Adaptive designs for binary treatment responses in phase III clinical trials: controversies and progress

Abstract

In phase III clinical trials the problem is to compare two treatments or therapies for their effects. The randomized 50: 50 allocation to the two competing treatments is popular in most of the cases. In contrast there is a class of adaptive designs available in literature for this purpose. The object is to treat a larger number of patients by the eventual better treatment. A few such adaptive designs were conducted out in practical applications and consequently a lot of controversy arose. In spite of that there is steady theoretical progress in this area over the past three decades. The present paper reviews some of the real-life adaptive clinical trials and discusses some logistics of such trials.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Efron B. Forcing a sequential experiment to be balanced . Biometrika 1971; 58: 403-417 .

Vann Hoff DD , Kuhn J , Clark GM. Designs and conduct of phase I trials. In: Buyse ME , Staquet MJ , Sylvester RJ eds. Cancer clinical trial. New York: Oxford University Press , 1984: 210-220.

O’Quigley J , Pepe M , Fisher L. Continual reassessment method: a practical design for phase I clinical trials in cancer . Biometrics 1990; 46: 33-48 .

Iglewicz B. Alternative designs: sequential, multi-stage, decision theory and adaptive designs. In: Buyse ME , Staquet J , Sylvester RJ eds. Cancer clinical trials: methods and practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1983: 312-334.

Bartlett RH , Roloff DW , Cornell RG , Andrews AF , Dillon PW , Zwischenberger JB. Extracorporeal circulation in neonatal respiratory failure: a prospective randomized trial . Pediatrics 1985; 76: 479-487 .

Tamura RN , Faries DE , Andersen JS , Heiligenstein JH. A case study of an adaptive clinical trials in the treatment of out-patients with depressive disorder . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1994; 89: 768-776 .

Ware JH. Investigating therapies of potentially great benefit: ECMO . Statistical Science 1989; 4: 298-340 .

Rout CC , Rocke DA , Levin J , Gouws E , Reddy D. A reevaluation of the role of crystalloid preload in the prevention of hypotension associated with spinal anesthesia for elective cesarean section . Anesthesiology 1993; 79: 262-269 .

Robbins H. Some aspects of the sequential design of experiments . Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society 1952; 58: 527-535 .

10.

Anscombe F. Sequential medical trials . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1963; 58: 365-384 .

11.

Colton T. A model for selecting one of two medical treatments . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1963; 58: 388-401 .

12.

Zelen M. Play-the-winner rule and the controlled clinical trial . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1969; 64: 131-146 .

13.

Sobel M , Weiss GH. Play-the-winner and inverse sampling in selecting the better of two binomial populations . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1971; 66: 545-551 .

14.

Sobel M , Weiss GH. A comparison of play-the-winner and vector-at-a-time sampling for selecting the better of two binomial populations with restricted parameter values . Trabajos de Estadistica Y de Investigation Operativa 1971; 22: 195-206 .

15.

Sobel M , Weiss GH. Recent results on using play the winner sampling rule with binomial selection problems . In: Proceedings of the Sixth Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics and Probability. Vol. I, 1972: 717-736 .

16.

Zelen M , Wei LJ. Foreward. In: Flournoy N , Rosenberger WF eds. Adaptive designs. Hayward, CA: IMS , 1996.

17.

Connor EM , Sperling RS , Gelber R et al. Reduction of maternal-infant transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 with zidovudine treatment . New England Journal of Medicine 1994; 331: 1173-1180 . (Report written for the Pediatric AIDS Clinical Trial Group Protocol 076 Study Group.)

18.

Yao Q , Wei LJ. Play the winner for phase II/III clinical trials . Statistics in Medicine 1996; 15: 2413-2423 .

19.

Wei LJ , Durham S. The randomized play-the-winner rule in medical trials . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1978; 73: 838-843 .

20.

Wei LJ. The generalized Polya’s urn for sequential medical trials . Annals of Statistics 1979; 7: 291-296 .

21.

Wei LJ. Exact two-sample permutation tests based on the randomized play-the-winner rule . Biometrika 1988; 75: 603-606 .

22.

Wei LJ , Smythe RT , Lin DY , Park TS. Statistical inference with data-dependent treatment allocation rules . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1990; 85: 156-162 .

23.

Bandyopadhyay U , Biswas A. Sequential comparison of two treatments in clinical trials: a decision theoretic approach based on randomized play-the-winner rule . Sequential Analysis 1997; 16: 65-91 .

24.

Bandyopadhyay U , Biswas A. Some sequential tests in clinical trials based on randomized play-the-winner rule . Calcutta Statistical Association Bulletin 1997; 47: 67-89 .

25.

Bandyopadhyay U , Biswas A. Sequential-type procedures to select the best treatments . Statistics and Decisions 1999 (Suppl. 4): 139-164 (in Honor of Robert E Bechhofer).

26.

Rosenberger WF. Asymptotic inference with response-adaptive treatment allocation designs . Annals of Statistics 1993; 21: 2098-2107 .

27.

Rosenberger WF. New directions in adaptive designs . Statistical Science 1996; 11: 137-149 .

28.

Rosenberger WF , Lachin JM. The use of response-adaptive designs in clinical trials . Controlled Clinical Trials 1993; 14: 471-484 .

29.

Matthews PC , Rosenberger WF. Variance in randomized play-the-winner clinical trials . Statistics and Probability Letters 1997; 35: 233-240 .

30.

Rosenberger WF , Sriram TN. Estimation for an adaptive allocation design . Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference 1997; 59: 309-319 .

31.

Cornell RG , Landenberger BD , Bartlett RH. Tandomized play-the-winner clinical trials . Communications in Statistics, Series A 1986; 15: 159-178 .

32.

Ware JH , Epstein MF. Extracorporeal circulation in neonatal respiratory failure: a prospective randomized study . Pediatrics 1985; 76: 849-851 .

33.

Begg CB. On inference from Wei’s biased coin design for clinical trials (with discussion) . Biometrika 1990; 77: 467-484 .

34.

Royall RM. Ethics and statistics in randomized clinical trials (with discussion) . Statistical Science 1991; 6: 52-62 .

35.

Rosenberger WF. Practical implementation of randomized play-the-winner clinical trials . Controlled Clinical Trials 1999.

36.

Reiger DA , Myers JK , Kramer M , Robins LN , Blazer DG , Hough RL , Eaton WW , Locke BZ. The NIMH epidemiologic catchment area program . Archives of General Psychiatry 1984; 41: 934-991 .

37.

Bandyopadhyay U , Biswas A. Delayed response in randomized play-the-winner rule: a decision theoretic outlook . Calcutta Statistical Association Bulletin 1996; 46; 69-88 .

38.

Andersen J , Faries D , Tamura R. A randomized play-the-winner design for multi-arm clinical trials . Communications in Statistics, Theory and Methods 1994; 23: 309-323 .

39.

Biswas A. Delayed response in randomized play-the-winner rule revisited . Communications in Statistics, Simulation and Computation 1999; 28: 715-731 .

40.

Begg CB , Iglewicz B. A treatment allocation procedure for sequential clinical trials . Biometrics 1980; 36: 81-90 .

41.

Atkinson AC. Optimal biased coin designs for sequential clinical trials with prognostic factors . Biometrika 1982; 69: 61-67 .

42.

Atkinson AC. Optimum biased-coin designs for sequential treatment allocation with covariate information . Statistics in Medicine 1999; 18: 1741-1752 .

43.

Atkinson AC. Bayesian and other biased-coin designs for sequential clinical trials . Tatra Mountains Mathematical Publications 1999; 17: 133-139 .

44.

Atkinson AC. The comparison of designs for sequential clinical trials with covariate information (preprint).

45.

Bandyopadhyay U , Biswas A. Allocation by randomized play-the-winner rule in the presence of prognostic factors . Sankhya Series B 1999; 61: 397-412 .

46.

Durham SD , Flournoy N , Li W. A sequential design for maximizing the probability of a favourable response . Canadian Journal of Statistics 1998; 26: 479-495 .

47.

Bandyopadhyay U , Biswas A. A class of adaptive designs . Sequential Analysis 2000; 19: 45-62 .

48.

Faries DE , Tamura RN , Andersen JS. Adaptive designs in clinical trials: Lilly experience (with discussions) . Biopharmaceutical Report 1995; 3: 1-11 .