): 139–159.
8.
HeD (2004) Discussion on Neolithic Age Agriculture in Shandong. Agricultural Archaeology24(03): 58–69.
9.
HeKLuHZhangJ, et al. (2022) Holocene spatiotemporal millet agricultural patterns in northern China: A dataset of archaeobotanical macroremains. Earth System Science Data Discussions14(10): 4777–4791.
10.
HouLLiJDengH, et al. (2021) Stable isotope analysis of animal bones at Nanzhuangtou Site, Xushui, Hebei. Archaeology5(2): 107–114.
11.
HuangY (2012) Identification report of animal bones unearthed at Niuheliang Site, Report on Excavation of Niuheliang – Hongshan Cultural Site (1983-2003), Vol., Cultural Relics Publishing House, pp.507–510.
12.
Inner Mongolia Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology (2004) Edited: Baiyin Changhan—Report on Excavation of Neolithic Sites. Beijing: Science Press.
13.
Inner Mongolia Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology, Jilin University Frontier Archaeology Research Center (2012) Shangjifang Yingzi and Xiliang in Chifeng. Beijing: Science Press, pp.249–250 (in Chinese).
14.
Institute of Archaeology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (1997) Aohan Zhaobaogou - Neolithic Settlement. Beijing, China: Encyclopedia of China Publishing House.
15.
JiaXLeeHFZhangW, et al. (2016b) Human-environment interactions within the West Liao River basin in northeastern China during the holocene Optimum. Quaternary International: The Journal of the International Union for Quaternary Research426: 10–17.
16.
JiaXLiHLeeHF, et al. (2021b) Agricultural adaptations to topography and climate changes in central China during the mid- to late-Holocene. The Holocene31(11–12): 1705–1715.
17.
JiaXSunYWangL, et al. (2016a) The transition of human subsistence strategies in relation to climate change during the Bronze Age in the West Liao River Basin, Northeast China. The Holocene26(5): 781–789.
18.
JiaXSunYYangJ, et al. (2017a) Flotation results and analysis of Xiajiadian Culture period in the upper reaches of Western Liaohe River. Agricultural Archaeology37(06): 33–39 (in Chinese).
19.
JiaXWangSSunY, et al. (2021a) Charcoal evidence for environmental change ca. 3.5 ka and its influence on ancient people in the West Liao River Basin of northeastern China. The Quaternary Research (Daiyonki-Kenkyu)102: 1–11.
20.
JiaXYiSSunY, et al. (2017b) Spatial and temporal variations in prehistoric human settlement and their influencing factors on the south bank of the Xar Moron River, northeastern China. Earth Science Frontiers11(1): 137–147.
21.
JiaXZhangZSunY, et al. (2024) Amelioration of habitat since the early holocene contributed to the origin of agriculture in the farming-pastoral zone of northern China. Science China Earth Sciences67(8): 2535–2546.
22.
JonesMKLiuX (2009) Archaeology. Origins of Agriculture in East Asia. Science324(5928): 730–731.
23.
LinZ (1986) Historical research on deer and deer farming. Agricultural History of China6(04): 68–75.
24.
LiuD (1987) Deer resources and their utilization in ancient China. Agricultural History of China7(04): 78–90.
25.
LiuG (2006) Introduction to archaeological culture from Neolithic Age to Early Bronze Age in Western Liaohe River Basin. Journal of Liaoning Normal University: Social Science Edition29(1): 113–122.
26.
LiuG (2010) The patterns and characteristics of Hongshan Culture and Western Liaohe River Civilization origin. Steppe Cultural Relics30(1): 43–51.
27.
LiuGXJiaXBZhaoMH, et al. (2004) Excavations at the Xinglonggou Settlement Site in Chifeng City, Inner Mongolia, 2002–2003. Archaeology50(07): 3–8.
28.
LiuJSunYZhangH (2022a) A study on the plant remains unearthed from the Upper Xiajiadian cultural site in Xiatianjiayingzi, Inner Mongolia. Journal of Chifeng University (Chinese Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition)43(03): 90–93 (in Chinese).
29.
LiuJDongX (1996) A brief discussion on the agricultural economy of Zhaobaogou Culture. Archaeology42(2): 61–65.
30.
LiuLZhangYLiuY, et al. (2022b) Study on the relationship between geographical environment and human activity sites in eastern Inner Mongolia in recent 10,000 years. Quaternary Sciences42(1): 236–249.
31.
LiuSJiaXSunY, et al. (2022c) Investigating the plant microremains on ceramic Li Tripods to ascertain their function and the plant resource exploitation strategies during the Lower Xiajiadian culture period in Chifeng, Northeast China. Frontiers of Earth Science10: 836403.
32.
LiuXJonesMKZhaoZ, et al. (2012) The earliest evidence of millet as a staple crop: New light on neolithic foodways in North China. American Journal of Physical Anthropology149(2): 283–290.
33.
LuHZhangHZengL, et al. (2015) Loess records of pleistocene vegetation in northeast China affected by temperature. Quaternary Sciences35(4): 828–836.
34.
LuoYB (2009) Raising and ritual use of pigs at the Dadianzi site. Frontier Archaeological Research8: 288–300.
35.
LyuALuHZengL, et al. (2018) Vegetation variation of loess deposits in the southeastern Inner Mongolia, NE China over the past ∼1.08 million years. Journal of Asian Earth Sciences155: 174–179.
36.
MaZYangXZhangC, et al. (2016) Utilization of millet plants in the early and Middle Holocene in Western Liaohe River. Science China Earth Sciences46(07): 918–925.
37.
MoreyDFJegerR (2017) From wolf to dog: Late Pleistocene ecological dynamics, altered trophic strategies, and shifting human perceptions. Historical Biology29(7): 895–903.
38.
NingCLiTWangK, et al. (2020) Ancient genomes from northern China suggest links between subsistence changes and human migration. Nature Communications11(1): 2700.
39.
PartapTKapoorP (1987) The Himalayan grain chenopods. III. An under-exploited food plant with promising potential. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment19(1): 71–79.
40.
PengMSHanJLZhangYP (2022) Missing puzzle piece for the origins of domestic chickens. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences119(44): e2210996119.
41.
PetersJLebrasseurOIrving-PeaseEK, et al. (2022) The biocultural origins and dispersal of domestic chickens. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences119(24): e2121978119.
42.
QinL (2012) Plant archaeology study and its prospects on the origin of agriculture in China. Archaeological Research21: 260–315.
43.
QiuSLiQXiaY (1992) Paleosols of sandy lands and environmental changes in the western plain of northeast China during Holocene. Quaternary Sciences35(3): 224–232.
44.
RobbeetsMBouckaertRConteM, et al. (2021) Triangulation supports agricultural spread of the transeurasian languages. Nature599(7886): 616–621.
45.
Shelach-LaviGTengMGoldsmithY, et al. (2019) Sedentism and plant cultivation in northeast China emerged during affluent conditions. PLoS One14(7): e0218751.
46.
ShiHJiaXWangC (2022) Zooarchaeology research at the Shuiquan Site in Jianping County, Liaoning Province: Discussion of the utilization strategies of animal remains along the Great Wall in North China around 4000 a B.P. Quaternary Sciences42(01): 32–46.
47.
ShiYKongZWangS, et al. (1992) Basic Features of Climates and Environments During Holocene Megathermalin China. The Climates and Environments of Holocene Megathermal in China. Beijing: China Ocean Press, pp.1–18.
48.
SongYSunBGaoY, et al. (2019) The environment and subsistence in the lower reaches of the Yellow River around 10,000 BP ——faunal evidence from the bianbiandong cave site in Shandong Province, China. Quaternary International: The Journal of the International Union for Quaternary Research521: 35–43.
49.
SongYXinY (2012) Analysis of Animal Remains at Chahai Site. Report on Excavation of Neolithic Settlement Site, Vol. Cultural Relics Publishing House, pp.525–630.
50.
StevensCJFullerDQ (2017) The spread of agriculture in Eastern Asia: Archaeological bases for hypothetical farmer/language dispersals. Language Dynamics and Change7(2): 152–186.
51.
StevensCJShelach-LaviGZhangH, et al. (2021) A model for the domestication of panicum miliaceum (common, proso or broomcorn millet) in China. Vegetation History and Archaeobotany30(1): 21–33.
52.
SunY (2007) The relationship between the diversity of Horqin sandy land change and economic environment of the Hongshan culture period. Journal of Chifeng College (Social Science)28(1): 8–9.
53.
SunY (2014) Study on Plant Remains From Neolithic Age to Early Bronze Age in Upper Reaches of Western Liaohe River. Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, China: Inner Mongolia Normal University (in Chinese).
54.
SunYLiY (2019) Study on Bronze Age subsistence pattern and related problems in Southeast Inner Mongolia. Journal of Liaoning Normal University (Social Sciences Edition)46(01): 107–115 (in Chinese).
55.
SunYLiYZhangX, et al. (2023) Study on carbonized plant remains unearthed at Shuiquan Site, Jianping in 2021. Agricultural Archaeology43(01): 18–24 (in Chinese).
56.
SunYZhaoZ (2013) A comprehensive study of plant remains unearthed from Hongshan cultural site of Weijiawopu. Agricultural Archaeology33(03): 1–5.
57.
SunYZhaoZCaoJ, et al. (2014) Analysis report of flotation results of Erdaojingzi Site in Inner Mongolia in 2009. Agricultural Archaeology34(06): 1–9 (in Chinese).
58.
SuoX (2005) Holocene human and geographical relationship in West Liaohe River Basin. Frontier Archaeological Research4: 247–260.
59.
SuoXLiS (2013) Animal remains of Neolithic Age in western Liaoning. Steppe Cultural Relics33(1): 43–49.
60.
TangHLiuS (2001) C4 plant list in Inner Mongolia. Journal of Inner Mongolia University: Natural Science Edition32(4): 431–438.
61.
TangZ (2005) A Quantitative Study on the Development Stage of Man-Land Relationship From Paleolithic to Bronze Age in Southwest China. Jilin province, China: Jilin University (in Chinese).
62.
TaoDWuYGuoZ, et al. (2011) Starch grain analysis for groundstone tools from Neolithic Baiyinchanghan site: Implications for their function in Northeast China. Journal of Archaeological Science38(12): 3577–3583.
63.
WangJZhouXXuH, et al. (2021) Relationship between C4 biomass and C4 agriculture during the holocene and its implications for millet domestication in northeast China. Geophysical Research Letters48(1): e2020GL089566.
64.
WangL (2007) The economic form and environmental background of Lower Xiajiadian culture reflected in the excavation data of Dashanqian Site. Frontier Archaeological Research6: 350–357.
65.
WangLWuHJiaX (2016) Study on the correlation between the temporal and spatial evolution of prehistoric settlements and their subsistence patterns and climatic history in West Liaohe Region. Advances in Earth Science31(11): 1159.
66.
WangWZhaoH (2022) The project of exploring the source of Chinese civilization and its main Achievements. Research in Chinese History44(04): 5–32.
67.
WangXQianHCaiM (2011) Study on the Change of Production Tools and Economic Forms in the Yellow River Basin From 3500-1500 BC, vol. 3. Beijing: Science and Technology Archaeology, Science Press (in Chinese).
68.
WangYChenJBaoS, et al. (2017) Study on animal remains unearthed at Nailingao Site, Inner Mongolia in 2015. Steppe Cultural Relics37(1): 115–124.
69.
WangYSunYRoyleTCA, et al. (2022) Ancient DNA investigation of the domestication history of pigs in Northeast China. Journal of Archaeological Science141: 105590.
70.
WangYWuW (2012) Study on carbonized plant remains at Chahai Site in Fuxin, Liaoning Province. Northern Cultural Relics32(04): 17 (in Chinese).
71.
XiangHGaoJCaiD, et al. (2017) Origin and dispersal of early domestic pigs in northern China. Scientific Reports7(1): 5602.
72.
XiaoJWuJSiB, et al. (2006) Holocene climate changes in the monsoon/arid transition reflected by carbon concentration in Daihai Lake of inner mongolia. The Holocene16(4): 551–560.
73.
XiaZDengHWuH (2000) Geomorphologic background of the prehistoric cultural evolution in the Xar Moron Basin, Inner Mongolia. Acta Geographica Sinica67(03): 329–336 (in Chinese).
74.
XuG (1984) The New Discovery of Fuhe Culture. Archaeological Discovery and Research in New China. Beijing, China: Cultural Relics Publishing House, pp.176–180 (in Chinese).
75.
YangHLinX (2009) Brief Introduction of XiaoHexi Site in Aohan Banner, Inner Mongolia. Northern Cultural Relics, No. 2, pp.3–4 (in Chinese).
76.
YanW (1987) The unity and diversity of prehistoric culture in China. Cultural Relics38(03): 38–50.
77.
YuanJ (2006) The origin of domestic pigs in ancient China. Western Archaeology1: 43–49.
78.
YuanJ (2010) Zooarchaeology of ancient domestic animals in China. Quaternary Sciences53(2): 298–306.
79.
YuanYSunY (2019) A review of prehistoric archaeobotany in western Liaoning. Journal of Chifeng University (Chinese Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition)40(07): 6–10.
80.
ZhangSTianHSunY (2016) Analysis of flotation results at Aohan Reshuitang Site in Inner Mongolia. Agricultural Archaeology36(06): 22–27 (in Chinese).
81.
ZhangXLiuGWangM, et al. (2017) Stable isotope analysis of carbon and nitrogen from human bones unearthed at Xinglonggou Site. Cultural Relics of Southern China29(04): 185–195 (in Chinese).
82.
ZhangXQiuSZhongJ, et al. (2010) Analysis of human food status at several archaeological sites of Yangshao Culture in Central China. Acta Anthropologica Sinica29(02): 197–207.
83.
ZhangYSunY (2022) A study on Zhao Baogou culture’s subsistence pattern. Journal of Chifeng University (Chinese Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition) (in Chinese) 43(3): 84–89.
84.
ZhangZ (2019) A preliminary study on animal resource dependence of Neolithic-Bronze Age in Western Liaoning. Frontier Archaeological Research18(02): 297–302 (in Chinese).
85.
ZhaoKLiXShangX, et al. (2009) Characteristics of agricultural activities in western Liaoning during the Middle and Late Bronze Age. Acta Botanica Sinica44(06): 718.
86.
ZhaoKLiXZhouX, et al. (2011) Characteristics and environmental effects of agricultural activities in Xiajiadian Lower Culture stage at Chengzishan Site, western Liaoning. Quaternary Sciences31(1): 8–15.
87.
ZhaoZ (2004) On the origin of dry farming in North China from the flotation results of Xinglonggou Site. East Asian Antiquities (Volume A), Cultural Relics Publishing House.
88.
ZhaoZ (2011) Characteristics of agricultural economy development in the formation period of Chinese Civilization. Journal of National Museum of China33(01): 19–31.
89.
ZhaoZ (2014) Formation process of ancient Chinese agriculture: Evidence of plant remains unearthed by flotation. Quaternary Research34(1): 73–84 (in Chinese).
90.
ZhaoZ (2020) Plant archaeology and the origin of agriculture in the Neolithic Age. Agricultural History of China39(3): 3–13 (in Chinese).
91.
ZhuKZhangZTaoL, et al. (2024) The genetic diversity in the ancient human population of Upper Xiajiadian culture. Journal of Systematics and Evolution62(4): 785–793.
92.
ZhuY (1987) A preliminary study on the Upper Xijiadian culture. Collections of Archaeological Culture (I). Beijing: Cultural Relics Press, pp.99–128.
93.
ZhuYGuoZWangL (1998) A brief report on excavations in 1996 at Dashan Site, Harqin Banner, Inner Mongolia. Archaeology44(9):43–49.
94.
Zooarchaeology Research Group (2011) Zooarchaeology in the Formation Period of Chinese Civilization, Science and Technology Archaeology Center, Institute of Archaeology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, eds. Science and Technology Archaeology (Series 3), Science Press, China, pp.80–99.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
