Environmentalists consider invasions by exotic species of plants and animals to be one of the most serious environmental problems we face today, as well as one of the leading causes of biodiversity loss. We argue that in order to develop and enact sensible policies, it is crucial to consider two philosophical questions: (1) What exactly makes a species native or exotic, and (2) What values are at stake? We focus on the first of these two questions, and offer some preliminary suggestions with regard to the second. Through a series of case studies, we show that it is not always clear whether a species is native or exotic. We identify five possible criteria that could be used for distinguishing natives from exotics. Rather than identifying one of these criteria as the ‘correct’ one, we suggest that the concepts of ‘native’ and ‘exotic’ function more like what some philosophers have called cluster concepts. That is, there are several characteristics that are typical of native species, and a corresponding set of characteristics that are typical of exotic species. None of these characteristics is either necessary or sufficient for identifying a species as either native or exotic. We then identify several of the values that are at stake in dealing with exotic species, and we suggest that policies need to avoid being overly simplistic.
BarelaTsgt. TimothyP.1993. ‘Massacre on Guam’, Airman37: 28–31.
2.
BotkinDaniel B.1990. Discordant Harmonies: A New Ecology for the Twenty-first Century.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3.
BrightChris1998. Life Out of Bounds: Bioinvasion in a Borderless World.New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
4.
CahenHarley1988. ‘Against the Moral Considerability of Ecosystems’, Environmental Ethics10: 195–216.
5.
CallicottJ. Baird1991. ‘The Wilderness Idea Revisited: The Sustainable Development Alternative’, The Environmental Professional13: 235–247.
6.
CallicottJ. Baird1996. ‘Do Deconstructive Ecology and Sociobiology Undermine Leopold's Land Ethic?’, Environmental Ethics18: 353–372.
7.
CarrArchie1994. A Naturalist in Florida: A Celebration of Eden, CarrMarjorie Harris (ed). New Haven: Yale University Press.
8.
CarrollScott P., and HughDingle1996. ‘The Biology of Post-Invasion Events’, Biological Conservation78: 207–214.
9.
CliftonMerritt1991. ‘Feral Animals: Alien Menace?’, The Animals AgendaXI: 16–22.
10.
CostanzaRobert, NortonBryan G., and HaskellBenjamin D. (eds) 1992. Ecosystem Health: New Goals for Environmental Management.Washington, D.C.: Island Press.
11.
DevineRobert1998. Alien Invasion: America's Battle with Non-Native Animals and Plants.Washington, D.C.: National Geographic Society.
12.
DiamondJared1987. ‘Reflections on goals and the relationship between theory and practice’, in JordanWilliam R.III, GilpinMichael E., and AberJohn D. (eds) Restoration Ecology: A synthetic approach to ecological research.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
13.
DiamondJared1989. ‘Overview of Recent Extinctions’, in WesternDavid and PearlMary C. (eds) Conservation for the Twenty-first Century.New York: Oxford University Press.
14.
DrakeJames E.. (eds) 1989. Biological Invasions: A Global Perspective.New York: John Wiley.
15.
DyerDeborah R.1996. ‘The Role of Exotic Species Within Ecosystem Management’, Environs19: 75–86.
16.
ElliotRobert1997. Faking Nature: the ethics of environmental restoration.London: Routledge.
17.
EvansPaul1998. ‘Response to Peretti, “Nativism and Nature”’, Environmental Values7: 198–200.
18.
EverndenNeil1993. The Natural Alien: Humankind and Environment, 2nd ed. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
19.
GarrettB.J.1988. ‘Vagueness and Identity’, Analysis48: 130–4.
20.
GarrottRobert A., WhiteP.J., and Vanderbilt WhiteCallie A.1993. ‘Overabundance: An Issue for Conservation Biologists?’, Conservation Biology7: 946–9.
21.
GertHeather1995. ‘Alternative Analysis’, The Southern Journal of Philosophy33: 31–7.
22.
GraberDavid M.1995. ‘Resolute Biocentrism: The Dilemma of Wilderness in National Parks’, in SouléMichael E. and LeaseGary (eds) Reinventing Nature? Responses to Postmodern Deconstruction.Washington, D.C.: Island Press.
23.
GrahamRussell W.1988. ‘The Role of Climatic Change in the Design of Biological Reserves: The Paleoecological Perspective for Conservation Biology’, Conservation Biology2: 391–4.
24.
GrovesRob H., and BurdonJeremy James1986. The Ecology of Biological Invasions.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
25.
HagenJoel B.1992. An Entangled Bank: The Origins of Ecosystem Ecology.New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
26.
HengeveldR.1989. Dynamics of Biological Invasions.New York: Chapman and Hall.
27.
HettingerNed2001. ‘Exotic Species, Naturalisation, and Biological Nativism’, Environmental Values10: 193–224.
28.
HollandAlan1995. ‘The Use and Abuse of Ecological Concepts in Environmental Ethics’, Biodiversity and Conservation4: 812–826.
29.
HunterMalcolm L.Jr.1996. Fundamentals of Conservation Biology.Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
30.
HunterMalcom L.Jr.; JacobsonGeorge L.Jr.; and WebbThompsonIII1988. ‘Paleoecology and the Course-Filter Approach to Maintaining Biological Diversity’, Conservation Biology2: 375–385.
31.
JacksonWes. 1996. Becoming Native to This Place.Washington, D.C.: Counterpoint.
32.
JamiesonDale1995. ‘Ecosystem Health: Some Preventive Medicine’, Environmental Values4: 333–344.
33.
KingslandSharon E.1995. Modeling Nature: Episodes in the History of Population Ecology, 2nd ed. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
34.
LackDavid1983. Darwin's Finches.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
LeopoldAldo1949. A Sand County Almanac: And Sketches Here and There.London: Oxford University Press.
36.
McIntoshRobert P.1985. The Background of Ecology: Concept and Theory.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
37.
MillsEdward L., LeachJoseph H., CarltonJames T., and SecorCarol L.1994. ‘Exotic Species and the Integrity of the Great Lakes: Lessons from the past’, BioScience44: 666–676.
38.
MollerHenrik1996. ‘Lessons for Invasion Biology from Social Insects’, Biological Conservation78: 125–142.
39.
MoriartyPaul Veatch, and WoodsMark1997. ‘Hunting ≠ Predation’, Environmental Ethics19: 391–404.
40.
MoylePeter B., and LightTheo1996. ‘Biological Invasions of Fresh Water: Empirical Rules and Assembly Theory’, Biological Conservation78: 149–161.
41.
NabhanGary Paul1995. ‘Cultural Parallax in Viewing North American Habitats’, in SouléMichael E. and LeaseGary (eds) Reinventing Nature? Responses to Postmodern Deconstruction. Washington, D.C.: Island Press.
42.
National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior1988. Management Policies.
43.
NossReed F., and CooperriderAllen Y.1994. Saving Nature's Legacy: Protecting and Restoring Biodiversity.Washington, D.C.: Island Press.
PickettS.T.A., and WhiteP.S. (eds) 1985. The Ecology of Natural Disturbance and Patch Dynamics.San Diego: Academic Press.
46.
PickettS.T.A., ParkerV. Thomas, and FiedlerPeggy L.1992. ‘The New Paradigm in Ecology: Implications for Conservation Above the Species Level’, in FiedlerPeggy L. and JainSubodh K. (eds) Conservation Biology: The Theory and Practice of Nature Conservation Preservation and Management.New York: Chapman and Hall.
47.
PimentelD., LackL., ZunigaR., and MorrisonD.1999. Environmental and Economic Costs Associated with Non-indigenous Species in the United States. Presentation at the American Association for the Advancement of Science, Anaheim, CA.
48.
PollanMichael1994. ‘Against Nativism’, New York Times Magazine May 15: 52–5.
PutmanHillary1975. ‘The Analytic and the Synthetic’, Mind and Language: Philosophical Papers, Volume 2. New York: Cambridge University Press.
51.
ReganTom1983. The Case for Animal Rights.Berkeley: University of California Press.
52.
RodmanJohn1993. ‘Restoring Nature: Natives and Exotics’, in BennettJane and ChaloupkaWilliam (eds) In the Nature of Things: Language, Politics, and the Environment.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
53.
RolstonHolmesIII1994. Conserving Natural Value.New York: Columbia University Press.
54.
RoyteElizabeth1995. ‘On the Brink: Hawaii's Vanishing Species’, National Geographic188 September: 2–37.
55.
SchererDonald1994. ‘Between Theory and Practice: Some Thoughts on Motivations Behind Restoration’, Restoration and Management Notes11: 31–4.
56.
SchmitzDon1997. ‘Call for Exotic Species Task Force’, Science275: 915.
57.
SearleJohn1958. ‘Proper Names’, Mind67: 166–173.
58.
Seligsohn-BennettKyla1990. ‘Mismanaging Endangered and ‘Exotic’ Species in the National Parks’, Environmental Law20: 415–440.
59.
Shrader-FrechetteKristin S., and McCoyEarl D.1993. Method in Ecology: Strategies for Conservation.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
60.
SingerPeter1990. Animal Liberation, 2nd ed. New York: Avon Books.
61.
SnyderGary. 1990. The Practice of the Wild.New York: North Point Press.
62.
SouléMichael E.1990. ‘The Onslaught of Alien Species, and Other Challenges in the Coming Decades’, Conservation Biology4: 233–9.
63.
SpurrStephen H.1980. ‘Wilderness Concepts’, Idaho Law Review16: 439–448.
ThroopWilliam2000. ‘Eradicating the Aliens: Restoration and Exotic Species’, in ThroopWilliam (ed) Environmental Restoration: Ethics, Theory, and Practice.Amherst, NY: Humanity Books.
66.
TownsendColin R.1991. ‘Exotic Species Management and the Need for a Theory of Invasion Biology’, New Zealand Journal of Ecology15: 1–3.
67.
VermeijGeerat J.1996. ‘An Agenda for Invasion Biology’, Biological Conservation78: 3–9.
68.
WadeSteven A.1995. ‘Stemming the Tide: A Plea for New Exotic Species Legislation’, Journal of Land Use & Environmental Law10: 343–370.
69.
WestmanWalter E.1990. ‘Park Management of Exotic Plant Species: Problems and Issues’, Conservation Biology4: 251–260.
70.
WilsonEdward O.1992. The Diversity of Life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
