This article examines the role of contemporary art in a post-9/11 context through The American Effect exhibition at the Whitney Museum of American Art in New York in 2003. This exhibition displayed a range of artworks from around the world that specifically engaged with, commented upon and interrogated the USA's pre-eminent position as a global superpower. In the politically charged climate after 9/11, the exhibition offered itself as a critical voice amid the more obvious patriotic clamour: it was one of the places where Americans could ask (and answer) the question, `Why do they hate us so much?' Although The American Effect claimed to be a space of dissent, it ultimately failed to question, let alone challenge, US global hegemony. Instead, the exhibition articulated a benevolent patriotism that forced artwork from other nations into supplicating and abject positions, and it obscured the complex discursive networks that connect artists, curators, critics, audiences and art museums.
Adorno, Theodore, 1981. Prisms, trans. Samuel & Shierry Weber. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
2.
Alberro, Alexander & Isabelle Graw, eds, 2006. Institutional Critique and After. Zurich: JRP Editions .
3.
Ammirati, Domenick, 2003. `Review of The American Effect', ArtUS 0 (November— December): 36—37.
4.
Anderson, Maxwell L., 2003. `Foreword', in Lawrence Rinder, ed., The American Effect: Global Perspectives on the United States, 1990—2003. New York: Whitney Museum of American Art/Harry N. Abrams (11—13).
5.
Araeen, Rasheed, 2001. `Art and the Art World After September 11', Artthrob50 (October); available at http://www.artthrob.co.za/01oct/news/wtc.html (accessed 19 May 2006).
6.
Banksy, 2005. Wall and Piece. London: Random House .
7.
Birnbaum, Daniel; Gunnar Kvaran & Hans Ulrich Obrist , 2006. Uncertain States of America ; available at http://www.serpentinegallery.org/2006/08/uncertain_states_of_america_9.html (accessed 1 November 2006).
8.
Bleiker, Roland, 2006. `Art After 9/11', Alternatives31(1): 77—99.
9.
Buchholz, Larissa & Ulf Wuggenig, 2005. `Cultural Globalization Between Myth and Reality: The Case of the Contemporary Visual Arts', Artefact4 (`Glocalogue'); available at http://artefact.mi2.hr/_a04/lang_en/theory_buchholz_en.htm (accessed 21 May 2006).
10.
Buchloh, Benjamin H.D., 1990. `Conceptual Art 1962—1969: From the Aesthetics of Administration to the Critique of Institutions', October 55: 105—143.
11.
Conner, Jill, 2003. `Review: The American Effect', Brooklyn Rail, August —September.
12.
Conrad, Peter, 2002. `The Presumption of Art: Can Writers, Playwrights and Singers Help Us Come To Terms with 11 September?', The Observer , 8 September.
13.
Dailey, Meghan & Norman Rosenthal, eds, 2006. USA Today. London: Royal Academy of Arts.
14.
Danchev, Alex, 2005. Georges Braque: A Life. London: Hamish Hamilton.
15.
Danchev, Alex, 2006. `The Strategy of Still Life, or the Politics of Georges Braque', Alternatives31(1): 1—26.
16.
Desmond, Jane C., 2004. `″As Others See Us?″ Fetishizing the Foreign at the Whitney', American Quarterly56(4): 1051—1066.
17.
Foucault, Michel, 1997. The Politics ofTruth , ed. Sylvie Lotringer & Lysa Hochroth. New York: Semiotext(e) and MIT Press.
18.
Fraser, Andrea, 2005. `From the Critique of Institutions to an Institution of Critique', ArtforumXLIV(1): 278—283.
19.
Gardner, James, 2003. `Art Looks at U.S.: We Win in Foreign Artists' Take on America', New York Post, 8 July.
20.
Gopnik, Blake, 2003. `The Whitney, Using a Long Lens for Its U.S. Close-Up: ″American Effect″ Unwittingly Affirms Nation's Egocentricity', Washington Post, 24 August.
21.
Gouveia, Georgette, 2003. `The Eagle's Show: A Whitney Exhibit Reminds Us America Is One Powerful Muse', Journal News, 4 July.
22.
Griffin, Tim, 2003. `Global Tendencies: Globalism and the Large-Scale Exhibition ', Artforum International42 (November): 153—207.
23.
Heartney, Eleanor, 2003. `America, Real and Imagined', Art in America , September (99—104).
24.
Hofmann, Klaus, 2005. `Poetry After Auschwitz: Adorno's Dictum', German Life and Letters58(2): 182-194.
25.
Hurley, Clare, 2003. `The Texture of Life in a Few Instances', World Socialist Website, 14 October; available at http://www.wsws.org/articles/2003/oct2003/us-o14.shtml (accessed 4 April 2006).
26.
Jones, Jonathan, 2002. `Stop Spreading the News: New York Wasn't Just a City, It Was a Work of Art', The Guardian, 28 August.
27.
Kravagna, Christian, ed., 2001. The Museum as Arena: Artists on Institutional Critique. Cologne: Walther Konig.
28.
Kunitz, Daniel, 2003. `″Effect″-less Art', New York Sun, 3 July.
29.
Lacayo, Richard, 2003. `Withering Superheroes and Air Jordanski in a Reductive Show at the Whitney', Time, 4 August.
30.
Lee, Pamela M., 2003. `Boundary Issues: The Art World Under the Sign of Globalism ', Artforum International42 (November): 164—167.
31.
Levin, Kim, 2003. `A Foreign Affair', The Village Voice , 30 July—5 August.
32.
Littlejohn, David, 2003. `The Gallery: Ways the World Sees Us', Wall Street Journal, 19 August.
33.
Luke, Timothy W., 1992. Shows of Force: Power, Politics, and Ideology at Art Museums . Durham, NC: Duke University Press .
34.
Luke, Timothy W., 2002. Museum Politics: Power Plays at the Exhibition. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
35.
Ogbechie, Sylvester Okwunodu, 2005. `Ordering the Universe: Documenta 11 and the Apotheosis of the Occidental Gaze', Art Journal64 (March): 80—89.
36.
Panero, James, 2003. `That Is To Say: Nowhere', The New Criterion , September.
37.
Pogrebin, Robin, 2001. `Arts Groups Are Reeling in Wake of the Attacks', New York Times, 18 November.
38.
Politi, Giancarlo, 2001. `Art and the Art World After September 11', Artthrob50 (October); available at http://www.artthrob.co.za/01oct/news/wtc.html (accessed 19 May 2006).
39.
Pollack, Barbara, 2001. `How Can You Think About Making Art at a Time Like This ?', Artnews, November; available at http://artnews.com/issues/article.asp?art_id=1004 (accessed 22 May 2006).
40.
Rinder, Lawrence, 2003. `The American Effect', in Lawrence Rinder, ed., The American Effect: Global Perspectives on the United States, 1990—2003. New York: Whitney Museum of American Art/Harry N. Abrams (15—44).
41.
Rinder, Lawrence, 2005. Personal e-mail correspondence, 23 September.
42.
Rosenberg, Karen, 2003. `Review: The American Effect', Art Monthly , October.
43.
Salamon, Julie, 2002. `Reliving 9/11: Too Much? Too Soon?', New York Times, 12 May.
44.
Schjeldahl, Peter, 2003. `Target America: The View from Abroad at the Whitney', The New Yorker, 4 August.
45.
Shteyngart, Gary, 2003. `The Whole World is Watching', New York Times, 13 July.
46.
Spencer, Jared, 2003. `The Global Mirror: America from Afar', Columbia Spectator, 9 July.
47.
Sundell, Margaret, 2003. `Turning the Tables: The Whitney Invites Foreign Artists To Weigh In on the U.S.', Time Out New York, 7—14 August.
48.
Sylvester, Christine, forthcoming. Facing Art/Museums: International Relations Where It Is Not Supposed To Be
49.
Thomas, Kelly Divine, 2001. `Aftershocks', Artnews, November; available at http://artnews.com/issues/article.asp?art_id=1005 (accessed 22 May 2006).
50.
Vascellaro, Jessica, 2003. `Foreign Artists Say to America: This Is You', Vancouver Sun, 9 August.
51.
Vincent, Steven, 2003. `Resisting the ″American Effect″', National Review, 9 September.
52.
Whitney Museum of American Art, 2003. `The American Effect: Comment Form'; available at http://www.whitney.org/exhibition/americaneffect.shtml (accessed 3 April 2006).
53.
Wise, Michael Z., 2003. `America Starkly Drawn by Others', Los Angeles Times, 5 July.
54.
Wolfson, Richard, 2001. `Controversy and the Composer Stockhausen's Outrageous Comments About the Atrocities in New York Were Snatched Out of Context', Daily Telegraph, 29 September.
55.
Zeaman, John, 2003. `A Look at the View from Out There: American Culture Takes a Hit', The Record, 18 July.
56.
Zinn, Howard, 2003. Artists in Times of War. New York: Open Media/Seven Stories Press.
