Discourses evoking an antibiotic apocalypse and a war on superbugs are emerging just at a time when so-called “catastrophe discourses” are undergoing critical and reflexive scrutiny in the context of global warming and climate change. This article combines insights from social science research into climate change discourses with applied metaphor research based on recent advances in cognitive linguistics, especially with relation to “discourse metaphors.” It traces the emergence of a new apocalyptic discourse in microbiology and health care, examines its rhetorical and political function and discusses its advantages and disadvantages. It contains a reply by the author of the central discourse metaphor, “the post-antibiotic apocalypse,” examined in the article.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allenby, B. ( 2007) "Duelling Elites and Catastrophic Visions," CSPO Newsletter. URL: www.cspo.org/documents/CSPONewsletterFebruary2007.pdf (accessed 20 February 2007).
2.
Annas, G.J. ( 1995) "Reframing the Debate on Health Care Reform by Replacing our Metaphors," New England Journal of Medicine332: 744-7.
3.
Ash, C. ( 1996) "Antibiotic Resistance: The New Apocalypse?," Trends in Microbiology4(10): 371-2.
4.
Barry, A.W. ( 2005) The Great Influenza: The Story of the Deadliest Pandemic in History. New York: Penguin.
5.
Bono, J. ( 2001) "Why Metaphor? Toward a Metaphorics of Scientific Practice ," in S. Maasen and M. Winterhager (eds) Science Studies: Probing the Dynamics of Scientific Knowledge, pp. 215-34. Bielefeld : Transcript.
6.
Brahic, C. ( 2007) "Sex Up Climate Talk Says Arnie," New Scientist environment blog. URL: http://www.newscientist.com/blog/environment/2007/04/sex-up-climate-talk-says-arnie.html (accessed 6 August 2007).
7.
Cannon, G. ( 1995) Superbug-Nature’s Revenge: Why Antibiotics Can Breed Disease. London: Virgin Publishing Ltd.
8.
Entman, R. ( 1993) "Framing: Towards Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm ," Journal of Communication43: 51-8.
9.
Ereaut, G. and Segnit, N. ( 2006) Warm Words: How We Are Telling the Climate Story and Can We Tell it Better?London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
10.
Fitzpatrick, M. ( 2003) "Apocalypse From Now On," The Lancet361(9365): 1310.
11.
Fox, M.J. ( 2005) "Microbiologists Toy withToss ing ‘War’ Metaphor for Infectious Diseases," Microbe magazine. URL: http://www.asm.org/microbe/index.asp?bid=35615 (accessed 20 February 2007).
12.
Futerra (2007) "UK Communications Strategy on Climate Change" URL: http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/climatechange/pubs/pdf/ccc-execsumm.pdf (accessed 23 September 2007).
13.
Garrett, L. ( 1994) Coming Plague: Newly Emerging Diseases in a World Out of Balance. New York: Penguin .
14.
Gilland, T., ed. (2002) Nature’s Revenge? Hurricanes, Floods and Climate Change. London : Institute of Ideas/Hodder and Stoughton.
15.
Goldstein, F.W. and Kitzis, M.D. ( 2003) "Vancomycin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus: No Apocalypse Now," Clinical Microbiology and Infection9(8): 761-5.
16.
Goodman, E. ( 2007) "No Change in Political Climate," Boston Globe 9 February.
17.
Gratzer, W. ( 2003) "Apocalypse Soon?," Current Biology13(3): 78-9.
18.
Hajer, M. ( 1995) The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernisation and the Policy Process. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
19.
Hanlon, M. ( 2007) "Apocalypse When?," New Scientist 17 November, p. 20.
20.
Hansen, J.E. ( 2007) "Scientific Reticence and Sea Level Rise," Environmental Research Letters2. URL: http://www.iop.org/EJ/article/1748-9326/2/2/024002/erl7_2_024002.html (accessed 7 August 2007).
21.
Hiramatsu, K., Aritaka, N., Hanaki, H., Kawasaki, S., Hosoda, Y., Hori, S., Fukuchi, Y. and Kobayashi, I. ( 1997) "Dissemination in Japanese Hospitals of Strains of Staphylococcus aureus Heterogeneously Resistant to Vancomycin," The Lancet50(9092): 1670-3.
22.
Hodgkin, P. ( 1985) "Medicine is War: And Other Medical Metaphors," British Medical Journal291(6511): 1820-1.
23.
Hulme, M. ( 2006) "Chaotic World of Climate Truth," BBC News, 4 November. URL: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/6115644.stm (accessed 15 December 2006).
24.
Hulme, M. ( 2007) "Newspaper Scare Headlines Can be Counter-Productive ," Nature445 (22 February): 818.
25.
Hulme, M. (in press) "Mediated Messages: Reporting the IPCC Fourth Assessment in the UK Print Media," Science Communication.
26.
Humphrey, C. ( 2000) "Antibiotic Resistance: An Exemplary Case of Medical Nemesis ," Critical Public Health10: 353-8.
27.
James, R. ( 2005) "Battling Bacteria," Vision magazine, University of Nottingham. URL: http:// research.nottingham.ac.uk/Vision/display.aspx?id=1119&pid=211 (accessed 13 January 2007).
28.
James, R. ( 2007a) "Out of Control?," Exchange magazine , University of Nottingham, February. URL: http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/shared/shared_exchange/pdf/feb07_10.pdf (accessed 13 January 2007).
29.
James, R. ( 2007b) "Battle of the Superbugs," Vision magazine , University of Nottingham, Spring: 1-2. URL: http://research.nottingham.ac.uk/Vision/display.aspx?id=730&pid=178 (accessed 20 March 2007).
30.
Kay, L. ( 2000) Who Wrote the Book of Life? A History of the Genetic Code . Stanford: Stanford University Press.
31.
Koteyko, N., Nerlich, B., Crawford, P. and Wright, N. (in press) "‘Not Rocket Science’ or ‘No Silver Bullet’? Media and Government Discourses about MRSA and Cleanliness," Applied Linguistics.
32.
Lakoff, G. and Johnson, M. ( 1980) Metaphors We Live By. Chicago : Chicago University Press.
33.
Lanchester, J. ( 2007) "Warmer, Warmer," London Review of Books 22 March, pp. 3-9.
34.
Larabee, A. ( 2000) Decade of Disaster. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.
35.
Larson, B.M.H., Nerlich, B. and Wallis, P. ( 2005) "Metaphors and Biorisks: The War on Infectious Diseases and Invasive Species," Science Communication26: 243-68.
36.
Lederberg, J. ( 2000) "Evolving Metaphors of Infection: Teach War No More," Science. URL: http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/reprint/295/5559/1469.pdf
37.
Levy, S. ( 1998) "Antibmicrobial Resistance: Bacteria on the Defense ," British Medical Journal317: 612-13.
38.
Levy, S. ( 2002) The Antibiotic Paradox: How the Misuse of Antibiotics Destroys their Curative Powers. New York: Perseus Publishing.
39.
Lorenzoni, I., Pidgeon, N.F. and O’Connor, R.E. ( 2005) "Dangerous Climate Change: The Role of Risk Research ," Risk Analysis25(6): 1387-98.
40.
Lowe, T., Brown, K., Dessai, S., Doria, M., Haynes, K. and Vincent, K. ( 2006) "‘Does Tomorrow Ever Come?’ Disaster Narrative and Public Perceptions of Climate Change," Public Understanding of Science15(4): 435-57.
41.
Meek, W.A. ( 2000) "Apocalyptic Discourse and Strategies of Goodness ," The Journal of Religion80(3): 461-75.
42.
Montgomery, S.C. ( 1996) The Scientific Voice. New York : The Guilford Press.
43.
Moser, S. and Dilling, L. ( 2007) Creating a Climate for Change: Communicating Climate Change and Facilitating Social Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
44.
Musolff, A. ( 2006) "Metaphor Scenarios in Public Discourse," Metaphor and Symbol2(1): 23-38.
45.
Nerlich, B. and Hellsten, I. ( 2004) "Genomics: Shifts in Metaphorical Landscape between 2001 and 2003," New Genetics and Society23(3): 255-68.
46.
Nerlich, B. and Koteyko, N. (in press) "MRSA-Portrait of a Superbug: A Media Drama in Three Acts," in A. Musolff and J. Zinken (eds) Metaphor and Discourse. London: Palgrave.
47.
Newswise (2007) " Gore, Scientists Need to Do More to Unite Public Opinion," 15 October. URL: http://www.newswise.com/articles/view/534344/ (accessed 17 November 2007).
48.
Nicholson-Cole, S. ( 2005) "Representing Climate Change Futures: A Critique on the Use of Images for Visual Communication," Computers, Environment and Urban Systems29: 255-73.
49.
Nisbet, M.C. and Scheufele, D.A. ( 2007) "The Future of Public Engagement," The Scientist21(10): 38.
50.
Ostwald, K. ( 1998) "Visions of the End: Secular Apocalypse in Recent Hollywood Film," Journal of Religion and Film2(1). URL: http://www.unomaha.edu/jrf/OstwaltC.htm (accessed 2 February 2007).
51.
Palfreman, J. ( 2006) "A Tale of Two Fears: Exploring Media Depictions of Nuclear Power and Global Warming," Review of Policy Research23(1): 23-43.
52.
Raman, S. (in press) "When a Simple Cut Might Kill? The Implications of Technological Degradation for Democracy," Science as Culture.
53.
Romaine, S. ( 1997) "War and Peace in the Global Greenhouse: Metaphors We Die By," Metaphor and Symbolic Activity11: 175-94.
54.
Rotbart, H.A. ( 2007) Germ Proof Your Kids: The Complete Guide to Protecting (without Overprotecting) Your Family from Infections. New York: American Society for Microbiology Press.
55.
Schön, D.A. and Rein, M. ( 1994) Frame Reflection: Toward the Resolution of Intractable Policy Controversies. New York: Basic Books.
56.
Sharp, D.W. ( 2001) "Are We Returning to a Pre-antibiotic Age?," Science Watch®12(2) (March/April). URL: http://www.sciencewatch.com/march-april2001/sw_march-april2001_page7.htm
57.
Shnayerson, M. and Plotkin, M.J. ( 2002) The Killers Within: The Deadly Rise of Drug Resistant Bacteria. New York: Little Brown & Co.
58.
Smith, R. ( 1998) "Action on Antimicrobial Resistance: Not Easy, but Europe Can do it," Editorial, British Medical Journal317: 764-70.
59.
Sokoloff, B. ( 1949) The Miracle Drugs. Chicago: Ziff-Davies Publishing.
60.
Study of Man’s Impact on Climate, Inadvertent Climate Modification ( 1971) Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
61.
Tabaqchali, S. ( 1997) "Vancomycin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus: Apocalypse Now?," The Lancet350: 1644-5.
62.
Taylor, G.R. ( 1970) The Doomsday Book. New York : World Publishers.
63.
Varaldo, P.E. ( 2002) "Antimicrobial Resistance and Susceptibility Testing: An Evergreen Topic," Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy50: 1-4.
64.
Waert, S. ( 2006) "The Discovery of Climate Change" URL: http://www.aip.org/history/exhibits/climate/bibdate.htm (accessed 31 March 2006).
65.
Warren, V.L. ( 1991) "The Medicine is War Metaphor," HEC Forum: An Interdisciplinary Journal on Hospitals. Ethical and Legal Issues3(1): 39-50.
66.
Weingart, P. ( 1998) "Science and the Media," Research Policy27(8): 869-79.
67.
Weingart, P. ( 2002) "Kassandrarufe und Klimawandel," Gegenworte10(2): 21-5. Berlin : Berlin-Brandenburgische Akademie der Wissenschaften .
68.
Wenner, M. ( 2007) "The War against War Metaphors," The Scientist February. URL: http://www.the-scientist.com/news/home/52851/
69.
Zinken, J. ( 2007) "Discourse Metaphors: The Link between Figurative Language and Habitual Analogies," Cognitive Linguistics18(3): 443-64.
70.
Zinken, J., Hellsten, I. and Nerlich, B. (in press) "Discourse Metaphors" in R. Frank, R. Dirven, T. Ziemke and R. Bernárdez (eds) Body, Language and Mind, Vol. 2: Interrelations between Biology, Linguistics and Culture. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
