While acknowledging the absence of a single definition or theory of sustainability, this paper argues that a discussion of sustainability which refers only to definitions is pointless without an understanding of how the definitions are operationalised. In this context, the paper considers the operationalisation of strong sustainability.
The definitions and operationalisation of strong sustainability most closely associated with (i) neoclassical environmental economics and (ii) ecological economics are discussed and compared. This analysis raises questions about the extent to which ecological economics has been able to influence real-world decisions and policy. The paper ends by considering whether the economic and political power structure taken as given by ecological economics is compatible with its policy perspective.
ArrowK., SolowR., PortneyP.R., LeamerE.E., RadnerR. and Schuman. (1993). ‘Report of the NOAA Panel on Contingent Valuation’.Report to the General Counsel of the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Resources for the Future, Washington, D.C.
2.
BarbierE.B., MarkandyaA., and PearceD. (1990). ‘Environmental Sustainability and Cost-Benefit Analysis’, Environment and Planning A, 22: 1259–66.
3.
BoyceJ. (1994). ‘Inequality as a Cause of Environmental Degradation’, Ecological Economics, 11: 169–78.
4.
CastellsN. and MundaG. (1999). ‘International Environmental Issues: Towards a New Integrated Assessment Approach’ in O'ConnorM. and SpashC. (eds)(1999), pp. 309–27.
5.
ClarkJ. (1995). ‘Economic Development vs. Sustainable Societies: Reflections on the Players in a Crucial Contest’, Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 26: 225–48.
6.
CommonM.S., BlameyR.K. and NortonT.W. (1993). ‘Sustainability and Environmental Valuation, Environmental Values, 2(4): 299–334.
7.
CostanzaR. (ed.) (1991). Ecological Economics: The Science and Management of Sustainability. New York:Columbia University Press.
8.
CostanzaR., CumberlandJ., DalyH.E., GoodlandR. and NorgaardR. (eds) (1997). An Introduction to Ecological Economics.ISEE, Florida:St. Lucie Press.
9.
CostanzaR., SeguraO. and Martinez-AlierJ. (eds) (1996). Getting Down to Earth: Practical Applications of Ecological Economics.Washington, D.C.: Island Press.
10.
CostanzaR., SeguraO. and Martinez-AlierJ. (1996). ‘Integrated Envisioning, Analysis and Implementation of a Sustainable and Desirable Society’, in CostanzaR.. (eds.) (1996), pp. 1–16.
11.
CraigP.P. and GlasserH. and KemptonW. (1993). ‘Ethics and Values in Environmental Policy: The Said and The UNCED’, Environmental Values, 2: 137–57.
12.
DevineP. (1988). Democracy and Economic Planning: The Political Economy of a Self-governing Society, Cambridge:Polity Press.
13.
DevineP. (1992). ‘Market Socialism or Participatory Planning?’, Review of Radical Political Economics, 24: 67–90.
14.
DiamondPA. and HausmannJ.A. (1994). ‘Contingent Valuation: Is Some Number Better than No Number?’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8(4): 45–64.
15.
DryzekJ.S. (1994). ‘Ecology and Discursive Democracy: Beyond Liberal Capitalism and the Administrative State’, in O'ConnorM. (ed.) (1994), pp. 177–97.
FaberM., ManstettenR., ProopsJ. and BaumgärtnerS. (1996). ‘Entropy: A Unifying Concept for Ecological Economics’, in FaberM., ManstettenR. and ProopsJ. (eds), Ecological Economics: Concepts and Methods. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, pp. 95–115.
18.
FaucheuxS. and O'ConnorM. (eds) (1998). Valuation for Sustainable Development: Methods and Policy Indicators. Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
19.
FaucheuxS. and O'ConnorM. (1999). ‘Natural Capital and the National Product: A Controversial Terrain’, International Journal of Development Planning Literature, 14(2): 233–68.
20.
FosterJ. (1994). The Vulnerable Planet.New York:Monthly Review Press.
21.
FosterJ. (ed.) (1997). Valuing Nature? Economics, Ethics and Environment. London and New York:Routledge.
22.
FrogerG. and MundaG. (1998). ‘Methodology for Environmental Decision Support’, in FaucheuxS. and O'ConnorM. (eds), Valuation for Sustainable Development: Methods and Policy Indicators.Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, pp. 167–86.
23.
FuntowiczS. and RavetzJ.R. (1990). Uncertainty and Quality in Science for Policy.Dordrecht: Kluwer.
24.
FuntowiczS. and RavetzJ.R. (1994). ‘The Worth of a Songbird: Ecological Economics as a Post-Normal Science’, Ecological Economics, 10: 197–207
25.
Georgescu-ReogenN. (1971). The Entropy Law and The Economic Process. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.
26.
GowdyJ. (1997). ‘The Value of Biodiversity: Markets, Society, and Ecosystems’, Land Economics, 73(1): 25–41.
27.
GowdyJ. (1999). ‘Hierarchies in Human Affairs: Microfoundations and Environmental Sustainability’ in Köhn. (eds) (1999), pp. 67–84.
28.
HanemannM.W. (1994). ‘Valuing the Environment through Contingent Valuation’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8(4): 19–43.
29.
HanleyN. and SpashC. (1993). Cost-Benefit Analysis and The Environment.USA: Edward Elgar.
30.
HodgsonG. (1997). ‘Economics, Environmental Policy and Transcendence of Utilitarianism’, in FosterJ. (ed.) (1997), pp. 47–63.
31.
HowarthR.B. and NorgaardR.B. (1990). ‘Intergenerational Resource Rights, Efficiency, and Social Optimality, Land Economics, 66: 1–11.
32.
JacobsM. (1991). The Green Economy: Environment, Sustainable Development and the Politics of the Future.London:Pluto Press.
33.
JacobsM. (1994). ‘The Limits to Neo-classicism: Towards an Institutional Environmental Economics’, in RedcliftM. and BentonT. (eds), Social Theory and the Global Environment.London and New York:Routledge, pp. 67–91.
34.
JacobsM. (1997). ‘Environmental Valuation, Deliberative Democracy and Public Decision-Making Institutions’, in FosterJ. (1997) (ed.), pp. 211–31.
35.
JanssonA., HammerM., FolkeC., and CostanzaR. (eds) (1994). Investing in Natural Capital: The Ecological Economics Approach to Sustainability.Washington:Island Press.
36.
KlaassenG.A.J. and OpschoorJ.B. (1991). ‘Economics of Sustainability or the Sustain-ability of Economics: Different Paradigms’, Ecological Economics, 4: 93–115.
37.
KöhnJ., GowdyJ., HinterbergerF. and van der StraatenJ. (eds) (1999). Sustainability in Question: the Search for a Conceptual Framework.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
38.
LiokadisG. (2000). ‘Environmental Implications of International Trade and Uneven Development: Toward a Critique of Environmental Economics’, Review of Radical Political Economics, 32(1): 40–79.
39.
Martinez-AlierJ. (1995). ‘Political Ecology, Distributional Conflicts, and Economic Incommensurability’, New Left Review, 211: 70–78.
40.
Martinez-AlierJ. (1997). ‘Ecological Economics and Environmental Policy: A Southern European View’ in TylecoteA. and van der StraatenJ. (eds)(1997), pp. 15–39.
41.
Martinez-AlierJ. and O'ConnorM. (1999). ‘Distributional Issues: An Overview’ in van den BerghJ. C.J.M. (ed.), Handbook of Environmental and Resource Economics, Cheltenham:Edward Elgar, pp. 381–92.
42.
Martinez-AlierJ., MundaG. and O'NeillJ. (1998). ‘Weak Comparability of Values as a Foundation for Ecological Economics’, Ecological Economics, 26: 277–86
43.
Martinez-AlierJ., MundaG. and O'NeillJ. (1999a). ‘Commensurability and Compensability in Ecological Economics’ in O'ConnorM. and SpashC. (eds) (1999), pp. 37–57.
44.
Martinez-AlierJ., MundaG. and O'NeillJ. (1999b). ‘Theories and Methods in Ecological Economics; a Tentative Classification’, European Commission Environment and Climate Programme, Advance Study Course, mimeo.
45.
M'GonigleM.R. (1999). ‘Ecological Economics and Political Ecology: Towards a Necessary Synthesis’, Ecological Economics, 28: 11–26.
46.
MundaG. (1997). ‘Environmental Economics, Ecological Economics, and the Concept of Sustainable Development’, Environmental Values, 6:213–33.
47.
MundaG., NijkampP. and RieltveldP. (1994). ‘Qualitative Multicriteria Evaluation for Environmental Management’, Ecological Economics, 10:97–112.
48.
NeumayerE. (1999). Weak and Strong Sustainability: Exploring the Limits of Two Opposing Paradigms.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
49.
NoëlJ.F. and O'ConnorM. (1998). ‘Strong Sustainability and Critical Natural Capital’ in FaucheuxS. and O'ConnorM. (eds) (1998), pp. 75–98.
50.
NorgaardR.B. (1984). ‘Coevolutionary Development Potential’, Land Economics, 60:160–73.
51.
NorgaardR.B. and HowarthR.B. (1991). ‘Sustainability and Discounting the Future’, in CostanzaR. (ed.) (1991), pp. 88–101.
52.
O'ConnorM. (1998). ‘Ecological-Economic Sustainability’, in FaucheuxS. and O'ConnorM. (eds) (1998), pp. 19–42.
53.
O'ConnorM., FaucheuxS., FrogerG., FuntowiczS. and MundaG. (1996). ‘Emergent Complexity and Procedural Rationality: Post-Normal Science for Sustainability’, in CostanzaR. et al (eds.) (1996), pp. 224–47.
54.
O'ConnorM. and SpashC. (eds) (1999). Valuation and the Environment: Theory, Method and Practice. Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
55.
O'ConnorM. (ed.) (1994). Is Capitalism Sustainable? Political Economy and Politics of Ecology. New York and London:Guilford Press.
56.
O'ConnorJ. (1998). Natural Causes: Essays in Ecological Marxism. New York and London:Guilford Press.
57.
O'NeillJ. (1993). Ecology, Policy and Politics: Human Well-being and the Natural World.London and New York:Routledge.
58.
O'NeillJ. (1997). ‘Value Pluralism, Incommensurability and Institutions’ in FosterJ. (ed.) (1997), pp. 75–87.
59.
OpschoorJ.B. and van der StraatenJ. (1993). ‘Sustainable Development: An Institutional Approach’, Ecological Economics, 7:203–22.
60.
OzkaynakB. (2000). ‘Operationalising Sustainability: Definitions, Methodologies and Outcomes’. MPhil Thesis, University of Manchester, UK.
61.
PearceD. (1976). ‘The limits of cost-benefit analysis as a guide to environmental policy, Kyklos, 29:27–110.
PearceD. (1993). Economic Values and the Natural World. London:Earthscan.
64.
PearceD. (1998). Economics and Environment: Essays on Ecological Economics and Sustainable Development.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
65.
PearceD., BarbierE.B. and MarkandyaA. (1988). Sustainable Development and Cost-Benefit Analysis. LEEC Paper 88–03, IIED/UCL London Environmental Economics Centre, 3Endsleigh St., London WC1.
66.
PearceD., BarbierE.B. and MarkandyaA. (1989). Blueprint for a Green Economy.London:Earthscan.
67.
PearceD., BarbierE.B., and MarkandyaA. (1990). Sustainable Development: Economics and the Environment in the Third World.London:Earthscan.
68.
PearceD. and MoranD. (1994). The Economic Value of Biodiversity.London:Earth-scan.
69.
PearceD. and TurnerK.R. (1990). Economics of Natural Resources and the Environment. Hemel Hempstead:Harvester Wheatsheaf.
70.
PearceD. and WarfordJ.J. (1993). World Without End: Economics, Environment and Sustainable Development.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
71.
PearceD., WhittingtonD., GeorgiouS. and JamesD. (1994). Project and Policy Appraisal: Integrating Economics and Environment. OECD Collections.
72.
SöderbaumP. (1992). ‘Neo-classical and Institutional Approaches to Development and the Environment’, Ecological Economics, 5:127–44.
73.
SpashC. (1999). ‘Reflections Upon the Role of Moral Sentiments in Economics’, in Köhn. (eds) (1999), pp. 135–52.
74.
SpashC. (1999). ‘The Development of Environmental Thinking in Economics’, Environmental Values, 8:413–435.
75.
TurnerK.R. (1993). ‘Sustainability: Principles and Practice’ in TurnerK., (ed.) (1993) Sustainable Environmental Economics and Management: Principles and Practice, London:Belhaven Press.
76.
TurnerK., PerringsC. and FolkeC. (1996). Ecological Economics: Paradigm or Perspective. CSERGE Working Paper, ISSN 0967-8875, University of East Anglia and University College London.
77.
TylecoteA. and van der StraatenJ. (eds.)(1997). Environment, Technology and Economic Growth: The Challenge to Sustainable Development. Cheltenham:Edward Elgar.
78.
VictorP.A. (1991). ‘Indicators of Sustainable Development: Some Lessons From Capital Theory’, Ecological Economics, 4:191–213.
79.
Van der PerkJ., ChiesuraA. and de GrootR. (mimeo). ‘Towards a Conceptual Framework to Identify and Operationalise Critical Natural Capital’, European Commission CRITINC Project Working Paper 1B.
80.
Van der StraatenJ. (1999). ‘What Type of Economic Theory Dealing with the Environment Do We Need?’ in Köhn. (eds) (1999), pp. 33–49
81.
VatnA. and BromleyW.D. (1995). ‘Choices without Prices without Apologies’ in BromleyD. (ed.) (1995), Handbook of Environmental Economics.UK:Blackwell, pp. 3–26.
82.
ViedermanS. (1994). ‘Public Policy: Challenge to Ecological Economics’ in Jansson. (eds) (1994), pp. 467–78.
